Scholars often overlook key similarities between the narrative cycles of Gideon (Judg. 6.11–8.35) and Jephthah (Judg. 11.1–12.7). They are the only so-called judges who recall the exodus tradition and are the only men who are described as גבור חיל. Their cycles are the only places in the Hebrew Bible where גבור חיל is associated with the recalling of the exodus tradition. In this article, I read the stories of these two men together and argue that such unique parallels suggest a connection between masculinity and memory in Judges. I demonstrate that in instances where the ‘going up’ from Egypt is cited, only males are the agents of the action. Furthermore, two of the men who do refer to the exodus—Gideon and Jephthah—are described as גבור חיל, a title often linked to ideas of masculinity. This connection is further accentuated by the manner in which the Gideon and Jephthah cycles present the uneven nature of each judge’s demonstration of memory recollection, following the uneven demonstrations of other aspects of their masculinity, specifically: their relationships with women and other men, their posterity, and their persuasive skill. By examining the narratives’ philological features and integrating theoretical frameworks of memory and masculinist studies, I demonstrate how Gideon and Jephthah’s ability to recall the deliverance from Egypt is integral to the maintenance of their masculinity. This study invites a deeper analysis of under-examined parallels between Gideon and Jephthah and has ramifications for understanding memory’s role in Judges, the Hebrew Bible’s conceptions of masculinity, and the priorities of the scribes who produced the narratives.
AlbertzR (1992) A History of Israelite Religion in the Old Testament Period, vol. 1, From the Beginnings to the End of the Monarchy. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox.
2.
AssisE (2005) Self-Interest or Communal Interest: An Ideology of Leadership in the Gideon, Abimelech and Jephthah Narratives (Judg 6–12). Leiden: Brill.
3.
AssmannJ (1995) Collective Memory and Cultural Identity. Translated by John Czaplicka. New German Critique65: 125–33.
4.
AssmannJ (2011) Cultural Memory and Early Civilization: Writing, Remembrance, and Political Imagination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
5.
AuldAG (2011) I & II Samuel: A Commentary. Old Testament Library. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox.
6.
BergeK (2022) Cultural Memory, Identity, and the Past. In The Hunt for Ancient Israel: Essays in Honour of Diana V. Edelman, edited by Shafer-ElliottCynthiaJoachimsenKristinZviEhud BenVivianoPauline A.Sheffield: Equinox, pp. 455–75.
7.
BertheauE (1883) Das Buch der Richter und Ruth. Leipzig: S. Hirzel.
8.
BolingRG (1975) Judges: Introduction, Translation, and Commentary. Anchor Bible. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
9.
BrettlerMZ (2017) Happy Is the Man Who Fills His Quiver with Them (Ps. 127:5): Constructions of Masculinities in the Psalms. In Being a Man: Negotiating Ancient Constructs of Masculinity, edited by ZsolnayIlona. London: Routledge, pp. 198–220.
10.
BriggsW (2017) ‘A Man’s Gotta Do What a Man’s Gotta Do?’: The Criticism of Hegemonic Masculinity in Judges 19.1–20.7. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament42 (1): 51–71.
11.
BusterAE (2022) Remembering the Story of Israel: Historical Summaries and Memory Formation in Second Temple Judaism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
12.
ButlerTC (2009) Judges. Word Biblical Commentary 8. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan.
13.
CarmanJM (2019) Abimelech the Manly Man? Judges 9.1-57 and the Performance of Hegemonic Masculinity. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament43 (3): 301–16.
14.
CartledgeTW (1992) Vows in the Hebrew Bible and the Ancient Near East. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Series 147. Sheffield: JSOT Press.
15.
CharleboisJ (2011) Gender and the Construction of Dominant, Hegemonic, and Oppositional Femininities. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
16.
ChikeJC (2023) Judges 2:11–19: A Palimpsest of Political History. Journal of Biblical Literature142 (4): 567–88.
17.
ChisholmRBJr (2013) A Commentary on Judges and Ruth. Grand Rapids, MI: Kregel.
18.
CliftonBJ (2022) Family and Identity in the Book of Judges. Boston, MA: Brill.
19.
ClinesDJA (1995) Interested Parties: The Ideology of Writers and Readers of the Hebrew Bible. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press.
20.
ClinesDJA (2019) The Most High Male: Divine Masculinity in the Bible. In Hebrew Masculinities Anew, edited by CreangǎOvidiu. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, pp. 61–82.
ConnellRWMesserschmidtJW (2005) Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept. Gender and Society19 (6): 829–59.
23.
CraigKMJr (1998) Bargaining in Tov (Judges 11, 4-11): The Many Directions of So-called Direct Speech. Biblica79 (1): 76–85.
24.
De CastelbajacI (2007) Le Cycle de Gédéon ou la Condemnation du Refus de la Royauté, Vetus Testamentum57 (2): 145–61.
25.
DiPalmaBC (2010) De/Constructing Masculinity in Exodus1-4. In Men and Masculinity in the Hebrew Bible and Beyond, edited by CreangǎOvidiu. The Bible in the Modern World 33. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, pp. 36–53.
26.
DiPalmaBC (2018) Masculinities in the Court Tales of Daniel: Advancing Gender Studies in the Hebrew Bible. Routledge Studies in the Biblical World. London: Routledge.
27.
FarberZ (2023) Struck Down by a Woman: Abimelech’s Humiliating Intertextual Death. In Reading Gender in Judges: An Intertextual Approach, edited by BirdsongShelley L.de VosJ. CornelisKimHyun Chul Paul. Atlanta, GA: SBL Press, pp. 121–36.
28.
FrenchBA (2020) Voices from Below: The Role of Anonymous Women’s Opinion in the Birth of Israel’s Monarchy. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament44 (4): 563–74.
29.
GordonCH (1962) Before the Bible: The Common Background of the Greek and Hebrew Civilisations. London: Collins.
30.
HaddoxSE (2006) (E)Masculinity in Hosea’s Political Rhetoric. In Israel’s Prophets and Israel’s Past: Essays on the Relationship of Prophetic Texts and Israelite History in Honor of John H. Hayes, edited by KelleBrad E.MooreMegan Bishop. Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies 446. New York: T&T Clark, pp. 174–200.
31.
HaddoxSE (2010a) ‘The Lord Is with You, You Mighty Warrior’: The Question of Gideon’s Masculinity. Proceedings of the EGLBS & MWSBL30: 70–87.
32.
HaddoxSE (2010b) Favoured Sons and Subordinate Masculinities. In Men and Masculinity in the Hebrew Bible and Beyond, edited by CreangǎOvidiu. The Bible in the Modern World 33. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, pp. 2–19.
33.
HaddoxSE (2013) Gendering Violence and Violating Gender in Judges 4-5. Conversations with the Biblical World33: 67–81.
34.
HaddoxSE (2016) Masculinity Studies of the Hebrew Bible: The First Two Decades. Currents in Biblical Research14 (2): 176–206.
35.
HalbwachsM (1992) On Collective Memory. Translated by CoserLewis A.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
36.
HendelR (2001) The Exodus in Biblical Memory. Journal of Biblical Literature120 (4): 601–22.
37.
HoffnerHAJr (1966) Symbols for Masculinity and Femininity: Their Use in Ancient Near Eastern Sympathetic Magic Rituals. Journal of Biblical Literature85 (3): 326–34.
38.
KalmanofskyA (2017) Manoah, Manoah’s Wife, Samson, and Delilah. In Gender-Play in the Hebrew Bible: The Ways the Bible Challenges Its Gender Norms, edited by KalmanofskyAmy. London: Routledge, pp. 68–94.
39.
Lazarewicz-WyrzykowskaE (2010) Samson: Masculinity Lost (and Regained?). In Men and Masculinity in the Hebrew Bible and Beyond, edited by CreangǎOvidiu. The Bible in the Modern World 33. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, pp. 171–88.
40.
LipkaH (2014) Masculinities in Proverbs: An Alternative to the Hegemonic Ideal. In Biblical Masculinities Foregrounded, edited by CreangǎOvidiuSmitPeter-Ben. Hebrew Bible Monographs 62. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, pp. 86–103.
41.
LipkaH (2017) Shaved Beards and Bared Buttocks: Shaming and the Undermining of Masculine Performance in Biblical Texts. In Being a Man: Negotiating Ancient Constructs of Masculinity, edited by ZsolnayIlona. London: Routledge, pp. 176–97.
42.
MartinLR (2010) ‘Where Are All His Wonders?’: The Exodus Motif in the Book of Judges. Journal of Biblical and Pneumatological Research2: 87–109.
43.
MathiasS (2020) Paternity, Progeny, and Perpetuation: Creating Lives after Death in the Hebrew Bible. London: T&T Clark.
44.
MatthewsVH (2004) Judges and Ruth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
45.
MeyersC (1999) Mother to Muse: An Archaeomusicological Study of Women’s Performance in Ancient Israel. In Recycling Biblical Figures: Papers Read at NOSTER Colloquium in Amsterdam 12–13 May 1997, edited by BrennerAthalyaVan HentenJan Willem. Leiderdorp: Deo, pp. 50–77.
46.
MillerCL (2010a) Definiteness and the Vocative in Biblical Hebrew. Journal of Northwest Semitic Languages36 (1): 43–64.
47.
MillerCL (2010b) Vocative Syntax in Biblical Hebrew Prose and Poetry: A Preliminary Analysis. Journal of Semitic Studies55 (2): 347–64.
48.
MobleyG (2005) The Empty Men: The Heroic Tradition of Ancient Israel. New York: Doubleday.
49.
MurphyKJ (2015) Masculinity, Moral Agency, and Memory: The Spirit of the Deity in Judges, Samuel, and Beyond. Journal of the Bible and Its Reception2 (2): 175–96.
50.
MurphyKJ (2019) Rewriting Masculinity: Gideon, Men, and Might. New York: Oxford University Press.
51.
NelsonRD (2017) Judges: A Critical and Rhetorical Commentary. London: T&T Clark.
52.
NewsomCA (2014) Selective Recall and Ghost Memories: Two Aspects of Cultural Memory in the Hebrew Bible. In Memory and Identity in Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity: A Conversation with Barry Schwartz, edited by ThatcherTom. Atlanta, GA: Society of Biblical Literature, pp. 41–56.
53.
NiditchS (2008) Judges. Louisville: Westminster John Knox.
54.
NissinenM (2014) Biblical Masculinities: Musings on Theory and Agenda’. In Biblical Masculinities Foregrounded, edited by CreangǎOvidiuSmitPeter-Ben. Hebrew Bible Monographs 62. Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press, pp. 271–85.
55.
NissinenM (2017) Relative Masculinities in the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament. In Being a Man: Negotiating Ancient Constructs of Masculinity, edited by ZsolnayIlona. London: Routledge, pp. 221–47.
56.
PfohE (2023) Some Observations on Cultural Memory, the Hebrew Bible and the History of ‘Ancient Israel’. Old Testament Essays36 (3): 568–86.
57.
PioskeD (2015) Retracing a Remembered Past: Methodological Remarks on Memory, History and the Hebrew Bible. Biblical Interpretation23: 291–315.
58.
PoethigEB (1985) The Victory Song Tradition of the Women of Israel. PhD Dissertation, Union Theological Seminary, USA.
59.
PurcellRA (2020) Yhwh, Moses, and Pharaoh: Masculine Competition as Rhetoric in the Exodus Narrative. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament44 (4): 532–50.
60.
RossJL (2023) A People Heeds Not Scripture: Allusion in Judges. Eugene, OR: Pickwick.
61.
SassonJM (2014) Judges 1–12: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary. Anchor Bible 6D. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
62.
SchippersM (2007) Recovering the Feminine Other: Masculinity, Femininity, and Gender Hegemony. Theory and Society36 (1): 85–102.
SchneiderTJ (2024) A Gileadite Responder: Verbing the Character of Jephthah. In Characters and Characterization in the Book of Judges, edited by BodnerKeithJohnsonBenjamin J. M.London: T&T Clark, pp. 105–18.
65.
SchwartzB (2000) Abraham Lincoln and the Forge of Memory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
66.
ShectmanS (2023) ‘She Shall Be Burned with Fire’: Femininity and Intersectionality in the Bible’s Priestly Source. In The Pentateuch and Its Readers, edited by BadenJoel S.StackertJeffrey. Forschungen zum Alten Testament 170. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, pp. 237–54.
SmithMS (2014a) Warfare Song as Warrior Ritual. In Warfare, Ritual, and Symbol in Biblical and Modern Contexts, edited by KelleBrad E.AmesFrank RitchelWrightJacob L. Ancient Israel and Its Literature 18. Atlanta, GA: SBL Press, pp. 165–86.
69.
SmithMS (2014b) Poetic Heroes: Literary Commemorations of Warriors and Warrior Culture in the Early Biblical World. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
70.
SmithMSBloch-SmithE (2021) Judges 1: A Commentary on Judges 1:1–10:5. Hermeneia. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
71.
SpronkK (2019) Judges. Historical Commentary on the Old Testament. Leuven: Peeters.
72.
StoneK (1995) Gender and Homosexuality in Judges 19: Subject-Honor, Object-Shame?Journal for the Study of the Old Testament20 (67): 87–107.
73.
SweeneyMA (2023) 1–2 Samuel. New Cambridge Bible Commentary. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
74.
ThiedeB (2022) Male Friendship, Homosociality, and Women in the Hebrew Bible: Malignant Fraternities. London: Routledge.
75.
WilsonSM (2014) Samson the Man-Child: Failing to Come of Age in the Deuteronomistic History. Journal of Biblical Literature133 (1): 43–60.
76.
WilsonSM (2015) Making Men: The Male Coming-of-Age Theme in the Hebrew Bible. New York: Oxford University Press.
77.
WilsonSM (2020) Why Hebrew Bible Masculinity Studies and Childhood Studies Have Not Connected, and Why They Should. In Children and Methods: Listening To and Learning From Children in the Biblical World, edited by GarrowayKristine M.MartensJohn W. Brill’s Series in Jewish Studies 67. Leiden: Brill, pp. 35–52.
78.
WrightJL (2011) Making a Name for Oneself: Martial Valor, Heroic Death, and Procreation in the Hebrew Bible. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament36 (2): 131–162.
79.
WrightJL (2020) War, Memory, and National Identity in the Hebrew Bible. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
80.
ZsolnayI (2009) Do Divine Structures of Gender Mirror Mortal Structures of Gender? In In the Wake of Tikva Frymer-Kensky, edited by HollowayStevenScurlockJoAnnBealRichard. Gorgias Précis Portfolios 4. Piscataway, NJ: Gorgias, pp. 103–20.
