This paper discusses the development of a Place-Based Food Insecurity and Vulnerability Index (PFIVI), which incorporates six indicators and 30 variables. It also presents an application of this Index within the context of Philadelphia, a postindustrial U.S. city. The paper argues that in order to thoroughly measure a multidimensional socioeconomic problem that is tied to the built environment (e.g., food insecurity and vulnerability), the use of participatory and mixed-methods approaches in GIS (e.g., participatory GIS or PGIS) may produce more comprehensive results compared to other commonly used methods. This paper makes an intervention in the food environment literature, which tends to analyze food access in a narrow way, by applying a methodology conceptually grounded in community food security and operationalized through a PGIS project. It also contributes to still-evolving PGIS methodologies by directly engaging stakeholders in a complicated GIS-based analytical process.
AdamsCBarteltDEleshD (2008) Restructuring the Philadelphia Region: Metropolitan Divisions and Inequality, Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
2.
AitkenSCMichelSM (1995) Who contrives the ‘real’ in GIS? Geographic information, planning and critical theory. Cartography and Geographic Information Systems22: 17–29.
3.
AkersAY (2011) When you got nothing to do, you do somebody: a community’s perceptions of neighborhood effects on adolescent sexual behaviors. Social Science & Medicine72(1): 91–99.
4.
Al-KodmanyK (2002) Visualization tools and methods in community planning: From freehand sketches to virtual reality. Journal of planning Literature17(2): 189–211.
5.
AlkonAAgyemanJ (2011) Cultivating Food Justice: Race, Class, and Sustainability, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
6.
AndersonMCookJ (1999) Community food security: Practice in need of theory?Agriculture and Human Values16: 141–150.
7.
BeaulacJKristjanssonECumminsS (2009) A systematic review of food deserts, 1966–2007. Preventing Chronic Disease6(3): 1–10.
8.
BlackJMacinkoJDixonL (2010) Neighborhoods and obesity in New York City. Health & Place16(3): 489–499.
9.
BodorJRoseDFarleyT (2008) Neighborhood fruit and vegetable availability and consumption: The role of small food stores in an urban environment. Public Health Nutrition11(4): 413–420.
10.
BosworthMDonovanJCoueyP (2002) Portland metro’s dream for public involvement. In: CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (eds) Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems, London: Taylor and Francis, pp. 125–136.
11.
BrownG (2005) Mapping spatial attributes in survey research for natural resource management: Methods and applications. Society and Natural Resources18: 17–39.
12.
BrownGFagerholmN (2015) Empirical PPGIS/PGIS mapping of ecosystem services: A review and evaluation. Ecosystem Services13: 119–133.
13.
BrownGKyttaM (2014) Key issues and research priorities for public participation GIS (PPGIS): A synthesis based on empirical research. Applied Geography46: 122–136.
14.
BrownGWeberD (2011) Public participation GIS: A new method for use in national park planning. Landscape and Urban Planning102: 1–15.
15.
BrownGWeberD (2012) Measuring change in place values using public participation GIS (PPGIS). Applied Geography34: 316–324.
16.
BrownGWeberDBieK (2014) Assessing the value of public lands using public participation GIS (PPGIS) and social landscape metrics. Applied Geography53: 77–89.
17.
CharreireHCaseyRSalzeP (2010) Measuring the food environment using geographical information systems: A methodological review. Public Health Nutrition13(11): 1773–1785.
18.
CinderbyS (2010) How to reach the ‘hard-to-reach’: The development of Participatory Geographic Information Systems (P-GIS) for inclusive urban design in UK cities. Area42(2): 239–251.
CorbettJMKellerCP (2005) An analytical framework to examine empowerment associated with participatory geographic information systems (PGIS). Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization40(4): 91–102.
21.
Craig WJ, Harris TM, Weiner D (eds) (2002) Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems. London: Taylor and Francis.
22.
CumminsSCurtisSDiez-RouxAV (2007) Understanding and representing ‘place’ in health research: A relational approach. Social Science and Medicine65(9): 1825–1838.
23.
DonovanSMLooneyCHansonT (2009) Reconciling social and biological needs in an endangered ecosystem: The Palouse as a model for bioregional planning. Ecology and Society14(1): 9.
24.
DunnC (2007) Participatory GIS – A people’s GIS?Progress in Human Geography31(5): 616–637.
25.
ElwoodS (2002) GIS use in community planning: A multidimensional analysis of empowerment. Environment and Planning A34(5): 905–922.
26.
ElwoodS (2006) Critical issues in participatory GIS: Deconstructions, reconstructions, and new research directions. Transactions in GIS10(5): 693–708.
27.
ElwoodSGhoseR (2001) PPGIS in community development planning: Framing the organizational context. Cartographica: The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization38(3–4): 19–33.
28.
FieldingNCisneros-PueblaC (2009) CAQDAS-GIS convergence: Toward a new integrated mixed method research practice?Journal of Mixed Methods Research3(4): 349–370.
29.
GhoseRHuxholdWE (2001) Role of local contextual factors in building public participation GIS: The Milwaukee experience. Cartography and Geographic Information Systems28(3): 195–208.
30.
GordonCPurciel-HillMGhaiN (2011) Measuring food deserts in New York City’s low-income neighborhoods. Health & Place17(2): 696–700.
GundersenCKreiderB (2009) Bounding the effects of food insecurity on children’s health outcomes. Journal of Health Economics28: 971–983.
33.
HammMWBellowsAC (2003) Community food security and nutrition educators. Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior35(1): 37–43.
34.
HarawayD (1996) Situated knowledges: The science question in feminism and the privilege of partial knowledge. In: AgnewJLivingstoneDRodgersA (eds) Human Geography: An Essential Anthology, Malden, MA: Blackwell, pp. 108–128.
35.
HarrisTWeinerD (1998) Empowerment, marginalization, and community-oriented GIS. Cartography and Geographic Information Systems25(2): 67–76.
36.
HawthorneTKrygierJKwanMP (2008) Mapping ambivalence: Exploring the geographies of community change and rails-to-trails development using photo-based Q method and PPGIS. Geoforum39(2): 1058–1078.
37.
JacobsenMPruitt-ChapinKRugeleyC (2009) Toward reconstructing poverty knowledge: Addressing food insecurity through grassroots research design and implementation. Journal of Poverty13: 1–19.
38.
JungK (2009) Computer-aided qualitative GIS: A software-level integration of qualitative research and GIS. In: CopeMElwoodS (eds) Qualitative GIS: A Mixed Methods Approach, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, pp. 115–135.
39.
KingBH (2002) Towards a participatory GIS: Evaluating case studies of participatory rural appraisal and GIS in the developing world. Cartography and Geographic Information Science29: 43–52.
40.
KingstonR (2007) Public participation in local policy decision making: The role of web-based mapping. The Cartographic Journal44: 138–144.
41.
KniggeLCopeM (2006) Grounded visualization: Integrating the analysis of qualitative and quantitative data through grounded theory and visualization. Environment and Planning A38(11): 2021–2037.
42.
KwanM (2002) Feminist visualization: Re-envisioning GIS as a method in feminist geographic research. Annals of the Association of American Geographers92(4): 645–661.
43.
KwanM (2007) Affecting geospatial technologies: Towards a feminist politics of emotion. The Professional Geographer59(1): 22–34.
44.
KwanMDingG (2008) Geo-narratives: Extending geographic information systems for narrative analysis in qualitative and mixed-method research. The Professional Geographer60(4): 443–465.
45.
LancasterKCarrierLDickJ (2010) Building community capacity in resource poor neighborhoods: Community–university partnerships. Explorations V. 128–150.
46.
LarsonNStoryMNelsonM (2009) Neighborhood environments: Disparities in access to healthy foods in the US. American Journal of Preventive Medicine36(1): 74–81.
47.
LucasS (2002) From Levittown to Luther Village: Retirement communities and the changing suburban dream. Canadian Journal of Urban Research11(2): 323–341.
48.
LucasSSandersR (2010) The view from here: Family images in retirement community brochures. In: HallmanBC (ed.) Family Geographies: The Spatiality of Families and Family Life, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 184–207.
49.
MaciasT (2008) Working toward a just, equitable, and local food system: The social impact of community-based agriculture. Social Science Quarterly89(5): 1086–1101.
50.
MarbleD (1990) The potential methodological impact of geographic information systems on the social sciences. In: AllenKGreenSZubrowE (eds) Interpreting Space: GIS and Archaeology, London: Taylor & Francis, pp. 9–21.
51.
MatthewsSDetwilerJBurtonL (2005) Geo-ethnography: Coupling geographic information analysis techniques with ethnographic methods in urban research. Cartographica40(4): 75–90.
52.
McCallM (2003) Seeking good governance in participatory-GIS: A review of processes and governance dimensions in applying GIS to participatory spatial planning. Habitat International27: 549–573.
53.
McCallMDunnC (2012) Geo-information tools for participatory spatial planning: Fulfilling the criteria for ‘good’ governance?Geoforum43(1): 81–94.
54.
McEnteeJAgyemanJ (2010) Towards the development of a GIS method for identifying rural food deserts: Geographic access in Vermont, USA. Applied Geography30(1): 165–176.
55.
McKinnonRReedyJMorrissetteM (2009) Measures of the food environment: A compilation of the literature, 1990–2007. American Journal of Preventive Medicine36(4): S124–S133.
56.
McMillanT (2007) The relative influence of urban form on a child’s travel mode to school. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice41(1): 69–79.
57.
MeenarM (2012) Feeding the hungry: Analysis of food insecurity in lower income urban Communities. In: ReidNGatrellJRossP (eds) Local Food Systems in Old Industrial Regions, Surrey, UK: Ashgate, pp. 71–91.
58.
MeenarM (2015) Nonprofit-driven community capacity building efforts in community food systems. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development6(1): 77–94.
59.
MeenarMHooverB (2012) Community food security via urban agriculture: Understanding people, place, economy, and accessibility from a food justice perspective. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development3(1): 143–160.
60.
MennisJMasonMCaoY (2013) Qualitative GIS and the visualization of narrative activity space data. International Journal of Geographical Information Science27(2): 267–291.
61.
Metallinos-KatsarasESherryBKallioJ (2009) Food insecurity is associated with overweight in children younger than 5 years of age. Journal of the American Dietetic Association109(10): 1790–1794.
62.
MooreLDiez RouxA (2006) Associations of neighborhood characteristics with the location and type of food stores. American Journal of Public Health96(2): 325–331.
63.
MorganDL (1993) Qualitative content analysis: A guide to paths not taken. Qualitative Health Research3(1): 112–121.
64.
MorlandKEvensonK (2009) Obesity prevalence and the local food environment. Health & Place15(2): 491–495.
65.
Nord M, Andrews M and Carlson S (2009) Household food security in the United States, 2008. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Agriculture, 12 November, 2010, http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/err83.
66.
OleinikA (2011) Mixing quantitative and qualitative content analysis: Triangulation at work. Quality & Quantity45: 859–873.
67.
PavlovskayaM (2002) Mapping urban change and changing GIS. Gender, Place and Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography. 9, 281–289.
68.
PearsonTRussellJCampbellMJ (2005) Do “food deserts” influence fruit and vegetable consumption? A cross-sectional study. Appetite45(2): 195–197.
69.
PicklesJ (1995) Ground Truth: The Social Implications of Geographic Information Systems, New York, NY: Guilford.
70.
PocewiczANielsen-PincusMBrownG (2012) An evaluation of Internet versus paper-based methods for public participation Geographic Information Systems (PPGIS). Transactions in GIS16(1): 39–53.
71.
PoplinA (2012) Web-based PPGIS with Wilhelmsburg, Germany: An integration of interactive GIS-based maps with an online questionnaire. Urisa Journal24(2): 75–88.
72.
PotterWJLevine-DonnersteinD (1999) Rethinking validity and reliability in content analysis. Journal of Applied Communication Research27(3): 258–284.
73.
PrestonBWilsonMW (2014) Practicing GIS as mixed method: Affordances and limitations in an urban gardening study. Annals of the Association of American Geographers104(3): 510–529.
74.
QuinnSYapaL (2016) Open street map and food security: A case study in the City of Philadelphia. The Professional Geographer68(2): 271–280.
75.
RajaSMaCYadavP (2008) Beyond food deserts measuring and mapping racial disparities in neighborhood food environments. Journal of Planning Education and Research27(4): 469–482.
76.
RaymondCMBryanBAMacDonaldDH (2009) Mapping community values for natural capital and ecosystem services. Ecological Economics68: 1301–1315.
77.
SchlossbergMShufordE (2005) Delineating “public” and “participation” in PPGIS. URISA Journal16(2): 16–26.
78.
Schroeder P (1996) Report on public participation GIS workshop. NCGIA Technical Report, 96–97, Scientific Report for Initiative 19 Specialist Meeting.
79.
ShannonJ (2014) Food deserts: Governing obesity in the neoliberal city. Progress in Human Geography38(2): 248–266.
80.
SheppardE (1995) GIS and society: Towards a research agenda. Cartography and Geographic Information Systems22(1): 5–16.
81.
SieberR (2006) Public participation geographic information systems: A literature review and framework. Annals of the Association of American Geographers96: 491–507.
82.
SurowieckiJ (2005) The Wisdom of Crowds, New York: Anchor.
83.
The Policy Map (2012) GIS mapping: Up to date demographics, population, unemployment, crime and more. Available at: http://www.policymap.com (accessed 22 June 2012).
84.
TeigEAmulyaJBardwellL (2009) Collective efficacy in Denver, Colorado: Strengthening neighborhoods and health through community gardens. Health & Place15: 1115–1122.
85.
TravalineKHunoldC (2010) Urban agriculture and ecological citizenship in Philadelphia. Local Environment15(6): 581–590.
86.
Treuhaft S and Karpyn A (2010) The grocery gap: Who has access to healthy food and why it matters. Oakland, CA: PolicyLink. Available at: http://www.policylink.org (accessed 22 June 2012).
87.
TsaiBLuDChungM (2013) Evaluation of PPGIS empowerment – A case study of Meinong Yellow Butterfly Valley in Taiwan. Journal of Environmental Management116: 204–212.
WalkerRKeaneCBurkeJ (2010) Disparities and access to healthy food in the United States: A review of food deserts literature. Health & Place16(5): 876–884.
90.
WillemenLVerburgPHHeinL (2008) Spatial characterization of landscape functions. Landscape and Urban Planning88: 34–43.
