We apply a new methodology, modified Granger causality tests, to further analyze the information flows between earnings and forecasts. Our application focuses on the dynamic interaction between reported earnings and analysts’ forecasts. Based on long time series of analyst earnings forecasts and reported earnings, we provide formal and compelling evidence of bi-directional ‘causality’. Further, we report that the lag structure in information flows is longer than has been documented in the previous literature. This is consistent with our expectation that, in addition to past earnings reports, the forecasts themselves make a significant contribution to the information that is reflected in future earnings. However, the presence of feedback also suggests that past earnings reports, as well as past forecasts, are incorporated into later forecasts. Collectively, our findings imply that the information in earnings reports has inherent positive value and that forecasts do not fully substitute for earnings releases.
AhmedASchneibleR (2007) The impact of regulation fair disclosure on investors’ prior information quality – Evidence from an analysis of changes in trading volume and stock price reactions to earnings announcements. Journal of Corporate Finance13: 282–299.
2.
AiolfiCCapistranCTimmermannA (2011) Forecast combinations. In: ClementsMPHendryDF (eds)The Oxford Handbook of Economic Forecasting. New York: Oxford University Press, pp.355–390.
3.
AliAZarowinP (1992a) Permanent versus transitory components of annual earnings and estimation error in earnings response coefficients. Journal of Accounting and Economics15: 249–264.
4.
AliAZarowinP (1992b) The role of earnings levels in annual earnings-returns studies. Journal of Accounting Research30: 286–296.
5.
AliAKleinARosenfeldJ (1992) Analysts’ use of information about permanent and transitory earnings components in forecasting annual EPS. Accounting Review67: 183–198.
6.
AsquithPMikhailMAuA (2005) Information content of equity analyst reports. Journal of Financial Economics75: 245–282.
7.
BaberWKangSKumarK (1999) The explanatory power of earnings levels vs. earnings changes in the context of executive compensation. Accounting Review74: 459–472.
8.
BaginskiS (1987) Intra-industry information transfer associated with management forecasts of earnings. Journal of Accounting Research25: 196–219.
9.
BallRBartovE (1996) How naïve is the stock market’s use of earnings information?Journal of Accounting and Economics21: 319–337.
10.
BarronOEByardDKimO (2002) Changes in analysts’ information around earnings announcements. Accounting Review77: 821–846.
11.
BartovEGivolyDHaynC (2002) The rewards to meeting or beating earnings expectations. Journal of Accounting and Economics33: 173–204.
12.
BartovERadhakrishnanSKronskyI (2000) Investor sophistication and patterns in stock returns after earnings announcements. Accounting Review75: 43–63.
13.
BeaverWLambertRMorseD (1980) The information content of security prices. Journal of Accounting and Economics2: 3–28.
14.
BernardVThomasJ (1989) Post-earnings announcement drift: Delayed price response or risk premium?Journal of Accounting Research27: 1–48.
15.
BernardVThomasJ (1990) Evidence that stock prices do not fully reflect the implications for current earnings for future earnings. Journal of Accounting and Economics13: 305–340.
16.
BhojrajSHribarPPicconiM. (2009) Making sense of cents: An examination of firms that marginally miss or beat analyst forecasts. Journal of Finance5: 2361–2388.
17.
BhushanR (1994) An informational efficiency perspective on the post-earnings announcement drift. Journal of Accounting and Economics18: 45–65.
18.
BrennanMJegadeeshNSwaminathanB (1993) Investment analysis and the adjustment of stock prices to common information. Review of Financial Studies6: 799–824.
19.
BrownLHigginsH (2005) Managers’ forecast guidance of analysts: International evidence. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy24: 280–299.
ChengQ (2005) The role of analysts’ forecasts in accounting-based valuation: A critical approach. Review of Accounting Studies10: 5–31.
22.
ChenSMatsumotoD (2006) Favorable versus unfavorable recommendations: The impact on analyst access to management-provided information. Journal of Accounting Research44: 657–689.
23.
ClinchGSinclairN (1987) Intra-industry information releases. Journal of Accounting and Economics9: 89–106.
24.
CollinsDKothariS (1989) An analysis of intertemporal and cross-sectional determinants of earnings response coefficients. Journal of Accounting and Economics11: 143–181.
25.
CollinsDMaydewEWeissE (1997) Changes in the value-relevance of earnings and book values over the past forty years. Journal of Accounting and Economics17: 3–40.
26.
CornettMTehranianHYalcinA (2008) Regulation fair disclosure and the market’s reaction to analyst investment recommendation changes. Journal of Banking & Finance31: 567–588.
27.
DengZLevBNarinF (1999) Science and technology as predictors of stock performance. Financial Analysts Journal55: 20–32.
28.
DickeyDFullerW (1979) Distribution of estimators for autoregressive time series with a unit root. Journal of the American Statistical Association74: 427–431.
29.
ElgarsPLoMPfeifferR (2001) Delayed security price adjustments to financial analysts forecasts of annual earnings. Accounting Review76: 613–632.
30.
ElliottG (2006) Forecasting with trending data. In: ElliottGGrangerCTimmermannA (eds)Handbook of Economic Forecasting. Amsterdam: North-Holland, pp.555–604.
31.
FerreiraESmithS (2006) Effect of Reg FD on information in analysts’ rating changes. Financial Analysts Journal62: 44–57.
32.
FosterG (1981) Intra-industry information transfers associated with earnings releases. Journal of Accounting and Economics3: 201–232.
33.
FrancisJSchipperK (1999) Have financial statements lost their relevance?Journal of Accounting Research26: 319–352.
34.
FrancisJSofferL (1997) The relative informativeness of analysts’ stock recommendations and earnings forecasts revisions. Journal of Accounting Research35: 193–211.
35.
FrancisJSchipperKVincentL (2002) Earnings announcements and competing information. Journal of Accounting and Economics33: 313–342.
36.
FrankelRKothariSWeberJ (2006) Determinants of the informativeness of analyst research. Journal of Accounting and Economics41: 29–54.
37.
FrostCA (1995) Intra-industry information transfer: An analysis of research methods and additional evidence. Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting5: 111–126.
38.
GivolyD (1985) The formation of earnings expectations. Accounting Review60: 372–386.
39.
GomesAGortonGMadureiraL (2007) SEC Regulation fair disclosure, information, and the cost of capital. Journal of Corporate Finance13: 300–334.
GrangerC (1969) Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica37: 424–438.
42.
GuayWKothariSPShuS (2011) Properties of implied cost of capital using analysts’ forecasts. Australian Journal of Management36: 125–149.
43.
HallBJaffeATrajtenbergM (2005) Market value and patent citations. RAND Journal of Economics36: 16–37.
44.
HsuGLindsaySTutticciI (2011) Inter-temporal changes in analysts’ forecast properties under the Australian continuous disclosure regime. Accounting and Finance51: 1–23.
45.
HuttonA (2005) Determinants of managerial earnings guidance prior to regulation fair disclosure and bias analysts earnings forecasts. Contemporary Accounting Research22: 867–914.
46.
JacobJRockSWeberD (2008) Do non-investment bank analysts make better earnings forecasts?Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance23: 23–61.
47.
JonesJMortonRSchaeferT (2000) Valuation implications of investment opportunities and earnings permanence. Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting15: 21–35.
48.
KaramanouI (2011) On the determinants of optimism in financial analyst earnings forecasts: The effect of the market’s ability to adjust for the bias. Abacus47: 1–26.
49.
KimOVerrecchiaR (1991) Market reaction to anticipated announcements. Journal of Financial Economics30: 273–309.
50.
KimOVerrecchiaRE (1994) Market liquidity and volume around earnings announcements. Journal of Accounting and Economics17: 41–67.
51.
KimOVerrecchiaR (1997) Pre-announcement and event-period private information. Journal of Accounting and Economics30: 395–419.
52.
KormendiRLipeR (1987) Earnings innovations, earnings persistence, and stock returns. Journal of Business60: 323–345.
LennoxCParkC (2006) The informativeness of earnings and management’s issuance of earnings forecasts. Journal of Accounting and Economics42: 439–458.
55.
LevBZarowinP (1999) The boundaries of financial information and how to extend them. Journal of Accounting Research37: 353–385.
56.
LibbyRTanHHuntonJ (2006) Does the form of management’s earnings guidance affect analysts’ earnings forecasts. Accounting Review81: 207–225.
57.
LopezTReesL (2001) The effect of meeting analyst forecasts and systematic positive forecast errors on the information content of unexpected earnings. Available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=181929 (accessed 30 October, 2008).
58.
ManskiC (2011) Interpreting and combining heterogeneous survey forecasts. In: ClementsMPHendryDF (eds)The Oxford Handbook of Economic Forecasting. New York: Oxford University Press, pp.457–472.
MorseDStephanJSticeE (1991) Earnings announcements and the convergence (or divergence) of beliefs. Accounting Review66: 246–276.
61.
NicholsDWahlenJ (2004) How do earnings numbers relate to stock returns? A review of classic accounting research with updated evidence. Accounting Horizons18: 263–286.
62.
OtaK (2010) The value relevance of management forecasts and their impact on analysts’ forecasts: Empirical evidence from Japan. Abacus46: 28–59.
63.
OuJPenmanS (1989) Accounting measurement, price-earnings ratio and the information content of security prices. Journal of Accounting Research27: 111–144.
64.
PenmanS (2010) Financial forecasting, risk and valuation: Accounting for the future. Abacus46: 211–228.
65.
PiotroskiJRoulstoneD (2004) The influence of analysts, institutional investors, and insiders on the incorporation of market, industry, and firm-specific information into stock prices. Accounting Review79: 1119–1151.
66.
PownallGWasleyCWaymireG (1993) The stock price effects of alternative types of management earnings forecasts. Accounting Review68: 896–912.
67.
RichardsonSTeohSWysockiP (2004) The walk-down to beatable analyst forecasts: The role of equity issuance and insider trading incentives. Contemporary Accounting Research21: 885–924.
68.
SequeiraJHoYTangT (2007) Earnings surprises, asymmetry of returns and market level changes – An industry level study. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance22: 2–31.
69.
SidhuBSmithTWhaleyR. (2008) Regulation fair disclosure and the cost of adverse selection. Journal of Accounting Research46: 697–728.
70.
SkinnerD (1994) Why firms voluntarily disclose bad news. Journal of Accounting Research32: 38–60.
71.
SkinnerDSloanR (2002) Earnings surprises, growth expectations and stock returns: Don’t let an earnings torpedo sink your portfolio. Review of Accounting Studies7: 289–312.
72.
SofferLThiagarajanSWaltherB (2000) Earnings preannouncement strategies. Review of Accounting Studies5: 5–26.
73.
TodaHYamamotoT (1995) Statistical inference in vector autoregressions with possibly integrated processes. Journal of Econometrics66: 225–250.
