Abstract
We address the recent ascendancy of “stakeholder capitalism” and its potential impact on US corporate governance practice. Utilizing a four dimensional, analytic framework (legal, ethical, economic, and political), the authors evaluate the potential effects of stakeholder capitalism on the existing corporate governance of companies, concluding that stakeholder capitalism is a commitment, not a legal requirement; it is currently being practiced in boardrooms; and yet it is not the responsibility of the company, under stakeholder capitalism, to solve America’s social issues. The article concludes with business policy recommendations for directors concerning likely legal, ethical, economic, and political changes affecting stakeholder capitalism.
Keywords
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexander
FH
(2018 ) Benefit Corporation Law and Governance: Pursuing Profit With Purpose . Oakland, CA : Berrett-Koehler Publications .
2.
Anand
S
(2008 ) Essentials of Corporate Governance . Hoboken, NJ : John Wiley & Sons, Inc .
3.
Barney
J
(1991 ) Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage . Journal of Management 17 (1 ): 99 –120 .
4.Benefit Corporation (2020 ) State-by state status of legislation . Available at : https://benefitcorp.net/policymakers/state-by-state-status (accessed 16 February 2020) .
5.Bloomberg (2018 ) Where have all the public companies gone? Editorial Board . Available at : https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-04-09/where-have-all-the-u-s-public-companies-gone (accessed 15 February 2020) .
6.
Borgatti
SP
Halgin
DS
(2011 ) On network theory . Organization Science 22 (5 ): 1168 –1181 .
7.
Burt
RS
(1992 ) Structural Holes: The Social Structure of Competition . Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
8.Business Roundtable (2016 ) Principles of corporate governance . Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance , 8 September . Available at : https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2016/09/08/principles-of-corporate-governance (accessed 15 March 2020) .
9.Business Roundtable (2019 ) Business roundtable redefines the purpose of a corporation to promote “an economy that serves all Americans.” 19 August . Available at : https://www.businessroundtable.org/business-roundtable-redefines-the-purpose-of-a-corporation-to-promote-an-economy-that-serves-all-americans (accessed 27 January 2020) .
10.
Coase
RH
(1937 ) The nature of the firm . Economica 4 (16 ): 386 –405 .
11.
Davis
GF
Stout
SK
(1992 ) Organization theory and the market for corporate control: a dynamic analysis of the characteristics of large takeover targets, 1980-1990 . Administrative Science Quarterly 37 (4 ): 605 –633 .
12.Deloitte (2016 ) Framing the Future of Corporate Governance. Center for Board Effectiveness . Available at : https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/us/Documents/risk/us-aers-framing-the-future-of-corporate-governance-09262014.pdf (accessed 15 March 2020) .
13.
Dizikes
P
(2016 ) Laws allowing companies to prioritize stakeholders boost innovative activity . PHSORG , 17 February . Available at : https://phys.org/news/2016-02-laws-companies-prioritize-stakeholders-boost-html (accessed 14 February 2020) .
14.
Donaldson
T
Dunfee
TW
(1999 ) Ties That Bind: A Social Contracts Approach to Business Ethics . Cambridge, MA : Harvard Business School Press .
15.
Donaldson
TJ
(1990 ) The ethical hand: organizational economics and management theory? Academy of Management Review 15 (3 ): 369 –381 .
16.
Easterbrook
FH
Fischel
DR
(1991 ) The Economic Structure of Corporate Law . Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
17.
Eisenhardt
HM
(1989 ) Agency theory: an assessment and review . Academy of Management Review 22 (1 ): 20 –47 .
18.
Fligstein
N
(2001 ) The Architecture of Markets . Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
19.
Freeman
RE
(1984 ) Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach . Boston, MA : Pittman .
20.
Freeman
RE
Liedtka
J
(1997 ) Stakeholder capitalism and the value chain . European Management Journal 15 (3 ): 286 –296 .
21.
Freeman
RE
Harrison
JS
Wicks
AC
, et al. (2010 ) Stakeholder Theory: The State of the Art . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
22.
Friedman
M
(1970 ) The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits . The New York Times Magazine , 13 September , 32 –33 , 122 –126 .
23.
Gates
B
(2008 ) A new approach to capitalism in the 21st century . World Economic Forum 2008, Network World . 25 January . Available at : https://www.networkworld.com/article/2282669/microsoft-s-bill-gates---a-new-approach-to-capitalism-in-the-21st-century-.html (accessed 25 March, 2020) .
24.
Geczy
C
Jeffers
J
Musto
DK
, et al. (2015 ) Institutional investing when shareholders are not supreme . Harvard Business Law Review 5 (2 ): 73 –139 .
25.
Granovetter
MS
(1973 ) The strength of weak ties . American Journal of Sociology 78 (6 ): 1360 –1380 .
26.
Greider
W
(2017 ) How corporate capitalism looted democracy . The Nation , 14 September . Available at : https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/how-corporate-capitalism-looted-democracy/ (accessed 2 March 2020) .
27.
Gulati
R
(1998 ) Alliances and networks . Strategic Management Journal 19 (4 ): 203 –215 .
28.
Hannan
MT
Freeman
J
(1977 ) The population ecology of organizations . American Journal of Sociology 82 (5 ): 929 –964 .
29.
Hart
O
(1989 ) An economist’s perspective on the theory of the firm . Columbia Law Review 89 (7 ): 1757 –1773 .
30.
Hasnas
J
(1998 ) The normative theories of business ethics: a guide for the perplexed . Business Ethics Quarterly 8 (1 ): 19 –42 .
31.
Jensen
MC
Meckling
WH
(1976 ) Theory of the firm: managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure . Journal of Financial Economics 3 (4 ): 305 –360 .
32.
Jones
TM
Wicks
AC
(1999 ) Convergent stakeholder theory . Academy of Management Review 24 (2 ): 206 –221 .
33.
Kim
KA
Nofsinger
JR
Mohr
DJ
(2010 ) Corporate Governance . 3rd edn . Upper Saddle River, NJ : Pearson Education, Inc .
34.
Kristol
I
(1975 ) On corporate capitalism in America . National Affairs 41 (Fall ): 124 –141 .
35.
Macey
JR
(1991 ) An economic analysis of the various rationales for making shareholders the exclusive beneficiaries of corporate fiduciary duties . Stetson Law Review 21 (1 ): 23 –44 .
36.
McDonnell
B
(2004 ) Corporate constituency statutes and employee governance . William Mitchell Law Review 30 (4 ): 1227 –1259 .
37.
Nozick
R
(1974 ) Anarchy, State and Utopia . New York, NY : Basic Books .
38.Organisation for Economic Co-Operation Development (2015 ) G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance . Available at : http://www.oecd.org/corporate/principles-corporate-governance/ (accessed 16 February 2020) .
39.
Penn
C
(2016 ) Corporate concentration . The Economist , 24 March . Available at : https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2016/03/24/corporate-concentration (accessed 3 March 2020) .
40.
Pfeffer
J
(1982 ) Organizations and Organization Theory . Chicago, IL : Pittman .
41.
Pfeffer
J
Salancik
G
(1978 ) The External Control of Organizations: A Resource-Dependence Perspective . New York, NY : Harper & Row .
42.
Phillips
RA
(1997 ) Stakeholder theory and a principle of fairness . Business Ethics Quarterly 7 (1 ): 51 –66 .
43.
Pirson
M
Turnbull
S
(2015 ) The future of corporate governance: network governance—a lesson from the financial crisis . Human Systems Management 34 : 81 –89 .
44.
Ramaswamy
V
(2020 ) The “stakeholders” vs. the people . The Wall Street Journal February 12 : A7 .
45.
Rawls
J
(1971 ) A Theory of Justice . Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
46.
Roosevelt
FD
(1938 , April 29 ) Message to Congress on the concentration of economic power, Pepperdine University . Available at : https://publicpolicy.pepperdine.edu/academics/research/faculty-research/new-deal/roosevelt-speeches/fr042938.htm (accessed 14 December 2020 ).
47.
Rowley
T
(1997 ) Moving beyond dyadic ties: a network theory of stakeholder influence . Academy of Management Review 22 (4 ): 887 –910 .
48.
Schneper
WD
Guillén
MF
(2004 ) Stakeholder rights and corporate governance: a cross-national study of hostile takeovers . Administrative Quarterly 49 : 263 –295 .
49.
Schwab
K
(2019 ) Why we need the “Davos manifesto” for a better kind of capitalism . 1 December . Available at : https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/12/why-we-need-the-davos-manifesto-for-better-kind-of-capitalism/?emailType=Newsletter (accessed 27 January 2020) .
50.
Simon
HA
(1956 ) Rational choice and the structure of the environment . Psychological Review 63 (2 ): 129 –138 .
51.
Simon
HA
(1979 ) Rational decision making in business organizations . The American Economic Review 69 (4 ): 493 –513 .
52.Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2017 ) Distributive justice . 26 September . Available at : https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-distributive/ (accessed 29 February 2020) .
53.
Stout
LA
(2008 ) Why we should stop teaching dodge v. ford . UCLA School of Law, Law-Econ Research Paper No. 07-11 . Available at SSRN : https://ssrn.com/abstract=1013744orhttp://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1013744 (accessed 23 March 2020) .
54.
Stout
LA
(2012 a) The problem of corporate purpose . Issues in Governance Studies . 48 (1 ): 1 –14 .
55.
Stout
LA
(2012 b) The Shareholder Value Myth: How Putting Shareholders First Harms Investors, Corporations and the Public . Oakland, CA : Berrett-Koehler Publications .
56.
Stracqualursi
M
(2017 ) The rise of the public benefit corporation: considerations for start-ups . Boston College Law School, BC Legal Services Lab , 21 March . Available at : https://bclawlab.org/eicblog/2017/3/21/the-rise-of-the-public-benefit-corporation-considerations-for-start-ups (accessed 20 February 2020) .
57.
Tehrani
P
(2019 ) Can the business judgment rule serve multiple masters? Bloomberg Law Journal , 4 November . Available at : https://news.bloomberglaw.com/bloomberg-law-analysis/analysis-can-the-business-judgment-rule-serve-multiple-masters (accessed 25 March 2020) .
58.
The Economist
(2019 ) Big business is beginning to accept broader social responsibilities . 22 August . Available at : https://www.economist.com/briefing/2019/08/22/big-business-is-beginning-to-accept-broader-social-responsibilities (accessed 15 January 2020) .
59.
The New York Times
(2015 ) How mergers damage the economy . The Editorial Board , 31 October . Available at : https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/01/opinion/sunday/how-mergers-damage-the-economy.html (accessed March 3, 2020) .
60.
Tucker
AM
(2015 ) Institutional investing when shareholders are not supreme . Harvard Law School on Corporate Governance , 1 June . Available at : https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2015/06/01/institutional-investing-when-shareholders-are-not-supreme/ (accessed 20 February 2020) .
61.
Wernerfelt
B
(1984 ) A resource-based view of the firm . Strategic Management Journal 5 (2 ): 171 –180 .
62.
Williamson
OE
(1975 ) Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications . New York. NY : Free Press .
63.
Williamson
OE
(1985 ) The Economic Institutions of Capitalism . New York, NY : Free Press .
64.World Economic Forum (2019 ) The Universal Purpose of a Company in the Fourth Industrial Revolution . 2 December . Available at : http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_AM20_Davos_Manifesto.pdf?emailType= (accessed 27 January 2020) .