In the 1960s the human geneticist James V. Neel and collaborators launched a research
program aimed at investigating the human biology of South American indigenous
populations, which would become one of the most influential such studies in the
second half of the 20th century. In the first part of this article I explore the
trajectory of some components of the Amazonian research program and situate it in
the context of worldwide human biological research in the 1960s and 1970s. In the
second half I suggest that the comparative analysis of previous research on the
human biology of indigenous peoples might provide insights into highly debated
issues pertaining to contemporaneous research agendas, including the `Human Genome
Diversity Project' (HGDP).
Cavalli-Sforza, L.L.
,
A.C. Wilson
,
C.R. Cantor
,
R.M. Cook-Deegan
and
M.C. King
(1991)
`Call for a Worldwide Survey of Human Genetic Diversity: A Vanishing
Opportunity for the Human Genome Project'
, Genomics11: 490-1.
8.
Collins, K.J.
and
J.S. Weiner
(1977) Human Adaptability: A History and Compendium of
Research in the International Biological Programme.
London : Taylor and
Francis.
9.
Cunningham, A.B.
(1991)
`Indigenous Knowledge and Biodiversity'
, Cultural Survival Quarterly:
4-8.
10.
Cunningham, H.
(1998)
`Colonial Encounters in Postcolonial Contexts: Patenting Indigenous DNA and
the Human Genome Diversity Project'
, Critique of Anthropology18: 205-33.
11.
Diamond, S.
(1993) In Search of the Primitive: A Critique of
Civilization . New Brunswick, NJ:
Transaction Publishers.
12.
Dickson, D.
(1996)
`Whose Genes are They Anyway?'
, Nature381: 11-14.
13.
Dikotter, F.
(1998)
`Race Culture: Recent Perspectives on the History of Eugenics'
, American Historical Review103: 467-78.
14.
Dodson, M.
and
R. Williamson
(1999)
`Indigenous Peoples and the Morality of the Human Genome Diversity
Project'
, Journal of Medical Ethics25: 204-8.
15.
Ferguson, T.J.
(1996)
`Native Americans and the Practice of Archaeology'
, Annual Review of Anthropology25: 63-79.
16.
Friedlaender, J., ed. (1996)
`Genes, People, and Property: Furor Erupts over Genetic Research on
Indigenous Peoples'
, Special Issue of Cultural Survival Quarterly,
20(2).
17.
Greely, H.T.
(1998a)
`Genomics Research and Human Subjects'
, Science282:
625
.
18.
Greely, H.T.
(1998b)
`Legal, Ethical, and Social Issues in Human Genome Research'
, Annual Review of Anthropology27: 473-502.
19.
Gutin, J.
(1994)
`End of the Rainbow'
, Discover15: 70-4.
20.
Harrison, G.A.
(1982) `The Past Fifty Years of Human Population Biology in
North America: An Outsider's View', in
F. Spencer
(ed.) A History of American Physical Anthropology , pp.
467-72. New York:
Academic Press.
21.
Headland, T.N.
(1997)
`Revisionism in Ecological Anthropology'
, Current Anthropology38: 605-30.
Kevles, D.
(1995) In the Name of Eugenics: Genetics and the Uses of
Human Heredity. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
24.
Kidd, J.R.
,
F.L. Black
,
K.M. Weiss
,
I. Balazs
and
K.K. Kidd
(1991)
`Studies of Three Amerindian Populations using Nuclear DNA
Polymorphisms'
, Human Biology63: 775-94.
25.
Kidd, J.R.
,
K.K. Kidd
and
K.M. Weiss
(1993)
`Human Genome Diversity Initiative'
, Human Biology65: 1-6.
26.
Kirk, R.L.
(1981) Aboriginal Man Adapting: The Human Biology of
Australian Aborigines. Oxford:
Clarendon Press .
27.
Kuper, A.
(1988) The Invention of Primitive Society: Transformation of
an Illusion. London:
Routledge .
28.
Kwa, C.
(1987)
`Representations of Nature Mediating between Ecology and Science Policy:
The Case of the International Biological Programme'
, Social Studies of Science17: 413-42.
29.
Lee, R.
(1992)
`Art, Science or Politics? The Crisis in Hunter-Gatherer Studies'
, American Anthropologist94: 31-54.
30.
Lévi-Strauss, C.
(1968) Tristes Tropiques. New
York : Atheneum. (First published
1955 .)
31.
Lindee, M.S.
(1994) Suffering Made Real: American Science and the
Survivors at Hiroshima. Chicago:
Chicago University Press.
32.
Little, M.A.
and
J.D. Haas
, eds (1989) Human Population Biology: A Transdisciplinary
Science. New York: Oxford
University Press.
33.
Lock, M.
(1994)
`Interrogating the Human Genome Diversity Project'
, Social Science and Medicine39: 603-6.
34.
Ludmerer, K.M.
(1972) Genetics and American Society: A Historical
Appraisal .
Baltimore
, MD:
Johns Hopkins University Press
.
35.
Macilwain, C.
(1996)
`Tribal Groups Attack Ethics of Genome Diversity Project'
, Nature383:
208
.
36.
Marks, J.
(1995a) Human Biodiversity: Genes, Race, and History.
New York: Aldine de
Gruyter.
37.
Marks, J.
(1995b)
`The Human Genome Diversity Project'
, American Anthropological Association Newsletter36(4):
72
.
38.
Martin, D.
(1998) `Owning the Sins of the Past: Historical Trends,
Missed Opportunities, and New Directions in the Study of Human Remains',
in
A.H. Goodman
and
T.L. Leatherman
(eds) Building a New Biocultural Synthesis: Political-Economic
Perspectives on Human Biology, pp. 171-90.
Ann Arbor: University of Michigan
Press.
39.
Neel, J.V.
(1958)
`The Study of Natural Selection in Primitive and Civilized Human
Populations'
, Human Biology30: 43-72.
40.
Neel, J.V.
(1968) `The American Indian in the International Biological
Program', in Biomedical Challenges Presented by the American Indian,
Pan American Health Organization, Scientific Publication no. 165.
Washington, DC: Pan American
Health Organization .
41.
Neel, J.V.
(1970)
`Lessons from a "Primitive" People'
, Science170: 815-22.
42.
Neel, J.V.
(1989)
`Update to "The Study of Natural Selection in Primitive and Civilized Human
Populations" '
, Human Biology61: 811-23.
43.
Neel, J.V.
(1994) Physician to the Gene Pool: Genetic Lessons and Other
Stories. New York: John Wiley
and Sons.
44.
Neel, J.V.
and
F.M. Salzano
(1967) `A Prospectus for Genetic Studies on the American
Indians', in
P.T. Baker
and
J.S. Weiner
(eds) The Biology of Human Adaptability, pp.
245-74. Oxford:
Clarendon Press.
45.
Neel, J.V.
and
W.J. Schull
(1956) The Effect of Exposure to the Atomic Bombs on
Pregnancy Termination in Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Washington, DC: National Academy
of Sciences - National Research Council Publication,
no. 461.
46.
Neel, J.V.
and
W.J. Schull
(1991) The Children of Atomic Bomb Survivors: A Genetic
Study. Washington, DC: National
Academy Press.
47.
Neel, J.V.
,
F.M. Salzano
,
P.C. Junqueira
,
F. Keiter
and
D. Maybury-Lewis
(1964)
`Studies on the Xavante Indians of the Brazilian Mato Grosso'
, American Journal of Human Genetics16: 52-140.
48.
Paul, D.B.
(1995) Controlling Human Heredity: 1865 to the Present
. Atlantic Highlands: Humanities
Press.
49.
Pennisi, E.
(1997)
`NRC Oks Long-delayed Survey of Human Genome Diversity'
, Science278:
568
.
50.
Roberts, L.
(1992)
`Anthropologists Climb (gingerly) on Board'
, Science258: 1300-1.
51.
Rose, J.C.
,
T.J. Green
and
V.D. Green
(1996)
`NAGPRA is Forever: Osteology and the Repatriation of Skeletons'
, Annual Review of Anthropology25: 81-103.
52.
Salzano, F.M.
and
S.M. Callegari-Jacques
(1988) South American Indians: A Case Study in Human
Evolution. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
53.
Shephard, R.J.
and
A. Rode
(1996) The Health Consequences of `Modernization': Evidence
from Circumpolar Peoples. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
54.
Simpson, M.G.
(1996) Making Representations: Museums in the Post-Colonial
Era. London:
Routledge.
55.
Solway, J.J.
and
R.B. Lee
(1990)
`Foragers, Genuine or Spurious? Situating the Kalahari San in
History'
, Current Anthropology31: 109-46.
56.
Swedlund, A.C.
(1993)
`Is There an Echo in Here? Historical Reflections on the Human Genome
Diversity Project'
, paper presented at the Wenner-Gren sponsored meeting
`Anthropological Perspectives on the Human Genome Diversity Project',
Seven Springs Center, Mt Kisco, New
York.
57.
Todorov, T.
(1993) On Human Diversity: Nationalism, Racism, and Exoticism
in French Thought. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
58.
Ulijaszek, S.J.
and
R. Huss-Ashmore
, eds (1997) Human Adaptability: Past, Present, and
Future. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
59.
Weiss, K.M.
(1998)
`Coming to Terms with Human Variation'
, Annual Review of Anthropology27: 273-300.
60.
Weiss, K.M.
,
K.K. Kidd
and
J. Kidd
(1992)
`Human Genome Diversity Project'
, Evolutionary Anthropology1: 80-2.
61.
WHO (World Health Organization)
(1964) Research in Population Genetics of Primitive
Groups, Geneva ,
WHO Technical Report Series, No. 279.
62.
Wilmsen, E.
(1989) Land Filled with Flies: A Political Economy of the
Kalahari. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press.
