In the 1870s, the life sciences witnessed the rise of a new site for scientific research: the marine station. This new workplace brought the laboratory of the biologist closer to the natural surroundings of the marine organisms that he/she was studying. It was therefore a site where the lab could be `renaturalized'. In this paper, the extent of this `renaturalization' is studied with regard to two stations. The first, Anton Dohrn's Stazione zoologica in Naples, was to become an international centre for laboratory research, while the second, Alfred Giard's marine station in Wimereux (France), turned out to be an important hub for field studies. Field-oriented animal life studies could be developed in Wimereux, whereas these were largely outshone by physiological and morphological research in Naples. I argue that differences in the physical and social organization of the two stations — or their `ecologies' — accounted for the varying practices and types of knowledge found in Naples and Wimereux.
Acloque, Alexandre & Casimir Cépède (1910) Observations biologiques et écologiques sur la flore de Wimereux et de ses environs ( Boulogne sur Mer: G. Hamain).
2.
Anonymous (1897) `Some Unwritten History of the Naples Zoological Station', American Naturalist31: 960-65.
3.
Bohn, Georges (1901) Des mécanismes respiratoires chez les crustacés décapodes, essai de physiologie évolutive, éthologique et phylogénique (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés).
4.
Bohn, Georges (1910) Alfred Giard et son oeuvre ( Paris: Mercure de France).
5.
Boissay, Charles (1877), `Le laboratoire de zoologie maritime de Wimereux', La Nature. Revue des Sciences et de leurs Applications aux Arts et à l'Industrie5: 129-30.
6.
Bouyssi, François (1998) Alfred Giard (1846-1908) et ses élèves. Un cenacle de `philosophes biologists'. Aux origines du scientisme? Unpublished Doctoral Thesis, 2 vols, Paris.
7.
Boveri, Theodor (1910) Anton Dohrn. Gedächtnisrede gehalten auf dem Internationalen Zoologen-Kongress in Graz am 18 August 1910 (Leipzig: Verl. von S. Hirzel).
8.
Brunner, Bernd (2005) The Ocean at Home: An Illustrated History of the Aquarium (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Architectural Press).
9.
Burkhardt, Richard W. Jr (1999) `Ethology, Natural History, and the Problem of Place', Journal of the History of Biology32: 489-508.
10.
Burkhardt, Richard W. Jr (2005) Patterns of Behavior: Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen and the Foundation of Ethology (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
11.
Cartaz, Adolphe (1900) `La station zoologique de Wimereux', La Nature . Revue des Sciences et de leurs Applications aux Arts et à l'Industrie28: 146-48.
12.
Caullery, Maurice (1909) `Giard (Alfred Mathieu)', Association amicale de secours des anciens élèves de l'école normale supérieure (10 January): 111.
13.
Caullery, Maurice (1950) `Les stations françaises de biologie marine', Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London8: 95-115.
14.
De Bont, Raf (2008) `Evolutionary Morphology in Belgium: The Fortunes of the "Van Beneden School", 1870-1900', Journal of the History of Biology41: 81-118.
15.
Di Gregorio, Mario (2005) From Here to Eternity: Ernst Haeckel and Scientific Faith (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck and Rubbrecht).
16.
Dierig, Sven (2003) `Engines for Experiment: Laboratory Revolution and Industrial Labor in the Nineteenth-century City', Osiris , 2nd series, 18: 116-34.
17.
Dohrn, Anton (1872) `The Foundation of Zoological Stations', Nature5: 277-80, 437-40.
18.
Dohrn, Anton (1875) `Mittheilungen aus und über die Zoologische Station von Neapel. Offenes Sendschreiben an Prof. C. Th. V. Siebold', Zeitschrift für wissenschaftliche Zoologie25: 457-80.
19.
Dohrn, Anton (1876) Erster Jahresbericht der Zoologischen Station in Neapel (Leipzig: Engelmann).
20.
Dohrn, Anton (1879) `Bericht über die zoologische Station während der Jahre 1876-1878', Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel1: 137-64.
21.
Dohrn, Anton (1881) `Bericht über die Zoologische Station während der Jahre 1879-1880', Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel2: 495-514.
22.
Dohrn, Anton (1882a) `Studien zur Urgeschichte des Wirbelthierkörpers I: Der Mund der Knockenfische', Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel3: 242-79.
23.
Dohrn, Anton (1882b) `Bericht über die Zoologische Station während des Jahres 188 ', Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel3: 591-602.
24.
Dohrn, Anton (1886) `Bericht über die Zoologische Station wärhend der Jahre 1882-1884', Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel6: 93-148.
25.
Dohrn, Anton (1893) `Bericht über die Zoologische Station während der Jahre 1885-1892', Mittheilungen aus der Zoologischen Station zu Neapel10: 633-74.
26.
Dohrn, Anton (1926[1872]) `Der gegenwärtige Stand der Zoologie und die Gründung zoologischer Stationen', Die Naturwissenschaften14: 412-24.
27.
Ensch, Norbert & Louis Querton (1897) `La station zoologique de Wimereux', Revue de l'Université de Bruxelles1: 305-10.
28.
Erlingsson, Steindor J. (2006) `The Plymouth Laboratory of the Marine Biological Association and the Rise of Experimental Zoology in Britain', in B. Grob & H. Hooijmaijers (eds), Who Needs Scientific Instruments? ( Leiden: Boerhaave Museum).
29.
Finnegan, Diarmid A. (2008) `The Spatial Turn: Geographical Approaches to the History of Science', Journal of the History of Biology41: 369-88.
30.
Forgan, Sophie (1998) `"But Indifferently Lodged ... ": Perception and Place in Building for Science in Victorian London', in C. Smith & J. Agar (eds), Making Space for Science: Territorial Themes in the Shaping of Knowledge (Basingstoke, Hampshire: Macmillan ): 195-215.
31.
Galison, Peter (1999) `Buildings and the Subject of Science', in P. Galison & E. Thompson (eds), The Architecture of Science ( Cambridge: MIT Press): 1-25.
32.
Ghiselin, Michael T. (2003) `Carl Gegenbaur versus Anton Dohrn', Theory of the Biosciences122: 142-47.
33.
Giard, Alfred (1896) Exposé des titres et travaux scientifiques (1869-1896) (Paris: Imprimerie générale Lahure).
34.
Giard, Alfred (1905a) `Les tendances actuelles de la morphologie et ses rapports avec les autres sciences', Revue scientifique (revue rose), 5th series, 3: 129-36, 166-72.
35.
Giard, Alfred (1905b) `L'évolution des sciences biologiques', Revue scientifique (revue rose), 5th series, 4: 193-205.
36.
Giard, Alfred (1911a [1908]), `L'éducation du morphologiste, in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 1: 41-56.
37.
Giard, Alfred (1911b [1905]), `Néovitalisme et finalité', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 1: 187-94.
38.
Giard, Alfred (1911c [1896]), `La méthode expérimentale en entomologie' , in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'evolution des âtres organisés), vol. 1: 195-201.
39.
Giard, Alfred (1911d [1878]) `Particularités de reproduction de certains echinodermes en rapport avec l'éthologie de ces animaux', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses ( Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés ), vol. 1: 509-514.
40.
Giard, Alfred (1913a [1874]) `Discours prononcé à l'inauguration du laboratoire de zoologie maritime à Wimereux (Pas-de-Calais)', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses ( Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés ), vol. 2: 5-17.
41.
Giard, Alfred (1913b [1888]) `Le laboratoire de Wimereux en 1888 (Recherches fauniques)', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 2: 38-62.
42.
Giard, Alfred (1913c [1889]) `Le laboratoire de Wimereux en 1889 (Recherches fauniques)', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 2: 18-37.
43.
Giard, Alfred (1913d [1899]) `La station zoologique de Wimereux de 1874 à 1899 ', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 2: 75-81.
44.
Giard, Alfred (1913e [1889]) `Le laboratoire du Portel. Les grandes et les petites stations maritimes ', in A. Giard, Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 2: 63-74.
45.
Giard, Alfred (1913f [1904]) `Sur l'habitat de Silene Maritima Wither. Dans le Nord de la France', in A. Giard , Oeuvres diverses (Paris: Laboratoire d'évolution des êtres organisés), vol. 2: 252-53.
46.
Gieryn, Thomas (1998) `Biotechnology's Private Parts (and Some Public Ones)', in C. Smith & J. Agar (eds), Making Space for Science: Territorial Themes in the Shaping of Knowledge (Basingstoke , Hampshire: Macmillan): 281-312.
47.
Gieryn, Thomas (1999a) Cultural Boundaries of Science: Credibility on the Line (Chicago, IL, & London : University of Chicago Press).
48.
Gieryn, Thomas (1999b) `Two Faces on Science. Building Identities for Molecular Biology and Biotechnology', in P. Galison & E. Thompson (eds), The Architecture of Science (Cambridge: MIT Press): 423-55.
49.
Gieryn, Thomas (2002) `Three Truth-spots', Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences38: 113-32.
50.
Golinski, Jan (1998) Making Natural Knowledge: Constructivism and the History of Science (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
51.
Groeben, Christiane (ed.) (1982) Charles Darwin 1809-1882, Anton Dohrn 1840-1909: Correspondence ( Naples: Macchiaroli).
52.
Groeben, Christiane (1985) `Anton Dohrn - The Statesman of Darwinism', Biological Bulletin16: 4-25.
53.
Groeben, Christiane (2006) `The Stazione Zoologica Anton Dohrn as a Place for the Circulation of Scientific Ideas: Vision and Management', in K.L. Anderson & C. Thiery (eds), Information for Responsible Fisheries: Libraries as Mediators (Fort Pierce, FL: IAMSLIC): 291-99.
54.
Groeben, Christiane & Irmgard Müller (1975) The Naples Zoological Station at the Time of Anton Dohrn (Naples: Stazione Zoologica di Napoli).
55.
Helmholtz, Hermann, Rudolf Virchow & Edmond Du Bois-Reymond (1980[1879]) `Die zoologische Station in Neapel. Eingabe an den Reichstag Privatdruck', in: H.R. Simon (ed.), Anton Dohrn und die Zoologische Station Neapel (Frankfurt am Main: Edition Erbrich ): 49-51.
56.
Heuss, Theodor (1948) Anton Dohrn, second edition ( Stuttgart: Rainer Wunderlich).
57.
Jack, Homer A. (1945) `Biological Field Stations of the World', Chronica Botanica9: 1-73.
58.
Kofoid, Charles A. (1910) The Biological Stations of Europe ( Washington, DC: Government Printing Office).
59.
Kohler, Robert E. (2002a) Landscapes and Labscapes: Exploring the Lab-Field Border in Biology (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
60.
Kohler, Robert E. (2002b) `Labscapes: Naturalizing the Lab', History of Science40: 473-501.
61.
Kraft, Alison & Samuel J.M.M. Alberti (2003) `"Equal though Different": Laboratories, Museums and the Institutional Development of Biology in late-Victorian Northern England' , Studies in the History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences34: 203-36.
62.
Kühn, Alfred (1950) `Anton Dohrn und die Zoologie seiner Zeit', Pubblicazioni della Stazione Zoologica di Napoli28: 1-205.
63.
Livingstone, David N. (2003) Putting Science in its Place: Geographies of Scientific Knowledge (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
64.
Lynch, Michael (1991) `Laboratory Space and the Technological Complex: An Investigation of Topical Contextures', Science in Context4: 51-78.
65.
MacLeod, Julius (1882) `La station zoologique de Naples', Annales de la Société de médecine de Gand52: 13-21.
66.
Maienschein, Jane (1989) 100 Years Exploring Life, 1888-1988: The Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods Hole (Boston, MA: Jones & Bartlett).
67.
Maienschein, Jane (1991) Transforming Traditions in American Biology, 1880-1915 (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press).
68.
Massart, Jean (1912) `Les naturalistes actuels et l'étude de la nature', Bulletins de l'Académie royale belge des sciences, des lettres et des beaux-arts, series 4, 11: 944-65.
69.
Ménégaux, Auguste (1905) `Le laboratoire maritime de Wimereux', Bulletin de l'Institut général psychologique6: 459-85.
70.
Naylor, Simon (2005) `Introduction: Historical Geographies of Science - Places, Contexts, Cartographies', British Journal for the History of Science38: 1-12.
71.
Nyhart, Lynn K. (1995) Biology takes Form: Animal Morphology and the German Universities 1800-1900 (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press).
72.
Nyhart, Lynn K. (1996) `Natural History and the "New" Biology', in N. Jardine, J.A. Secord & E.C. Spary (eds), Cultures of Natural History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 426-43.
73.
Ophir Adi & Steven Shapin (1991) `The Place of Knowledge: A Methodological Survey', Science in Context4: 3-21.
74.
Partsch, Karl J.( 1980) Die Zoologische Station in Neapel. Modell internationaler Wissenschaftszusammenarbeit (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht).
75.
Paul, Harry W. (1985) From Knowledge to Power: The Rise of the Science Empire in France, 1860-1939 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
76.
Pelseneer, Paul (1935) Essai d'éthologie zoologique d'après l'étude des mollusques (Brussels: Académie royale de Belgique).
77.
Powell, Richard C. (2007) `Geographies of Science: Histories, Localities, Practices, Futures', Progress in Human Geography31: 309-29.
78.
Rabaud, Etienne (1912) Ethologie et comportement des diverses larves endophytes (Paris: P. Klincksiek).
79.
Rentetzi, Maria (2005) `Designing (for) a new Scientific Discipline: The Location and Architecture of the Institut für Radiumforschung in Early Twentieth-century Vienna', British Journal for the History of Science38: 275-306.
80.
Richards, Robert J. (2004) `If this be Heresy: Haeckel's Conversion to Darwinism' , in A. Lusting, R.J. Richards & M. Ruse (eds), Darwinian Heresies (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 101-30.
81.
Schaffer, Simon (1998) `Physics Laboratories and the Victorian Country House', in C. Smith & J. Agar (eds), Making Space for Science: Territorial Themes in the Shaping of Knowledge (Basingstoke, Hampshire: Macmillan): 149-80.
82.
Shapin, Steven (1998) `Placing the View from Nowhere: Historical and Sociological Problems in the Location of Science', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers23: 5-12.
83.
Simon, Hans-Rainer (ed.) (1980) Anton Dohrn und die Zoologische Station Neapel (Frankfurt am Maine: Erbrich).
84.
Tort, Patrick (1998) `Giard, Alfred Mathieu', in Dictionnaire du darwinisme et de l'évolution, vol. 2 (Paris: PUF): 1911-39.
85.
Traweek, Sharon (1988) Beamtimes and Lifetimes: The World of High Energy Physics (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
86.
Van den Broeck, Ernest (1882) `Une visite à la station zoologique et l'aquarium de Naples', Annales de la Société Royale Malacologique de Belgique17: 3-14.
87.
Whitman, Charles O. (1883) `The Advantages of Study at the Naples Zoological Station', Science2: 93-97.
88.
Yung, Emile (1881) `Le laboratoire de zoologie maritime de Naples', La nature. Revue des sciences et de leurs applications aux arts et à l'industrie9: 230-34.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
