Attitudes to some aspects of death and dying,living wills and substituted health care decision-making in South Australia: public opinion survey for a parliamentary select committee

Abstract

This study aimed to provide evidence on community attitudes to certain death and dying issues in South Australia for a state parliamentary committee on the law and practice relating to death and dying. The following areas were studied: truth-telling, pain control, level of treatment, preferred place of death, rights of patients to refuse treatment, opinion about living wills and substituted health care decision making. A representative population survey of 625 households in metropolitan Adelaide and three major rural centres was made in August 1991, using personal interviews administered at home with one adult in each house hold aged over 18 years. A total of 462 (74%) adults completed the interviews. There was strong support for truth-telling by doctors about incurable cancer and impending death, although this was not universal. Fears of potential addiction, habituation, tolerance and impaired cognitive function as a result of analgesia for cancer pain were strongly expressed, particularly amongst those who reported least formal education. Those with experience of a death in the last eight years were most likely to consider the level of treatment offered to patients with incurable cancer to be inadequate, but 53% considered the level to be about right. Nearly 60% of respondents favoured death at home, but there was a trend for older people to favour death in hospital. Despite the existence of the Natural Death Act (1982), only 20% were aware that living wills were legal in South Australia. There was strong support for a medical power of attorney.

Keywords

advance directives death hospices living wills palliative treat ment terminal care

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Illich I. Medical nemesis: the expropriation of health. New York : Random House, 1976.

Hunt R. , Roder D. , MacHarper T. The impact of hospice services on place of death of South Australians. Cancer Forum 1989; 13(3): 110-13.

Hunt R. , Bond MJ , Groth RK , King PM Place of death in South Australia: patterns from 1910 to 1987. Med J Aust 1991; 155: 549-53.

Van der Maas PJ , Van Delden Jjm , Pijnenborg L. , Loonan Cwn. Euthanasia and other medical decisions at the end of life. Lancet 1991; 338: 669-74.

Weir RF Aborting treatment with critically ill patients: ethical and legal limits to the medical prolongation of life. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989.

James N. , Field D. The routinization of hospice: charisma and bureaucratisation. Soc Sci Med 1992: 34: 1363-75.

Dominica F. Reflections on death in childhood. Br Med J 1987; 294: 108-10.

First Interim Report of the Select Committee of House of Assembly on the Law and Practice Relating to Death and Dying. Adelaide: Parliament of South Australia, 1991.

Second Interim Report of the Select Committee of House of Assembly on the Law and Practice Relating to Death and Dying. Adelaide : Parliament of South Australia, 1992.

10.

Final Report of the Select Committee of House of Assembly on the Law and Practice Relating to Death and Dying. Adelaide: Parliament of South Australia, 1992.

11.

Dean AG , Dean JA , Burton AH , Dicker RC Epi Info, Version 5:A, a word processing, database and statistics program for epidemiology on microcomputers. Georgia: USD Inc., 1990.

12.

Moser CA , Kalton G. Survey methods in social investigation. London: Heinemann, 1977.

13.

Gilhooly Mlm , Berkeley JS , McCann K. , Gibling F. , Murray K. Truth telling with dying cancer patients. Palliative Med 1988; 2: 64-71.

14.

Sutherland HJ , Llewellyn-Thomas HA , Lockwood GA , Tritchler DL , Till JE Cancer patients: their desire for information and participation in treatment decisions. J R Soc Med 1989; 82: 260-63.

15.

Senra A. , Palmeiro R. , Garcia-Blanco P. Reaction of a representative sample of the Spanish population to communicating the diagnosis to cancer patients. Bull Cancer 1988; 75: 517-22.

16.

Wakefield M. , Ashby MA Attitudes of surviving relatives to terminal care in South Australia. J Pain Symptom Management (in Press).

17.

Bruera E. , Miller L. , McCallion J. , Macmillan K. , Krefting L. , Hanson J. Cognitive failure in patients with terminal cancer: a prospective study. J Pain Symptom Management 1992; 7: 192-95.

18.

Addington-Hall JM , MacDonald LD , Anderson HR , Freeling P. Dying from cancer: the views of bereaved family and friends about the experiences of terminally ill patients. Palliative Med 1991; 5: 207-14.

19.

Townsend J. , Frank AO , Fermont D. et al. Terminal cancer and patients' preference for place of death: a prospective study. Br Med J 1990; 301: 415-17.

20.

Collins ER , Weber D. The Society for the Right to Die: the complete guide to living wills. New York: Bantam Books, 1991.

21.

Wolf SM , Boyle P. , Callahan D. et al. Special report: sources of concern about the Patient Self Determination Act. N Engl J Med 1991; 325: 1666-71.

22.

Mendelson D. The Medical Treatment (Enduring Power of Attorney) Act and assisted suicide: the legal position in Victoria. Bioethics News 1992; 12(1): 34-42.

23.

Gamble ER , McDonald PJ , Lichstein PR Knowledge, attitudes and behaviour of elderly persons regarding living wills . Arch Intern Med 1991; 151: 277-80.

24.

Danis M. , Sontherland LI , Garrett JM et al. A prospective study of advance directives for life sustaining care. N Engl J Med 1991; 324: 882-88.

25.

Malloy DW , Guyatt GH A comprehensive health care directive in a home for the aged. Can Med Assoc J 1991; 145: 307-11.

26.

Hope T. Advance directives about medical treatment. Br Med J 1992; 304: 398.

27.

Maddocks I. 'Good palliative care' orders. Palliative Med 1993; 7: 35-37.

28.

Parliament of Victoria, Social Development Committee. Inquiry into options for dying with dignity. Second and final report. Melbourne: Government Printer, 1987.