Transnational labour migration and the offshoring of knowledge-intensive business services within global production networks: The case of a German automotive company in Turkey
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 2019
Transnational labour migration and the offshoring of knowledge-intensive business services within global production networks: The case of a German automotive company in Turkey
Even though labour has been an important research topic in the field of economic geography for many years, up to now little has been known about transnational labour migration of highly skilled employees in global production networks. This article examines the role and the impact of highly skilled (re-)migrants of Turkish origin who studied and/or worked in Germany for several years in knowledge-intensive business services (KIBS) offshoring. To do so we analyse the empirical case of a German automotive company that operates as a lead firm within a global automotive production network. The company has insourced enterprise resource planning (ERP) software services from their suppliers in Germany and offshored those to a captive offshore service centre in Istanbul (Turkey). Based on our empirical material, we found that highly skilled (re-)migrants of Turkish origin are used as boundary spanners to efficiently and effectively manage the knowledge transfers from the onshore organizations to the service centre in Istanbul. Thereby, highly skilled (re-)migrants of Turkish origin help to mitigate resistance and facilitate the dis- and re-embedding of knowledge within the offshoring process. The exploration of highly skilled labour migration from a transnational perspective contributes to the discussion about the role of labour in global production networks.
AlscherSBaraulinaTMüllerB (2014) ‘Exodus’ oder Normalität? Annäherung an Umfang und Struktur türkeistämmiger Abwanderung. In: AlscherSKreienbrinkA (eds) Abwanderung von Türkeistämmigen. Wer verlässt Deutschland und warum?
Nürnberg:
Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, pp.86–159.
2.
AltreiterCFibichTFleckerJ (2015) Capital and labour on the move: The dynamics of double transnational mobility. In: DrahokoupilJ (ed.) The Outsourcing Challenge: Organizing Workers across Fragmented Production Networks.
Brussels:
ETUI, pp.67–87.
3.
AminACohendetP (2004) Architectures of Knowledge: Firms, Capabilities and Communities.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
4.
AndersonV (2015)
International HRD and offshore outsourcing. Human Resource Development Review14(3): 259–278.
5.
AundheMDMathewSK (2009)
Risks in offshore IT outsourcing: A service provider perspective. European Management Journal27(6): 418–428.
6.
Barner-RasmussenWEhrnroothMKoveshnikovA, et al. (2014)
Cultural and language skills as resources for boundary spanning within the MNC.Journal of International Business Studies45(7): 886–905.
7.
BeaverstockJV (1996)
Migration, knowledge and social interaction: Expatriate labour within investment banks. Area28(4): 459–470.
8.
BeerepootNHendriksM (2013)
Employability of offshore service sector workers in the Philippines: Opportunities for upward labour mobility or dead-end jobs?Work, Employment & Society27(5): 823–841.
9.
BeulenETiwariVvan HeckE. (2011)
Understanding transition performance during offshore IT outsourcing.Strategic Outsourcing: An International Journal4(3): 204–227.
10.
BollhornKFranzM (2015)
Production network knowledge as a foundation for resistance: Workers influence on a Chinese acquisition in Germany.Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie107(4): 407–420.
11.
BologaRLupuAR (2014)
Organizational learning networks that can increase the productivity of IT consulting companies: A case study for ERP consultants.Expert Systems with Applications41(1): 126–136.
12.
BoschmaR (2005)
Proximity and innovation: A critical assessment.Regional Studies39(1): 61–74.
13.
Botta-GenoulazVMilletA (2006)
An investigation into the use of ERP systems in the service sector.International Journal of Production Economics99(1–2): 202–221.
14.
Braun B and Fuchs M (2013) Europäische Automobilindustrie: Neuere Entwicklungen und Herausforderungen. Geographische Rundschau 65(6): 4--11.
15.
BrownJSDuguidP (2001)
Knowledge and organization: A social-practice perspective.Organization Science12(2): 198–213.
16.
BunnellTGCoeNM (2001)
Spaces and scales of innovation.Progress in Human Geography25(4): 569–589.
17.
ChenJMcQueenRJSunPY (2013)
Knowledge transfer and knowledge building at offshored technical support centers.Journal of International Management19(4): 362–376.
18.
ChoudhuryP (2016)
Return migration and geography of innovation in MNEs: A natural experiment of knowledge production by local workers reporting to return migrants.Journal of Economic Geography16(3): 585–610.
19.
ChuaAPanS (2008)
Knowledge transfer and organizational learning in IS offshore sourcing.Omega36(2): 267–281.
20.
CiriaciDMontresorSPalmaD (2015)
Do KIBS make manufacturing more innovative? An empirical investigation of four European countries.Technological Forecasting and Social Change95: 135–151.
21.
CoeNM (2014)
Missing links: Logistics, governance and upgrading in a shifting global economy. Review of International Political Economy21(1): 224–256.
22.
Coe NM and Bunnell TG (2003) ‘Spatializing’ knowledge communities: towards a conceptualization of transnational innovation networks. Global Networks 3(4): 437--456.
23.
CoeNMHessM (2013)
Global production networks, labour and development.Geoforum44: 4–9.
24.
CoeNMYeungHWC (2015) Global Production Networks: Theorizing Economic Development in an Interconnected World.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
25.
CohenWMLevinthalDA (1990)
Absorptive capacity: A new perspective on learning and innovation.Administrative Science Quarterly35(1): 128–152.
26.
ContractorFJKumarVKunduSK, et al. (2010)
Reconceptualizing the firm in a world of outsourcing and offshoring: The organizational and geographical relocation of high-value company functions. Journal of Management Studies47(8): 1417–1433.
27.
CurrahAWrigleyN (2004)
Networks of organizational learning and adaptation in retail TNCs.Global Networks4(1): 1–23.
28.
DAAD (Deutscher Akademischer Austauschdienst) and DZHW (Deutsches Zentrum für Hochschul- und Wissenschaftsforschung) (2017) Wissenschaft weltoffen kompakt 2017. Facts and Figures on the International Nature of Study and Research in Germany. Available at: http://www.wissenschaftweltoffen.de/kompakt/wwo2017_kompakt_en.pdf (accessed 19 May 2017).
DepnerHBatheltH (2005)
Exporting the German model: The establishment of a new automobile industry cluster in Shanghai.Economic Geography81(1): 53–81.
31.
DogsonM (1993)
Learning, trust and technological collaboration. Human Relations46(1): 77–95.
32.
DossaniRKenneyM (2007)
The next wave of globalization: Relocating service provision to India.World Development35(5): 772–791.
33.
DuvivierFPeetersC (2011) The use of expatriates in the offshoring of services: Framework and research propositions. Working Paper 59(11). Brussels: Centre Emile Bernheim.
34.
EisenhardtKM (1989)
Building theories from case study research.Academy of Management Review14(4): 532–550.
35.
FarndaleEPaauweJHoeksemaL (2009)
In-sourcing HR: Shared service centres in the Netherlands.International Journal of Human Resource Management20(3): 544–561.
36.
FarrellD (2005)
Offshoring: Value creation through economic change.Journal of Management Studies42(3): 675–683.
37.
FaulconbridgeJR (2007)
Relational networks of knowledge production in transnational law firms.Geoforum38(5): 925–940.
FleckerJMeilP (2010)
Organisational restructuring and emerging service value chains: Implications for work and employment.Work, Employment and Society24(4): 680–698.
40.
FreemanRB (2010)
Globalization of scientific and engineering talent: International mobility of students, workers, and ideas and the world economy.Economics of Innovation and New Technology19(5): 393–406.
41.
FriedmanRAPodolnyJ (1992)
Differentiation of boundary spanning roles: Labor negotiations and implications for role conflict.Administrative Science Quarterly37(1): 28–47.
42.
FrostTSBirkinshawJMEnsignPC (2002)
Centers of excellence in multinational corporations.Strategic Management Journal23(11): 997–1018.
43.
FullerCPhelpsNA (2018)
Revisiting the multinational enterprise in global production networks.Journal of Economic Geography18(1): 139–161.
44.
GereffiGHumphreyJSturgeonT (2005)
The governance of global value chains.Review of International Political Economy12(1): 78–104.
45.
GertlerMS (2003)
Tacit knowledge and the economic geography of context, or the undefinable tacitness of being (there).Journal of Economic Geography3(1): 75–99.
46.
GregoryRBeckRPriflingM (2009) Breaching the knowledge transfer blockade in IT offshore outsourcing projects: A case from the financial services industry. In: Proceedings of the 42nd Hawaii international conference on system sciences, 5--8 January 2009, Piscataway, NJ: IEEE: 1–10.
HaasA (2015)
Crowding at the frontier: Boundary spanners, gatekeepers and knowledge brokers.Journal of Knowledge Management19(5): 1029–1047.
49.
HardyJHollinsheadG (2011)
The embeddedness of software development in the Ukraine: An offshoring country perspective. European Planning Studies19(9): 1633–1650.
50.
HendersonJDickenPHessM, et al. (2002)
Global production networks and the analysis of economic development. Review of International Political Economy9(3): 436–464.
51.
HessM (2004)
‘Spatial’ relationships? Towards a reconceptualization of embeddedness.Progress in Human Geography28(2): 165–186.
52.
HowellsJ (2012)
The geography of knowledge: Never so close but never so far apart.Journal of Economic Geography12(5): 1003–1020.
53.
IbertO (2007)
Towards a geography of knowledge creation: The ambivalences between ‘knowledge as an object’ and ‘knowing in practice’.Regional Studies41(1): 103–114.
54.
JensenPDØLarsenMMPedersenT (2013)
The organizational design of offshoring: Taking stock and moving forward.Journal of International Management19(4): 315–323.
55.
KlaggeBKlein-HitpaßK (2010)
High-skilled return migration and knowledge-based development in Poland.European Planning Studies18(10): 1631–1651.
56.
KleibertJM (2015)
Global production networks, offshore services and the branch–plant syndrome. Regional Studies50(12): 1–15.
57.
KleibertJM (2016)
Pervasive but neglected: Conceptualising services and global production networks.Geography Compass10(8): 333–345.
58.
KoDGKirschLJKingWR (2005)
Antecedents of knowledge transfer from consultants to clients in enterprise system implementations. MIS Quarterly29: 59–85.
59.
KostovaTRothK (2003)
Social capital in multinational corporations and a micro–macro model of its formation. Academy of Management Journal28(2): 297–317.
60.
KrancherOSlaughterS (2013) Governing individual learning in the transition phase of software maintenance offshoring: A dynamic perspective. In: The 33rd international conference on information systems, Wailea, Maui County, Hawai, USA, 7--10 January 2013, pp. 3543--3552. IEEE Xplore.
61.
LamA (2014)
Tacit knowledge, embedded agency and learning: Local nodes and global networks.Prometheus32(1): 93–99.
62.
LarsenMMManningSPedersenT (2013)
Uncovering the hidden costs of offshoring: The interplay of complexity, organizational design, and experience.Strategic Management Journal34(5): 533–552.
63.
LevinaNKaneAA (2010) Onshore immigrant managers as boundary spanners on offshored software development projects: Partners or bosses? Working Paper 2. Pullman, WA: Industry Studies Association.
64.
LorencASzkodaM (2015) Customer logistic service in the automotive industry with the use of the SAP ERP system. In: 4th IEEE international conference on advanced logistics and transport advanced logistics and transport (ICALT), Valenciennes, France, 20--22 May 2015, pp.18–23. IEEE Xplore.
65.
ManningSHutzschenreuterTStrathmannA (2012)
Emerging capability or continuous challenge? Relocating knowledge work and managing process interfaces.Industrial and Corporate Change22(5): 1159–1193.
66.
MaskellPPedersenTPetersenB, et al. (2007)
Learning paths to offshore outsourcing: From cost reduction to knowledge seeking. Industry and Innovation14(3): 239–257.
67.
MassiniSMiozzoM (2010)
Outsourcing and offshoring of business services: Challenges to theory, management and geography of innovation.Regional Studies46(9): 1219–1242.
68.
MayringP (2000)
Qualitative content analysis. Forum: Qualitative Social Research1: 20.
69.
Moe NB, Šmite D, Hanssen GK and Barney H (2014) From offshore outsourcing to insourcing and partnerships: Four failed outsourcing attempts. Empirical Software Engineering 19(5): 1225--1258.
70.
Müller P (2017) Gefragte Talente: Türkeistämmige Hochqualifizierte in deutschen Unternehmen in der Türkei. Standort 41(1): 27--32.
71.
MullerEZenkerA (2001)
Business services as actors of knowledge transformation: The role of KIBS in regional and national innovation systems.Research Policy30(9): 1501–1516.
72.
NorlanderP (2014)
Organizing migrations: People and knowledge flows in the global economy. PhD Thesis, University of California, USA.
73.
PluggeABrookJ (2012) Understanding resistance in IT outsourcing: A service provider perspective. In: KotlarskyJOshriIWilcocksLP (eds) The Dynamics of Global Sourcing: Perspectives and Practices.
Berlin:
Springer, pp.126–141.
74.
RainnieAHerodAMcGrath-ChampS (2011)
Review and positions: Global production networks and labour.Competition & Change15(2): 155–169.
75.
Raj-ReichertG (2013)
Safeguarding labour in distant factories: Health and safety governance in an electronics global production network.Geoforum44: 23–31.
76.
RuttenR (2017)
Beyond proximities.Progress in Human Geography41(2): 159–177.
77.
SaxenianA (2006) The New Argonauts: Regional Advantage in a Global Economy.
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
78.
SchampEWStammA (2012)
New trends in an old sector: Exploring global knowledge and HR management in MNCs and the North–South divide in human capital formation.Innovation and Development2(2): 285–302.
79.
SezerKDağlarN (2009) Die Identifikation der TASD mit Deutschland. Abwanderungsphänomen der TASD beschreiben und verstehen.
Krefeld/Dortmund:
Futureorg Institut.
80.
SiggelkowN (2007)
Persuasion with case studies.The Academy of Management Journal50(1): 20–24.
81.
StrambachS (2001) Innovation processes and the role of knowledge-intensive business services (KIBS). In: KoschatzkyKMKulickeMZenkerA (eds) Innovation Networks: Concepts and Challenges in the European Perspective.
Heidelberg:
Physica Verlag, pp.53–68.
82.
StringfellowATeagardenMBNieW (2008)
Invisible costs in offshoring services work.Journal of Operations Management26(2): 164–179.
83.
Tushman ML (1977) Special Boundary Roles in the Innovation Process. Administrative Science Quarterly 22(4): 587--605.
84.
VlaarPWvan FenemaPCTiwariV (2008)
Cocreating understanding and value in distributed work: How members of onsite and offshore vendor teams give, make, demand, and break sense. MIS Quarterly32(2): 227–255.
85.
von BaryBWestnerM (2018)
Information system backsourcing: A literature review. Journal of Information Technology Management29(1): 62–78.
86.
WangD (2015)
Activating cross-border brokerage: Interorganizational knowledge transfer through skilled return migration. Administrative Science Quarterly60(1): 133–176.
87.
WelchDEWelchLS (2008)
The importance of language in international knowledge transfer.Management International Review48(3): 339–360.
88.
WilliamsAM (2007)
International labour migration and tacit knowledge transactions: A multi-level perspective. Global Networks7(1): 29–50.
89.
YeungHWCCoeNM (2015)
Toward a dynamic theory of global production networks.Economic Geography91(1): 29–58.
90.
YinRK (2009) Case Study Research: Design and Methods.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE.
91.
YoungdahlWERamaswamyKDashKC (2010)
Service offshoring: The evolution of offshore operations.International Journal of Operations & Production Management30(8): 798–820.
92.
ZaheerSLaminASubramaniM (2009)
Cluster capabilities or ethnic ties? Location choice by foreign and domestic entrants in the services offshoring industry in India.Journal of International Business Studies40(6): 944–968.
