This paper argues that while critical realist insights are important for heterodoxy, any engagement with the economic mainstream must remain faithful to Bhaskar’s original formulation with its explicit focus on ‘ideology critique’. The article proceeds by distinguishing Bhaskar’s more Marxian-inspired realism from the broadly heterodox variety of the ‘critical realism in economics’ (CRE) project. It then highlights the weaknesses of the CRE critique of the economic mainstream before positing an alternative critique in terms of ideology.
Archer M. et al. (1998) Critical Realism: Essential Readings. London: Routledge.
3.
Bhaskar R. ( 1989) Reclaiming Reality: A Critical Introduction to Contemporary Philosophy. London: Verso.
4.
Bhaskar R. ( 1991) Philosophy and the Idea of Freedom. London: Blackwell.
5.
Bhaskar R. ( 1998). The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of The Contemporary Human Sciences, 3rd edition. Brighton, London: Harvester.
6.
Bhaskar R., Callinicos A. ( 2003) Marxism and critical realism: A debate. Journal of Critical Realism1(2), May: 89-114.
7.
Bhaskar R. ( 2008) A Realist Theory of Science. London : Verso.
8.
Collier A. ( 1989) Scientific Realism and Socialist Thought. Hertfordshire: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
9.
Fine B. ( 2002) Addressing the critical and the real in critical realism . Dialogue in Economics, available upon request from <dialogue@herald.ox.ac.uk>.
10.
Fine B. ( 2004) Addressing the critical and the real in critical realism . In Lewis P (ed.) Transforming Economics. London: Routledge.
11.
Fleetwood S. ( 1999) Situating critical realism in economics. In Fleetwood S (ed.) Critical Realism in Economics, Development and Debate. London: Routledge.
12.
Guerrin B. ( 2004) Irrelevance and ideology. Post-Autistic Economics Review 29, December.
13.
Hands W. ( 1999) Empirical realism as meta-method: Tony Lawson on neoclassical economics. In Fleetwood S (ed.) Critical Realism in Economics, Development and Debate. London: Routledge.
14.
Hartwig M. ( 2000) Charging at red flags? Blind spots in Geoff Hodgson’s Promised Land. Alethia3(1), April: 36-40.
15.
Henry J. ( 1990) The Making of Neoclassical Economics. Boston: Unwin Hyman.
16.
Hodgson G. ( 2004) On the problem of formalism in economics. Post-Autistic Economics Review28.
17.
Hosseini H. ( 1990) The archaic, the obsolete and the mythical in neoclassical economics: Problems with the rationality and optimizing assumptions of the Jevons-Marshallian system. American Journal of Economics and Sociology49(1): 81-92.
18.
Joseph J. ( 1998) In defense of critical realism. Capital & Class65: 73-107.
19.
Kanth R. ( 1999) Against Eurocentred epistemologies: A critique of science, realism and economics. In Fleetwood S (ed.) Critical Realism in Economics, Development and Debate. London: Routledge.
20.
Kaul N. ( 2002) A critical ‘post’ to critical realism. Cambridge Journal of Economics26: 709-726.
21.
Lawson T. ( 1994) A realist theory for economics. In Backhouse R (ed.) New Directions in Economic Methodology . London: Routledge.
22.
Lawson T. ( 1997) Economics and Reality. London: Routledge.
23.
Lawson T. ( 1999a) Developments in economics as realist social theory. In Fleetwood S (ed.) Critical Realism in Economics, Development and Debate. London: Routledge.
24.
Lawson T. ( 1999b) Critical issues in economics as realist social theory . In Fleetwood S (ed.) Critical Realism in Economics, Development and Debate. London: Routledge.
25.
Lawson T. ( 2003) Reorienting Economics. London: Routledge.
26.
Lawson T. ( 2005) The nature of heterodox economics. Cambridge Journal of Economics30(4): 483-505; published online 9 Dec 2005.
27.
Lukács G. ( 1971) History and Class Consciousness. London : Merlin Press.
28.
Nielsen P. ( 2002) Reflections on critical realism in political economy. Cambridge Journal of Economics26: 727-738.
29.
Nielsen P., Morgan J. ( 2006) From mainstream economics to the boundaries of Marxism . Capital & Class89: 91-120.
30.
Pressman S.(2004-5) The two dogmas of neoclassical economics. Science and Society68: 483-493.
31.
Samuelson P. ( 1955) Professor Samuelson on operationalism in economic theory: A comment. Quarterly Journal of Economics69(2), May: 310-314.
32.
Samuelson P. ( 1957) Wages and interest: A modern discussion of Marxian economic models. American Economic Review47: 884-912.
33.
Seligman B. ( 1967) On the question of operationalism. American Economic Review57(1), March: 146-161.
34.
Sraffa P. ( 1960) Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities: Prelude to a Critique of Economic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
Steinmetz G., Chae OB ( 2002) Sociology in an era of fragmentation: From the sociology of knowledge to the philosophy of science, and back again. Sociological Quarterly43(1): 111-137.
