In September 2001 when Pasminco Ltd was placed in voluntary administration, it was the world’s biggest zinc producer with over 10% of global output. This paper examines the hedging strategies that Pasminco had in place in the years leading up to the firm being declared insolvent and documents the financial factors that contributed to the corporate collapse. We build a valuation model that illustrates in stark terms that the company’s hedging strategies materially reduced neither the exposure to market risk nor the probability of financial distress, and were a major contributing factor to the company’s downfall. The analysis in this case study contains valuable lessons for companies facing quantity and exchange rate risk.
Alburquerque (2007) Optimal currency hedging. Global Finance Journal18: 16–33.
2.
BartholomeuszS (2001) Pasminco disgrace is complete. The Age21July.
3.
BerkmanHBradburyMHancockPInnesC (2002) Derivative financial instrument use in Australia. Accounting and Finance42: 97–109.
4.
BodnarGMde JongAMacraeV (2003) The impact of institutional differences on derivatives usage: a comparative study of US and Dutch firms. European Financial Management9: 271–297.
5.
BrownGW (2001) Managing foreign exchange risk with derivatives. Journal of Financial Economics60: 401–448.
6.
DeMarzoPDuffieD (1995) Corporate incentives for hedging and hedge accounting. Review of Financial Studies8: 743–771.
7.
DoldeW (1993) The trajectory of corporate financial risk management. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance6: 33–41.
8.
EdwardsFCanterM (1995) The collapse of Metallgesellschaft: Unhedgeable risks, poor hedging strategy or just bad luck?Journal of Futures Markets15, 211–264.
9.
FrootK (1993) Currency hedging over long horizons, NBER Working Paper, No. 4355.
10.
FrootKScharfsteinDSteinJ (1993) Risk management: coordinating corporate investment and financing policies. Journal of Finance48: 1629–1658.
11.
GarmanMBKohlhagenSW (1983) Foreign currency option values. Journal of International Money and Finance2: 231–237.
12.
GayGNamJ (1998) The underinvestment problem and corporate derivatives use. Financial Management27: 53–69.
13.
GayGDNamJTuracM (2001) On the optimal mix of corporate hedging instruments: linear versus non-linear derivatives. Journal of Futures Markets23(3): 217–239.
14.
GéczyCMintonBASchrandC (1997) Why firms use currency derivatives. Journal of Finance52: 1323–1354.
15.
GrahamJRogersD (2002) Do firms hedge in response to tax incentives. Journal of Finance57: 815–839.
16.
HentschelLKothariSP (2001) Are corporations reducing or taking risks with derivatives?Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis36: 93–118.
17.
HowtonSDPerfectSB (1998) Currency and interest rate derivatives use in US firms. Financial Management27: 111–121.
18.
KimballM (1990) Precautionary saving in the small and in the large. Econometrica58: 53–73.
19.
KimballM (1993) Standard risk aversion. Econometrica61: 589–611.
20.
LessardD (1991) Global competition and corporate finance in the 1990s. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance3: 59–72.
21.
LewentJCKearneyAJ (1990) Identifying, measuring, and hedging currency risk at Merck. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance2: 19–28.
22.
MoschiniLapan (1995) The hedging role of options and futures under joint price, basis and production risk. International Economic Review36: 1025–1049.
23.
NanceDSmithCSmithsonC (1993) On the determinants of corporate hedging. Journal of Finance48: 267–284.
24.
NguyenHFaffR (2002) On the determinants of derivative usage by Australian companies. Australian Journal of Management27(1): 1–24.
25.
NguyenHFaffR (2003) Further evidence on the corporate use of derivatives in Australia: the case of foreign currency and interest rate instruments. Australian Journal of Management28(3): 307–317.
PenningsJGarciaP (2004) Hedging behavior in small and medium-sized enterprises: the role of unobserved heterogeneity. Journal of Banking and Finance28(5): 951–978.
28.
SmithCStulzR (1985) The determinants of firm’s hedging policies. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis20: 391–405.
29.
SparkJMMcCluskeyPD (2002) Report to Creditors Pursuant to Section 439A of the Corporation Act (2001).
30.
StulzR (1984) Optimal hedging policies. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis19: 127–140.
TufanoP (1996) Who manages risk? An empirical examination of the risk management practices of the gold mining industry. Journal of Finance51: 1097–1137.
33.
WongK (2003) Currency hedging with options and futures. European Economic Review47: 833–839.
