The Counsellors of the Lord in Isaiah 40—55: A Proposal to Understand their Role in the Literary Composition

Abstract

The presence of counsellors in Isaiah 40…55 is, although well-known, never explained satisfactorily. The main reason for this is the difficulty in giving meaning to the mutual relationship between the texts speaking of 'giving counsel' (41.28) or being 'a counsellor' (40.13; 46.11). This article seeks to provide a new understanding of the function of these counsellors, on the basis of a step-by-step examination of these texts, starting from the level of syntax via analyses of discourse and participants up to the level of the literary composition. These examinations make it clear that the counsellors of Yhwh play a prominent role in the disputation between Yhwh and Jacob/Israel about knowledge. In opposition to the counsellors of Jacob/Israel, Yhwh presents his own advisers: Wisdom (40.13), the failure of the idols (41.28), and Cyrus (46.11).

Keywords

counsellor corpus-linguistics Isaiah 40-55 knowledge literary composition syntactic construction textual hierarchy verbal valency.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1987 Jes 40,13-14-ein Schlüssel zur Einheit Deutero-Jesajas? , BN 37: 7-10.

Baltzer, K. 2001 Deutero-Isaiah: A Commentary on Isaiah 40-55 ( Minneapolis: Fortress Press [German original 1999]).

Boer, P.A.H. de 1955 The Counsellor , in M. Noth and D. Winton Thomas (eds.), Wisdom in Israel and in the Ancient Near East ( Festschrift H.H. Rowley ; VTSup, 3; Leiden: E.J. Brill): 42-71.

Cohen, M.B. 1972 Masoretic Accents as a Biblical Commentary , JANESCU 4: 2-11.

Dahood, M. 1973 The Breakup of Two Composite Phrases in Isaiah 40,13 , Bib 54: 537-38.

Driver, G.R. 1951 Hebrew Notes , VT 1: 241-50.

Dyk, J.W. , and E. Talstra 1999 Paradigmatic and Syntagmatic Features in Identifying Subject and Predicate in Nominal Clauses, in C.L. Miller (ed.), The Verbless Clause in Biblical Hebrew: Linguistic Approaches (Linguistic Studies in Ancient West Semitic, 1; Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns): 133-85.

Holter, K. 1993 The Wordplay on ‭לא‬ ("God") in Isaiah 45,20-21 , SJOT 7: 88-98.

Kaddari, M.Z. 1965 The Root TKN in the Qumran Texts , RevQ 18: 219-24.

10.

Koole, J.L. 1997 Isaiah. III.1. Isaiah 40-48 (Historical Commentary on the Old Testament; Kampen: Kok Pharos) .

11.

Korpel, M.C.A. , and J.C. de Moor 1998 The Structure of Classical Hebrew Poetry: Isaiah 40-55 (OTS, 41; Leiden: E.J. Brill).

12.

Leene, H. 1974 Universalism or Nationalism: Isaiah XLV 9-13 and its Context , Bijdragen 35: 309-34.

13.

Leene, H. 1987 De vroegere en de nieuwe dingen bij Deuterojesaja (Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit Press).

14.

Luyster, R. 1981 Wind and Water: Cosmogonic Symbolism in the Old Testament , ZAW 93: 1-10.

15.

Muilenburg, J. 1956 The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 4066 , in The Interpreters Bible, V ( New York: Abingdon Press): 381-773.

16.

Oosting, R.H. 2002 Returning (to) Zion: Isaiah 52.8 in Light of Verbal Valency Patterns, in F. Postma , K. Spronk , and E. Talstra (eds.), The New Things: Eschatology in Old Testament Prophecy ( Festschrift H. Leene ; Amsterdamse Cahiers voor Exegese van de Bijbel en zijn Tradities Supplement Series, 3; Maastricht: Shaker ): 159-66.

17.

Oswalt, J.N. 1998 The Book of Isaiah: Chapters 40-66 (NICOT; Grand Rapids : Eerdmans).

18.

Owens, R.J. 1989 The Early Syriac Text of Ben Sira in the Demonstrations of Aphrahat , JSS 34: 39-75.

19.

Rosenbaum, M. 1997 Word-Order Variation in Isaiah 40-55: A Functional Perspective (Studia Semitica Neerlandica, 36; Assen: Van Gorcum ).

20.

Talstra, E. 1999 Reading Biblical Hebrew Poetry-Linguistic Structure or Rhetorical Device? , JNSL 25: 101-26.

21.

Van Hecke, P.J. P. 2003 Searching for and Exploring Wisdom. A Cognitive-Semantic Approach to the Hebrew Verb hāqar in Job 28 , in E. van Wolde (ed.), Job 28: Cognition in Context (Biblical Interpretation, 64; Leiden: E.J. Brill): 139-62.

22.

Whybray, R.N. 1971 The Heavenly Counsellor in Isaiah xl 13-14: A Study of the Sources of the Theology of Deutero-Isaiah (SOTSMS, 1; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).