The Effectiveness of Intramedullary Screw Fixation Using the Herbert Screw for Fifth Metatarsal Stress Fractures in High-Level Athletes

Abstract

Background:

Intramedullary screw fixation is the most common operative procedure used for treatment of fifth metatarsal stress fractures in athletes. However, the optimal implant in intramedullary screw fixation is still being investigated.

Purpose:

To review experiences with intramedullary screw fixation using the Herbert screw for fifth metatarsal stress fractures in high-level athletes.

Study Design:

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

Methods:

The authors retrospectively analyzed 37 high-level athletes (Tegner activity score ≥7) who underwent intramedullary screw fixation using the Herbert screw for fifth metatarsal stress fractures between August 2005 and August 2017. The minimum follow-up period of the patients was 2 years. In assessing the surgical results, time to obtain bone union, time to return to original level of sport participation, and treatment failures/complications were reviewed. Additionally, the effect of intraoperative plantar gap widening caused by the screw insertion was analyzed. The surgical results of the 2 groups, the no-gap group (intraoperative plantar gap widening, <1 mm) and the gap group (intraoperative plantar gap widening, ≥1 mm), were compared, while correlations between intraoperative plantar gap widening and the surgical results were statistically analyzed.

Results:

Bone union and return to the original sport were attained in all patients without treatment failures/complications such as delayed union, nonunion, or refracture. The mean time to obtain bone union was 10.1 weeks, and the mean time to return to sport was 10.9 weeks. In comparing the no-gap group (n = 16) and the gap group (n = 21), no significant differences in the time to obtain bone union (P = .392) or to return to sport (P = .399) were noted. Additionally, there was no correlation between intraoperative plantar gap widening and the time to obtain bone union (r = 0.131; P = .428) or to return to sport (r = 0.160; P = .331).

Conclusion:

The use of the Herbert screw for intramedullary screw fixation to treat fifth metatarsal stress fractures in high-level athletes provided satisfactory results enabling all the athletes to return to the original sport without treatment failures/complications. Additionally, intraoperative plantar gap widening does not affect the surgical results using this technique.