A three-year single case study of a composer was undertaken in order to track the
compositional process in real time. A combination of data collection techniques was
used to attempt to map cognitive processes: digital MIDI save-as files, analogue
audio files, semi-structured interviews, immediately retrospective verbal accounts
and verification sessions between composer and researcher. Findings indicated a
chunking of processes and strategies at micro and macro levels. A hypothetical model
is presented which points to a generative process of problem proliferation and
successive solution implementation, occurring not only in a linear manner but also
recursively. Moments of creative insight were observed which related to Gestalt
theory problem restructuring; some were seen to overlap in real time with others,
indicating an element of parallelism in creative thinking. A synthesis of differing
creative process theories is suggested to explain the compositional process observed
in the study.
Alty, J.L.
(1995)
‘Navigating through Compositional Space: The Creativity Corridor’
, Leonardo28(3):
215-219
.
2.
Aranosian, C.M.
(1981)
‘Musical Creativity: The Stream of Consciousness in Composition,
Improvisation and Education’
, Imagination, Cognition and Personality1(1):
67-88
.
3.
Bamberger, J.
(1977) ‘In search of a Tune’,
in
D. Perkins
and
B. Leondar
(eds) The Arts and Cognition, pp. 284-389.
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
4.
Bamberger, J.
(1978) ‘Intuitive and Formal Musical Knowing:
Parables of Cognitive Dissonance’, in
S.S. Madeja
(ed.) The Arts; Cognition and Basic Skills, pp.
173-209.
St. Louis, MO: CEMREL
.
5.
Bamberger, J.
(1982) ‘Revisiting Children’s Drawings
of Simple Rhythms: A Function for Reflection-in-Action’, in
S. Strauss
(ed.) U-shaped Behavioural Growth, pp.
191-226.
New York: Academic Press
.
6.
Bamberger, J.
(1991) The Mind Behind the Musical Ear: How Children Develop
Musical Intelligence.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
7.
Bamberger, J.
and
Schon, D.A.
(1977) ‘Learning as Reflective Conversation with
Materials’, in
F. Steir
(ed.) Research and Reflexivity, pp. 186-209.
London: Sage
.
8.
Baroni, M.
(1999)
‘Musical Grammar and the Study of Cognitive Processes of Composition’
, Musicae Scientiae3(1):
3-21
.
9.
Bennett, S.
(1976)
‘The Process of Musical Creation: Interviews with Eight Composers’
, Journal of Research in Music Education24(1):
3-13
.
10.
Boden, M.
(1994) ‘What is Creativity?’
in
M. Boden
(ed.) Dimensions of Creativity, pp. 75-117.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
11.
Bunting, R.
(1987)
‘Composing Music: Case Studies in the Teaching and Learning Process’
, British Journal of Music Education4(1):
25-32
.
12.
Burnard, P.
and
Younker, B.A.
(2002)
‘Mapping Pathways: Fostering Creativity in Composition’
, Music Education Research4(2):
245-261
.
13.
Colley, A.
,
Banton, L.
and
Down, J.
(1992)
‘An Expert-Novice Comparison in Musical Composition’
, Psychology of Music20(2):
124-137
.
14.
Collins, D. (2001) ‘Investigating Computer-Based Compositional
Processes: A Case-Study Approach’, unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of Sheffield.
15.
Conant, B. (1988) ‘A Study of Cognitive Processes of Children
Creating Music in a Computer Learning Environment’, unpublished doctoral
dissertation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA.
16.
Davidson, J.E.
and
Scripp, L.
(1988) ‘Young Children’s Musical
Representations: Windows on Music Cognition’, in
J.A. Sloboda
(ed.) Generative Processes in Music: The Psychology of Performance,
Improvisation and Composition, pp. 193-230.
Oxford: Oxford Science Publications
.
17.
Davidson, J.E.
and
Sternberg, R.J.
(1984)
‘The Role of Insight in Intellectual Giftedness’
, Gifted Child Quarterly28:
58-64
.
18.
Davidson, L.
and
Welsh, P.
(1988) ‘From Collections to Structure: the
Developmental Path of Tonal Thinking’, in
J.A. Sloboda
(ed.) Generative Processes in Music; the Psychology of Performance,
Improvisation and Composition, pp. 260-285.
Oxford: Oxford Science Publications
.
19.
Doig, D.
(1941)
‘Creative Music: 1. Music Composed for a Given Text’
, Journal of Educational Research35(4):
263-275
.
20.
Duncker, K.
(1945) On Problem Solving. Psychological Monographs 58.
Washington DC: American Psychological Association
.
21.
Emmerson, S.
(1989)
‘Composing Strategies and Pedagogy’
, Contemporary Music Review3:
133-144
.
22.
Ericsson, K.A.
and
Simon, H.A.
(1980)
‘Verbal Reports as Data’
, Psychological Review87(3):
214-225
.
23.
Ericsson, K.A.
and
Simon, H.A.
(1984) Protocol Analysis.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
Folkestad, G.
(1996) Computer Based Creative Music Making: Young
People’s Music in the Digital Age. Göteborg
Studies in Educational Sciences 104.
Gothenburg: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis
.
27.
Folkestad, G.
,
Hargreaves, D.J.
and
Lindstrom, B.
(1997)
‘Compositional Strategies in Computer-Based Music Making’
, British Journal of Music Education15(1):
83-98
.
Gruber, H.E.
(1980) Darwin on Man: A Psychological Study of Scientific
Creativity,
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
30.
Gruber, H.E.
and
Davis, S.
(1988) ‘Inching Our Way Up Mount Olympus: The
Evolving Systems Approach to Creative Thinking’, in
R.J. Sternberg
(ed.) The Nature of Creativity: Contemporary Psychological
Perspectives, pp. 243-270.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
31.
Hayes, J.R.
and
Flower, L.S.
(1983) ‘Uncovering Cognitive Processes in
Writing: An Introduction to Protocol Analysis’, in
P. Mosenthal
,
L. Taylor
and
S. Walmsley
(eds) Research in Writing Principles and Methods, pp.
207-220.
New York: Longman
.
32.
Johnson-Laird, P.
(1988) ‘Freedom and Constraint in
Creativity’, in
R. Sternberg
(ed.) The Nature of Creativity, pp. 202-219.
Cambridge University Press
.
33.
Johnson-Laird, P.
(1993) Human and Machine Thinking.
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
34.
Kennedy, M.A.
(1999)
‘Where Does the Music Come From? A Comparison Case-Study of the
Compositional Processes of a High-School and a Collegiate Composer’
, British Journal of Music Education16(2):
157-177
.
35.
Kohler, W.
(1940) Dynamics in Psychology.
New York: Macmillan
.
36.
Kratus, J. (1985) ‘Rhythm, Melody, Motive and Phrase
Characteristics of Original Songs by Children Aged 5 to 13’, unpublished
doctoral dissertation, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL.
37.
Kratus, J.
(1989)
‘A Time Analysis of the Compositional Processes Used by Children
Ages 7 to 11’
, Journal of Research in Music Education37(1):
5-20
.
38.
Kratus, J.
(1994)
‘Relationships Among Children’s Music Audiation and
their Compositional Processes and Products’
, Journal of Research in Music Education42(2):
115-130
.
39.
Langer, S.
(1967) Feeling and Form.
London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
.
40.
Laske, O.
(1989)
‘Composition Theory: An Enrichment of Music Theory’
, Interface18(1-2):
45-49
.
41.
Loane, B.
(1984)
‘Thinking about Children’s Compositions’
, British Journal of Music Education1(3):
205-231
.
42.
Lubart, T.
(1994) ‘Creativity’, in
R.J. Sternberg
(ed.) Thinking and Problem Solving, pp.
289-332.
San Diego, CA: Academic Press
.
43.
Metcalfe, J.
and
Weibe, D.
(1987)
‘Intuition in Insight and Non-Insight Problem Solving’
, Memory and Cognition12(2):
238-246
.
44.
Minsky, M.
and
Laske, O.
(1992)
‘Forward: A Conversation with Marvin Minsky’
, AI Magazine13(3):
31-45
.
45.
Moore, B.
(1989) ‘Musical Thinking
Processes’, in
E. Boardman
(ed.) Dimensions of Musical Thinking, pp.
33-44.
Reston, VA: MENC
.
46.
Mumford, M.D.
(2003)
‘Where Have We Been, Where Are We Going? Taking Stock in
Creativity Research’
, Creativity Research Journal15(2/3):
107-120
.
47.
Newell, A.
and
Simon, H.A.
(1972) Human Problem Solving.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
.
48.
Newell, A.
,
Shaw, J.C.
and
Simon, H.A.
(1962) ‘The Processes of Creative
Thinking’, in
H. Gruber
,
G. Terell
, and
M. Wertheimer
(eds) Contemporary Approaches to Creative Thinking, pp.
63-119.
New York: Atherton Press
.
49.
Perkins, D.L.
(1981) The Mind’s Best Work.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
.
50.
Persson, R.S.
and
Robson, C.
(1995)
‘The Limits of Experimentation: On Researching Music and Musical Settings’
, Psychology of Music23(1):
39-47
.
51.
Reitman, W.R.
(1965) Cognition and Thought.
New York: Wiley
.
52.
Reybrouk, M.
(1997) ‘Gestalt Concepts and Music: Limitations
and Possibilities’, in
M. Leman
(ed.) Music, Gestalt and Computing: Lecture Notes in Artificial
Intelligence, No. 1317, pp. 57-69.
Berlin: Springer-Verlag
.
53.
Roozendaal, R.
(1993)
‘Psychological Analysis of Musical Composition: Composition as Design’
, Contemporary Music Review9(1/2):
311-324
.
54.
Schoon, I.
(1992) Creative Achievement in Architecture: A Psychological
Study.
Leiden University: DSWO Press
.
55.
Scripp, L
,
Meyaard, J.
and
Davidson, L.
(1988)
‘Discerning Musical Development: Using Computers to Discover What
We Know’
, Journal of Aesthetic Education22(1):
75-88
.
56.
Seddon, F.A.
and
O’Neill, S.A.
(2003)
‘Creative Thinking Processes in Adolescent Computer-Based
Composition: An Analysis of Strategies Adopted and the Influence of
Instrumental Music Training’
, Music Education Research5(2):
125-137
.
57.
Sloboda, J.
(1985) The Musical Mind.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
58.
Sloboda, J.
(1995)
‘Do Psychologists Have Anything Useful to Say about Composition?’
Paper presented at the Third European Conference of Music
Analysis, Montpellier, France, 16-19
February. Courtesy of the author.
59.
Smagorinsky, P.
(1994) Speaking about Writing: Reflections on Research
Methodology.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
60.
Smith, B.
and
Smith, W.
(1994) ‘Uncovering Cognitive Processes in Music
Composition: Educational and Computational Approaches’, in
M. Smith
,
A. Smaill
, and
G. Wiggins
(eds) Music Education: An Artificial Intelligence Approach, pp.
56-73.
New York: Springer-Verlag
.
61.
Swanwick, K.
and
Tillman, J.
(1986)
‘The Sequence of Musical Development: a Study of
Childrens’ Composition’
, British Journal of Music Education3(3):
305-338
.
62.
Tardif, T.Z.
and
Sternberg, R.
(1988) ‘What Do We Know About
Creativity?’ in
R. Sternberg
(ed.) The Nature of Creativity, pp. 429-440.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
63.
Tenney, J.
and
Polansky, L.
(1980)
‘Temporal Gestalt Perception in Music’
, Journal of Music Theory24(3):
205-241
.
64.
Terhardt, E.
(1987) ‘Gestalt Principles and Music
Perception’, in
W.A. Yost
and
C.S. Watson
(eds) Perception of Complex Auditory Stimuli, pp.
157-166.
Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
.
65.
Van Ernst, B.
(1993)
‘A Study of the Learning and Teaching Processes of Non-Naive
Music Students Engaged in Composition’
, Research Studies in Music Education1 (December):
22-39
.
66.
Wallas, G.
(1926) The Art of Thought.
London: Watts
.
67.
Webster, P.R.
(1987) ‘Conceptual Bases for Creative Thinking
in Music’, in
J.C. Peery
,
I.C. Peery
and
T.W. Draper
(eds) Music and Child Development, pp.
158-174.
New York: Springer-Verlag
.
68.
Webster, P.R.
(1989) ‘Creative Thinking in Music; the
Assessment Question’, in
J.W. Richmond
(ed.) The Proceedings of the Suncoast Music Education Forum on
Creativity, pp. 40-74.
Tampa: University of S. Florida
,
69.
Webster, P.R.
(1992) ‘Research on Creative Thinking in Music:
the Assessment Issue’, in
R. Colwell
(ed.) Handbook of Research on Music Teaching and Learning, Music
Educators National Conference, pp. 226-280.
New York: Schirmer
.
70.
Webster, P.R.
(2002) ‘Creative Thinking in Music: Advancing a
Model’, in
T. Sullivan
and
L. Willingham
(eds) Creativity and Music Education, pp.
16-33.
Edmonton: Canadian Music Educators Association
.
71.
Wertheimer, M.
(1945) Productive Thinking.
London: Tavistock
.
72.
Wilson, S.J.
and
Wales, R.J.
(1995)
‘An Exploration of Children’s Musical Compositions’
, Journal of Research in Music Education43(2):
94-111
.
73.
Witte, S.P.
and
Cherry, R.D.
(1994) ‘Think-Aloud Protocols, Protocol
Analysis, and Research Design: An Exploration of the Influence of Writing Tasks
on Writing Processes’, in
P. Smagorinsky
(ed.) Speaking About Writing: Reflections on Research Methodology,
pp. 20-54.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
74.
Younker, B.A.
and
Smith, W.H.
(1996)
‘Comparing and Modelling Musical Thought Processes of Expert and
Novice Composers’
, Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education128:
25-35
.
