In 2020, the International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care redefined palliative care to incorporate the concept of serious health-related suffering. An estimated 21 million children globally live with conditions which would benefit from a palliative approach to relieve suffering. Bangladesh is a lower-middle income country with isolated provision of palliative care.
Aim:
To synthesise existing evidence describing serious health-related suffering of children with disability and their families living in Bangladesh and the intersection between this suffering, palliative care and rehabilitation.
Design:
Scoping review methodology.
Data sources:
A search strategy related to serious health-related suffering and childhood disability was applied to online databases and grey literature. English language studies (1990–2021) were included. Papers pertaining to serious health-related suffering of typically developing children and those over eighteen years were excluded. Data which addressed the three domains of serious health-related suffering (physical, social and emotional/spiritual) were extracted. Palliative care interventions were assessed with a pre-existing checklist.
Results:
Forty-six studies were included, representing ten different methodologies. Sample sizes ranged from 11 to 2582 participants, with 87% of studies including children with cerebral palsy. Serious health-related suffering was described in 100% of the studies, only 14 of the studies described specific interventions to mitigate suffering. Convergence between palliative care and rehabilitation approaches was evident.
Conclusion:
Findings document the extensive nature and burden of serious childhood health-related suffering that may be remediated by a palliative approach. They highlight the urgent need to prioritise service development and research in this area.
KnaulFMFarmerPEKrakauerEL, et al. Alleviating the access abyss in palliative care and pain relief—an imperative of universal health coverage: the Lancet Commission report. Lancet2018; 391: 1391–1454.
2.
KnaulFMBhadeliaAHortonR. Health-related suffering: from Lancet Commission to DeclarAction. Lancet2018; 391: 2088–2089.
3.
SleemanKEde BritoMEtkindS, et al. The escalating global burden of serious health-related suffering: projections to 2060 by world regions, age groups, and health conditions. Lancet Glob Health2019; 7: e883–e892.
NambiarARRanaSRajagopalMR. Serious health-related suffering and palliative care in South Asian countries. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care2021; 15: 169–173.
6.
World Health Organization. Quality health services and palliative care: practical approaches andresources to support policy strategy and practice. Report no.9240035168. World Health Organization, Geneva, 2021.
7.
DowningJRajagopalMDe LimaL, et al.; Julia Downing (ed). Chapter 2: Universal Health coverage and serious health-related suffering: a case for children and young people. In: Children’s Palliative Care: an international case-based manual. London: Springer, 2020,Chapter 2: 13–22.
8.
RadbruchLDe LimaLKnaulF, et al. Redefining Palliative Care—a new consensus-based definition. J Pain Symptom Manag2020; 60: 754–764.
JahanIKarimTDasMC, et al. Mortality in children with cerebral palsy in rural Bangladesh: a population-based surveillance study. Dev Med Child Neurol2019; 61: 1336–1343.
11.
ConnorSRDowningJMarstonJ. Estimating the global need for palliative care for children: A cross-sectional analysis. J Pain Symptom Manag2017; 53: 171–177.
SDG Cell Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. SDG tracker: Bangladesh’s development mirror, https://www.sdg.gov.bd/page/allgoals/ (2020, accessed March 3 2022).
KhanNZSultanaRAhmedF, et al. Scaling up child development centres in Bangladesh. Child Care Health Dev2018; 44: 19–30.
18.
KhandakerGMuhitMKarimT, et al. Epidemiology of cerebral palsy in Bangladesh: a population-based surveillance study. Dev. Med. Child Neurol2019; 61: 601–609.
19.
JahanIMuhitMHardiantoD, et al. Epidemiology of cerebral palsy in low- and middle-income countries: preliminary findings from an international multi-centre cerebral palsy register. Dev Med Child Neurol2021; 63: 1327–1336.
DowningJKnappCMuckadenMA, et al. Priorities for global research into children’s palliative care: results of an international Delphi Study. BMC Palliat Care2015; 14: 36.
23.
Caruso BrownAEHowardSCBakerJN, et al. Reported availability and gaps of pediatric palliative care in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review of published data. J Palliat Med2014; 17: 1369–1383.
24.
SasakiHBouesseauM-CMarstonJ, et al. A scoping review of palliative care for children in low- and middle-income countries. BMC Palliat Care2017; 16: 60–60.
25.
NamisangoEBristoweKAllsopMJ, et al. Symptoms and concerns among children and young people with life-limiting and life-threatening conditions: a systematic review highlighting meaningful health outcomes. Patient2019; 12: 15–55.
26.
MalcolmCKnightingKTaylorC. Home-based end of life care for children and their families – a systematic scoping review and narrative synthesis. J Pediatr Nurs2020; 55: 126–133.
27.
ChowdhuryMKShopnaKLynch-GodreiA, et al. Providing home-based support for children with chronic conditions in an urban slum: experiences from a community-based palliative care program in Bangladesh. Glob Pediatr Health2021; 8: 2333794X2199915.
28.
SinthiaSA. Analysis of urban slum: Case study of Korail slum, Dhaka. Int J Urban Civil Eng2020; 14: 416–430.
29.
PetersMDJMarnieCTriccoAC, et al. Updated methodological guidance for the conduct of scoping reviews. JBI Evid Implement2021; 19: 3–10.
30.
ArkseyHO’MalleyL. Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. Int J Soc Res Methodol2005; 8: 19–32.
31.
LevacDColquhounHO’BrienKK. Scoping studies: advancing the methodology. Implement Sci2010; 5: 69.
32.
TriccoACLillieEZarinW, et al. PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation. Ann Intern Med2018; 169: 467–473.
33.
PowerRMuhitMHeanoyE, et al. Depression, anxiety and stress among caregivers of adolescents with cerebral palsy in rural Bangladesh. Disabil Rehabil2021; 43: 2123–2130.
34.
SogbossiESHouekpetodjiDKpadonouTG, et al. A cross-sectional study of the clinical profile of children with cerebral palsy in benin, a West African low-income country. J. Child Neurol2019; 34: 842–850.
KhandakerGSmithers-SheedyHIslamJ, et al. Bangladesh Cerebral Palsy Register (BCPR): a pilot study to develop a national cerebral palsy (CP) register with surveillance of children for CP. BMC Neurol2015; 15: 173–173.
International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care. Pallipedia: the free online palliaitve care dictionary, https://pallipedia.org/ (2021, accessed March 3 2022).
39.
AhmedK. Caring for the chronically ill in Bangladesh’s Rohingya camps. Refworld: IRIN, 2018.
40.
AkterKKhatunSHossainMS. Lived Experience of thalassaemic children in Bangladesh. Open J Nurs2020; 10: 1109–1125.
41.
AlamMMHossainMSIslamN, et al. Impacts of health and economic costs on street children working as waste collectors in Dhaka City. I J Environ Sustain Dev2021; 20: 29–50.
42.
AnamNBariNAlamK. Street children with disabilities: situation analysis and need assessment on the street children with disabilities in Dhaka city. Dhaka, Bangladesh: Centre for Services and Information on Disability, 1999.
43.
DasDZamanTHasanMS, et al. Outcomes of feeding training to mothers having child with cerebral palsy admitted at a tertiary level hospital in Bangladesh. Chattagram Maa-O-Shishu Hosp Med Coll J2016; 15: 25–29.
44.
HaqueMASalwaMSultanaS, et al. Parenting stress among caregivers of children with neurodevelopmental disorders: a cross-sectional study in Bangladesh. J Intellect Disabil2022; 26: 407-419. DOI: 10.1177/17446295211002355
45.
Hasan. Tales of darkness: A baseline study on child labour among children with disabilties. Centre Services and information on Disabilities Bangladesh, 2009.
46.
AdamsMS. The management of feeding difficulties in children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh. PhD, University of London, University College London (United Kingdom), Ann Arbor, 2009.
RahmanSIslamWKZ. Children with disabilities in Rajshahi city. A situation, 2008.
49.
AdamsMSKhanNZBegumSA, et al. Feeding difficulties in children with cerebral palsy: low-cost caregiver training in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Child Care Health Dev2012; 38: 878–888.
50.
CSF Global. Getting to know cerebral palsy caregiver training. Cerebral Palsy Association (Eastern Cape), Port Elizabeth, South Africa, 2011.
51.
DohertyMKhanF. Neglected suffering: the unmet need for palliative care in Cox’s Bazar. World Child Cancer, London, UK, 2018.
52.
EvansAChowdhuryMKarimiL, et al. Factors affecting parents to ‘Drop-Out’ from ponseti method and children’s clubfoot relapse. Ortho Res Online J2020; 6: 601–609.
53.
EvansAMChowdhuryMKhanS. A community audit of 300 “Drop-Out” instances in children undergoing Ponseti Clubfoot Care in Bangladesh—what do the parents say?Int J Environ Res Public Health2021; 18: 993.
AkhterRHassanNMMartinEF, et al. Caries experience and oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) of children and adolescents with cerebral palsy in a low-resource setting. BMC Oral Health2019; 19: 15.
56.
EvansAMChowdhuryMMKabirMH, et al. Walk for life – the National Clubfoot Project of Bangladesh: the four-year outcomes of 150 congenital clubfoot cases following ponseti method. J Foot Ankle Res2016; 9(1): 42.
57.
JahanIMuhitMKarimT, et al. What makes children with cerebral palsy vulnerable to malnutrition? Findings from the Bangladesh cerebral palsy register (BCPR). Disabil. Rehabil2019; 41: 2247–2254.
58.
JahanSArafKGriffithsMD, et al. Depression and suicidal behaviors among Bangladeshi mothers of children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: a comparative study. Asian J Psychiatr2020; 51: 101994.
59.
McConachieHHuqSMunirS, et al. Difficulties for mothers in using an early intervention service for children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh. Child Care Health Dev2001; 27(1): 1–12. DOI: 10.1046/j.1365-2214.2001.00207.x
60.
MitryDWilliamsCNorthstoneK, et al. Perceptual visual dysfunction, physical impairment and quality of life in Bangladeshi children with cerebral palsy. Br J Ophthalmol2016; 100: 1245–1250.
61.
MobarakRKahnNMunirS, et al. Predictors of stress in mothers of children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh. J Pediatr Psychol2000; 25: 427–433.
62.
NuriRPAlderseyHMGhahariS. Needs of families of children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh: a qualitative study. Child Care Health Dev2019; 45: 36–44. https://doi.org/10.1111/cch.12624
63.
PowerRMuhitMHeanoyE, et al. Health-related quality of life and mental health of adolescents with cerebral palsy in rural Bangladesh. PLoS One2019; 14: e0217675.
64.
PowerRWileyKMuhitM, et al. ’Flower of the body’: menstrual experiences and needs of young adolescent women with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh, and their mothers providing menstrual support. BMC Womens Health2020; 20: 160–160.
65.
RazuSRIslamSSDasDK. Hostility and violence impeding the development of children with disabilities: an experience from Bangladesh. Int J Disabil Hum Dev2019; 18: 55–62.
66.
SafaFIslamMN. Health related quality of life in children with autism spectrum disorder in Bangladesh. IMC J. Med. Sci2017; 11: 40–44.
67.
ZuurmondMAMahmudIPolackS, et al. Understanding the lives of caregivers of children with cerebral palsy in rural Bangladesh: use of mixed methods. Disabil. CBR Inclusive Dev2015; 26: 5–21.
68.
Al ImamMHJahanIDasMC, et al. Rehabilitation status of children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh: findings from the Bangladesh Cerebral Palsy Register. PLoS One2021; 16: e0250640–e0250640.
69.
BedfordJMackeySParvinA, et al. Reasons for non-uptake of referral: children with disabilities identified through the key informant method in Bangladesh. Disabil. Rehabil2013; 35: 2164–2170.
70.
MahmudI. Health seeking behaviour of disabled people attending a specialized rehabilitation centre in Dhaka, Bangladesh. 2007; 1-74. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.21615.46245
71.
MaloniPKDespresERHabbousJ, et al. Perceptions of disability among mothers of children with disability in Bangladesh: implications for rehabilitation service delivery. Disabil. Rehabil2010; 32: 845–854.
72.
McConachieHHuqSMunirS, et al. A randomized controlled trial of alternative modes of service provision to young children with cerebral palsy in Bangladesh. J. Pediatr2000; 137: 769–776.
73.
NesbittRCMackeySKuperH, et al. Predictors of referral uptake in children with disabilities in Bangladesh—exploring barriers as a first step to improving referral provision. Disabil Rehabil2012; 34: 1089–1095.
74.
NuriRPGhahariSAlderseyHM, et al. Exploring access to government-led support for children with disabilities in Bangladesh. PLoS One2020; 15: e0235439.
75.
NuriRPAlderseyHMGhahariS, et al. Experience of families in accessing government-led support for children with disabilities in Bangladesh. Disabil Rehabil2022; 44: 1354–1366.
76.
NuriRPAlderseyHMGhahariS, et al. Service providers’ perspectives in providing services to children with disabilities and their families in Bangladesh. Disabil Rehabil2022; 44: 4700–4708.
77.
PowerRMuhitMHeanoyE, et al. Depression, anxiety and stress among caregivers of adolescents with cerebral palsy in rural Bangladesh. Disabil Rehabil2019; 43: 1–8. DOI: 10.1080/09638288.2019.1692378
78.
YousafzaiAKLynchPGladstoneM. Moving beyond prevalence studies: screening and interventions for children with disabilities in low-income and middle-income countries. Arch. Dis. Child2014; 99: 840–848.
79.
AbbasKMAbdulleAMAdaneK, et al. Healthcare Access and Quality Index based on mortality from causes amenable to personal health care in 195 countries and territories, 1990–2015: a novel analysis from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. Lancet2017; 390: 231–266.
80.
BrightTWallaceSKuperH. A systematic review of access to rehabilitation for people with disabilities in low- and middle-income countries. Int J Environ Res Public Health2018; 15: 2165.
81.
MagnussonDSweeneyFLandryM. Provision of rehabilitation services for children with disabilities living in low- and middle-income countries: a scoping review. Disabil. Rehabil2019; 41: 861–868.
82.
McNeilMJNamisangoEHuntJ, et al. Grief and bereavement in parents after the death of a child in low- and middle-income countries. Children2020; 7: 39.
KumarSK. Kerala, India: a regional community-based palliative care model. J Pain Symptom Manag2007; 33: 623–627. 2007.
87.
KumarS. Models of delivering palliative and end-of-life care in India. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care2013; 7: 216–222.
88.
KumarSNumpeliM. Neighborhood network in palliative care. Indian J Palliat Care2005; 11: 6.
89.
MacRaeMCFazalOO’DonovanJ. Community health workers in palliative care provision in low-income and middle-income countries: a systematic scoping review of the literature. BMJ Glob Health2020; 5: e002368.
90.
KhandakerGMuhitMRashidH, et al. Infectious causes of childhood disability: results from a pilot study in rural Bangladesh. J Trop Pediatr2014; 60: 363–369.
91.
British Government. Disability, poverty and development. London: Department for International Development, 2009.
92.
DohertyMPowerLPetrovaM, et al. Illness-related suffering and need for palliative care in Rohingya refugees and caregivers in Bangladesh: a cross-sectional study. PLoS Med2020; 17: e1003011–e1003011.
MurshidMEHaqueM. Disability brief in single chapter and Bangladesh perspectives: A rapid overview. Adv Human Biol2020; 10: 41–50.
95.
DohertyMPowerLThabetC. Delivering hospital-based pediatric palliative care: the symptoms, interventions, and outcomes for children with cancer in Bangladesh. J. Glob. Oncol2020; 6(6): 884–891.
DohertyMRayalaSEvansE, et al. Using virtual learning to build pediatric palliative care capacity in South Asia: experiences of implementing a teleteaching and mentorship program (Project ECHO). J Glob Oncol2021; 7(7): 210–222.
98.
PallCHASE. Palliative care in humanitarian aid situations and emergencies, https://www.pallchase.org/ (2021, accessed March 3 2022).
PowerRAkhterRMuhitM, et al. Cross-cultural validation of the Bengali version KIDSCREEN-27 quality of life questionnaire. BMC Pediatr2019; 19: 19–19.
101.
PowerRAkhterRMuhitM, et al. A quality of life questionnaire for adolescents with cerebral palsy: psychometric properties of the bengali CPQoL-teens. Health Qual Life Outcomes2019; 17: 135.
102.
KhanNZMuslimaHShilpiAB, et al. Validation of a home-based neurodevelopmental screening tool for under 2-year-old children in Bangladesh. Child Care Health Dev2013; 39: 643–650.
103.
EvansAMPerveenRFord-PowellVA, et al. The Bangla clubfoot tool: a repeatability study. J Foot Ankle Res2014; 7: 27–36.
104.
MunirSZZamanSMcConachieH. Development of an independent behaviour assessment scale for Bangladesh. J Appl Res Intellect Disabil1999; 12: 241–252.
105.
MullickMSIGoodmanR. The prevalence of psychiatric disorders among 5–10 year olds in rural, urban and slum areas in Bangladesh. Soc. Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol2005; 40: 663–671.
106.
AlimSAHMKibriaSMELslamMJ, et al. Translation of DASS 21 into Bangla and validation among medical students. Banglad J Psychiatr2014; 28: 67–70.
107.
DurkinMSDavidsonLLDesaiP, et al. Validity of the ten questions screen for childhood disability: results from population-based studies in Bangladesh, Jamaica, and Pakistan. Epidemiology1994; 5: 283–289.
108.
MishuMPWattRGHeilmannA, et al. Cross cultural adaptation and psychometric properties of the Bengali version of the scale of Oral Health Outcomes for 5-year-old children (SOHO-5). Health Qual Life Outcomes2021; 19: 46–11.
109.
KarimTMuhitMJahanI, et al. Outcome of community-based early intervention and rehabilitation for children with cerebral palsy in rural Bangladesh: a quasi-experimental study. Brain Sci2021; 11: 1189.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
