Understanding the sediment delivery process at the drainage basin scale remains a challenge in erosion and sedimentation research. In the absence of reliable spatially distributed process-based models for the prediction of sediment transport at the drainage basin scale, area-specific sediment yield (SSY; t km—2 y—1) is often assumed to decrease with increasing drainage basin area (A). As the measurement of A is relatively simple, this assumption is frequently used for prediction of SSY in ungauged basins. However, over the last two decades several studies reported a positive or non-linear relation between A and SSY. Various authors have suggested diverse explanations for these opposing trends. This paper provides an overview of the different observed trends and summarizes the explanations for each trend. Furthermore, three typical trends are identified to conceptualize the main driving forces of the relation between A and SSY. First of all, it is emphasized that erosion and sediment deposition processes are scale dependent, and going from small (<m2) to larger areas (km2) more erosion processes become active leading to a rise in SSY with increasing A. However, for larger areas (>km2) erosion rates generally decrease and deposition in sediment sinks increases due to decreasing slope gradients, and so SSY decreases with increasing A. Next, land-cover conditions and human impact determine if hillslope erosion is dominant over channel erosion or vice versa. In the first case, SSY is expected to decrease with increasing A, while in the latter case SSY will show a continuous positive relation with A. Only for very large areas (A > ~104 km2) a decrease in SSY is observed when drainage density decreases or channel banks are stabilized. Finally, spatial patterns in lithology, land cover, climate or topography can cause SSY to increase or decrease at any basin area and can therefore result in non-linear relations with A. Altogether, with increasing A often first a rise and then a decrease in SSY is observed. The decrease can be absent or can be postponed within a region due to local factors of which lithology, land cover, climate and topography are the most important ones. The large regional, local and even temporal variability in the trend between A and SSY implies that prediction of SSY based on A alone is troublesome and preferably spatially distributed information on land use, climate, lithology, topography and dominant erosion processes is required.
Albergel, J. , Nasri, N. , Boufaroua, M. and Pepin, Y.2000: Bilan de l'erosion sur les petits bassins versants des lacs collinaires de la dorsale Tunisienne, Séminaire International Montpellier 2000 Hydrologie des Régions Méditerranéennes . Programme Hydrologique International, Documents Techniques en Hydrologie51, 63—70 .
2.
Arabkhedri, M. , Valikhojieni, A. , Hakimkhani, S. , Charkhabi, A.H. and Telvari, A.2004: Estimating and mapping of sediment yield for Iran, Final research report. Soil Conservation and Watershed ManagementResearch Institute .
3.
Avendaño Salas, C. , Sanz Montero, E. and Gómez Montaña, J.L.1997: Sediment yield at Spanish reservoirs and its relationship with the drainage basin area, Dix-neuvième Congrès des Grands Barrages. Florence: Commission Internationale De Grands Barrages , 863—74.
4.
Basso, F. , Pisante, M. and Basso, B.2002: Soil erosion and land degradation. In Geeson, N.A. , Brandt, C.J. and Thornes, J.B. , editors, Mediterranean desertification: a mosaic of processes and responses, Chichester: Wiley , 347—59.
5.
Bazzoffi, P.1987: Previsione dell'interrimento nei serbatoi artificiali italiani — modello P.I.S.A . Idrotecnica1, 5—17 .
6.
Bazzoffi, P. , Baldassarre, G. , Pellegrini, S. and Bassignana, A.1997: Models for prediction of water storage decrease in Italian reservoirs . In Shady, A.M., Kassem, A., Delize, C.E. and Bouchard, M.A., editors, Proceedings of the IX World Water Congress IWRA, 249—52.
7.
Bazzoffi, P. , Baldassarre, G. and Vacca, S.1996: Validation of PISA2 model for automatic assessment of reservoir sedimentation. In Albertson, M. , editor, International conference on reservoir sedimentation , Colorado State University , 519—28.
8.
Bergkamp, G.1998: A hierarchical view of the interactions of runoff and infiltration with vegetation and microtopography in semiarid shrublands . Catena33, 201—20 .
9.
Birkinshaw, S.J. and Bathurst, J.C.2006: Model study of the relationship between sediment yield and river basin area . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms31, 750—61 .
10.
Boix-Fayos, C. , Martinez-Mena, M. , Arnau-Rosalen, E. , Calvo- Cases, A. , Castillo, V. and Albaladejo, J.2006: Measuring soil erosion by field plots: understanding the sources of variation . Earth-Science Reviews78, 267—85 .
11.
Boix-Fayos, C. , Martínez-Mena, M. , Calvo-Cases, A. , Arnau-Rosalén, E. , Albaladejo, J. and Castillo, V.2007: Causes and underlying processes of measurement variability in field erosion plots in Mediterranean conditions . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms32, 85—101 .
12.
Boyce, R.C.1975: Sediment routing with sediment delivery ratios, present and prospective technology for predicting sediment yields and sources. US Department of Agriculture , 61—65.
13.
Brath, A. , Castellarin, A. and Montanari, A.2002: Assessing the effects of land-use changes on annual average soil losses . Hydrology and Earth Systems Sciences6, 255—65 .
14.
Calvo-Cases, A. , Boix-Fayos, C. and Imeson, A.C.2003: Runoff generation, sediment movement and soil water behaviour on calcareous (limestone) slopes of some Mediterranean environments in southeast Spain . Geomorphology50, 269—91 .
15.
Caredda, S. , Porqueddu, C. , Sulas, L. , Solinas, V. and Bazzoni, A.1997: Analisi ambientale di sistemi cerealicolo-zootecnici sardi: aspetti erosivi Nota I . Agricoltura Ricerca170, 43—50 .
16.
Chaplot, V. and Le Bissonnais, Y.2000: Field measurements of interrill erosion under different slopes and plot sizes . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms25, 145—53 .
17.
Church, M. and Slaymaker, H.O.1989: Disequilibrium of Holocene sediment yield in glaciated British Columbia . Nature337, 452—54 .
18.
Church, M. , Ham, D. , Hassan, M. and Slaymaker, H.O.1999: Fluvial clastic sediment yield in Canada: scaled analysis . Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences36, 1267—80 .
19.
de Araújo, J.C. and Knight, D.W.2005: A review of the measurement of sediment yield in different scales . REM: Revista Escola de Minas, Ouro Preto58, 257—65 .
20.
de Vente, J. and Poesen, J.2005: Predicting soil erosion and sediment yield at the basin scale: scale issues and semi-quantitative models . Earth-Science Reviews71, 95—125 .
21.
de Vente, J. , Poesen, J. , Bazzoffi, P. , Van Rompaey, A. and Verstraeten, G.2006: Predicting catchment sediment yield in Mediterranean environments: the importance of sediment sources and connectivity in Italian drainage basins . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms31, 1017—34 .
22.
Dedkov, A.P.2004: The relationship between sediment yield and drainage basin area. In Golosov, V. , Belyaev, V. and Walling, D.E. , editors, Sediment transfer through the fluvial system , Moscow: IAHS publication 288, 197—204.
23.
Dedkov, A.P. and Moszherin, V.T.1992: Erosion and sediment yield in mountain areas of the world . In Walling, D.E. , Davies, T.R. and Hasholt, B. , editors, Erosion, debris flows and environment in mountain regions , Chengdu: IAHS publication 209, 29—36.
24.
Dendy, F.E. and Bolton, G.C.1976: Sediment yield-runoff-drainage area relationships in the United States . Journal of Soil and Water Conservation31, 264—66 .
25.
Desmet, P.J.J. , Poesen, J. , Govers, G. and Vandaele, K.1999: Importance of slope gradient and contributing area for optimal prediction of the initiation and trajectory of ephemeral gullies . Catena37, 377—92 .
26.
Einsele, G. and Hinderer, M.1997: Terrestrial sediment yield and the lifetime of reservoirs, lakes, and larger basins . Geologische Rundschau86, 288—310 .
27.
Evans, R.1995: Some methods of directly assessing water erosion of cultivated land — a comparison of measurements made on plots and in fields. Progress in Physical Geography19, 115—29 .
28.
Ewen, J. , Parkin, G. and O'Connell, P.E.2000: SHETRAN: Distributed River Basin Flow and Transport Modeling System . Journal of Hydrologic Engineering5, 250—58 .
29.
Fang, H. , Chen, H. , Cai, Q. and Li, Q.2006: Scale effect on sediment yield from sloping surfaces to basins in hilly loess region on the Loess Plateau in China . Environmental Geology, DOI: 10.1007/s00254-006-0513-9.
30.
Fox, H.R. , Moore, H.M. , Newell Price, J.P. and El Kasri, M.1997: Soil erosion and reservoir sedimentation in the High Atlas Mountains, southern Morocco. In Walling, D.E. and Probst, J.L. , editors, Rabat symposium, Rabat: IAHS publication 245, 233—40.
31.
García Ruiz, J.M. , Lana Renault, N. , Beguería, S. , Valero Garcés, B. L., Lasanta, T. , Arnáez, J. , López Moreno, J.I. , Regüés, D. and Marti Bono, C.2004: Temporal and spatial interactions of slope and catchment processes in the central Spanish Pyrenees. In Golosov, V. , Belyaev, V. and Walling, D.E. , editors, Sediment transfer through the fluvial system, Moscow: IAHS publication 288, 21—28.
32.
Gögüs, M. and Yener, A.G.1997: Estimation of sediment yield rates of reservoirs in Turkey, Dix-neuvième Congrès des Grands Barrages. Florence: Commission Internationale De Grands Barrages , 1265—76.
33.
Gottschalk, L.C.1957: Problems of predicting sediment yields from watersheds . Transactions of the American Geophysical Union38, 885—88 .
34.
Haregeweyn, N. , Poesen, J. , Nyssen, J. , de Wit, J. , Haile, M. , Govers, G. and Deckers, S.2006: Reservoirs in Tigray (Northern Ethiopia): characteristics and sediment deposition problems . Land Degradation and Development17, 211—30 .
35.
Haregeweyn, N. , Poesen, J. , Nyssen, J. , Verstraeten, G. , de Vente, J. , Govers, G. , Deckers, S. and Moeyersons, J.2005: Specific sediment yield in Tigray-Northern Ethiopia: assessment and semi-quantitative modelling . Geomorphology69, 315—31 .
36.
Inbar, M.1992: Rates of fluvial erosion in basins with a Mediterranean type climate . Catena19, 393—409 .
37.
Jiongxin, X. and Yunxia, Y.2005: Scale effects on specific sediment yield in theYellow River basin and geomorphological explanations. Journal ofHydrology307, 219—32 .
38.
Kirchner, J.W. , Finkel, R.C. , Riebe, C.S. , Granger, D.E. , Clayton, J.L. , King, J.G. and Megahan, W.F.2001: Mountain erosion over 10 yr, 10 k.y., and 10 m.y. time scales . Geology29, 591—94 .
39.
Krishnaswamy, J. , Richter, D.D. , Halpin, P.N. and Hofmockel, M.S.2001: Spatial pattern of suspended sediment yields in a humid tropical watershed in Costa Rica . Hydrological Processes15, 2237—57 .
40.
Lahlou, A.1996: Environmental and socio-economic impacts of erosion and sedimentation in North Africa. In Walling, D.E. and Webb, B.W. , editors, Erosion and sediment yield: global and regional perspectives, Exeter: IAHS publication 236, 491—500.
41.
Lane, L.J. , Hernandez, M. and Nichols, M.1997: Processes controlling sediment yield from watersheds as function of spatial scale . Environmental Modelling and Software12, 355—69 .
42.
Le Bissonnais, Y. , Benkhadra, H. , Chaplot, V. , Fox, D. , King, D. and Daroussin, J.1998: Crusting, runoff and sheet erosion on silty loamy soils at various scales and upscaling from m2 to small catchments . Soil and Tillage Research46, 69—80 .
43.
Lim, K.J. , Sagong, M. , Engel, B.A. , Tang, Z. , Choi, J. and Kim, K.-S.2005: GIS-based sediment assessment tool . Catena64, 61—80 .
44.
Lu, H. , Moran, C.J. and Prosser, I.P.2006: Modelling sediment delivery ratio over the Murray Darling Basin . Environmental Modelling and Software21, 1297—308 .
45.
Lu, H. , Moran, C.J. and Sivapalan, M.2005: A theoretical exploration of catchment-scale sediment delivery . Water Resources Research41, W09415.
46.
Maner, S.B.1958: Factors affecting sediment delivery rates in the Red Hills physiographic area . Transactions of the American Geophysical Union39, 669—75 .
47.
Merritt, W.S. , Letcher, R.A. and Jakeman, A.J.2003: A review of erosion and sediment transport models . Environmental Modelling and Software18, 761—99 .
48.
Milliman, J.D. and Meade, R.H.1983: World wide delivery of river sediment to the oceans . The Journal of Geology91, 1—21 .
49.
Milliman, J.D. and Syvitski, J.P.M.1992: Geomorphic/tectonic control of sediment discharge to the ocean: the importance of small mountainous rivers . The Journal of Geology100, 525—44 .
50.
Montgomery, D.R.2001: Slope distributions, threshold hillslopes and steady state topography . American Journal of Science301, 432—54 .
51.
Montgomery, D.R. and Dietrich, W.E.1994: Landscape dissection and drainage area-slope thresholds . In Kirkby, M. , editor, Process models and theorethical geomorphology, Chichester : Wiley , 221—46.
52.
Osterkamp, W.R. and Toy, T.J.1997: Geomorphic considerations for erosion prediction. EnvironmentalGeology29, 152—57 .
53.
Parsons, A. , Wainwright, J. , Powel, D.M. , Kaduk, J. and Brazier, R.E.2004: A conceptual model for determining soil erosion by water . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms29, 1293—302 .
54.
Parsons, A.J. , Brazier, R.E. , Wainwright, J. and Powell, D.M.2006a: Scale relationships in hillslope runoff and erosion . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms31, 1384—93 .
55.
Parsons, A.J. , Wainwright, J. , Brazier, R.E. and Powell, D.M.2006b: Is sediment delivery a fallacy?Earth Surface Processes and Landforms31, 1325—28 .
56.
Poesen, J. and Hooke, J.M.1997: Erosion, flooding and channel management in Mediterranean environments of southern Europe. Progress in Physical Geography21, 157—99 .
57.
Poesen, J. , Nachtergaele, J. , Verstraeten, G. and Valentin, C.2003: Gully erosion and environmental change: importance and research needs . Catena50, 91—133 .
58.
Poesen, J. , Vandaele, K. and van Wesemael, B.1996: Contribution of gully erosion to sediment production on cultivated lands and rangelands. In Walling, D.E. and Webb, B.W. , editors, Erosion and sediment yield: global and regional perspectives, Exeter: IAHS symposium 236, 251—66.
59.
Porqueddu, C. and Roggero, P.P.1994: Effetto delle tecniche agronomiche di intensificazione foraggera sui fenomeni erosivi dei terreni in pendio in ambiente mediterraneo . Rivista di Agronomia28, 364—70 .
60.
Prosser, I.P. , Rutherfurd, I.D. , Olley, J.M. , Young, W.J. , Wallbrink, P.J. and Moran, C.J.2001: Large-scale patterns of erosion and sediment transport in river networks, with examples from Australia . Marine Freshwater Research52, 81—99 .
61.
Radoane, M. and Radoane, N.2005: Dams, sediment sources and reservoir silting in Romania . Geomorphology71, 112—25 .
62.
Renschler, C.S. and Harbor, J.2002: Soil erosion assessment tools from point to regional scales — the role of geomorphologists in land management research and implementation . Geomorphology47, 189—209 .
63.
Renwick, W.H. and Andereck, Z.D.2006: Reservoir sedimentation trends in Ohio, USA: sediment delivery and response to land-use change. In Rowen, J.S. , Duck, R.W. and Werritty, S. , editors, Sediment dynamics and the hydromorphology of fluvial systems, Dundee: IAHS publication 306, 341—47.
64.
Renwick, W.H. , Smith, S.V. , Bartley, J.D. and Buddemeier, R.W.2005: The role of impoundments in the sediment budget of the conterminous United States . Geomorphology71, 99—111 . Restrepo, J.D. , Kjerfve, B. , Hermelin, M. and Restrepo, J.C.2006: Factors controlling sediment yield in a major South American drainage basin: the Magdalena River, Colombia . Journal of Hydrology316, 213—32 .
65.
Rivoira, G. , Roggero, P.P. and Bullitta, S.1989: Influenza delle tecniche di miglioramento dei pascolo sui fenomeni erosivi dei terreni in pendio . Rivista di Agronomia23, 372—77 .
66.
Schaller, M. , von Blanckenburg, F. , Hovius, N. and Kubik, P.W.2001: Large-scale erosion rates from in situ-produced cosmogenic nuclides in European river sediments . Earth and Planetary Science Letters188, 441—58 .
67.
Schiefer, E. , Slaymaker, H.O. and Klinkenberg, B.2001: Physiographically controlled allometry of specific sediment yield in the Canadian cordillera: a lake sediment-based approach . Geografiska Annaler83A, 55—65 .
68.
Schumm, S.A.1977: The fluvial system. New York: Wiley , 338 pp.
69.
Schumm, S.A. , Mosley, M.P. and Zimpfer, G.L.1976: Unsteady state denudation . Science191, 871 .
70.
Slaymaker, O.2006: Towards the identification of scaling relations in drainage basin sediment budgets . Geomorphology80, 8—19 .
71.
Slaymaker, O. , Souch, C. , Menounos, B. and Filippelli, G.2003: Advances in Holocene mountain geomorphology inspired by sediment budget methodology . Geomorphology55, 305—16 .
72.
Summerfield, M.A. and Hulton, N.J.1994: Natural controls of fluvial denudation rates in major world drainage basins . Journal of Geophysical Research99(B7), 871-83 .
73.
Syvitski, J.P.M. , Peckham, S.D. , Hilberman, R. and Mulder, T.2003: Predicting the terrestrial flux of sediment to the global ocean: a planetary perspective . Sedimentary Geology162, 5—24 .
74.
Syvitski, J.P.M. , Vorosmarty, C.J. , Kettner, A.J. and Green, P.2005: Impact of humans on the flux of terrestrial sediment to the global coastal ocean . Science308(5720), 376—80 .
75.
Tamburino, V. , Barbagallo, S. and Vella, P.1990: Evaluation of sediment deposition in Sicilian artificial reservoirs. In Sinniger, R.O. and Monbaron, M. , editors, Hydrology in mountainous regions II: artificial reservoirs, water and slopes, Lausanne : IAHS publication 194, 113—20.
76.
Tidjani, A.E.B. , Yebdri, D. and Cherif, E.A.1998: Ampleur de l'envasement dans les barrages Algeriens . In Phi, editor, Séminaire international annuel du Groupe AMHY de FRIEND, Rapport annuel 6 (1997—1998) , PHI-V, Unesco , Documents techniques en hydrologie29, 212—28 .
77.
Trimble, S.W.1975: Denudation studies: can we assume stream steady state?Science188, 1207—208 .
78.
Trimble, S.W.1999: Decreased rates of alluvial sediment storage in the Coon Basin, Wisconsin, 1975—93 . Science285, 1244—46 .
79.
Trimble, S.W. and Crosson, P.2000: LAND USE: USA soil erosion rates — myth and reality . Science289(5477), 248—50 .
80.
Trimble, S.W. and Lund, S.W.1982: Soil conservation and the reduction of erosion and sedimentation in the Coon Creek Basin, Wisconsin. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1234, 35.
81.
Vacca, A. , Puddu, R. , Tommasi, D. and Usai, D.1994: Erosion measurements in three areas of Santa Lucia catchment with different land uses. In Enne, G. , Pulina, G. and Aru, A. , editors, Land use and soil degradation, Sassari (Italy): MEDALUS in Sardinia , 115—27.
82.
van Dijk, A.I.J.M. and Bruijnzeel, L.A.S.2005: Key controls and scale effects on sediment budgets: recent findings in agricultural upland Java, Indonesia . In Walling, D.E. and Horowitz, A.J. , editors, Sediment budgets 2, Foz do Iguacu, Brazil: IAHS publication 292, 24—31.
83.
Vandekerckhove, L. , Poesen, J. , Oostwoud Wijdenes, D. , Nachtergaele, J. , Kosmas, C. , Roxo, M.J. and de Figueiredo, T.2000: Thresholds for gully initiation and sedimentation in Mediterranean Europe . Earth Surface Processes and Landforms25, 1201—20 .
84.
Vanoni, V.A.1977: Sedimentation engineering. ASCE manuals and reports on engineering practice 54, 745.
85.
Vanwalleghem, T. , Poesen, J. , Nachtergaele, J. and Verstraeten, G.2005: Characteristics, controlling factors and importance of deep gullies under cropland on loess-derived soils . Geomorphology69, 76—91 .
86.
Verstraeten, G. and Poesen, J.2001: Factors controlling sediment yield from small intensively cultivated catchments in a temperate humid climate . Geomorphology40, 123—44 .
87.
Verstraeten, G. , Bazzoffi, P. , Lajczak, A. , Radoane, M. , Rey, F. , Poesen, J. and de Vente, J.2006: Reservoir and pond sedimentation in Europe. In Boardman, J. and Poesen, J. , editors, Soil erosion in Europe, Chichester: Wiley .
88.
Walling, D.E.1983: The sediment delivery problem. Journal ofHydrology65, 209—37 .
89.
Walling, D.E.1999: Linking land use, erosion and sediment yields in river basins . Hydrobiologia410, 223—40 .
90.
Walling, D.E. and Kleo, A.H.A.1979: Sediment yields of rivers in areas of low precipitation: a global view. In Iahs , editor, The hydrology of areas of low precipitation, Canberra: IAHS publication 128, 479—93.
91.
Walling, D.E. and Webb, B.W.1996: Erosion and sediment yield: a global overview. In Walling, D.E. and Webb, B.W. , editors, Erosion and sediment yield: global and regional perspectives, Exeter: IAHS publication 236, 3—19.
