Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

While women are undoubtedly disadvantaged in the process of preparing for a career in business ownership, there is a lack of experimental evidence to verify the belief that loan managers discriminate against women at the point of loan application. This study, therefore, investigates the extent to which concerns that women in business face discrimination from trading banks when seeking to raise start-up capital are valid. Scenarios of an application for loan finance to purchase a commercial enterprise were mailed to loan officers of major trading bank branches. The scenarios were identical in all respects, except that half included a photograph of a male applicant and the remainder a photograph of a female.

Loan officers were asked whether or not they would approve loan finance for the proposed business, and to indicate factors that contributed to their decision. Significant differences in loan officer response to female and male applicants were observed. This supported the widely held perception that women face discrimination in seeking start-up capital.

Keywords

DISCRIMINATION SMALL BUSINESS START-UP FINANCE WOMEN ENTREPRENEURS

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson, R.L. and K.P. Anderson , 1988, A comparison of women in large and small companies, American Journal of Small Business, 12, 3, 23–33.

Blair, E. , S. Sudman , N. Bradburn and C. Stocking , 1977, How to ask questions about drinking and sex: response effects in measuring consuming behavior, Journal of Marketing Research, 14, 3, 316–321.

Bowen, D. and R. Hisrich , 1986, The female entrepreneur: a career development perspective, Academy of Management Review, 2, 393–407.

Buono, A.F. and J.B. Kamm , 1983, Marginality and the organisational socialisation of female managers, Human Relations (New Zealand), 36, 1125–1140.

Chusmir, L.H. , 1982, Job commitment and the managerial woman, Academy of Management Review, 7, 595–602.

Devine, M. and D. Clutterbuck, 1985, The rise of the entrepreneuse, Management Today, January, 63–65, 105–107.

Donkels, R. and J.N. Meijer , eds., 1986, Women in Small Business: Focus on Europe (New Hampshire, Van Gorcum).

Dwyer, M., D. Rose and R. Sowman, 1985, Self-employment and small businesses, New Zealand Planning Council, Planning Paper 22.

Goffee, R. , R. Scase and M. Pollack , 1982, Why some women decide to become their own boss, New Society, 9, 408–410.

10.

Goffee, R. and R. Scase , 1983, Business ownership and women's subordination: a preliminary study of female proprietors, Sociological Review, 31, 4, 625–647.

11.

Goffee, R. and R. Scase , 1986, Women business start-up and economic recession, in: R. Donkels and J.N. Meijer , eds., Women in Small Business: Focus on Europe (New Hampshire, Van Gorcum) pp. 21–32.

12.

Hajba, S. , 1986, Male and female entrepreneurs, in: R. Donkels and J.N. Meijer , eds., Women in Small Business: Focus on Europe (New Hampshire, Van Gorcum).

13.

Hennig, M. and A. Jardim , 1979, The Managerial Women (London, Pan Books).

14.

Hertz, L. , 1986, The Business Amazons (London, Deutsch).

15.

Hisrich, R.D. , and M. O'Brien , 1982, The woman entrepreneur as a reflection of the type of business, in: K.H. Vesper , ed., Conference on Entrepreneurship (University of Washington, Babson College, Center for Entrepreneurial Studies).

16.

Hisrich, R.D. , and C.G. Brush , 1986, The Woman Entrepreneur: Starting, Managing and Financing a Successful New Business (London, Lexington Books).

17.

Humphries, M.A. and J. McClung , 1981, Women entrepreneurs in Oklahoma, Regional Review of Economics and Business (New Zealand), 6, 13–21.

18.

Hutchinson, P.J. , 1978, Financial assistance to small firms: the American experience, Quarterly Review, National Westminister Bank, November, 50–62.

19.

Johns, B.L. , W.C. Dunlop and K.M. Lamb , 1976, Finance for small business in Australia: an assessment of adequacy, National Small Business Bureau, Department of Trade and Industry, Canberra.

20.

Johns, B.L. , W.C. Dunlop and W.J. Sheehan , 1978, Small Business in Australia: Problems and Prospects (Sydney, George, Allen and Unwin).

21.

Meredith, G.G. , 1983, Small Business Management in Australia (Sydney, McGraw-Hill Company) 2nd edition.

22.

President's Interagency Taskforce on Women Business Owners , 1978, Report on Women Business Owners (Washington, GPO).

23.

Seigel, S. , 1956, Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioural Sciences (Tokyo, McGraw-Hill Inc.).

24.

Sondeno, S.F. , 1985, Small business management principles (Plano, TX, Business Publications Inc.).

25.

Stem, D.E. and R.K. Steinhorst , 1984, Telephone interview and mail questionnaire applications of the randomised response model, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 79, 387, 555–564.

26.

Vesper, K.H. , 1982, Frontiers of entrepreneurship, Proceedings of the 1982 Conference on Entrepreneurship, Babson College, Wellesley, Massachusetts.

27.

Webb, E.J. , D.T. Campbell , R.D. Schwartz and L. Sechrest , 1966, Unobtrusive Measures; Nonreactive Research in the Social Sciences (Chicago, McNally College Publishing Co.).

28.

Williams, L.E., 1987, Women in business, Unpublished Honours Dissertation, Marketing Department, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.

29.

Williams, P.J. , 1982, Patterns of small business failure, in: W.C. Dunlop and W.J. Sheehan , eds., Small Business Research (Newcastle, Institute of Industrial Economics).

Sex of Applicant and the Availability of Business “Start-Up” Finance

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References