Socio-economic factors play important roles in place of death. However, up-to-date knowledge on socio-economic determinants for place of death is warranted including analysis of collinearity between socio-economic determinants.
Aim:
To examine associations between socio-economic determinants (social class, deprivation level in area of residence, income, education, occupation, urbanisation) and place of death among adult patients with life-limiting illnesses. Furthermore, to describe how these factors are operationalised and examined for collinearity.
Design:
A systematic review was performed (PROSPERO, record: CRD42018091218) and quality was assessed using the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale.
Data sources:
A comprehensive search of PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, Scopus and PsycINFO was conducted for studies published from 1 January 2008 until the date of the search (23 March 2018) in English or Scandinavian languages.
Results:
Of the 1599 unique citations identified, 34 studies were eligible. Dying at home was to a high degree associated with better financial situation and living in rural areas. Furthermore, hospital death was associated with a high level of deprivation in the area of residence and being employed. Regarding educational level, we found mixed and inconclusive results.
Conclusion:
Inequalities concerning place of death were found, and attention towards socio-economic inequality concerning place of death is necessary, especially in patients with a poor financial status, patients living in deprived and metropolitan areas and patients who are employed. Furthermore, we found a low degree of assessment for collinearity and adjustment of socio-economic variables. These issues should be considered in planning of future studies of socio-economic determinants for place of death.
De RooMLMiccinesiGOnwuteaka-PhilipsenBD, et al. Actual and preferred place of death of home-dwelling patients in four European countries: making sense of quality indicators. PLoS ONE2014; 9(4): e93762.
2.
GomesBHigginsonIJ.Factors influencing death at home in terminally ill patients with cancer: systematic review. BMJ2006; 332(7540): 515–521.
3.
GillALaporteACoytePC.Predictors of home death in palliative care patients: a critical literature review. J Palliat Care2013; 29(2): 113–118.
4.
CostaV.The determinants of place of death: an evidence-based analysis. Ont Health Technol Assess Ser2014; 14(16): 1–78.
5.
CostaVEarleCCEsplenMJ, et al. The determinants of home and nursing home death: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Palliat Care2016; 15: 8.
6.
GaoWHoYKVerneJ, et al. Geographical and temporal understanding in place of death in England (1984–2010): analysis of trends and associated factors to improve end-of-life care (GUIDE_Care) – primary research. Southampton: Health Services and Delivery Research, 2014.
7.
TangSTMcCorkleR.Determinants of place of death for terminal cancer patients. Cancer Invest2001; 19(2): 165–180.
8.
MurrayMAFisetVYoungS, et al. Where the dying live: a systematic review of determinants of place of end-of-life cancer care. Oncol Nurs Forum2009; 36(1): 69–77.
9.
GrandeGEAddington-HallJMToddCJ.Place of death and access to home care services: are certain patient groups at a disadvantage. Soc Sci Med1998; 47(5): 565–579.
10.
LuckettTDavidsonPMLamL, et al. Do community specialist palliative care services that provide home nursing increase rates of home death for people with life-limiting illnesses? A systematic review and meta-analysis of comparative studies. J Pain Symptom Manage2013; 45(2): 279–297.
11.
ChenHNicolsonDJMacleodU, et al. Does the use of specialist palliative care services modify the effect of socioeconomic status on place of death? A systematic review. Palliat Med2016; 30(5): 434–445.
12.
NordlyMVadstrupESSjogrenP, et al. Home-based specialized palliative care in patients with advanced cancer: a systematic review. Palliat Support Care2016; 14(6): 713–724.
13.
RainsfordSMacLeodRDGlasgowNJ.Place of death in rural palliative care: a systematic review. Palliat Med2016; 30(8): 745–763.
14.
VatchevaKPLeeMMcCormickJB, et al. Multicollinearity in regression analyses conducted in epidemiologic studies. Epidemiology2016; 6(2): 227.
15.
LiberatiAAltmanDGTetzlaffJ, et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. J Clin Epidemiol2009; 62(10): e1–e34.
16.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ2009; 339: b2535.
17.
National Institute for Health Research. International prospective register of systematic reviews (PROSPERO), https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/ (accessed 3 March 2019).
18.
HuangXLinJDemner-FushmanD.Evaluation of PICO as a knowledge representation for clinical questions. AMIA Annu Symp Proc2006; 2006: 359–363.
19.
CookDAReedDA.Appraising the quality of medical education research methods: the medical education research study quality instrument and the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale-education. Acad Med2015; 90(8): 1067–1076.
Alonso-BabarroAAstray-MochalesJDominguez-BerjonF, et al. The association between in-patient death, utilization of hospital resources and availability of palliative home care for cancer patients. Palliat Med2013; 27(1): 68–75.
22.
AntenehAArayaTMisganawA.Factors associated with place of death in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. BMC Palliat Care2013; 12: 14.
23.
Castillo-GuzmánSPalacios-RiosDNava-ObregonTA, et al. Home versus hospital mortality from cancer in Mexico (1999–2009). Am J Hosp Palliat Care2013; 30(3): 249–252.
24.
ChisumpaVHOdimegwuCODe WetN.Adult mortality in Sub-Saharan Africa, Zambia: where do adults die?SSM Popul Health2017; 3: 227–235.
25.
CohenJHouttekierDOnwuteaka-PhilipsenB, et al. Which patients with cancer die at home? A study of six European countries using death certificate data. J Clin Oncol2010; 28(13): 2267–2273.
26.
CohenJPivodicLMiccinesiG, et al. International study of the place of death of people with cancer: a population-level comparison of 14 countries across 4 continents using death certificate data. Br J Cancer2015; 113(9): 1397–1404.
27.
Domínguez-BerjónMFEsteban-VasalloMDZoniAC, et al. Place of death and associated factors among patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis in Madrid (Spain). Amyotroph Lateral Scler Frontotemporal Degener2015; 17(1–2): 62–68.
28.
GaoWHoYKVerneJ, et al. Changing patterns in place of cancer death in England: a population-based study. PLoS Medicine2013; 10(3): e1001410.
29.
GisquetEJulliardSGeoffroy-PerezB.Do social factors affect the place of death? Analysis of home versus institutional death over 20 years. J Public Health2016; 38(4): e472–e479.
30.
GomesBPinheiroMJLopesS, et al. Risk factors for hospital death in conditions needing palliative care: nationwide population-based death certificate study. Palliative Med2018; 32: 891–901.
31.
GoodridgeDLawsonJRennieD, et al. Rural/urban differences in health care utilization and place of death for persons with respiratory illness in the last year of life. Rural Remote Health2010; 10(2): 1349.
32.
HardingRMarchettiSOnwuteaka-PhilipsenB, et al. Place of death for people with HIV: a population-level comparison of eleven countries across three continents using death certificate data. BMC Infect Dis2018; 18(1): 55.
33.
HigginsonIJReillyCCBajwahS, et al. Which patients with advanced respiratory disease die in hospital? A 14-year population-based study of trends and associated factors. BMC Med2017; 15(1): 19.
34.
HouttekierDCohenJBilsenJ, et al. Determinants of the place of death in the Brussels metropolitan region. J Pain Symptom Manage2009; 37(6): 996–1005.
35.
HouttekierDCohenJBilsenJ, et al. Place of death in metropolitan regions: metropolitan versus non-metropolitan variation in place of death in Belgium, The Netherlands and England. Health and Place2010; 16(1): 132–139.
36.
HouttekierDCohenJPepersackT, et al. Dying in hospital: a study of incidence and factors related to hospital death using death certificate data. Eur J Public Health2014; 24(5): 751–756.
37.
HowellDMAbernathyTCockerillR, et al. Predictors of home care expenditures and death at home for cancer patients in an integrated comprehensive palliative home care pilot program. Health Policy2011; 6(3): e73–92.
38.
HakansonCOhlenJMorinL, et al. A population-level study of place of death and associated factors in Sweden. Scand J Public Health2015; 43(7): 744–751.
39.
JarosekSLShippeeTPVirnigBA.Place of death of individuals with terminal cancer: new insights from Medicare hospice place-of-service codes. J Am Geriatr Soc2016; 64(9): 1815–1822.
40.
JayaramanJJosephK.Determinants of place of death: a population-based retrospective cohort study. BMC Palliat Care2013; 12: 19.
41.
KoMCHuangSJChenCC, et al. Factors predicting a home death among home palliative care recipients. Medicine2017; 96(41): e8210.
42.
LazenbyMMaTMoffatHJ, et al. Influences on place of death in Botswana. Palliat Support Care2010; 8(2): 177–185.
43.
LeeL-CHuC-CLohE-W, et al. Factors affecting the place of death among hospice home care cancer patients in Taiwan. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2014; 31(3): 300–306.
44.
López-CamposJLRuiz-RamosMMendezC, et al. Characteristics of subjects who died of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in Andalusia in 2010 and 2011. J Palliat Med2013; 16(12): 1610–1613.
45.
LouckaMPayneSABrearleySG.Place of death in the Czech Republic and Slovakia: a population based comparative study using death certificates data. BMC Palliat Care2014; 13(1): 13.
46.
MasucciLGuerriereDNChengR, et al. Determinants of place of death for recipients of home-based palliative care. J Palliat Care2010; 26(4): 279–286.
47.
NeergaardMAJensenABSokolowskiI, et al. Socioeconomic position and place of death of cancer patients; 24654054. BMJ Support Palliat Care2012; 2(2): 133–139.
48.
O’DowdELMcKeeverTMBaldwinDR, et al. Place of death in patients with lung cancer: a retrospective cohort study from 2004–2013. PLoS ONE2016; 11(8): e0161399.
49.
PinzonLCEWeberMClausM, et al. Factors influencing place of death in Germany. J Pain Symptom Manage2011; 41(5): 893–903.
50.
ReyniersTDeliensLPasmanHR, et al. International variation in place of death of older people who died from dementia in 14 European and Non-European countries. J Am Med Dir Assoc2015; 16(2): 165–171.
51.
SleemanKEHoYKVerneJ, et al. Reversal of English trend towards hospital death in dementia: a population-based study of place of death and associated individual and regional factors, 2001–2010. BMC Neurology2014; 14(1): 59.
52.
TaylorEJEnsorBStanleyJ.Place of death related to demographic factors for hospice patients in Wellington, Aotearoa New Zealand. Palliat Med2012; 26(4): 342–349.
53.
MacNeil VroomenJBosmansJEHolmanR, et al. Place of death with dementia – Dutch people rarely die in the hospital. J Am Geriatr Soc2015; 63(9): 1961–1962.
54.
ÖhlénJCohenJHakansonC.Determinants in the place of death for people with different cancer types: a national population-based study. Acta Oncol2017; 56(3): 455–461.
55.
LoCKMertzDLoebM.Newcastle-Ottawa Scale: comparing reviewers’ to authors’ assessments. BMC Med Res Methodol2014; 14: 45.
56.
StangA.Critical evaluation of the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for the assessment of the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses. Eur J Epidemiol2010; 25(9): 603–605.
57.
CostantiniMCamoiranoEMadedduL, et al. Palliative home care and place of death among cancer patients: a population-based study. Palliat Med1993; 7(4): 323–331.
58.
CostantiniMBalziDGarronecE, et al. Geographical variations of place of death among Italian communities suggest an inappropriate hospital use in the terminal phase of cancer disease. Public Health2000; 114(1): 15–20.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
