Crisis? What crisis? A critical appraisal of World Bank housing policy in the wake of the global financial crisis

Abstract

This paper critically assesses international policy advocacy on how to resolve massive shelter needs in the developing world. It does so by focusing on the World Bank as a leader in development. It argues that the Bank’s housing policy remains thoroughly limited by its persistent commitment to neoliberal and financialised policy practices. These put housing finance at the centre of attempts to relieve shelter needs in the developing world despite the dramatic failures of such an approach as laid bare through the global financial crisis. The paper takes a historical approach to examine the trajectory of World Bank housing policy and is based on close scrutiny of a combination of quantitative and qualitative data. It concludes that an urgent need persists for a decoupling of finance from housing in international policy advocacy.

Keywords

Housing housing finance World Bank neoliberal global financial crisis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aalbers

(2015) Introduction. Financialisation and housing studies. In: Aalbers

(ed.) The Financialisation of Housing, London and New York: Routledge.

Aalbers

(2017) Corporate financialisation. In: Richardson

Castree

Goodchild

et al. (eds) The International Encyclopedia of Geography: People, the Earth, Environment, and Technology, Oxford: Wiley. . Available at: www.academia.edu/7359027/Corporate_Financialization_includes_new_definition_of_financialization_.

Akyüz Y (2014) Internationalization of finance and changing vulnerabilities in Emerging and Developing Economies. In: United Nations conference on trade and development. Available at: http://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:unc:dispap:217.

Alacevich

(2009) The World Bank’s early reflections on development: A development institution or a bank? Review of Political Economy 21(2): 227–244.

Baken

van der Linden

(1993) ‘Getting the incentives right’: Banking on the formal private sector. A critique of World Bank thinking on low-income housing delivery in Third World cities. Third World Planning Review 15(1): 1–22.

Bateman

(2010) Why Doesn’t Microfinance Work? The Destructive Rise of Local Neoliberalism, London: Zed Books.

Bayliss K, Fine B and Van Waeyenberge E (eds) (2011) The Political Economy of Development: The World Bank, Neo-Liberalism and Development Research. London: Pluto Press.

Bayliss K, Fine B and Robertson M (2013) From financialisation to consumption: The systems of provision approach applied to housing and water. FESSUD Working Paper Series 2. Available at: www.fessud.eu.

Bayliss K and Van Waeyenberge E (2017) Unpacking the public private partnerships revival. The Journal of Development Studies. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00220388.2017.1303671.

10.

Bertaud

(1992) The impact of land-use regulations on land supply, consumption and price. Regional Development Dialogue 13: 35–40.

11.

Bratt

(2012) Home ownership as public policy in the United States. In: Ronald

Elsinga

(eds) Beyond Home Ownership. Housing, Welfare and Society, London and New York: Routledge.

12.

Buckley

(1999) Housing finance in developing countries: A review of the World Bank’s experience. In: Datta

Jones

(eds) Housing and Finance in Developing Countries, London and New York: Routledge.

13.

Buckley

Kalarickal

(2005) Housing policy in developing countries: Conjectures and refutations. World Bank Research Observer 20(2): 233–257.

14.

Buckley

Kallergis

Wainer

(2015) The Housing Challenge: Avoiding the Ozymandias Syndrome, New York: Rockefeller Foundation and New School.

15.

Buckley

Khadduri

Struyk

(1985) Housing Development Finance Corporation of India: Evaluation of the Housing Guarantee Loan, Washington, DC: USAID.

16.

Chiodelli

(2016) International housing policy for the urban poor and the informal city in the global South: A non-diachronic review. Journal of International Development 28: 788–807.

17.

Chiquier L and Lea M (eds) (2009) Housing Finance Policy in Emerging Markets. Washington: World Bank.

18.

Christophers

(2013) Banking across Boundaries, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

19.

Collier P and Venables A (2014) Housing and urbanization in Africa. Unleashing a formal market process. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 6871.

20.

Croese

Cirolia

Graham

(2016) Towards Habitat III: Confronting the disjunctures between global policy and local practice on Africa’s ‘challenge of slums’. Habitat International 53: 237–242.

21.

Datta

Jones

(2001) Housing and finance in developing countries: Invisible issues on research and policy agendas. Habitat International 25: 333–357.

22.

Desai

Loftus

(2012) Speculating on slums: Infrastructural fixes in informal housing in the Global South. Antipode 45(4): 789–808.

23.

Dimsky

(2012) The reinvention of banking and the subprime crisis: On the origins of subprime loans, and how economists missed the crisis. In: Aalbers

(ed.) Subprime Cities. The Political Economy of Mortgage Markets, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

24.

Doling

(2012) All That is Solid. The Great Housing Disaster, London: Penguin.

25.

Fine

(2001) Social Capital Versus Social Theory: Political Economy and Social Science at the Turn of the Millennium, London: Routledge.

26.

Fine

(2010) Flattening economic geography: Locating the World Development Report for 2009. Journal of Economic Analysis 1(1): 15–33.

27.

Fine B and Saad-Filho A (2016) Thirteen things you need to know about neoliberalism. Critical Sociology. https://doi.org/10.1177/0896920516655387.

28.

GAO (1995) Foreign Housing Guaranty Program. Financial condition is poor and goals are not achieved. United States General Accounting Office. Report to Congressional requesters.

29.

Gilbert

(2002) On the mystery of capital and the myths of Hernando de Soto: What difference does legal title make? International Development Planning Review 24: 1–20.

30.

Gotham

(2009) Creating liquidity out of spatial fixity: The secondary circuit of capital and the subprime mortgage market. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 33(2): 355–371.

31.

Gruffyd Jones B (2011) Civilising African cities: International housing policy from colonial to neoliberal times. DRAFT. Available at: www.open.ac.uk/socialsciences/bisa-africa/files/building-states-branwen-gruffydd-jones.pdf.

32.

Gruffyd Jones

(2012) ‘Bankable slums’: The global politics of slum upgrading. Third World Quarterly 33(5): 769–789.

33.

Gwinner B (2012) What does IFC look for in housing investments? Paper presented at the African Union for Housing Finance, Dar es Salaam. Available at: www.auhf.co.za/wordpress/assets/Day-1pm_Gwinner_300_IFC-AUHF-Oct-2012.pdf.

34.

Gwinner WB, Goldberg MJ, Solo TM, et al. (2005) From financial exclusion to inclusion. Increasing the availability of credit to the urban poor in Latin America. En Breve 98 World Bank. Available at: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTENBREVE/Newsletters/21217493/Nov06_98_FinExclSolov2.pdf.

35.

Harris

(1998) Viewpoint. A crank’s fate and the feting of a visionary: Reflections on the history of aided self-help housing. Third World Planning Review 20(3): iii–viii.

36.

Harris

Giles

(2003) A mixed message: The agents and forms of international housing policy, 1945–1973. Habitat International 27: 167–191.

37.

Harvey

(2009) Reshaping economic geography: The World Development Report 2009. Development and Change 40(6): 1269–1277.

38.

Harvey

(2013) Rebel Cities, London: Verso.

39.

IFC (2013) Housing finance factsheet. Available at: www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/015157004088487fb099b0cdd0ee9c33/HF-Factsheet2013.pdf?MOD=AJPERES.

40.

International Housing Coalition (IHC) (2008) Multilateral and bilateral funding of housing and slum upgrading development in developing countries. Available at: www.intlhc.org/docs/shea.pdf.

41.

Jones

Ward

(1994) The World Bank’s ‘new’ urban management programme: Paradigm shift or policy continuity? Habitat International 18(3): 33–51.

42.

Keivani

Werna

(2001) Modes of housing provision in developing countries. Progress in Planning 55: 65–118.

43.

Kumar

(2011) The research-policy dialectic. City 15(6): 662–673.

44.

LafargeHolcim (2016) Our value proposition to microfinance institutions and their borrowers. Presentation at the 7th Global Housing Finance Conference, May 25, World Bank Group, Washington, DC.

45.

Malpezzi

(1990) Urban housing and financial markets: Some international comparisons. Urban Studies 27: 971–1022.

46.

Malpezzi

(1994) ‘Getting the incentives right’. A reply to Robert-Jan Baken and Jan van der Linden. Third World Planning Review 16(4): 451–466.

47.

Mayo

Malpezzi

Gross

(1986) Shelter strategies for the urban poor in developing countries. World Bank Research Observer 1: 183–203.

48.

Mitlin

(1999) Housing finance and non-governmental organisations in developing countries. In: Datta

Jones

(eds) Housing and Finance in Developing Countries, London and New York: Routledge.

49.

Ortiz I and Cummins M (2013) The age of austerity: A review of public expenditures and adjustment measures in 181 Countries. Initiative for Policy Dialogue and the South Centre Working Paper March 2013.

50.

Otiso

(2003) State, voluntary and private sector partnerships for slum upgrading and basic service delivery in Nairobi City, Kenya. Cities 20(4): 221–229.

51.

Owusu G (2011) Urban growth, globalization and access to housing in Ghana’s largest metropolitan area, Accra. Paper presented at ECAS 4, Uppsala. Available at: www.nai.uu.se/ecas-4/panels/81-100/panel-90/ECAS-FULL-PAPER-GEORGE-OWUSU.pdf.

52.

Payne GK (ed) (1984) Low-Income Housing in the Developing World: The Role of Sites and Services and Settlement Upgrading. Chichester: John Wiley.

53.

Peck

Theodore

Brenner

(2013) Neoliberal urbanism redux? International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37(3): 1091–1099.

54.

Pugh

(1995) The role of the World Bank in housing. In: Aldrich

Sandhu

(eds) Housing and the Urban Poor. Policy and Practice in Developing Countries, London and New Jersey: Zed Books.

55.

Pugh

(2001) The theory and practice of housing sector development for developing countries, 1950–99. Housing Studies 16(4): 399–423.

56.

Ramsamy

(2006) The World Bank and Urban Development, Oxon: Routledge.

57.

Renaud

(1999) The financing of social housing in integrating financial markets: A view from developing countries. Urban Studies 36(4): 755–773.

58.

Richardson D, Castree N, Goodchild MF, et al. (eds) (2017) The International Encyclopedia of Geography: People, the Earth, Environment, and Technology. Oxford: Wiley.

59.

Robertson M (2014) The financialisation of British housing: A systems of provision approach. PhD Thesis, SOAS University of London, UK.

60.

Rolnik

(2013) Late neoliberalism: The financialisation of homeownership and housing rights. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37(3): 1058–1066.

61.

Roy

(2012) Poverty Capital: Microfinance and the Making of Development, Oxon: Routledge.

62.

Schwartz

(2012) Finance and the state in the housing bubble. In: Aalbers

(ed.) Subprime Cities. The Political Economy of Mortgage Markets, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

63.

Soederberg

(2014a) Subprime housing goes South: Constructing securitized mortgages for the poor in Mexico. Antipode 47(2): 481–499.

64.

Soederberg

(2014b) Debtfare States and the Poverty Industry. Money, Discipline and the Surplus Population, Oxon: Routledge.

65.

Solo

(2009) Between financial exclusion and community development, Washington, DC: World Bank Institute and Cities Alliance.

66.

Stren

(2014) Urban service delivery in Africa and the role of international assistance. Development Policy Review 32: S19–S37.

67.

Tipple

(2015) Housing policy-making in Africa: Ten common assumptions. Habitat International 49: 413–418.

68.

UNCHS (1987) Global Report on Human Settlements, Oxford: OUP for UNCHS.

69.

UN-Habitat (1996) The Habitat Agenda. Istanbul Declaration on Human Settlements.

70.

UN-Habitat (2011) Housing the Poor in African Cities. Quick Guide 5 on Housing Finance, Nairobi: UN-Habitat.

71.

UN-Habitat (2015) Housing at the Centre of the New Urban Agenda, Nairobi: UN-Habitat.

72.

Van Waeyenberge

(2006) From Washington to post-Washington Consensus. Illusions of development? In: Fine

Jomo

(eds) The New Development Economics, New Delhi: Tulika Press.

73.

Van Waeyenberge

Fine

(2011) A knowledge bank? In: Bayliss

Fine

Van Waeyenberge

(eds) The Political Economy of Development: The World Bank, Neo-Liberalism and Development Research, London: Pluto Press.

74.

Van Waeyenberge

Fine

Bayliss

(2011) Introduction. In: Bayliss

Fine

Van Waeyenberge

(eds) The Political Economy of Development: The World Bank, Neo-Liberalism and Development Research, London: Pluto Press.

75.

World Bank (1972a) Urbanization. Sector Paper, Washington, DC: World Bank.

76.

World Bank (1972b) Appraisal of a Sites-and-Services Project Senegal. Special Projects Department, Washington, DC: World Bank.

77.

World Bank (1974) Sites-and-Services Projects, Washington, DC: World Bank.

78.

World Bank (1975) Housing: Sector Policy Paper, Washington, DC: World Bank.

79.

World Bank (1982) Learning by Doing. World Bank Lending for Urban Development, 1972–1982, Washington, DC: World Bank.

80.

World Bank (1993) Housing: Enabling Markets to Work, Washington, DC: World Bank.

81.

World Bank (1994) Twenty Years of Lending for Urban Development, 1972–1992, Washington, DC: World Bank.

82.

World Bank. (2000) Cities in Transition. World Bank Urban and Local Government Strategy. Washington, DC: World Bank.

83.

World Bank (2003) Improving the Lives of the Poor in Cities: An Update on the Performance of the World Bank’s Urban Portfolio, Washington, DC: World Bank.

84.

World Bank (2006) Thirty Years of Shelter Lending. What Have We Learned?, Washington DC: World Bank.

85.

World Bank (2009) Reshaping Economic Geography. The 2009 World Development Report, Washington, DC: World Bank.

86.

World Bank (2010) Systems of Cities. Harnessing Urbanisation for Growth and Poverty Alleviation. The World Bank Urban and Local Government Strategy, Washington, DC: World Bank.

87.

World Bank (2015) Stocktaking of the Housing Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. Challenges and Opportunities, Washington, DC: World Bank.

88.

World Bank/UNCHS (1999) Cities alliance for cities without slums. Available at: www.citiesalliance.org/sites/citiesalliance.org/files/ActionPlan.pdf.