How do musicians performing together coordinate their actions to achieve a unified
performance? We observed a singer (the first author) and pianist/conductor (the
third author) as they prepared for two performances of Ricercar 1 from
Stravinsky's Cantata, one for voice and piano and one for voice and
ensemble. This article reports a content analysis of the musicians’ verbal
commentaries made in two individual practice sessions and their discussions during
two joint rehearsals at the beginning and end of the rehearsal period. In their
individual sessions, the musicians began identifying features of the music to use as
performance cues that would serve as landmarks to guide their
performances. In their joint sessions, some of these features were turned into
shared performance cues that could be used to coordinate their actions.
The musicians’ comments show how they resolved differences in their
conceptualizations of the compositional structure of the piece and how they
coordinated their music-making through the use of shared performance cues.
Allmendinger, J.
,
Hackman, R.
and
Lehman, E.V.
(1994) Life and Work in Symphony Orchestras: An Interim
Report of Research Findings, Cross-national study of symphony
orchestras, Report no. 7.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
.
2.
Atik, Y. (1992) ‘The Conductor and the Orchestra: A Study in
Leadership, Culture and Authority’, unpublished masters’
dissertation, University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology.
3.
Atik, Y.
(1994)
‘The Conductor and the Orchestra: Interactive Aspects of the
Leadership Process’
, Leadership and Organizational Development Journal15(1):
22–28
.
4.
Atik, Y.
(1995)
‘People Factors in the Performing Arts’
, Performing Arts Medicine News3(3):
7–12
.
5.
Chaffin, R.
and
Imreh, G.
(1997)
‘“Pulling Teeth and Torture”: Musical Memory
and Problem Solving’
, Thinking and Reasoning3:
315–336
.
6.
Chaffin, R.
and
Imreh, G.
(2001)
‘A Comparison of Practice and Self-report as Sources of
Information about the Goals of Expert Practice’
, Psychology of Music29:
39–69
.
7.
Chaffin, R.
and
Imreh, G.
(2002)
‘Practicing Perfection: Piano Performance as Expert Memory’
, Psychological Science13:
342–349
.
8.
Chaffin, R.
,
Imreh, G.
and
Crawford, M.
(2002) Practicing Perfection: Memory and Piano Performance.
Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
.
9.
Chaffin, R.
,
Lemieux, A.
, and
Chen, C.
(2004)
‘“It's Different Each Time I Play”:
Why Highly Polished Performances Vary’
, in
S.D. Lipscomb
,
R. Ashley
,
R.O. Gjerdingen
and
P. Webster
(eds) Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Music
Perception & Cognition, Evanston, IL, 2004. Adelaide:
Causal Productions.
10.
Chaffin, R.
,
Lemieux, A.
, and
Chen, C.
(in preparation) ‘“It's Different Each
Time I Play”: Variation and Control in Highly Prepared
Musical Performance’.
11.
Chaffin, R.
,
Imreh, G.
,
Lemieux, A.
, and
Chen, C.
(2003)
‘“Seeing the Big Picture”: Piano Practice as
Expert Problem Solving’
, Music Perception20:
465–490
.
12.
Chase, W.G.
, and
Ericsson, K.A.
(1982) ‘Skilled and Working
Memory’, in
G.H. Bower
(ed.) The Psychology of Learning and Motivation, Vol. 16, pp.
1–58.
New York: Academic Press
.
13.
Ericsson, K.A.
and
Kintsch, W.
(1995)
‘Long-Term Working Memory’
, Psychological Review102:
211–245
.
14.
Ericsson, K.A.
and
Lehmann, A.C.
(1996)
‘Expert and Exceptional Performance: Evidence of Maximal
Adaptation to Task Constraints’
, Annual Review of Psychology47:
273–305
.
15.
Ericsson, K.A.
,
Krampe, R.Th.
, and
Tesch-Römer, C.
(1993)
‘The Role of Deliberate Practice in the Acquisition of Expert Performance’
, Psychological Review100(3):
363–406
.
16.
Ginsborg, J.
(2000)
‘Off by Heart: Expert Singers’ Memorization Strategies
and Recall for the Words and Music of Songs’
, in
C. Woods
,
G. Luck
,
R. Brochard
,
F. Seddon
and
J.A. Sloboda
(eds) Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Music
Perception and Cognition(CD-ROM). Keele: Keele University.
17.
Ginsborg, J.
(2002)
‘Classical Singers Memorizing a New Song: An Observational Study’
, Psychology of Music30(1):
56–99
.
18.
Ginsborg, J.
(2003)
‘Singers’ Goals for Practice: Verbal Reports and
Behavioural Data’
, paper presented at the 5th Triennial Conference of the European
Society for the Cognitive Sciences of Music, Hanover University of Music and
Drama, September, Hanover, Germany.
19.
Gruson, L.M.
(1988) ‘Rehearsal Skill and Musical Competence:
Does Practice Make Perfect?’, in
J.A. Sloboda
(ed.) Generative Processes in Music: the Psychology of Performance,
Improvisation and Composition, pp. 91–112.
London: Oxford University Press
.
20.
Hallam, S.
(1997)
‘The Development of Memorization Strategies in Musicians:
Implications for Education’
, British Journal of Music Education14(1):
87–97
.
21.
Hardcastle, W.J.
and
Hewlett, N.
(1999) Coordination: Theory, Data and Techniques.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
22.
Imreh, G.
and
Chaffin, R.
(1996–97)
‘Understanding and Developing Musical Memory: The Views of a
Concert Pianist and a Cognitive Psychologist’
, American Music Teacher46(3):
20–24, 67–67
.
23.
Krampe, R.T.
and
Ericsson, K.A.
(1996)
‘Maintaining Excellence: Deliberate Practice and Elite
Performance in Young and Older Pianists’
, Journal of Experimental Psychologyy: General25:
331–359
.
24.
Lehmann, A.C.
and
Ericsson, K.A.
(1995),
‘Expert Pianists’ Mental Representations of Memorized Music’
, poster presented at the 36th meeting of the Psychonomic
Society, November, Los Angeles, California.
25.
Lehmann, A.C.
and
Ericsson, K.A.
(1998)
‘Preparation of a Public Piano Performance: The Relation between
Practice and Performance’
, Musicae Scientiae2(1):
67–94
.
26.
Lisboa, T.
,
Chaffin, R.
,
Schiaroli, A.G.
,
Barrera, A.
(2004)
‘Investigating Practice and Performance on the Cello’
, in
S.D. Lipscomb
,
R. Ashley
,
R.O. Gjerdingen
and
P. Webster
(eds) Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Music
Perception & Cognition, Evanston, IL, 2004(CD-ROM).
Adelaide: Causal Productions.
27.
Miklaszewski, K.
(1989)
‘A Case Study of a Pianist Preparing a Musical Performance’
, Psychology of Music17:
95–109
.
28.
Miklaszewski, K.
(1995)
‘Individual Differences in Preparing a Musical Composition for
Public Performance’
, in
M. Manturzewska
,
K. Miklaszewski
,
A. Bialkowski
(eds) Psychology of Music Today: Proceedings of the International
Seminar of Researchers and Lecturers in the Psychology of Music, pp.
138–146
. Radziejowice, Poland, September.
29.
Murnighan, J.K.
and
Conlon, D.E.
(1991)
‘The Dynamics of Intense Work Groups: A Study of British String Quartets’
, Administrative Science Quarterly36:
165–186
.
30.
Noice, H.
,
Chaffin, R.
,
Noice, A.Jeffrey, J.M.
and
Pelletier, J.
(2004)
‘Specifying the Flexible Mental Representation Used in Jazz Improvization’
, poster presented at the Psychonomic Society,
November, Minneapolis.
31.
Schögler, B.W.
(1999) ‘Studying Temporal Coordination in Jazz
Duets’, Musicae Scientiae Special Issue,
1999–2000: Rhythms, Musical Narrative, and the Origins of Human
Communication: 75–89.
32.
Sloboda, J.A.
,
Davidson, J.W.
,
Howe, M.J.A.
and
Moore, D.G.
(1996)
‘The Role of Practice in the Development of Expert Musical Performance’
, British Journal of Psychology87:
287–309
.
33.
Stravinsky, I.
(1952) ‘Cantata’ for Soprano and Tenor
Soli, Female Chorus and Instrumental Ensemble.
London: Boosey and Hawkes
.
34.
Williamon, A.
, and
Davidson, J.W.
(2002)
‘Exploring Co-performer Communication’
, Musicae Scientiae6:
53–72
.
35.
Williamon, A.
and
Valentine, E.
(2002)
‘The Role of Retrieval Structures in Memorizing Music’
, Cognitive Psychology44:
1–32
.
