Sociologists have long studied the educational incorporation of immigrants and refugees, but most scholarship focuses on questions of access, achievement, attainment, and acculturation. We extend this literature by examining the incorporation of immigrants and refugees in the cultural content of schooling, drawing on a unique dataset spanning 509 textbooks from 80 countries, representing all regions of the world from 1963 to 2011. Our descriptive and multilevel regression analyses reveal a mixed picture. On one hand, textbook discussions of immigrants and refugees have expanded over time and are especially pervasive in textbooks that invoke post-national conceptions of citizenship and in countries that host large foreign-born populations. But we also document stagnating discussions of immigrants and refugees in recent decades, a casting of these groups as part of the historical past more than contemporary civics and society, and a tendency toward their curricular omission in countries with a recent history of war.
AlbaRFonerN (2015) Strangers No More: Immigration and the Challenges of Integration in North America and Western Europe. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
2.
AnS (2022) Critical juxtaposing of war and migration: A content analysis of Southeast Asian refugee children’s literature. The Social Studies113(5): 249–263.
3.
AppleMW (1979) Ideology and Curriculum. London: Routledge.
4.
AppleMWChristian-SmithL (1991) The Politics of the Textbook. New York: Routledge.
5.
BellinoMJDryden-PetersonS (2018) Inclusion and exclusion within a policy of national integration: Refugee education in Kenya’s Kakuma Refugee Camp. British Journal of Sociology of Education40(2): 222–238.
6.
BenavotAChaYKKamensDH, et al. (1991) Knowledge for the masses: World models and national curricula, 1920-1986. American Sociological Review56(1): 85–100.
7.
BloemraadIKortewegAYurdakulG (2008) Citizenship and immigration: Multiculturalism, assimilation, and challenges to the nation-state. Annual Review of Sociology34(1): 153–179.
8.
BoliJThomasGM (1997) World culture in the world polity: A century of international non-governmental organization. American Sociological Review62(2): 171–190.
9.
BromleyP (2009) Cosmopolitanism in civic education: Explore cross-national trends, 1970-2008. Current Issues in Comparative Education12(1): 33–44.
10.
BromleyP (2014) Legitimacy and the contingent diffusion of world culture: Diversity and human rights in social science textbooks, divergent cross-national patterns (1970–2008). Canadian Journal of Sociology39(1): 1–44.
11.
BromleyPSmithDS (2019) Creating the canon: The meaning and effects of textbooks and curricula. In:DominaTGibbsBGNunnL, et al (eds) Education and Society: An Introduction to Key Issues in the Sociology of Education. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, pp. 157–177.
12.
BromleyPMeyerJWRamirezFO (2011) Student-centeredness in social science textbooks, 1970-2008: A cross-national study. Social Forces90(2): 547–570.
13.
BucknerERussellSG (2013) Portraying the global: Cross-national trends in textbooks’ portrayal of globalization and global citizenship. International Studies Quarterly57(4): 738–750.
14.
ColeWM (2017) World polity or world society? Delineating the statist and societal dimensions of the global institutional system. International Sociology32(1): 86–104.
15.
CollinsR (1971) Functional and conflict theories of educational stratification. American Sociological Review36(6): 1002–1019.
16.
CoppedgeMGerringJLindbergSI, et al. (2016a) V-Dem Codebook v6. Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Project. https://www.v-dem.net/data/dataset-archive/
17.
CoppedgeMGerringJLindbergSI, et al. (2016b) V-Dem [Country-Year/Country-Date] Dataset v6.2. Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Project. https://www.v-dem.net/data/dataset-archive/
18.
Council of Europe (2020) The Representation of Roma in European Curricula and Textbooks. A Joint Report Commissioned by the Council of Europe to the Georg Eckert Institute for International Textbook Research in Partnership with the Roma Education Fund. London: Council of Europe.
19.
CramerGJFonsCA (2020) Civics for non-citizens. The High School Journal104(1): 5–27.
20.
DaviesL (2003) Education and Conflict: Complexity and Chaos. London: Routledge Falmer.
21.
DreebenR (1968) On What Is Learned in School. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
22.
ElliottMA (2007) Human rights and the triumph of the individual in world culture. Cultural Sociology1(3): 343–363.
23.
FaasDRossW (2012) Identity, diversity and citizenship: A critical analysis of textbooks and curricula in Irish schools. International Sociology27(4): 574–591.
24.
FeenstraRCInklaarRTimmerMP (2015) The next generation of the Penn world table. American Economic Review105(10): 3150–3182.
25.
FosterSJ (2001) Pride and prejudice: Treatment of immigrant groups in United States history textbooks, 1890-1930. Education and Culture17(1): 1–7.
26.
FrankDJWongSYMeyerJW, et al. (2000) What counts as history: A cross-national and longitudinal study of university curricula. Comparative Education Review44(1): 29–53.
27.
GamlenA (2010) International migration data and the study of super-diversity. MMG working paper no. 10–05, May. Göttingen: Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and Ethnic Diversity.
28.
GirouxH (1983) Theories of reproduction and resistance in the new sociology of education. Harvard Education Review53(3): 257–293.
29.
GleditschNPWallensteenPErikssonM, et al. (2002) Armed conflict 1946–2001: A new dataset. Journal of Peace Research39(5): 615–637.
30.
HeathAFRothonCKilpiE (2008) The second generation in Western Europe: Education, unemployment, and occupational attainment. Annual Review of Sociology34: 211–235.
31.
HilburnJFitchettPG (2012) The new gateway, an old paradox: Immigrants and involuntary Americans in North Carolina history textbooks. Theory & Research in Social Education40(1): 35–65.
32.
HilburnJJournellWBuchananLB (2016) A content analysis of immigration in traditional, new, and non-gateway state standards for U.S. history and civics. The High School Journal99(3): 234–251.
33.
International Organization for Migration (IOM) (2020) World Migration Report 2020. Grand-Saconnex: IOM.
34.
JiménezJDLerchJC (2019) Waves of diversity: Depictions of marginalized groups and their rights in social science textbooks, 1900-2013. Comparative Education Review63(2): 166–188.
35.
KorzeniewiczRPMoranTP (2009) Unveiling Inequality: A World-Historical Perspective. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
36.
LerchJC (2019) INGO memberships revisited: Local variation of receptor sites in the education sector. International Journal of Comparative Sociology60(3): 117–139.
37.
LerchJC (2023) How global institutions matter: Education for all and the rise of education as a humanitarian response. Comparative Education Review67(2): 231–464.
38.
LerchJCBromleyPRamirezFO, et al. (2017) The rise of individual agency in conceptions of society: Textbooks worldwide, 1950-2011. International Sociology32(1): 38–60.
39.
ManziZM (2007) Civics for Secondary Schools: Book Four. 2nd ed.Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: BPL Publishers.
40.
MeyerJWBoliJThomasGM, et al. (1997) World society and the nation-state. American Journal of Sociology103(1): 144–181.
41.
MeyerJWBromleyPRamirezFO (2010) Human rights in social science textbooks: Cross-national analyses, 1970-2008. Sociology of Education83(2): 111–134.
42.
NakagawaMWotipkaCM (2016) The worldwide incorporation of women and women’s rights discourse in social science textbooks, 1970–2008. Comparative Education Review60(3): 501–529.
43.
NaseemMA (2014) Deconstructing militarism in Pakistani textbooks. Journal of Educational Media, Memory, and Society6(2): 10–24.
44.
National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) (2007) Politics in India since Independence: Textbook in Political Science for Class XII. New Delhi, India: NCERT.
45.
NormandL (2021) From blind spot to hotspot: Representations of the ‘immigrant others’ in Norwegian curriculum/schoolbooks (1905-2013). Journal of Curriculum Studies53(1): 124–141.
46.
PearceD (1983) Textbook production in developing countries. Prospects13(3): 327–341.
PetterssonTHögbladhSÖbergM (2019) Organized violence, 1989-2018 and peace agreements. Journal of Peace Research56(4): 589–603.
49.
PevehouseJCNordstromTWarnkeK (2004) The COW-2 international organizations dataset version 2.3. Conflict Management and Peace Science21: 101–119.
50.
PinsonHArnotM (2007) Sociology of education and the wasteland of refugee education research. British Journal of Sociology of Education28(3): 399–407.
51.
RamirezFO (2006) From citizen to person? Rethinking education as incorporation. In: BakerDPWisemanAW (eds) The Impact of Comparative Education Research on Neo-Institutional Theory. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp.320–336.
52.
RamirezFOBoliJ (1987) The political construction of mass schooling: European origins and worldwide institutionalization. Sociology of Education60(1): 2–17.
53.
RamirezFOBromleyPRussellSG (2009) The valorization of humanity and diversity. Multicultural Education Review1(1): 29–54.
54.
RaudenbushSBrykA (2002) Hierarchical Linear Models: Applications and Data Analysis Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
55.
RussellSG (2015) Global civil society and education policy in post-genocide Rwanda. International Sociology30(6): 599–618.
56.
RussellSG (2019) Becoming Rwandan: Education, Reconciliation, and the Making of a Post-Genocide Citizen. Rutgers, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
57.
RussellSGLerchJCWotipkaCM (2018) The making of a human rights issue: A cross-national analysis of gender-based violence in textbooks, 1950-2011. Gender and Society32(5): 713–738.
58.
SkinnerNABromleyP (2019) Individual and collective social justice education: Comparing emphases on human rights and social movements in textbooks worldwide. Comparative Education Review63(4): 502–528.
59.
SkinnerNABromleyP (2022) Rights, conflict, and removal: Depictions of Indigenous groups in Californian and Texan history textbooks, 1836-2019. Journal of Curriculum Studies55(2): 203–222.
60.
SkrentnyJD (2009) The Minority Rights Revolution. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
61.
SneiderDC (2011) The war over words: History textbooks and international relations in Northeast Asia. In: ShinGWSneiderDC (eds) History Textbooks and the Wars in Asia: Divided Memories. New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, pp.246–68.
62.
SoysalYN (1994) Limits of Citizenship: Migrants and Postnational Membership in Europe. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
63.
SoysalYNSzakácsS (2010) Reconceptualizing the republic: Diversity and education in France, 1945-2008. Journal of Interdisciplinary History41(1): 97–115.
64.
SoysalYNBertilottiTMannitzS (2005) Projections of identity in French and German history and civics textbooks. In: SchisslerHSoysalYN (eds) The Nation, Europe and the World: Textbooks and Curricula in Transition. Oxford and New York: Berghahn Books, pp.13–34.
65.
SzakácsS (2017) Europe in the Classroom: World Culture and Nation-Building in Post-Socialist Romania. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
66.
Torney-PurtaJLehmannROswaldH, et al. (2001) Citizenship and Education in Twenty-Eight Countries: Civic Knowledge and Engagement at Age Fourteen. Amsterdam: IEA Secretariat.
67.
Union of International Associations (UIA) (numerous years)Yearbook of International Organizations. Munich: UIA and K. G. Saur Verlag.
68.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2021) Global trends: Forced displacement in 2020. Report, UNHCR Statistics and Demographics Section, Copenhagen. https://www.unhcr.org/refugee-statistics
69.
ValverdeGABianchiLJWolfeRG, et al. (2002) According to the Book: Using TIMSS to Investigate the Translation of Policy into Practice through the World of Textbooks. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
70.
VeraER (2018) Textbooks and Education. In: FuchsEBockA (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Textbook Studies. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.103–114.
71.
WallaceMSingerJD (1970) International governmental organization in the global system, 1815–1964. International Organization24: 239–287.
72.
WeinerMF (2018) Curricular alienation: Multiculturalism, tolerance, and immigrants in Dutch primary school history textbooks. Humanity & Society42(2): 147–170.
73.
World Bank (2022) World Development Indicators. Washington, DC: World Bank.
74.
WotipkaCMSvecJYiuL, et al. (2021) The status and agency of children in school textbooks, 1970–2012: A cross-national analysis. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education53: 949–966.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
