Extant research is equivocal on the positive and negative implications of counterfeits and is unable to offer an explanation for why purchase and use of counterfeits evoke mixed and contentious responses. We argue that the unreconciled claims about counterfeits are partially rooted in the divided logics of value, as articulated by the goods-dominant logic (GDL) versus service-dominant logic (SDL). We develop a conceptual understanding of non-deceptive counterfeits (NDCs) atop SDL axioms, along key extant research debates. Our examination of the theoretical GDL-SDL views of NDCs with a synthesis of 132 extant academic works, informs the adversarial orientation towards such products. We address extant debates using a content analysis of studies on NDCs. We offer propositions that link the theoretical relevance of evaluating outcomes of NDCs from an SDL perspective and provide foci for future research on this subject.
AmaralNelson B.LokenBarbara (2016), “Viewing Usage of Counterfeit Luxury Goods: Social Identity and Social Hierarchy Effects on Dilution and Enhancement of Genuine Luxury Brands,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 26 (4), 483-495.
2.
AmaralNelson Borges (2020), “What Can Be Done to Address Luxury Counterfeiting? An Integrative Review of Tactics and Strategies,” Journal of Brand Management, 27 (6), 691-709.
3.
Augusto de MatosCelsoItuassuCristiana TrindadeRossiCarlos Alberto Vargas (2007), “Consumer Attitudes toward Counterfeits: A Review and Extension,” Journal of Consumer Marketing, 24 (1), 36-47.
4.
BaghiIlariaGabrielliVeronicaGrappiSilvia (2016), “Consumers’ Awareness of Luxury Brand Counterfeits and Their Subsequent Responses: When a Threat Becomes an Opportunity For the Genuine Brand,” Journal of Product & Brand Management, 25 (5), 452-464.
5.
BeqirajEltonFedeliSilviaGiuriatoLuisa (2020), “Policy Tolerance of Economic Crime? An Empirical Analysis of the Effect of Counterfeiting on Italian Trade,” European Journal of Political Economy, 65, 101933.
6.
BermanBarry (2008), “Strategies to Detect and Reduce Counterfeiting Activity,” Business Horizons, 51 (3), 191-199.
7.
BianXuemei (2006), “An Examination of Factors Influencing the Formation of the Consideration Set and Consumer Purchase Intention in the Context of Non-deceptive Counterfeiting,” doctoral dissertation, University of Glasgow.
8.
BianXuemei (2018), “Do Counterfeits Only Affect Brands That Are Heavily Counterfeited? New Insights,” The Brand Protection Professional, 3(2), 20-22.
9.
BianXuemeiMoutinhoLuiz (2011), “The Role of Brand Image, Product Involvement, and Knowledge in Explaining Consumer Purchase Behaviour of Counterfeits: Direct and Indirect Effects,” European Journal of Marketing, 45 (1/2), 191-216.
10.
BianXuemeiWangKai-YuSmithAndrewYannopoulouNatalia (2016), “New Insights into Unethical Counterfeit Consumption,” Journal of Business Research, 69 (10), 4249-4258.
11.
CampbellNorahO’DriscollAidanSarenMichael (2013), “Reconceptualizing Resources: A Critique of Service-Dominant Logic,” Journal of Macromarketing, 33 (4), 306-321.
12.
CastañoRaquelPerezMaria (2014), “A Matter of Love: Consumers’ Relationships with Original Brands and their Counterfeits,” Journal of Consumer Marketing, 31 (6/7), 475-482.
13.
CesareoLudovica (2015), Counterfeiting and Piracy: A Comprehensive Literature Review. New York, NY: Springer.
14.
CesareoLudovicaStöttingerBarbara (2015), “United We Stand, Divided We Fall: How Firms Can Engage Consumers in their Fight Against Counterfeits,” Business Horizons, 58 (5), 527-537.
15.
ChaudhryPeggyZimmermanAlan (2013), “The Global Growth of Counterfeit Trade,” in Protecting Your Intellectual Property Rights. New York, NY: Springer, 7-31.
16.
ChaudhryPeggyZimmermanAlanPetersJonathan R.CordellVictor V. (2009), “Preserving Intellectual Property Rights: Managerial Insight into the Escalating Counterfeit Market Quandary,” Business Horizons, 52 (1), 57-66.
17.
ChenJieTengLefaLiuShixiongZhuHuihuang (2015), “Anticipating Regret and Consumers’ Preferences for Counterfeit Luxury Products,” Journal of Business Research, 68 (3), 507-515.
18.
ChreimSamia (2005), “The Continuity–Change Duality in Narrative Texts of Organizational Identity,” Journal of Management Studies, 42 (3), 567-593.
19.
CorbinJulietStraussAnselm (2008), Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
20.
CordellVictor V.WongtadaNittayaKieschnickRobert L. (1996), “Counterfeit Purchase Intentions: Role of Lawfulness Attitudes and Product Traits as Determinants,” Journal of Business Research, 35 (1), 41-53.
21.
DavcikNebojsa S.SharmaPiyushChanRickyRoyRajat (2019), “An Introduction to the Special Issue on the Past, Present and Future Research on Deliberate Lookalikes,” Journal of Product & Brand Management, 28 (6), 701-706.
22.
DeyBidit LalPanditAmeetSarenMikeBhowmickSanjayWoodruffe-BurtonHelen (2016), “Co-creation of Value at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Analysing Bangladeshi Farmers’ Use of Mobile Telephony,” Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 29, 40-48.
23.
EckhardtGianna M.BelkRussellDevinneyTimothy M. (2010), “Why Don’t Consumers Consume Ethically?” Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 9(6), 426-436.
24.
Eisend (2019), “Morality Effects and Consumer Responses to Counterfeit and Pirated Products: A Meta-analysis,” Journal of Business Ethics, 154 (2), 301-323.
25.
EisendMartinTarrahiFarid (2019), “Does Counterfeiting Benefit or Harm Original Products? A Meta-analytic Investigation,” Journal of Marketing Behavior, 3 (4), 293-333.
26.
EkiciAhmetGencTugce O.CelikHafize (2021), “The Future of Macromarketing: Recommendations Based on a Content Analysis of the Past Twelve Years of the Journal of Macromarketing,” Journal of Macromarketing, 41(1), 25-47.
27.
EvansBradley P.StarrRichard G.BrodieRoderick J. (2019), “Counterfeiting: Conceptual Issues and Implications for Branding,” Journal of Product & Brand Management, 28 (6), 707-719.
28.
FernandesCedwyn (2013), “Analysis of Counterfeit Fashion Purchase Behaviour in UAE,” Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management: An International Journal, 17 (1), 85-97.
29.
FrancisJulie E.BurgessLoisLuMingyuan (2015), “Hip to be Cool: A Gen Y View of Counterfeit Luxury Products,” Journal of Brand Management, 22 (7), 588-602.
Geiger-OnetoStephanieGelbBetsy D.WalkerDougHessJames D. (2013), “‘Buying Status’ by Choosing or Rejecting Luxury Brands and their Counterfeits,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 41 (3), 357-372.
33.
GentryJames W.PutrevuSanjayShultzClifford J. (2006), “The Effects of Counterfeiting on Consumer Search,” Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 5 (3), 245-256.
34.
GinoFrancescaNortonMichael I.ArielyDan (2010), “The Counterfeit Self: The Deceptive Costs of Faking It,” Psychological Science, 21 (5), 712-720.
35.
GioiaDennis A.CorleyKevin G.HamiltonAimee L. (2013), “Seeking Qualitative Rigor in Inductive Research: Notes on the Gioia Methodology,” Organizational Research Methods, 16 (1), 15-31.
36.
GlassRichard S. and WoodWallace A. (1996), “Situational Determinants of Software Piracy: An Equity Theory Perspective,” Journal of Business Ethics, 15 (11), 1189-1198.
37.
GoslineRenée Ann Richardson (2009), “The Real Value of Fakes: Dynamic Symbolic Boundaries in Socially Embedded Consumption.” Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University.
38.
GossenMaikeZiesemerFlorenceSchraderUlf (2019), “Why and How Commercial Marketing Should Promote Sufficient Consumption: A Systematic Literature Review,” Journal of Macromarketing, 39(3), 252-269.
39.
GreenRobert T.SmithTasman (2002), “Executive Insights: Countering Brand Counterfeiters”, Journal of International Marketing, 10 (4), 89-106.
40.
GreerCharles R.LuschRobert F.VargoStephen L. (2016), “A Service Perspective,” Organizational Dynamics, 45 (1), 28-38.
41.
GrönroosChristian (2011), “Value Co-creation in Service Logic: A Critical Analysis,” Marketing Theory, 11 (3), 279-301.
42.
GrönroosChristianVoimaPäivi (2013), “Critical Service Logic: Making Sense of Value Creation and Co-creation,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 41 (2), 133-150.
43.
GurzkiHannesSchlatterNadiaWoisetschlägerDavid M. (2019), “Crafting Extraordinary Stories: Decoding Luxury Brand Communications,” Journal of Advertising, 48 (4), 401-414.
44.
HamelinNicolasNwankwoSonnyHadouchiRachad El (2013), “‘Faking Brands’: Consumer Responses to Counterfeiting,” Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 12 (3), 159-170.
45.
HatchMary JoSchultzMajken (2010), “Toward a Theory of Brand Co-creation with Implications for Brand Governance,” Journal of Brand Management, 17 (8), 590-604.
46.
HennigsNadineWiedmannKlaus-PeterKlarmannChristianeStrehlauSuzaneGodeyBrunoPederzoliDaniele, et al. (2012), “What is the Value of Luxury? A Cross-Cultural Consumer Perspective,” Psychology & Marketing, 29 (12), 1018-1034.
47.
HersteinRamDroriNetanelBergerRonBarnesBradley R. (2015), “Anticounterfeiting Strategies and Their Influence on Attitudes of Different Counterfeit Consumer Types: Counterfeit Consumption,” Psychology & Marketing, 32 (8), 842-859.
48.
HietanenJoelAndéhnMikaelBradshawAlan (2018), “Against the Implicit Politics of Service-Dominant Logic,” Marketing Theory, 18 (1), 101-119.
49.
HietanenJoelMattilaPekkaSihvonenAnttiTikkanenHenrikki (2018), “Paradox and Market Renewal: Knockoffs and Counterfeits as Doppelgänger Brand Images of Luxury,” Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 36 (7), 750-763.
KapfererJean-NoëlLaurentGilles (2016), “Where Do Consumers Think Luxury Begins? A Study of Perceived Minimum Price for 21 Luxury Goods in 7 Countries,” Journal of Business Research, 69 (1), 332-340.
52.
KaufmannHans RuedigerPetroviciDan AlexFilhoCid GonçalvesAyresAdriano (2016), “Identifying Moderators of Brand Attachment for Driving Customer Purchase Intention of Original vs Counterfeits of Luxury Brands,” Journal of Business Research, 69 (12), 5735-5747.
53.
KeyThomas M.BoostromRobert E.JrAdjeiMavis T.CampbellDavid A. (2013), “Watch Out: Themes in Timepiece Communities of Counterfeit Consumption,” Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 12 (4), 307-317.
54.
KhanSameeullahFaziliAsif I.BashirIrfan (2021), “Counterfeit Luxury Consumption: A Review and Research Agenda,” Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 20(2), 337-367.
55.
KhandeparkarKapilMotianiManoj (2018), “Fake-Love: Brand Love for Counterfeits,” Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 36 (6), 661-677.
56.
KhoujaMoutazParkSungjune (2007), “Optimal Pricing of Digital Experience Goods under Piracy,” Journal of Management Information Systems, 24 (3), 109-141.
57.
KimJae-EunJohnsonKim K. P. (2014), “Shame or Pride?: The Moderating Role of Self-Construal on Moral Judgments Concerning Fashion Counterfeits,” European Journal of Marketing, 48 (7/8), 1431-1450.
58.
KrippendorffKlaus (2018), Content Analysis: An Introduction to its Methodology. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
59.
LangleyAnn (1999), “Strategies for Theorizing from Process Data,” Academy of Management Review, 24 (4), 691-710.
60.
LiTigerSeatonBruce (2015), “Emerging Consumer Orientation, Ethical Perceptions, and Purchase Intention in the Counterfeit Smartphone Market in China,” Journal of International Consumer Marketing, 27 (1), 27-53.
61.
LiaoChun-HsiungHsiehI-Yu (2013), “Determinants of Consumer’s Willingness to Purchase Gray-Market Smartphones,” Journal of Business Ethics, 114 (3), 409-424.
62.
ListerSam (2006), “Heart patients get fake drugs supplied to NHS pharmacies.” 3rd August 2006.
63.
LittleVicki JanineLeeChristina Kwai ChoiNairSumesh (2019), “Macro-demarketing: The Key to Unlocking Unsustainable Production and Consumption Systems?” Journal of Macromarketing, 39 (2), 166-187.
64.
LuschRobert F. (2011), “Reframing Supply Chain Management: A Service-Dominant Logic Perspective,” Journal of Supply Chain Management, 47 (1), 14-18.
65.
LuschRobert F.VargoStephen L. (2011), “Service-Dominant Logic: A Necessary Step,” European Journal of Marketing, 45 (7/8), 1298-1309.
66.
LuschRobert F.VargoStephen L.GustafssonAnders (2016), “Fostering a Trans-Disciplinary Perspectives of Service Ecosystems,” Journal of Business Research, 69 (8), 2957-2963.
67.
MacdonaldEmma K.KleinaltenkampMichaelWilsonHugh N. (2016), “How Business Customers Judge Solutions: Solution Quality and Value in Use,” Journal of Marketing, 80(3), 96-120.
68.
MarticotteFrançoisArcandManon (2017), “Schadenfreude, Attitude and the Purchase Intentions of a Counterfeit Luxury Brand,” Journal of Business Research, 77, 175-183.
69.
MartinezLuis F.JaegerDorothea S. (2016), “Ethical Decision Making in Counterfeit Purchase Situations: The Influence of Moral Awareness and Moral Emotions on Moral Judgment and Purchase Intentions,” Journal of Consumer Marketing, 33 (3), 213-223.
70.
McKeageKimCrosbyElizabethRittenburgTerri (2018), “Living in a Gender-binary World: Implications for a Revised Model of Consumer Vulnerability,” Journal of Macromarketing, 38(1), 73-90.
71.
MeravigliaLaura (2018), “Technology and Counterfeiting in the Fashion Industry: Friends or Foes?” Business Horizons, 61 (3), 467-475.
72.
MichaelidouNinaChristodoulidesGeorge (2011), “Antecedents of Attitude and Intention towards Counterfeit Symbolic and Experiential Products,” Journal of Marketing Management, 27 (9–10), 976-991.
73.
MooresTrevor T. and ChangJerry Cha-Jan (2006), “Ethical Decision Making in Software Piracy: Initial Development and Test of a Four-Component Model,” MIS Quarterly, 30 (1), 167.
74.
NorumPamela S.CunoAngela (2011), “Analysis of the Demand for Counterfeit Goods,” Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management: An International Journal, 15(1), 27-40.
75.
OECD/EUIPO, Organisation de coopération et de développement (2016), Trade in Counterfeit and Pirated Goods: Mapping the Economic Impact. Paris: OECD Publishing.
76.
PadelaShoaib M. FarooqWooliscroftBenGanglmair-WooliscroftAlexandra (2021), “Brand Externalities: A Taxonomy,” Journal of Macromarketing, 41(2), 356-372.
77.
PenzElfriedeStottingerBarbara (2005), “Forget the Areal@ Thingbtake the Copy! an Explanatory Model For the Volitional Purchase of Counterfeit Products,” ACR North American Advances, 32, 568-575.
78.
PenzElfriedeStöttingerBarbara (2008), “Original Brands and Counterfeit Brands—Do They Have Anything in Common?” Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 7 (2), 146-163.
79.
PenzElfriedeStöttingerBarbara (2012), “A Comparison of the Emotional and Motivational Aspects in the Purchase of Luxury Products versus Counterfeits,” Journal of Brand Management, 19 (7), 581-594.
80.
PerezMaría EugeniaCastañoRaquelQuintanillaClaudia (2010), “Constructing Identity through the Consumption of Counterfeit Luxury Goods,” Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, 13 (3), 219-235.
81.
PhauIanTeahMin (2009), “Devil Wears (Counterfeit) Prada: A Study of Antecedents and Outcomes of Attitudes towards Counterfeits of Luxury Brands,” Journal of Consumer Marketing, 26 (1), 15-27.
82.
PoddarAmitForemanJeffBanerjeeSyagnik (Sy)EllenPam Scholder (2012), “Exploring the Robin Hood effect: Moral Profiteering Motives for Purchasing Counterfeit Products,” Journal of Business Research, 65 (10), 1500-1506.
83.
PunHubertSwaminathanJayashankar M.HouPengwen (2021), “Blockchain Adoption for Combating Deceptive Counterfeits,” Production and Operations Management, 30 (4), 864-882.
84.
QianYi (2008), “Impacts of Entry by Counterfeiters,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123 (4), 1577-1609.
85.
QianYi (2014), “Counterfeiters: Foes or friends? How Counterfeits Affect Sales by Product Quality Tier,” Management Science, 60(10), 2381-2400.
86.
RandhawaPraneetCalantoneRoger J.VoorheesClay M. (2015), “The Pursuit of Counterfeited Luxury: An Examination of the Negative Side Effects of Close Consumer–brand Connections,” Journal of Business Research, 68 (11), 2395-2403.
87.
RanjanKumar RakeshReadStuart (2016), “Value Co-creation: Concept and Measurement,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 44 (3), 290-315.
88.
RanjanKumar RakeshRohitSudeepDashRupanwitaSinghRamendra (2021), “Thinking, Feeling and Coping by BoP Healthcare Consumers: Policy-based Intervention in an Emerging Market,” Journal of Marketing Management, 37(9–10), 914-961.
89.
RaustialaKalSprigmanChristopher (2006), “The Piracy Paradox: Innovation and Intellectual Property in Fashion Design,” Virginia Law Review, 92 (8), 1687-1777.
90.
RomaniSimonaGistriGiacomoPaceStefano (2012), “When Counterfeits Raise the Appeal of Luxury Brands,” Marketing Letters, 23 (3), 807-824.
91.
SamaddarKaushikMenonPreetha (2021), “Non-Deceptive Counterfeit Products: A Morphological Analysis of Literature and Future Research Agenda,” Journal of Strategic Marketing, 2, 1-24.
92.
SharmaPiyushChanRicky Y. K. (2011), “Counterfeit Proneness: Conceptualisation and Scale development,” Journal of Marketing Management, 27 (5–6), 602-626.
93.
SharmaPiyushChanRicky Y. K. (2017), “Exploring the Role of Attitudinal Functions in Counterfeit Purchase Behavior via an Extended Conceptual Framework,” Psychology & Marketing, 34 (3), 294-308.
94.
ShultzClifford J.NillAlexander (2002), “The Societal Conundrum of Intellectual Property Rights: A Game-theoretical approach to the Equitable Management and Protection of IPR,” European Journal of Marketing, 36 (5/6), 667-688.
95.
ShultzClifford J.SaporitoBill (1996), “Protecting Intellectual Property: Strategies and Recommendations to Deter Counterfeiting and Brand Piracy in Global Markets,” The Columbia Journal of World Business, 31 (1), 18-28.
96.
StaakeThorstenThiesseFredericFleischElgar (2009), “The Emergence of Counterfeit Trade: A Literature Review,” European Journal of Marketing, 43 (3/4), 320-349.
97.
StevensonMarkBusbyJerry (2015), “An Exploratory Analysis of Counterfeiting Strategies: Towards Counterfeit-resilient Supply Chains,” International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 35 (1), 110-144.
98.
StöttingerBarbaraPenzElfriede (2015), “Concurrent Ownership of Brands and Counterfeits: Conceptualization and Temporal Transformation from a Consumer Perspective,” Psychology & Marketing, 32 (4), 373-391.
99.
StumpfStephen A.ChaudhryPeggy E.PerrettaLeeann (2011), “Fake: Can Business Stanch the Flow of Counterfeit Products?” Journal of Business Strategy, 32 (2), 4-12.
100.
TanBenjamin (2002), “Understanding Consumer Ethical Decision Making with Respect to Purchase of Pirated Software,” Journal of Consumer Marketing, 19 (2), 96-111.
101.
Van KempenLuuk (2003), “Fooling the Eye of the Beholder: Deceptive Status Signalling among the Poor in Developing Countries,” Journal of International Development, 15 (2), 157-177.
102.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2004), “Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing,” Journal of Marketing, 68 (1), 1-17.
103.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2008), “From Goods to Service(s): Divergences and Convergences of Logics,” Industrial Marketing Management, 37 (3), 254-259.
104.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2011), “It’s all B2B…and Beyond: Toward a Systems Perspective of the Market,” Industrial Marketing Management, 40 (2), 181-187.
105.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2014), “Inversions of Service-dominant Logic,” Marketing Theory, 14 (3), 239-248.
106.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2016), “Institutions and Axioms: An Extension and Update of Service-dominant Logic,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 44 (1), 5-23.
107.
VargoStephen L.LuschRobert F. (2017), “Service-dominant Logic 2025,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 34 (1), 46-67.
108.
VargoStephen L.MaglioPaul P.AkakaMelissa Archpru (2008), “On Value and Value Co-creation: A Service Systems and Service Logic Perspective,” European Management Journal, 26 (3), 145-152.
109.
WanWendy W. N.LukChung-LeungYauOliver H. M.AlanC. B.SinLeo Y. M.KwongKenneth K., et al. (2009), “Do Traditional Chinese Cultural Values Nourish a Market for Pirated CDs?” Journal of Business Ethics, 88 (1), 185-196.
110.
WangFangZhangHongxiaZangHengjiaOuyangMing (2005), “Purchasing Pirated Software: An Initial Examination of Chinese Consumers,” Journal of Consumer Marketing, 22 (6), 340-351.
111.
WangLiangyanWangYitongPechmannCornelia (2012), “Decrease or Enhance? Assessment of the Effect of Shanzhai on the Original Products,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 40, Zeynep Gürhan-Canli, Cele Otnes, and Rui (Juliet) Zhu, Duluth, eds. MN : Association for Consumer Research, 784-785.
112.
WeberRobert P. (1990), Basic Content Analysis (No. 49). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
113.
WilcoxKeithKimHyeong MinSenSankar (2009), “Why Do Consumers Buy Counterfeit Luxury Brands?” Journal of Marketing Research, 46 (2), 247-259.
114.
YazdanparastAtefehNaderiImanSpearsNancyFabrizeRobert O. (2018), “Advertising and Pseudo-culture: An Analysis of the Changing Portrayal of Women in Print Advertisements,” Journal of Macromarketing, 38(2), 185-205.
115.
YooBoongheeLeeSeung-Hee (2012), “Asymmetrical Effects of Past Experiences with Genuine Fashion Luxury Brands and their Counterfeits on Purchase Intention of Each,” Journal of Business Research, 65 (10), 1507-1515.
116.
ZhangJieZhangRachel Q. (2015), “Supply Chain Structure in a Market with Deceptive Counterfeits,” European Journal of Operational Research, 240 (1), 84-97.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
