We explored semantic memory and feeling of knowing (FOK) for titles, lyrics, and
melodies of songs as well as the effectiveness of these three components as cues for
each other. Melodies and titles were recalled equally well and better than lyrics,
but lyrics were the better cue for both. Lyrics were also better cues for titles or
melodies than vice versa. When recall failed, lyrics were given the higher FOK
ratings, especially with the melody cues. In addition, titles elicited stronger FOKs
for lyrics, melodies elicited stronger FOKs for lyrics, and titles elicited stronger
FOKs for melodies than vice versa. Accuracy data also showed asymmetries between
these three components. In addition, in recall, lyrics cued subsequent lyrics and
melodies cued subsequent melodies, although melodies elicited stronger FOKs than did
lyrics. Possible explanations for the findings are discussed.
Ali, S.O.
and
Peynircioğlu, Z.F.
(2006) `
Songs and Emotions: Are Lyrics and Melodies Equal Partners?
', Psychology of Music34:
511—32.
2.
Bartlett, J.C.
and
Snelus, P.
(1980) `
Lifespan Memory for Popular Songs
', American Journal of Psychology93:
551—60.
3.
Buchanan, T.
and
Adolphs, R.
(2002) `The Role of the Human Amygdala in Emotional
Modulation of Long-term Declarative Memory', in
S. Moore
and
M. Oaksford
(eds) Emotional Cognition: From Brain to Behavior, pp.
9—34. London:
Benjamins.
4.
Buday, E.
(1995) `
The Effects of Signed and Spoken Words Taught with Music on Sign and Speech
Imitation by Children with Autism
', Journal of Music Therapy32:
189—202.
5.
Crowder, R.G.
,
Serafine, M.L.
and
Repp, B.
(1990) `
Physical Interaction and Association by Contiguity in Memory for the Words
and Melodies of Songs
', Memory & Cognition18:
469—76.
6.
Feierabend, J.
,
Saunders, T.
,
Holahan, J.
and
Getnick, P.
(1998) `
Song Recognition among Preschool-age Children: An Investigation of Words
and Music
', Journal of Research in Music Education46:
351—9.
7.
Gingold, H.
and
Abravanel, E.
(1987) `
Music as a Mnemonic: The Effects of Good- and Bad-music Settings on
Verbatim Recall of Short Passages by Young Children
', Psychomusicology7:
25—39.
8.
Hamann, S.
(2001) `
Cognitive and Neural Mechanisms of Emotional Memory', Trends
in Cognitive Sciences5:
394—400.
9.
Hart, J.T.
(1965) `
Memory and the Feeling-of-knowing Experience
', Journal of Educational Psychology56:
208—16.
10.
Jeffries, K.J.
,
Fritz, J.B.
and
Braun, A.R.
(2003) `
Words in Melody: An H(2) 150 PET Study of Brain Activation during Singing
and Speaking
', Neuroreport14:
749—54.
11.
Korenman, L.M.
and
Peynircioğlu, Z.F.
(2004) `
The Role of Familiarity in Episodic Memory and Metamemory for Music',
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, &Cognition30:
917—22.
12.
Nelson, T.O.
(1984) `
A Comparison of Current Measures of Feeling-of-knowing Accuracy
', Psychological Bulletin95:
109—33.
13.
Nelson, T.O.
,
McSpadden, M.
,
Fromme, K.
and
Marlatt, G.A.
(1986) `
Effects of Alcohol Intoxication on Metamemory and on Retrieval from
Long-term Memory
', Journal of Experimental Psychology: General115:
247—54.
14.
Peretz, I.
,
Radeau, M.
and
Arguin, M.
(2004) `
Two-way Interactions between Music and Language: Evidence from Priming
Recognition of Tune and Lyrics in Familiar Songs
', Memory & Cognition32:
142—52.
15.
Peretz, I.
,
Gagnon, L.
,
Hébert, S.
and
Macoir, J.
(2004) `
Singing in the Brain: Insights from Cognitive Neuropsychology
', Music Perception21:
373—90.
16.
Peynircioğlu, Z.F.
,
Tekcan, A.İ.
,
Wagner, J.L.
,
Baxter, T.L.
and
Shaffer, S.D.
(1998) `
Name or Hum That Tune: Feeling of Knowing for Music
', Memory and Cognition26:
1131—7.
17.
Rainey, D.W.
and
Larsen, J.D.
(2002) `
The Effects of Familiar Melodies on Initial Learning and Long-term Memory
for Unconnected Text
', Music Perception20:
173—86.
Rubin, D.
(1977) `
Very Long-term Memory for Prose and Verse
', Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior16:
611—21.
20.
Samson, S.
and
Zatorre, R.J.
(1991) `
Recognition Memory for Text and Melody of Songs after Unilateral Temporal
Lobe Lesion: Evidence for Dual Encoding', Journal of Experimental
Psychology: Learning, Memory, &Cognition17:
793—804.
21.
Serafine, M.L.
,
Crowder, R.G.
and
Repp, B.H.
(1984) `
Integration of Melody and Text in Memory for Songs
', Cognition16:
285—303.
22.
Serafine, M.L.
,
Davidson, J.
,
Crowder, R.G.
and
Repp, B.H.
(1986) `
On the Nature of Melody—Text Integration in Memory for Songs.
Journal of Memory andLanguage25:
123—35.
23.
Sousou, S.D.
(1997) `
Effects of Melody and Lyrics on Mood and Memory
', Perceptual & Motor Skills85:
31—40.
24.
Stratton, V.N.
, and
Zalanowski, A.H.
(1994) `
Affective Impact of Music vs. Lyrics
', Empirical Studies of the Arts12:
173—84.
25.
Tulving, E.
(1972) `Episodic and Semantic Memory', in
E. Tulving
and
W. Donaldson
(eds) Organization of Memory, pp.
381—403. New
York: Academic Press.
26.
Wallace, W.T.
(1994) `
Memory for Music: Effect of Melody on Recall of Text', Journal of
Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, &Cognition20:
1471—85.
27.
Watkins, M.J.
(1979) `Engrams as Cuegrams and Forgetting as Cue Overload: A
Cueing Approach to the Structure of Memory', in
C.R. Puff
(ed.) Memory Organization and Structure, pp.
347—72. New
York: Academic Press.
28.
Watkins, O.C.
and
Watkins, M.J.
(1975) `
Buildup of Proactive Inhibition as a Cue-overload Effect
', Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory1:
442—52.
29.
Yalch, R.F.
(1991) `
Memory in a Jingle Jungle: Music as a Mnemonic Device in Communicating
Advertising Slogans
', Journal of Applied Psychology76:
268—75.
