Changes in out of home care and permanence planning among young children in Scotland,2003 to 2017

Abstract

UK policy has increasingly promoted early intervention and permanence planning for children who experience, or are at risk of experiencing, abuse or neglect, raising the question of whether these practices have actually increased ‘on the ground.’ There is already evidence of growing early intervention in the form of out of home care, in England as well as Australia and Canada. However, we do not yet know whether this trend also exists in Scotland. Furthermore, there is no research investigating whether rates of permanence planning have changed anywhere in the UK or globally. The current study addressed these gaps through a comparison of two samples of children in Scotland: 110 children born in 2003 and 117 born in 2013, all of whom were placed under compulsory measures of supervision prior to three years of age. The 2013 cohort was significantly more likely than the 2003 cohort to be removed from their parents at birth, to reside away from parents throughout the first three years of life and to live apart from parents at three years of age. Significantly more of the 2013 cohort than the 2003 cohort had a plan for permanence by three years. These findings are consistent with the view that policy changes in the UK are affecting practice (although practice changes may have resulted from other sources as well/instead). The fall in parental care was largely compensated by an increase in the use of foster care, which has resource implications. Children removed from their parents at birth were usually not returned in the first three years of life, not raised by extended family members, and were separated from one or more siblings. This typically reduced instability for young children, but also entailed substantial birth family fragmentation. The impact on children and families of early removal into foster care must therefore be carefully assessed in light of the increasing prevalence of this practice in Scotland and elsewhere.

Keywords

Looked after children permanence Children’s Hearings System out of home care early intervention Scotland

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anthony

Meakings

Doughty

et al. (2016) Factors affecting adoption in Wales: predictors of variation in time between entry to care and adoptive placement. Children and Youth Services Review 67: 184–190.

Barn

(2006) Research and Practice Briefings: Children and Families – Improving services to meet the needs of minority ethnic children and families, London: DfES.

Biehal

Ellison

Baker

Sinclair

(2009) Characteristics, Outcomes and Meanings of Three Types of Permanent Placement: Adoption by strangers, adoption by carers and long-term foster care, London: DCSF.

Boddy

(2013) Understanding Permanence for Looked After Children: A review for the care inquiry, London: House of Commons.

Broadhurst

Alrouh

Yeend

et al. (2016) Connecting events in time to identify a hidden population: birth mothers and their children in recurrent care proceedings in England. British Journal of Social Work 45(8): 2241–2260.

Cabinet Office (2011) Early Intervention: The next steps. Available at: www.gov.uk/government/publications/early-intervention-the-next-steps.

Department for Education (2012) An Action Plan for Adoption: Tackling delay, London: DfE.

Department for Education (2015) The Children Act 1989 Guidance and Regulations, Volume 2: Care planning, placement and case review, London: DfE.

Department for Education and Skills (2006) Statistics of Education: Children Looked After by Local Authorities Year Ending 31 March 2005 Volume 1: National tables. Available at: http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/5330/1/vweb01-2005_1.pdf.

10.

Gilbert

(2012) A comparative study of child welfare systems: abstract orientations and concrete results. Children and Youth Services Review 34(3): 532–536.

11.

Gilbert

Fluke

O’Donell

et al. (2012) Child maltreatment: variation in trends and policies in six developed countries. The Lancet 379: 758–772.

12.

Gill

(2007) No Fear: Growing up in a risk averse society, London: Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation.

13.

Gilligan

Akhtar

(2006) Cultural barriers to the disclosure of child sexual abuse in Asian communities: listening to what women say. British Journal of Social Work 36(8): 1361–1377.

14.

Gupta

Blumhardt

(2016) Giving poverty a voice: families’ experiences of social work practice in a risk-averse child protection system. Families, Relationships and Societies 5(1): 163–172.

15.

Henderson G and Hanson L (2015) Child Protection Orders. Stirling: Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration. Available at: www.scra.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/Child-Protection-Orders-Research-Report-2015.pdf.

16.

Henderson

Hanson

Whitehead

(2011) Care and Permanence Planning for Looked After Children in Scotland, Stirling: Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration.

17.

Henderson

Woods

Kurlus

(2017) An Exploration of Ethnic Minority Communities’ Understanding and Awareness of Child Protection and the Children’s Hearings System in Scotland, Stirling: Scottish Children’s Reporter AdministrationAvailable at: www.scra.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Ethnic-Minority-Research.pdf.

18.

Jones

Henderson

(2017) Supporting Sibling Relationships of Children in Permanent Fostering and Adoptive Families. School of Social Work and Social Policy Research Briefing 1. Glasgow: University of Strathclyde.

19.

Kosonen

(1996) Maintaining sibling relationships: neglected dimension in child care practice. British Journal of Social Work 6(6): 809–822.

20.

Marsh

Brownea

Taylora

Davis

(2017) Characteristics and outcomes of newborns who entered into care (EIC) within 7 days of birth in NSW, Australia. Children and Youth Services Review 81: 261–267.

21.

McGrath-Lone

Dearden

Nasima

et al. (2016) Changes in first entry to out-of-home care from 1992 to 2012 among children in England. Child Abuse & Neglect 51: 163–171.

22.

McSherry

Fargas Malet

Weatherall

(2016) Comparing long-term placements for young children in care: Does placement type really matter? Children and Youth Services Review 69: 56–66.

23.

McSherry

Weatherall

Larkin

et al. (2010) Who goes where? Young children’s pathways through care in Northern Ireland. Adoption & Fostering 34(2): 23–37.

24.

Mitchell

Porter

(2016) Permanence and Care Excellence (PACE): Background, approach and evidence, University of Strathclyde Centre for Excellence for Looked After Children in Scotland (CELCIS).

25.

Munro ER and Hardy A (2007) Placement stability: a review of the literature. Available at: https://dspace.lboro.ac.uk/dspacejspui/bitstream/2134/2919/1/placementstabilitylitreview.pdf.

26.

National Records of Scotland (2017) Drug-related deaths in Scotland in 2016. Statistics of drug-related deaths in 2016 and earlier years, broken down by age, sex, selected drugs reported, underlying cause of death and NHS Board and Council areas. Available at: www.nrscotland.gov.uk/files//statistics/drug-related-deaths/drd2016/16-drug-rel-deaths.pdf.

27.

Norrie

(2013) Children’s Hearings in Scotland, 3rd edn. Edinburgh: W. Green.

28.

O’Donnell

Maclean

Sims

et al. (2016) Entering out-of-home care during childhood: cumulative incidence study in Canada and Australia. Child Abuse & Neglect 59: 78–87.

29.

Rubin

O’Reilly

ALR

Luan

Localio

(2007) The impact of placement stability on behavioral well-being for children in foster care. Pediatrics 119(2): 336–344.

30.

Ryan

Testa

(2005) Child maltreatment and juvenile delinquency: investigating the role of placement and placement instability. Children and Youth Services Review 27: 227–249.

31.

Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration (2017) Statistical Analysis. Available at: www.scra.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/SCRA-Full-Statistical-Analysis-2016-17.pdf.

32.

Scottish Government (2008) A Guide to Implementing Getting it Right for Every Child. Available at: www.gov.scot/resource/doc/238985/0065813.pdf.

33.

Scottish Government (2009) The Early Years Framework. Available at: www.gov.scot/Publications/2009/01/13095148/1.

34.

Scottish Government (2011) Guidance on the Looked After Children (Scotland) Regulations 2009 and the Adoption and Children (Scotland) Act 2007, Edinburgh: Scottish Government.

35.

Scottish Government (2015a) Getting it Right for Looked After Children and Young People: Early engagement, early permanence and improving the quality of care. Available at: www.gov.scot/Resource/0048/00489805.pdf.

36.

Scottish Government (2015b) Getting it Right for Looked After Children and Young People Strategy. Available at: www.gov.scot/Publications/2015/11/2344/0.

37.

Scottish Government (2017) Children’s Social Work Statistics 2015–16. Additional Tables. Available at: www.gov.scot/Topics/Statistics/Browse/Children/PubChildrenSocialWork/CSWSAT1516.

38.

Scottish Parliament (2013) Education and Culture Committee. 10^th Report, 2013 (Session 4). Report on decision-making on whether to take children into care. Edinburgh: Scottish Parliament.

39.

Sinclair

Baker

Wilson

Gibbs

(2005) Foster Children: Where they go and how they get on, London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

40.

Ubbesen

Gilbert

Thoburn

(2015) Cumulative incidence of entry into out-of-home care: changes over time in Denmark and England. Child Abuse & Neglect 42: 63–71.

41.

Ubbesen

Petersen

Mortensen

Kristensen

(2013) Temporal stability of entries and predictors for entry into out-of-home care before the third birthday: a Danish population-based study of entries from 1981 to 2008. Children and Youth Services Review 35: 1526–1535.

42.

Ward

Skuse

(2001) Performance targets and stability of placements for children long looked after away from home. Children & Society 15(5): 333–346.

43.

Webster

Barth

Needell

(2000) Placement stability for children in out-of-home care: a longitudinal analysis. Child Welfare 79: 614–632.

44.

Welch

Lerpiniere

Young

Sadler

Fitzpatrick

(2014) Overseen but Often Overlooked: Children and young people ‘looked after at home’, University of Strathclyde Centre for Excellence for Looked After Children in Scotland (CELCIS).

45.

Whelan

(2003) Using attachment theory when placing siblings in foster care. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal 20(1): 21–36.

46.

Wilkinson

Bowyer

(2017) The Impacts of Abuse and Neglect on Children; and Comparison of Different Placement Options: Evidence review, London: DfE.

47.

Woods

(2013) Children’s Moral Lives: An ethnographic and psychological approach, Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.

48.

Woods R, Henderson G, Kurlus I, et al. (2018) Complexity in the Lives of Looked After Children and their Families in Scotland: 2003 to 2016. Stirling: Scottish Children’s Reporter Administration. Available at www.scra.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Complexity-in-the-lives-of-looked-after-children-and-their-families.pdf.