Grade Retention and School Dropout: Comparing Specific Grade Levels Across Childhood and Early Adolescence

Abstract

Students who repeat a grade are at a higher risk of dropping out of high school. Previous research has examined this in a methodologically aggregated way (e.g., repeated any grade versus never repeated) or only specific grades/grade ranges (e.g., Kindergarten or elementary) leaving questions about which grades are more detrimental to repeat with respect to school dropout. This study uses data from the National Center for Education Statistics (N = 9,309) to comparatively examine which grades, when repeated, show the strongest associations with dropping out. Overall, those who repeated sixth or seventh had the highest odds of dropping out of high school with unique patterns by gender and race/ethnicity. These grades are typically when youth transition into middle school. When examined through a developmental lens, these results highlight the important impact that grade retention while youth experience other normative physical, cognitive, and social changes.

Keywords

grade retention repeat dropout

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akos

(2002). Student perceptions of the transition from elementary to middle school. Professional School Counseling, 5, 339-346.

Anderson

G. E.

Whipple

A. D.

Jimerson

S. R.

(2002). Grade retention: Achievement and mental health outcomes. National Association of School Psychologists. Retrieved from https://www.fmptic.org/download/grade_retention_achievement_and_mental_health_outcomes.pdf

Anderson

M. L.

Magruder

(2017). Split-sample strategies for avoiding false discoveries [No. w23544]. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Andrew

(2014). The scarring effects of primary-grade retention? A study of cumulative advantage in the educational career. Social Forces, 93, 653-685.

Balfanz

Herzog

Mac Iver

D. J.

(2007). Preventing student disengagement and keeping students on the graduation path in urban middle-grades schools: Early identification and effective interventions. Educational Psychologist, 42, 223-235.

Barber

B. K.

Olson

J. A.

(2004). Assessing the transitions to middle and high school. Journal of Adolescent Research, 191, 3-30.

Benner

A. D.

Graham

(2009). The transition to high school as a developmental process among multiethnic urban youth. Child Development, 80, 356-376.

Bornsheuer

J. N.

Polonyi

M. A.

Andrews

Fore

Onwuegbuzie

A. J.

(2011). The relationship between ninth-grade retention and on-time graduation in a southeast Texas high school. Journal of At-Risk Issues, 16(2), 9-16.

Brophy

(2006). Grade repetition. Education Policy Series, 6, 420-437.

10.

Burkam

D. T.

LoGerfo

Ready

Lee

V. E.

(2007). The differential effects of repeating kindergarten. Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk, 12, 103-136.

11.

Cardoso

J. B.

Padilla

Y. C.

Sampson

(2010). Racial and ethnic variation in the predictors of maternal parenting stress. Journal of Social Service Research, 36, 429-444.

12.

Clotfelter

C. T.

Ladd

H. F.

Vigdor

J. L.

(2007). Are teaching absences worth worrying about in the US? [No. W13648]. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

13.

Cohen

Frydenberg

(1996). Coping for capable kids. Waco, TX:Prufrock Press.

14.

Cross

T. L.

(1997). Psychological and social aspects of educating gifted students. Peabody Journal of Education, 72, 180-200.

15.

Cumming

(2009). Inference by eye: Reading the overlap of independent confidence intervals. Statistics in Medicine, 28, 205-220.

16.

Eccles

J. S.

Roeser

R. W.

(2009). Schools, academic motivation, and stage-environment fit. In Lerner

R. M.

Steinberg

(Eds.), Handbook of adolescent psychology: Individual bases of adolescent development (pp. 404-434). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.

17.

Eccles

J. S.

Roeser

R. W.

(2011). Schools as developmental contexts during adolescence. Journal of Research on Adolescence, 21, 225-241.

18.

Eccles

J. S.

Wang

(2012). Part I commentary: So what is student engagement anyway? In Christenson

S. L.

Reschly

A. L.

Wylie

(Eds.), Handbook of research on student engagement (pp. 133-145). New York, NY: Springer.

19.

Elder

(1998). The life course as developmental theory. Child Development, 69(1), 1-12.

20.

Fruehwirth

J. C.

Navarro

Takahashi

(2016). How the timing of grade retention affects outcomes: Identification and estimation of time-varying treatment effects. Journal of Labor Economics, 34(4), 979-1021.

21.

Ganiban

J. M.

Saudino

K. J.

Ulbricht

Neiderhiser

J. M.

Reiss

(2008). Stability and change in temperament during adolescence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95, 222-236.

22.

Gelman

(2007). Struggles with survey weighting and regression modeling. Statistical Science, 22, 153-164.

23.

Goos

Schreier

B. M.

Knipprath

H. M. E.

De Fraine

Van Damme

Trautwein

(2012). How can cross-country differences in the practice of grade retention be explained? A closer look at national educational policy factors. Comparative Education Review, 57, 54-84.

24.

Grissom

Shepard

(1989). Repeating and dropping out of school. In Shepard

L.A.

Smith

M.L.

(Eds.), Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention (pp. 16-33). London, UK: The Falmer Press.

25.

Gunter

W. D.

Bakken

N. W.

(2010). Transitioning to middle school in the sixth grade: A hierarchical linear modeling (HLM) analysis of substance use, violence, and suicidal thoughts. Journal of Early Adolescence, 306, 895-915.

26.

Hughes

J. N.

Cao

West

S. G.

Smith

P. A.

Cerda

(2017). Effect of retention in elementary grades on dropping out of school early. Journal of School Psychology, 65, 11-27.

27.

Hwang

S. H.

Cappella

(2018). Rethinking early elementary grade retention: Examining long-term academic and psychosocial outcomes. Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 11, 559-587.

28.

Jacob

B. A.

Lefgren

(2009). The effect of grade retention on high school completion. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 1, 33-58.

29.

James

K. E.

White

R. F.

Kraemer

H. C.

(2005). Repeated split sample validation to assess logistic regression and recursive partitioning: An application to the prediction of cognitive impairment. Statistics in Medicine, 24, 3019-3035.

30.

Jewell

Kambhampati

U. S.

(2015). Are happy youth also satisfied adults? An analysis of the impact of childhood factors on adult life satisfaction. Social Indicators Research, 121, 543-567.

31.

Jimerson

S. R.

(2001). Meta-analysis of grade retention research: Implications for practice in the 21st century. School Psychology Review, 30, 420-437.

32.

Jimerson

S. R.

Pletcher

S. M.

Graydon

Schnurr

B. L.

Nickerson

A. B.

Kundert

D. K.

(2006). Beyond grade retention and social promotion: Promoting the social and academic competence of students. Psychology in the Schools, 43, 85-97.

33.

Kish

Frankel

M. R.

(1974). Inference from complex samples. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Methodological), 36, 1-22.

34.

Kott

P. S.

(2007). Clarifying some issues in the regression analysis of survey data. Survey Research Methods, 1, 11-18.

35.

Kozol

(2005). The shame of the nation: The restoration of apartheid schooling in America. New York, NY: Crown.

36.

Lansford

J. E.

Dodge

K. A.

Pettit

G. S.

Bates

J. E.

(2016). A public health perspective on school dropout and adult outcomes: A prospective study of risk and protective factors from age 5 to 27 years. Journal of Adolescent Health, 58, 652-658.

37.

Lerner

R. M.

(2011). Trajectories of school engagement during adolescence: Implications for grades, depression, delinquency, and substance use. Developmental Psychology, 47, 233-247.

38.

Lincove

J. A.

Painter

(2006). Does the age that children start kindergarten matter? Evidence of long-term educational and social outcomes. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 28, 153-179.

39.

Lorence

(2006). Retention and academic achievement research revisited from a United States perspective. International Education Journal, 7, 731-777.

40.

Lys

(2009). Supporting high school graduation aspirations among Latino middle school students. RMLE Online, 33(3), 1-12.

41.

Marinell

W. H.

Coca

V. M.

(2013). “Who stays and who leaves?” Findings from a three-part study of teacher turnover in NYC middle school. Retrieved from https://steinhardt.nyu.edu/research-alliance/research/publications/who-stays-and-who-leaves

42.

Mathys

Véronneau

M. H.

Lecocq

(2019). Grade retention at the transition to secondary school: Using propensity score matching to identify consequences on psychosocial adjustment. Journal of Early Adolescence, 39, 97-133.

43.

McCoy

A. R.

Reynolds

A. J.

(1999). Grade retention and school performance: An extended investigation. Journal of School Psychology, 37, 273-298.

44.

McFarland

Cui

Holmes

Wang

(2019). Trends in high school dropout and completion rates in the United States: 2019 (NCES 2020-117). U.S. Department of Education. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch

45.

Midgley

Berman

Hicks

(1995). Differences between elementary and middle school teachers and students: A goal theory approach. Journal of Early Adolescence, 151, 90-113.

46.

Miller

(2015). Partnering for education reform. U.S. Department of Education. Retrieved from https://www.ed.gov/news/speech-archive?page=16

47.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2015). Trends in high school dropout and completion rates in the United States: 1972-2012. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2015/2015015.pdf

48.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2019a). High school longitudinal study of 2009. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/hsls09/

49.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2019b). Indicator 15: Retention, suspension, and expulsion. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/programs/raceindicators/indicator_RDA.asp

50.

Obinna

D. N.

Ohanian

M. M.

(2020). Uncertain aspirations: Latino students and dropout in the United States. Race Ethnicity and Education, 23, 654-672.

51.

S. R.

Reynolds

A. J.

(2010). Grade retention, postsecondary education, and public aid receipt. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 32, 118-139.

52.

Peixoto

Monteiro

Mata

Sanches

Pipa

Almeida

L. S.

(2016). “To be or not to be retained . . . That’s the question!” retention, self-esteem, self-concept, achievement goals, and grades. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, Article 1550.

53.

Pharris-Ciurej

Hirschman

(2012). The 9th grade shock and the high school dropout crisis. Social Science Research, 413, 709-730.

54.

Raffaele-Mendez

L. M.

Kim

E. S.

Ferron

Woods

(2015). Altering school progression through delayed entry or kindergarten retention: Propensity score analysis of long-term outcomes. The Journal of Educational Research, 108, 186-203.

55.

Reynolds

A. J.

(1992). Grade retention and school adjustment: An explanatory analysis. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 14, 101-121.

56.

Roderick

(1994). Grade retention and school dropout: Investigating the association. American Educational Research Journal, 31, 729-759.

57.

Rodney

Crafter

Rodney

H. E.

Mupier

R. M.

(2010). Variables contributing to grade retention among African American adolescent males. The Journal of Educational Research, 92, 185-190.

58.

Roenneberg

Kuehnle

Pramstaller

P. P.

Ricken

Havel

Guth

Merrow

(2004). A marker for the end of adolescence. Current Biology, 14, R1038-R1039.

59.

Rothstein

(2004). Class and schools: Using social, economic, and educational reform to close the black-white achievement gap. Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.

60.

Schiller

K. S.

(1999). Effects of feeder patterns on students’ transitions to high school. Sociology of Education, 724, 216-233.

61.

Schwerdt

West

M. R.

Winters

M. A.

(2017). The effects of test-based retention on student outcomes over time: Regression discontinuity evidence from Florida. Journal of Public Economics, 152, 154-169.

62.

Shin

Hecht

(2013). Does parentification place Mexican-heritage youth at risk for substance use? Identifying the intervening nature of parent-child communication about alcohol. Journal of Adolescence, 36, 149-159.

63.

Sinha

(2020). Bootstrap p-values reduce type 1 error of the robust rank-order test of difference in medians. Arxiv Preprint Arxiv: 2009.02362. Retrieved from https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/397fm8xdz2/1

64.

Snyder

T. D.

de Brey

Dillow

S. A.

(2019). Digest of education statistics 2017 (NCES 2018-070). U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.

65.

Stone

S. I.

Engel

(2007). Same old, same old? Students’ experiences of grade retention under Chicago’s ending social promotion policy. American Journal of Education, 113, 605-634.

66.

Tingle

L. R.

Schoeneberger

Algozzine

(2012). Does grade retention make a difference? The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas, 85, 179-185.

67.

van den Bergh

Denessen

Hornstra

Voeten

Holland

R. W

. (2010). The implicit prejudiced attitudes of teachers: Relations to teacher expectations and the ethnic achievement gap. American Educational Research Journal, 47, 497-527.

68.

Warren

J. R.

Hoffman

Andrew

(2014). Patterns and trends in grade retention rates in the United States, 1995–2010. Educational Researcher, 43, 433-443.

69.

Warren

J. R.

Saliba

(2012). First-through eighth-grade retention rates for all 50 states: A new method and initial results. Educational Researcher, 41, 320-329.

70.

Wichmann

F. A.

Hill

N. J.

(2001). The psychometric function: II. Bootstrap-based confidence intervals and sampling. Perception & Psychophysics, 63, 1314-1329.

71.

Williams

Merten

Giano

Herring

Delk

Gallus

Shreffler

(2020). Middle school teachers’ academic and behavioral perceptions of their students and expectations of high school graduation. Journal of Early Adolescence, 40, 1061–1086.

72.

Willson

V. L.

Hughes

J. N.

(2006). Retention of Hispanic/Latino students in first grade: Child, parent, teacher, school, and peer predictors. Journal of School Psychology, 44, 31-49.

73.

Winsler

Hutchison

L. A.

Feter

J. J.

Manfra

Bleiker

Hartman

S. C.

Levitt

(2012). Child, family, and childcare predictors of delayed school entry and kindergarten retention among linguistically and ethnically diverse children. Developmental Psychology, 48, 1299-1314.

74.

Wright

R. E.

Palmer

J. C.

(1999). Predicting performance of above and below average performers in graduate business schools: A split sample regression analysis. Educational Research Quarterly, 22(4), 35.

75.

West

S. G.

Hughes

J. N.

(2008). Short-term effects of grade retention on growth rate of Woodcock-Johnson III broad math and reading scores. Journal of School Psychology, 46, 85-105.