Severity of illness (Therapeutic Index Severity Score, Classes 1-4) and direct clinical costs (labour costs, diagnostic costs, drugs, disposables, etc.) were determined for 100 consecutive patients admitted to Royal Newcastle Hospital Intensive Care Unit over six weeks. Outcome was assessed using mortality, quality of life, functional status, productivity and mental status one month after separation from the Unit.
The mean total admission cost was $1,357 (Class 4 mean = $3,706) but for over 70% of patients costs were less than $1,000. The main component of cost was labour (about 60% for all classes). TISS proved a strong predictor (P<0.001) of total admission costs. Survival to one month was 89% and optimal association between cost and survival was found with those with low costs more likely to survive (P<0.001). On the other hand, no association was found between total admission cost and resulting quality of life. However, there was an association between pre-admission and follow-up quality of life (P<0.0005).
CullenD.J., FerraraL.C., BriggsB.A., WalkerP.F., GilbertJ.Survival, hospitalization charges and follow-up results in critically ill patients. N Engl J Med1976; 294: 982–987.
2.
GrinerP.F.Medical intensive care in the teaching hospital: costs versus benefits: the need for assessment. Ann Intern Med1973; 78: 581–585.
3.
MorganA., DalyC., MurawskiB.J.Dollar and human costs of intensive care. J Surg Res1973; 14: 441–448.
4.
CivettaJ.M.The inverse relationship between cost and survival. J Surg Res1973; 14: 265–269.
5.
DetskyA.S., StriekerS.C., MulleyA.G., ThibaultG.E.Prognosis, survival and the expenditure of hospital resources for patients in an intensive care unit. N Engl J Med1981; 305: 667–72.
6.
ParnoJ.R., TeresD., LemeshowS., BrownR.B.Hospital charges and longterm survival of ICU versus non-ICU patients. Crit Care Med1982; 10: 569–577.
7.
Leigh-ThompsonW.L.Critical care tomorrow: economics and challenges. Crit Care Med1982; 10: 561–568.
8.
HellingerF.J.Controlling costs by adjusting payment for medical technologies. Inquiry1982; 19: 34–43.
9.
HughesE.S.R.Intensive care units. Aust NZ J Surg1976; 46: 291.
10.
HostenA.O.Management of the patient in the intensive care unit. J Natl Med Assoc1973; 65: 89–94.
11.
WeilM.H., StrubinH.The practice of critical care medicine: is it viable?Crit Care Med1975; 3: 173–174.
12.
TelferA.B.M.Logistics of intensive care. In: Handbook of Intensive Care.BainW.H., TaylorK.M., WrightP.S.G., eds. Bristol1974; 6–24.
13.
ChassinM.R.Costs and outcomes of medical intensive care. Med Care1982; 20: 165–179.
14.
KnausW.A.The misuse and overuse of intensive care units. Med World News1982; 23: 121.
15.
LedinghamIMcA. Care of the critically ill. In: Recent Advances in Intensive Therapy. Number 1. LedinghamIMcA., ed. Churchill-Livingstone, Edinburgh1977; 1–7.
16.
SaxS.A.A report on hospitals in Australia.Hospitals and Health Services Commission, Canberra, 1974.
17.
HawkerJ.H.Hospitals and Health Services Yearbook. Australia 1977-78. Peter Issacson Publications, Melbourne, 1977.
18.
RelmanA.S.Intensive-care units: Who needs them?N Engl J Med1980; 302: 965–966.
19.
BendixenH.H.The cost of intensive care. In: Costs, risks and benefits of surgery.BunkerJ.P., BarnesB.A., MostellerF. eds., Oxford University Press, New York1977; 372–384.
20.
TaylorR.Medicine out of control. The anatomy of a malignant technology.Sun Books, Melbourne1979; 119–132 and 242-249.
21.
CullenD.J.Results and costs of intensive care. Anesthesiology1977; 47: 209.
22.
CullenD.J., CivettaJ.M., BriggsB.A., FerraraL.C.Therapeutic Intervention Scoring System: a method of quantitative comparison of patient care. Crit Care Med1974; 2: 57–60.
CouchN.P., TilneyN.L., RaynerA.A., MooreF.D.The high cost of low-frequency events: The anatomy and economics of surgical mishaps. N Engl J Med1981; 304: 634–637.
28.
KirkpatrickJ.R., WaltA.J.The high cost of gunshot and stab wounds. J Surg Res1973; 14: 260–264.
29.
PhillipsG.D., RoyalD.The cost of intensive care (Abstract). Anaesth Intens Care1976; 4: 81.
30.
BarnesB.A.Cost-benefit analysis of surgery: current accomplishments and limitations. Am J Surg1977; 133: 438–446.
31.
TurnbullA.D., CarlonG., BaronR., SichelW., YoungL., HowlandW.The inverse relationship between cost and survival in the critically ill cancer patient. Crit Care Med1979; 7: 20–23.
32.
KallaA.H., VossE.C.Is the intensive care unit cost effective?West Virginia Med J1980; 76: 151–158.
33.
ChassinM.R.Costs and outcomes of medical intensive care. Med Care1982; 20: 165–179.
34.
FedullaA.J., SwinburneA.J.Relationship of patient age to cost and survival in a medical ICU. Crit Care Med1983; 11: 155–159.
35.
McCleaveD.J., GilliganJ.E., WorthleyL.I.G.The role and function of an Australian intensive care unit. Crit Care Med1977; 5: 245–251.
36.
ShannonD.C., CroneR.K., TodresI.D., KrishnamoorthyK.S.Survival, cost of hospitalisation and prognosis in infants critically ill with respiratory distress syndrome requiring mechanical ventilation. Crit Care Med1981; 9: 94–97.
37.
KnausW.A., ZimmermanJ.E., WagnerD.P., DraperE.A., LawrenceD.E.APACHE — acute physiology and chronic health evaluation: a physiologically based classification system. Crit Care Med1981; 9: 591–597.
38.
ThibaultG.E., MulleyA.G., BarnettG.O.Medical intensive care: indications, interventions and outcomes. N Engl J Med1980; 302: 938–942.
39.
BakerC.C., MillerL.D., BauerA.E.Predictors of outcome following major trauma. J Trauma1983; 23: 627.
40.
PhillipsG.D., AustinK.L., RuncimanW.B., VedigA.E.Deaths in intensive care: Analysis and prediction. Med J Aust1980; 1: 424–426.
41.
DavisS.H., LefrafS.S., MillerD., MaltS.Prolonged mechanically assisted ventilation: an analysis of outcome and charges. JAMA1980; 243: 43–45.
42.
LastJ.M.A Dictionary of Epidemiology.Oxford University Press, New York, 1983; 73.
43.
MaddoxG.L.Interventions and outcomes: Notes on designing and implementing an experiment in health care. Int J Epidemiol1972; 1: 339–348.
44.
CullenD.J., KeenR., KunsmanJ.M., CalderaD.L., WaternauxG.Results, benefits and charges for intensive care of the critically ill patient — Update 1982 (Abstract). Anesthesiology1982; 57: A94.
45.
JacobsonS., LawsA., RosenthalM.H.Quality of Wellbeing after intensive care unit hospitalization (Abstract). Anesthesiology1982; 57: A144.
46.
Le GallJ.R., PlevenD., LatournerieJ., TrumetP., MouellicY.S.L.Evaluation of Health Status (HS) before intensive care unit and for one year after discharge (Abstract). Crit Care Med1981; 9: 276.
47.
KnausW.A., Le GallJ.R., WagnerD.P.A comparison of intensive care in the USA and France. Lancet1982; 8299: 642–646.
