Treatments of common conditions which do not affect mortality often become sidelined in the drive to improve efficiency and reduce costs. The rationing of patients is a divisive but crucial component to universal health care. How should this be accomplished?
Methods and Results:
In this article we examine the outcomes of various rationing methods in varicose veins.
Conclusions:
No method is perfect and treatment of symptoms and complications should remain the target for all physicians.
Beebe-DimmerJL, PfeiferJR, EngleJS. The epidemiology of chronic venous insufficiency and varicose veins.Ann Epidemiol2005; 15: 175–84
2.
RabeE, GuexJ-J, PuskasA. Epidemiology of chronic venous disorders in geographically diverse populations: results from the Vein Consult Program.Int Angiol2012; 31: 105–15
3.
RasmussenLH, LawaetzM, BjoernL. Randomized clinical trial comparing endovenous laser ablation, radiofrequency ablation, foam sclerotherapy and surgical stripping for great saphenous varicose veins.Br J Surg2011; 98: 1079–87
TiwariA, DouekM, AckroydJS. Rationing of surgery for varicose veins based on the presence or absence of cosmetic symptoms.J Eval Clin Tract2002; 8: 425–7
RabeE, Pannier-FischerF, BromenK. Bonner Venenstudie der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Phlebologie.Phlebologie2003; 32: 1–14
8.
RabeE, PannierF, KoA. Incidence of varicose veins, chronic venous insufficiency, and progression of the disease in the Bonn Vein Study II.J Vasc Surg2010; 51: 791–1
9.
SamaraeeAA, McCallumIJD, MudawiA. Endovenous therapy of varicose veins: a better outcome than standard surgery?Surgeon2009; 7: 181–6
10.
LaneTRA, MooreHM, Da viesAH. New potential methods for superificial vein occlusion. In: DaviesAH, ed. Fast Facts: Vascular and Endovascular Surgery Highlights 2011-2012.Oxford: Health Press Limited, 2012: 7–13
11.
LaneTRA, PandeyVA, DaviesAH. Superficial venous disease treatment – is there still a role for open surgery in 2011?Acta Chir Belg2011; 111: 125–9
12.
KelleherD, LaneTRA, FranklinIJ. Treatment options, clinical outcome (quality of life) and cost benefit (quality-adjusted life year) in varicose vein treatment.Phlebology2012; 27 (Suppl 1):16–22
13.
CampbellWB, DecaluweH, BoecxstaensV. The symptoms of varicose veins: difficult to determine and difficult to study.Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg2007; 34: 741–4
14.
JudgeA, JavaidMK, ArdenNK. Clinical tool to identify patients who are most likely to achieve long-term improvement in physical function after total hip arthroplasty.Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken)2012; 64: 881–9
15.
LaudicellaM, SicilianiL, CooksonR. Waiting times and socioeconomic status: evidence from England.Soc Sci Med2012; 74: 1331–41
McNicolMW. Rationing joint replacements:… and is false economy resulting in overall damage.BMJ2005; 331: 1473
18.
EdwardsAG, BaynhamS, LeesT. Management of varicose veins: a survey of current practice by members of the Vascular Society of Great Britain and Ireland.Ann R Coll Surg Engl2009; 91: 77–80
IqbalZ, PryceA, AfzaM. Rationalizing rationing in health care: experience of two primary care trusts.J Public Health2006; 28: 125–32
21.
LaneTRA, SritharanK, HerbertJR. Management of chronic venous disease by primary care.Phlebology2012doi:10.1258/phleb.2012.012012
22.
GaynorM, LaudicellaM, PropperC. Can governments do it better? Merger mania and hospital outcomes in the English NHS.J Health Econ2012; 31: 528–43
23.
Sampietro-ColomL, EspallarguesM, RodriguezE. Wide social participation in prioritizing patients on waiting lists for joint replacement: a conjoint analysis.Med Decis Mak2008; 28: 554–66
24.
Department of Health.Tackling Hospital Waiting: the 18 Week Patient Pathway.London: COI, 2006
25.
OudhoffJP, TimmermansDRM, RietbergM. The acceptability of waiting times for elective general surgery and the appropriateness of prioritising patients.BMC Health Serv Res2007; 7: 32
26.
DerrettS, PaulC, MorrisJM. Waiting for elective surgery: effects on health-related quality of life.Int J Qual Health Care1999; 11: 47–57
27.
LöfvendahlS, EckerlundI, HansagiH. Waiting for orthopaedic surgery: factors associated with waiting times and patients' opinion.Int J Qual Health Care2005; 17: 133–40
28.
QuintanaJ, GarciaS, BilbaoA. Waiting time for cataract extraction: predictive factors and influence on outcomes.J Cataract Refract Surg2011; 37: 19–26
29.
BlättlerW, KreisN, LunB. Leg symptoms of healthy people and their treatment with compression hosiery.Phlebology2008; 23: 214–21
30.
AmslerF, BlättlerW. Compression therapy for occupational leg symptoms and chronic venous disorders – a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg2008; 35: 366–72
31.
AmslerF, WillenbergT, BlättlerW. In search of optimal compression therapy for venous leg ulcers: a meta-analysis of studies comparing diverse [corrected] bandages with specifically designed stockings.J Vasc Surg2009; 50: 668–74
32.
PalfreymanSJ, MichaelsJA. A systematic review of compression hosiery for uncomplicated varicose veins.Phlebology2009; 24 (Suppl. 1): 13–33
33.
CataldoJL, de GodoyJMP, de BarrosN. The use of compression stockings for venous disorders in Brazil.Phlebology2012; 27: 33–7
34.
RajuS, HollisK, NeglénP. Use of compression stockings in chronic venous disease: patient compliance and efficacy.Ann Vasc Surg2007; 21: 790–5
35.
CarpentierPH, BeckerF, ThineyG. Acceptability and practicability of elastic compression stockings in the elderly: a randomized controlled evaluation.Phlebology2011; 26: 107–13
36.
HiraiM, IwataH, MiyazakiK. Development of separated elastic stockings.Phlebology2012 doi:10.1258/phleb.2011.011140
37.
HiraiM, YoshinagaM, NakayamaR. Assessment of venous insufficiency using photoplethysmography: a comparison to strain gauge plethysmography.Angiology1985; 36: 795–801
38.
HiraiM, IwataH, HayakawaN. Effect of elastic compression stockings in patients with varicose veins and healthy controls measured by strain gauge plethysmography.Skin Res Technol2002; 8: 236–9
39.
NelsonEA, Bell-SyerSEM. Compression for preventing recurrence of venous ulcers.Cochrane Database Syst Rev (Online)2012; 8: CD002303
40.
O'MearaS, CullumNA, NelsonEA. Compression for venous leg ulcers.Cochrane Database Syst Rev (Online)2009; 1: 1–142
41.
ThalerE, HuchR, HuchA. Compression stockings prophylaxis of emergent varicose veins in pregnancy: a prospective randomised controlled study.Swiss Med Wkly2001; 131: 659–62
42.
RatcliffeJ, BrazierJE, CampbellWB. Cost-effectiveness analysis of surgery versus conservative treatment for uncomplicated varicose veins in a randomized clinical trial.Br J Surg2006; 93: 182–6
43.
OudhoffJP, TimmermansDRM, BijnenAB. Waiting for elective general surgery: physical, psychological and social consequences.ANZ J Surg2004; 74: 361–7
MartinS, SmithPC. Rationing by waiting lists: an empirical investigation.J Public Econ1999; 71: 141–64
46.
BajwaA, MageeTR, GallandRB. Reduction in varicose vein services: impact on operative training.Ann R Coll Surg Engl2007; 89: 789–91
47.
LattimerCR, AzzamM, KalodikiE. Venous filling time using air-plethysmography correlates highly with great saphenous vein reflux time using duplex.Phlebology2012 doi:10.1258/phleb.2012.012042
48.
NavarroTP, DelisKT, RibeiroAP. Clinical and hemodynamic significance of the greater saphenous vein diameter in chronic venous insufficiency.Arch Surg2002; 137: 1233–7
49.
BarrosMVL, LabropoulosN, RibeiroALP. Clinical significance of ostial great saphenous vein reflux.Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg2006; 31: 320–4
50.
ConwayAM, NordonIM, HinchliffeRJ. Patient-reported symptoms are independent of disease severity in patients with primary varicose veins.Vascular2011; 19: 262–8
51.
Mdez-HerreroA, GutiérrezJ, CamblorL. The relation among the diameter of the great saphenous vein, clinical state and haemodynamic pattern of the saphenofemoral junction in chronic superficial venous insufficiency.Phlebology2007; 22: 207–13
52.
LabropoulosN, KokkosisAA, SpentzourisG. The distribution and significance of varicosities in the saphenous trunks.J Vasc Surg2010; 51: 96–103
53.
EklöfBG, RutherfordRB, BerganJJ. Revision of the CEAP classification for chronic venous disorders: consensus statement.J Vasc Surg2004; 40: 1248–52
54.
VasquezMA, RabeE, McLaffertyRB. Revision of the venous clinical severity score: venous outcomes consensus statement: special communication of the American Venous Forum Ad Hoc Outcomes Working Group.J Vasc Surg2010; 52: 1387–96
55.
GibsonK, MeissnerM, WrightD. Great saphenous vein diameter does not correlate with worsening quality of life scores in patients with great saphenous vein incompetence.J Vasc Surg2012; 56: 1634–41
56.
ShepherdAC, GohelMS, LimCS. A study to compare disease-specific quality of life with clinical anatomical and hemodynamic assessments in patients with varicose veins.J Vasc Surg2011; 53: 374–82
57.
LeeJE, WatsonD, Frey-LawLA. Psychological factors predict local and referred experimental muscle pain: a cluster analysis in healthy adults.Eur J Pain2012
58.
SharpeL, PerryKN, RogersP. A comparison of the effect of mindfulness and relaxation on responses to acute experimental pain.Eur J Pain2012
59.
HoldsworthJ, RobinsonL, WilliamsonEA. Nurse-led varicose vein assessment and implementation of guidelines for treatment.Phlebology2004; 19: 69–71
60.
HarrisMRE, DaviesRJ, BrownS. Surgical treatment of varicose veins: effect of rationing.Ann R Coll Surg Engl2006; 88: 37–9
61.
CampbellLindsey. Rationing of treatment for varicose veins and use of new treatment methods: a survey of practice in the United Kingdom.Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg2006; 32: 427
62.
GloviczkiP, ComerotaAJ, DalsingMC. The care of patients with varicose veins and associated chronic venous diseases: clinical practice guidelines of the Society for Vascular Surgery and the American Venous Forum.J Vasc Surg2011; 53 (Suppl. 5): 2S–48S
63.
IglesiasCP, BirksY, NelsonEA. Quality of life of people with venous leg ulcers: a comparison of the discriminative and responsive characteristics of two generic and a disease specific instruments.Quol Life Res2005; 14: 1705–18
64.
SmithJJ, GuestMG, GreenhalghRM. Measuring the quality of life in patients with venous ulcers.J Vasc Surg2000; 31: 642–9
65.
RabeE, PannierF. Societal costs of chronic venous disease in CEAP C4, C5, C6 disease.Phlebology2010; 25 (Suppl. 1): 64–7
66.
HeitJA, SilversteinMD, MohrDN. Risk factors for deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism: a population-based case-control study.Arch Intern Med2000; 160: 809–15
67.
DecoususH, QuéréI, PreslesE. Superficial venous thrombosis and venous thromboembolism: a large, prospective epidemiologic study.Ann Intern Med2010; 152: 218–24
68.
CarradiceD, MazariFAK, SamuelN. Modelling the effect of venous disease on quality of life.Br J Surg2011; 98: 1089–98
69.
DarvallKAL, BateGR, AdamDJ. Generic health-related quality of life is significantly worse in varicose vein patients with lower limb symptoms independent of CEAP clinical grade.Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg2012; 44: 341–4
70.
KaplanRM, CriquiMH, DenenbergJO. Quality of life in patients with chronic venous disease: San Diego population study.J Vasc Surg2003; 37: 1047–53
71.
BradburyA, EvansC, AllanP. What are the symptoms of varicose veins? Edinburgh vein study cross sectional population survey.BMJ1999; 318: 353–6
72.
DarvallKAL, SamRC, BateGR. Changes in health-related quality of life after ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy for great and small saphenous varicose veins.J Vasc Surg2010; 51: 913–20
73.
CarradiceD, MekakoAI, MazariFAK. Clinical and technical outcomes from a randomized clinical trial of endovenous laser ablation compared with conventional surgery for great saphenous varicose veins.Br J Surg2011; 98: 1117–23
74.
BradburyA, EvansCJ, AllanP. The relationship between lower limb symptoms and superficial and deep venous reflux on duplex ultrasonography: the Edinburgh Vein Study.J Vasc Surg2000; 32: 921–31
