Advance Care Planning is an iterative process of discussion, decision-making and documentation about end-of-life care. Advance Care Planning is highly relevant in palliative care due to intersecting clinical needs. To enhance the implementation of Advance Care Planning, the contextual factors influencing its uptake need to be better understood.
Aim:
To identify the contextual factors influencing the uptake of Advance Care Planning in palliative care as published between January 2008 and December 2012.
Methods:
Databases were systematically searched for studies about Advance Care Planning in palliative care published between January 2008 and December 2012. This yielded 27 eligible studies, which were appraised using National Institute of Health and Care Excellence Quality Appraisal Checklists. Iterative thematic synthesis was used to group results.
Results:
Factors associated with greater uptake included older age, a college degree, a diagnosis of cancer, greater functional impairment, being white, greater understanding of poor prognosis and receiving or working in specialist palliative care. Barriers included having non-malignant diagnoses, having dependent children, being African American, and uncertainty about Advance Care Planning and its legal status. Individuals’ previous illness experiences, preferences and attitudes also influenced their participation.
Conclusion:
Factors influencing the uptake of Advance Care Planning in palliative care are complex and multifaceted reflecting the diverse and often competing needs of patients, health professionals, legislature and health systems. Large population-based studies of palliative care patients are required to develop the sound theoretical and empirical foundation needed to improve uptake of Advance Care Planning in this setting.
RobinsonLDickinsonCBamfordC. A qualitative study: professionals’ experiences of advance care planning in dementia and palliative care, ‘a good idea in theory but…’. Palliat Med. Epub ahead of print 21 November 2012. DOI: 10.1177/0269216312465651.
5.
PrendergastTJ. Advance care planning: pitfalls, progress, promise. Crit Care Med2001; 29: N34–N39.
6.
HardinSBYusufalyYA. Difficult end-of-life treatment decisions: do other factors trump advance directives?Arch Intern Med2004; 164: 1531–1533.
7.
FagerlinASchneiderCE. Enough. The failure of the living will. Hastings Cent Rep2004; 34: 30–42.
8.
StreetAFOttmannG. State of the science review of advance care planning models. Bundoora, VIC, Australia: La Trobe University, 2006, 70 pp.
9.
SchickedanzADSchillingerDLandefeldCS. A clinical framework for improving the advance care planning process: start with patients’ self-identified barriers. J Am Geriatr Soc2009; 57: 31–39.
10.
RheeJJZwarNAKempLA. Uptake and implementation of Advance Care Planning in Australia: findings of key informant interviews. Aust Health Rev2012; 36: 98–104.
11.
BlackfordJStreetA. Is an advance care planning model feasible in community palliative care? A multi-site action research approach. J Adv Nurs2012; 68: 2021–2033.
12.
ChengMJKingLMAlesiER. Doing palliative care in the oncology office. J Oncol Pract2013; 9: 84–88.
13.
MeeussenKVan den BlockLEchteldM. Advance care planning in Belgium and The Netherlands: a nationwide retrospective study via sentinel networks of general practitioners. J Pain Symptom Manage2011; 42: 565–577.
14.
GramlingRNortonSALadwigS. Direct observation of prognosis communication in palliative care: a descriptive study. J Pain Symptom Manage2013; 45: 202–212.
15.
HussainJAdamsDCampbellC. End-of-life care in neurodegenerative conditions: outcomes of a specialist palliative neurology service. Int J Palliat Nurs2013; 19: 162–169.
16.
SilvesterWFullamRSParslowRA. Quality of advance care planning policy and practice in residential aged care facilities in Australia. BMJ Support Palliat Care. Epub ahead of print 14 November 2012. DOI: 10.1136/bmjspcare-2012-000262.
17.
Australian Government National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission. A healthier future for all Australians – final report. Publications no. P3-5499, June2009. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Blue Star Print Group.
18.
4th International Society of Advance Care Planning and End of Life Care Conference, http://acpelsociety.com.au/conference/ (2012, accessed 12 February 2013).
SandersCSeymourJClarkeA. Development of a peer education programme for advance end-of-life care planning. Int J Palliat Nurs2006; 12: 214, 216–223.
21.
PautexSHerrmannFRZulianGB. Role of advance directives in palliative care units: a prospective study. Palliat Med2008; 22: 835–841.
22.
LynnJArkesHRStevensM. Rethinking fundamental assumptions: SUPPORT’s implications for future reform. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences and Risks of Treatment. J Am Geriatr Soc2000; 48: S214–S221.
23.
AliNS. GM management. Promotion of advance care planning in the nonhospitalized elderly. Geriatr Nurs1999; 20: 260–262.
24.
MorrisonRSMorrisonEWGlickmanDF. Physician reluctance to discuss advance directives. An empiric investigation of potential barriers. Arch Intern Med1994; 154: 2311–2318.
25.
GatesMFSchinsISmithAS. Applying advanced directives regulations in home care agencies. Home Healthc Nurse1996; 14: 127–133.
26.
KelnerMBourgeaultILHebertPC. Advance directives: the views of health care professionals. CMAJ1993; 148: 1331–1338.
27.
BadzekLALeslieNSCorbo-RichertB. An ethical perspective. End-of-life decisions: are they honored?J Nurs Law1998; 5: 51–63.
28.
BowaterSESpeakmanJKThorneSA. End-of-life care in adults with congenital heart disease: now is the time to act. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care2013; 7: 8–13.
29.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ. The PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med2009; 6(6): e1000097.
30.
ReynoldsKSHansonLCHendersonM. End-of-life care in nursing home settings: Do race or age matter?Palliat and Support Care2008. 6(1): 21–27.
31.
DowLAMatsuyamaRKRamakrishnanV. Paradoxes in advance care planning: the complex relationship of oncology patients, their physicians, and advance medical directives. J Clin Oncol2010; 28: 299–304.
32.
WagnerGJRiopelleDSteckartJ.; Provider communication and patient understanding of life-limiting illness and their relationship to patient communication of treatment preferences. J Pain Symptom Manage2010; 39: 527–534.
33.
LauKSTseDMWTsan ChenTW. Comparing noncancer and cancer deaths in Hong Kong: a retrospective review. J Pain Symptom Manage2010; 40: 704–714.
34.
De GendtCBilsenJSticheleRV. Advance care planning and dying in nursing homes in Flanders, Belgium: a nationwide survey. J Pain Symptom Manage. Epub ahead of print 20 August 2012. DOI: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2012.02.011.
35.
FroggattKVaughanSBernardC. Advance care planning in care homes for older people: an English perspective. Palliat Med2009; 23: 332–338.
36.
StewartFGoddardCSchiffR. Advanced care planning in care homes for older people: a qualitative study of the views of care staff and families. Age Ageing2011; 40: 330–335.
37.
MacPhersonAWalsheCO’DonnellV. The views of patients with severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease on advance care planning: a qualitative study. Palliat Med. Epub ahead of print 26 March 2012. DOI: 10.1177/0269216312440606.
38.
GottMGardinerCSmallN. Barriers to advance care planning in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Palliat Med2009; 23: 642–648.
39.
GuoYPalmerJLBiantyJ. Advance directives and do-not-resuscitate orders in patients with cancer with metastatic spinal cord compression: advanced care planning implications. J Palliat Med2010; 13: 513–517.
40.
HirschmanKBCorcoranAMStratonJB. Advance care planning and hospice enrollment: who really makes the decision to enroll?J Palliat Med2010; 13(5): 519–523
41.
ClarkeASeymourJ. ‘At the foot of a very long ladder’: discussing the end of life with older people and informal caregivers. J Pain Symptom Manage2010; 40: 857–869.
42.
FriedTRBullockKIannoneL. Understanding advance care planning as a process of health behavior change. J Am Geriatr Soc2009; 57: 1547–1555.
43.
PiersRDVan EechoudIJVan CampS. Advance Care Planning in terminally ill and frail older persons. Patient Educ Couns. Epub ahead of print 2 August 2011. DOI: 10.1016/j.pec.2011.07.008.
44.
NilssonMEMaciejewskiPKZhangB. Mental health, treatment preferences, advance care planning, location, and quality of death in advanced cancer patients with dependent children. Cancer2009; 115: 399–409.
45.
SeymourJAlmackKKennedyS. Implementing advance care planning: a qualitative study of community nurses’ views and experiences. BMC Palliat Care2010; 9: 4.
46.
ZhouGStoltzfusJCHouldinAD. Knowledge, attitudes, and practice behaviors of oncology advanced practice nurses regarding advanced care planning for patients with cancer. Oncol Nurs Forum2010; 37: E400–E410.
47.
CartwrightCHughesMLienertT. End-of-life care for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people. Cult Health Sex2012; 14: 537–548.
48.
RheeJJZwarNAKempLA. How is advance care planning conceptualised in Australia? Findings from key informant interviews. Aust Health Rev2011; 35: 197–203.
49.
HuWYHuangCHChiuTY. Factors that influence the participation of healthcare professionals in advance care planning for patients with terminal cancer: a nationwide survey in Taiwan. Soc Sci Med2010; 70: 1701–1704.
50.
MintoFStricklandK. Anticipating emotion: a qualitative study of advance care planning in the community setting. Int J Palliat Nurs2011; 17: 278–284.
51.
WuPLorenzKAChodoshJ. Advance care planning among the oldest old. J Palliat Med2008; 11: 152–157.
52.
CorkeCMilnesSOrfordN. The influence of medical enduring power of attorney and advance directives on decision-making by Australian intensive care doctors. Crit Care Resusc2009; 11: 122–128.
53.
MurraySAKendallMBoydK. Illness trajectories and palliative care. BMJ2005; 330: 1007–1011.
54.
BoydKMurraySA. Recognising and managing key transitions in end of life care. BMJ2010; 341: c4863.
55.
GlarePA. Early implementation of palliative care can improve patient outcomes. J Natl Compr Canc Netw2013; 11(Suppl. 1): S3–S9.
56.
BriggsLAKirchhoffKTHammesBJ. Patient-centered advance care planning in special patient populations: a pilot study. J Prof Nurs2004; 20: 47–58.
57.
GillickMR. A broader role for advance medical planning. Ann Intern Med1995; 123: 621–624.
58.
TimmermansSMauckA. The promises and pitfalls of evidence-based medicine. Health Aff2005; 24: 18–28.
59.
SackettDLRosenbergWMGrayJA. Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn’t. BMJ1996; 312: 71–72.
60.
IsaacsDFitzgeraldD. Seven alternatives to evidence based medicine. BMJ1999; 319: 1618.
61.
CabanaMDRandCSPoweNR. Why don’t physicians follow clinical practice guidelines? A framework for improvement. JAMA1999; 282: 1458–1465.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
