This paper continues the debate concerning the availability of Universal Grammar (UG) to adult L2 acquirers. Specifically, an analysis of native (prodrop) Romance speakers' acquisition of negative placement in L2 German is provided. Contrary to Clahsen (1987; 1988a) and Clahsen and Muysken (1988), we argue that a UG-based analysis for the three stages of NEGplacement is not only possible but in fact provides independent support for UG-based analyses of the developmental sequence found in L1 Romance, L2 German Verb placement (duPlessis et al, 1987; Schwartz and Tomaselli, 1988). In particular, by combining (1) aspects of the L 1 grammar with (2) the independently needed changes in parameter values (characterizing principal differences between the L1 and L2 grammars), we arrive at a non- ad hoc account. We also show how the resolution of additional problems concerning the data of this same set of L2 acquirers naturally follows from the analysis argued for. Finally, some discussion comparing the two UG-based analyses of the verb-placement data (duPlessis et al.'s and Schwartz and Tomaselli's) is included.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Belletti, A.1988: Generalized Verb movement: on some differences and similarities between Italian and French. Paper presented at GLOW, Budapest.
2.
Bennis, H. and Hoekstra, T.1984: Gaps and parasitic gaps. The Linguistic Review4: 29-87.
3.
Cardinaletti, A. to appear: Aspetti sintattici della regola di estraposizione della frase relativa. La Revista di Grammatica Generativa.
4.
Chomsky, N.1986: Barriers. Cambridge, Mass.: The MIT Press. 1988: Some notes on economy of derivation and representation. Ms. MIT.
5.
Clahsen, H.1984: The acquisition of German word order: a test case for cognitive approaches to second language development. In: Andersen, R., editor, Second languages. Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House, 219-42.
6.
— 1987: Kritische Phasen der Grammatikenwicklung: Eine Untersuchung zum Negationserwerb bei Kindern und Erwachsenen. Ms. Universität Düsseldorf.
7.
— 1988a: Critical phases of grammar development: a study of the acquisition of negation in children and adults. In Jordens, P. and Lalleman, J., editors, Language development. Dordrecht: Foris, 123-48.
8.
— 1988b: Parameterized grammatical theory and language acquisition: A study of the acquisition of verb placement and inflection by children and adults. In Flynn, S. and O'Neill, W., editors, Linguistic theory in second language acquisition. Dordrecht: D. Reidel, 47-75.
9.
Clahsen, H., Meisel, J. and Pienemann, M.1983: Deutsch als Zweitsprache. Tübinger Beiträge zur Linguistik, Series A, Vol. 3. Tübingen: Gunter Narr.
10.
Clahsen, H. and Muysken, P.1986: The availability of Universal Grammar to adult and child learners - a study of the acquisition of German word order. Second Language Research2; 93-119.
11.
— 1988: The UG paradox in L2 acquisition. Ms. Universität Düsseldorf/Universiteit van Amsterdam.
12.
Den Besten, H. and Webelhuth, G.1987: Renmant topicalization and the constituent structure of VP in the Germanic SOV languages. Paper presented at GLOW, Venice.
13.
DuPlessis, J., Solin, D., Travis, L. and White, L.1987: UG or not UG, that is the question: a reply to Clahsen and Muysken. Second Language Research3: 56-75.
14.
Edmonds, J.1978: The verbal complex V' - V in French. Linguistic Inquiry9: 151-75.
15.
Eubank, L.1986: Formal models of language learning and the acquisition of German word order and negation by primary and nonprimary language learners. Unpublished PhD dissertation. The University of Texas, Austin.
16.
Eubank, L.1988: Untitled. Ms. International Programs . Austin, Texas.
17.
Frampton, J.1987: Parasitic gaps and the theory of WH-chains. Ms. Northeastern University. Paper presented at GLOW, Budapest.
18.
Haegeman, L.1989. Introduction to Generative Syntax. Ms. Université de Genève.
19.
Hoberg, U.1981: Die Wortstellung in der geschriebenen deutschen Gegenwartssprache . Munich: Max Hueber Verlag.
20.
Hoekstra, T.1984: Transitivity: grammatical relations in Government-Binding Theory. Dordrecht: Foris.
21.
Jordens, P.1988: The acquisition of word order in L2 Dutch and German. In Jordens, P. and Lalleman, J., editors, Language Development. Dordrecht: Foris.
22.
Kayne, R.1984: Connectedness and binary branching. Dordrecht: Foris.
23.
Kitagawa, Y.1986: Subject in Japanese and English. Unpublished PhD dissertation . University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
24.
Köpcke, K.-M.1987: Der Erwerb morphologischer Ausdrucksmittel durch L2 Lerner . Zeitschrift für Sprach wissenschaft6: 186-205.
25.
Koster, J.1987: Domains and Dynasties. Dordrecht: Foris.
26.
Kuroda, Y.1986: Whether we agree or not. Ms. University of California, San Diego.
27.
Meisel, J., Clahsen, H. and Pienemann, M.1981: On determining developmental sequences in natural second language acquisition. Studies in Second Language Acquisition3: 109-35.
28.
Pienemann, M.1981: Der Zweitspracherwerb ausländischer Arbeiterkinder. Bonn: Bouvier.
29.
Platzack, C. and Holmberg, A.1989: The role of AGR and finiteness. Working Papers in ScandinavianSyntax43: 51-76.
30.
Pollock, J.-Y.1988: Verb movement, UG and the structure of IP. Ms. Université de Haute Bretagne. (To appear in Linguistic Inquiry.)
31.
Rizzi, L.1987a: On the structural uniformity of syntactic categories. Ms. Université de Genève.
32.
— 1987b: Three issues in Romance dialectology. Paper presented at GLOW, Venice.
33.
Roberts, I.1985: Agreement parameters and the development of modal auxiliaries . Natural Language and Linguistic Theory3: 21-58.
34.
Schwartz, B.D. and Tomaselli, A.1988: Some implications from an analysis of German word order . Ms. Université de Genève/Università di Pavia. Paper presented at the Fifth Workshop on Comparative Germanic Syntax, Groningen. (To appear in: Abraham, W. and Reuland, E., editors, Germanic syntax workshop.)
35.
Schwartz, B.D. and Vikner, S.1989: All verb second clauses are CPs. Working Papers in ScandinavianSyntax43: 27-49.
36.
Sportiche, D.1988: A theory of floating quantifiers and its corollaries for constituent structure. Linguistic Inquiry19: 425-49.
37.
Tomaselli, A.1989: La sintassi del verbo finito nelle lingue Germaniche. Unpublished PhD dissertation. Università di Pavia.
38.
— in prep: Towards a theory of adjunction. Ms. Università di Pavia.
39.
Tomaselli, A. and Schwartz, B.D.1988: Negation in L2 German: Sequence data as support for UG in adult SLA. Paper presented at the Language Acquisition Research Symposium (LARS), Utrecht, August 1988.
40.
Travis, L.1984: Parameters and effects of word order variation. Unpublished PhD dissertation. MIT.
41.
— 1986: Parameters of phrase structure and V2 phenomena. Paper presented at the Princeton Workshop on Comparative Syntax , Princeton. (To appear in the proceedings.)
