Different revenue incentives,different content? Comparing economic news before and during the financial crisis in German public and commercial news outlets over time

Abstract

This study argues that revenue model incentives determine news content. The goal to make profits and the need to sell audiences to advertisers guide journalists’ selection and interpretation of newsworthy material and result in commercialised news. We compare the volume, tone, and the obtrusiveness of topics in all economic news stories for the evening TV news of the public broadcasters ARD and ZDF, the commercial broadcaster RTL, and the tabloid newspaper BILD from 2002 to 2010 in Germany (n = 26,467). Results indicate that news selection is guided by revenue model incentives since economic news differs by volume and topic between public and commercial outlets. News interpretation, i.e., news tone, stronger varies across the media types TV and print. We conclude that advertising income dependency and observation of competitor behaviour transmits to operative journalistic practices and decisions, which in turn determine journalistic outcome.

Keywords

Business model competition content analysis economics of media financial journalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aalberg

Van Aelst

Curran

(2010) Media systems and the political information environment: A cross-national comparison. International Journal of Press/Politics 15(3): 255–271.

Bähr

(2009) The world economy crisis and its actors in the online-publications of German newspapers and journals. Journal of Media Research (4): 56–64.

Beam

(1996) How perceived environmental uncertainty influences the marketing orientation of U.S. daily newspapers. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 73(2): 285–303.

Beam

Brownlee

Weaver

. (2009) Journalism and public service in troubled times. Journalism Studies 10(6): 734–753.

bild.de (2012) Alle Fakten zur BILD. Auflage, Redaktionen, Journalisten. [All facts of BILD. Circulation, editorial desks, journalists.] Available at: http://www.bild.de/digital/bild-zeitung-druck/bild-druck/alle-fakten-redaktionen-journalisten-19083750.bild.html (accessed 9 September 2013).

Brekken

Thorbjørnsrud

Aalberg

(2010) Media systems and political information resources: An empirical study of focus and frames across countries and news media outlets. In: APSA 2010 Annual Meeting Paper, Washington, DC. Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1642543## (accessed 1 November 2012).

Brettschneider

(2003) Economic affairs, media coverage, and the public’s perception of the economy in Germany. In: Schorr

(ed.) Communication Research and Media Science in Europe: Perspectives for Research and Academic Training in Europe’s Changing Media Reality. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, pp. 251–270.

Bussière

Imbs

Kollmann

. (2013) The financial crisis: Lessons for international macroeconomics. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 5(3): 75–84.

Demers

Craff

Choi

Y-H

. (1989) Issue obtrusiveness and the agenda-setting effects of national network news. Communication Research 16(6): 793–812.

10.

Doyle

(2006) Financial news journalism: A post-Enron analysis of approaches towards economic and financial news production in the UK. Journalism 7(4): 433–452.

11.

Ecke

(2011) Relevanz der Medien für die Meinungsbildung. Empirische Grundlagen zur Ermittlung der Wertigkeit der Mediengattungen bei der Meinungsbildung. [Relevance of media for opinion formation. Empirical basics for determining the weight of media types for opinion formation.] Available at: https://www.blm.de/apps/documentbase/data/pdf1/Medienkonzentration.pdf (accessed 26 November 2013).

12.

Esser

Brüggemann

(2010) The strategic crisis of German newspapers. In: Levy

DAL

(ed.) The Changing Business of Journalism and Its Implications for Democracy. Oxford: Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, University of Oxford, pp. 39–54.

13.

Esser

De Vreese

Stromback

. (2012) Political information opportunities in Europe: A longitudinal and comparative study of thirteen television systems. International Journal of Press/Politics 17(3): 247–274.

14.

Gniffke

(2013) Tagesschau-Redaktion. [Tagesschau editorial desk] Hamburg: E-Mail.

15.

Godler

Reich

(2013) How journalists think about facts. Journalism Studies 14(1): 94–112.

16.

Hagen

(2005) Konjunkturnachrichten, Konjunkturklima und Konjunktur. Wie sich die Wirtschaftsberichterstattung der Massenmedien, Stimmungen der Bevölkerung und die aktuelle Wirtschaftslage wechselseitig beeinflussen. Eine transaktionale Analyse. [Economic news, economic climate, and the business circle. How mass media economic news, public sentiment and the present state of the economy mutually influence each other. A transactional analysis.] Köln: von Halem.

17.

Hamilton

(2004) All the News That’s Fit to Sell: How the Market Transforms Information into News. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

18.

Hampton

(2008) The ‘objectivity’ ideal and its limitations in 20th-century British journalism. Journalism Studies 9(4): 477–493.

19.

Hanitzsch

Anikina

Berganza

. (2010) Modeling perceived influences on journalism: Evidence from a cross-national survey of journalists. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 87(1): 5–22.

20.

Heinrich

(2001a) Medienökonomie: Band 1: Mediensystem, Zeitung, Zeitschrift, Anzeigenblatt. [Media economics: Volume 1: Media system, newspaper, magazine, advertising paper.] Wiesbaden: Westdeutscher Verlag.

21.

Heinrich

(2001b) Ökonomisierung aus wirtschaftswissenschaftlicher Perspektive. [Commercialization from an economics perspective.] Medien und Kommunikationswissenschaft 49(2): 159–166.

22.

Hoffmann-Riem

(2003) Kann und soll der öffentliche Rundfunk eine Staatsaufgabe sein? [Can and should public broadcasting be government’s responsibility?] In: Donges

Puppis

(eds) Die Zukunft des öffentlichen Rundfunks. Internationale Beiträge aus Wissenschaft und Praxis. [The future of public broadcasting. International contributions from science and practice.] Köln: von Halem, pp. 29–51.

23.

Hofstetter

(1976) Bias in the News: Network Television Coverage of the 1972 Election Campaign. Columbus, OH: The Ohio State University Press.

24.

IVW (2013) Tageszeitungen Gesamtliste. [Daily newspapers total list.] Available at: www.ivw.eu (accessed 10 January 2013).

25.

Kepplinger

Ehmig

(2006) Predicting news decisions. An empirical test of the two-component theory of news selection. Communications 31(1): 25–43.

26.

Kirchner

(2013) Dependence by self-reinforcing processes. In: Sydow

Schreyögg

(eds) Self-reinforcing Processes in and among Organizations. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 35–45.

27.

Klein

(1998) Tabloidised political coverage in BILD-Zeitung. Javnost-The Public 5(3): 79–93.

28.

Köcher

(1986) Bloodhounds or missionaries: Role definitions of German and British journalists. European Journal of Communication 1(1): 43–64.

29.

Kostadinova

Dimitrova

(2012) Communicating policy change: Media framing of economic news in post-communist Bulgaria. European Journal of Communication 27(2): 171–186.

30.

Krüger

(2013) InfoMonitor 2012: Fernsehnachrichten bei ARD, ZDF, RTL und Sat.1. [Info monitor 2012: TV news of ARD, ZDF, RTL, and Sat.1.] Media Perspektiven (2): 91–114.

31.

Lee

(2004) Reconciling ‘cognitive priming’ vs ‘obtrusive contingency’ hypotheses: An analytical model of media agenda-setting effects. International Communication Gazette 66(2): 151–166.

32.

Lim

(2011) Intermedia agenda setting and news discourse. Journalism Practice 5(2): 227–244.

33.

Magee

(2013) All things considered: A content analysis of national public radio’s flagship news magazine from 1999–2009. Journal of Radio & Audio Media 20(2): 236–250.

34.

Maier

Ruhrmann

Stengel

(2009) Der Wert von Nachrichten im deutschen Fernsehen. Inhaltsanalyse von TV-Nachrichten im Jahr 2007. [The value of news in German TV. Content analysis of TV news in 2007.] Available at: http://www.lfm-nrw.de/fileadmin/lfm-nrw/Pressemeldungen/nachrichtenanalyse_1992-2007.pdf (accessed 1 November 2012).

35.

Manning

(2013) Financial journalism, news sources and the banking crisis. Journalism 14(2): 173–189.

36.

Marcinkowski

Marr

(2010) Medieninhalte und Medieninhaltsforschung. [Media content and media content research] In: Bonfadelli

Jarren

Siegert

(eds) Einführung in die Publizistikwissenschaft. [Introduction into mass communication science.] Bern: Verlag Paul Haupt, pp. 477–516.

37.

Marron

Sarabia-Panol

Sison

. (2010) The scorecard on reporting of the global financial crisis. Journalism Studies 11(2): 270–283.

38.

Media Tenor (2012) Working standards. Media content analysis. Available at: http://www.mediatenor.com/en/about-us (accessed 18 June 2014).

39.

Patterson

(1998) Political roles of the journalist. In: Graber

McQuail

Norris

. (eds) The Politics of News: The News of Politics. Washington, DC: CQ Press, pp. 17–32.

40.

Picard

(2004) Commercialism and newspaper quality. Newspaper Research Journal 25(1): 54–65.

41.

Picard

(2006) Journalism, value creation and the future of news organizations. Joan Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics and Public Policy Working Paper Series. Available at: http://www.robertpicard.net/PDFFiles/ValueCreationandNewsOrgs.pdf.

42.

Potschka

(2011) Broadcasting licence fee settlements in the UK and Germany. Economic Affairs 31(1): 115–117.

43.

Quiring

(2004) Wirtschaftsberichterstattung und Wahlen. Konstanz: UVK.

44.

Quiring

Weber

(2012) Between usefulness and legitimacy: Media coverage of governmental intervention during the financial crisis and selected effects. International Journal of Press/Politics 17(3): 294–315.

45.

Reinemann

(2007) Subjektiv rationale Akteure. Das Potenzial handlungstheoretischer Erklärungen für die Journalismusforschung. [Subjective rational actors. The potential of action theory explanations for journalism research.] In: Altmeppen

Hanitzsch

Schlüter

(eds) Journalismustheorie: Next Generation. Soziologische Grundlegung und theoretische Innovation. [Journalism theory. Next generation. Sociological basics and theoretical innovation.] Wiesbaden: VS Verlag.

46.

Reinemann

Stanyer

Scherr

. (2012) Hard and soft news: A review of concepts, operationalizations and key findings. Journalism 13(2): 221–239.

47.

Roberts

McCombs

(1994) Agenda setting and political advertising: Origins of the news agenda. Political Communication 11(3): 249–262.

48.

RTL interactive GmbH (2013) RTL Aktuell: Die Redaktion. [RTL Aktuell: The editorial desk.] Available at: http://www.rtl.de/cms/news/rtl-aktuell/rtl-aktuell-die-redaktion-200c1-51ca-23-1057642.html (accessed 6 September 2013).

49.

Russi

Gerth

Siegert

Krebs

(2014) The relationship of competition and financial commitment revisited. A fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis in European newspaper markets. Journal of Media Economics 27(2): 60–78.

50.

Schulz

(1976) Die Konstruktion von Realität in den Nachrichtenmedien. Analyse der aktuellen Berichterstattung. [The construction of reality in the news media. Analysis of current news coverage.] Freiburg (Breisgau) and München: Alber.

51.

Shoemaker

Reese

(1996) Mediating the Message: Theories of Influences on Mass Media Content. White Plains, NY: Longman.

52.

Siegert

Von Rimscha

(2013) Economic bases of communication. In: Cobley

Schulz

(eds) Theories and Models of Communication. Berlin: de Gruyter Mouton, pp. 123–145.

53.

Sims

(1980) Macroeconomics and reality. Econometrica 48(1): 1–48.

54.

Skovsgaard

Albæk

Bro

. (2013) A reality check: How journalists’ role perceptions impact their implementation of the objectivity norm. Journalism 14(1): 22–42.

55.

Sommer

(2013) Wirkung von Wirtschaftsberichterstattung: eine Systematisierung. [Effects of economic news coverage: A systematization.] In: Schweiger

Fahr

(eds) Handbuch Medienwirkungsforschung. [Handbook of research on media effects] Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden, pp. 369–384.

56.

Spachmann

(2005) Wirtschaftsjournalismus in der Presse. Theorie und Empirie [Business journalism in the press. Theory and empirical research.] (Zugl.: Hohenheim University, Dissertation, 2004). Konstanz: UVK.

57.

Strömbäck

Karlsson

Hopmann

(2012) Determinants of news content. Journalism Studies 13(5–6): 718–728.

58.

Van Dalen

De Vreese

Erik

(2012) Different roles, different content? A four-country comparison of the role conceptions and reporting style of political journalists. Journalism 13(7): 903–922.

59.

Vettehen

Beentjes

Nuijten

. (2011) Arousing news characteristics in Dutch television news 1990–2004: An exploration of competitive strategies. Mass Communication and Society 14(1): 93–112.

60.

Vettehen

Nuijten

Beentjes

(2005) News in an age of competition: The case of sensationalism in Dutch television news, 1995–2001. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 49(3): 282–295.

61.

Vliegenthart

Walgrave

(2008) The contingency of intermedia agenda setting: A longitudinal study in Belgium. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 85(4): 860–877.

62.

Weaver

Beam

Brownlee

. (2007) The American Journalist in the 21st Century: US News People at the Dawn of a New Millennium. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

63.

Wehmeier

(2001) Ökonomisierung des Fernsehens. Ein Beitrag zur Verbindung von System und Akteur. [Commercialization of TV. A contribution to the connection between system and actor.] Medien und Kommunikationswissenschaft 49(3): 306–324.

64.

Weischenberg

Löffelholz

Scholl

(1994) Merkmale und Einstellungen von Journalisten. [Characteristics and attitudes of journalists.] Media Perspektiven (4): 154–67.

65.

Weischenberg

Malik

Scholl

(2012) Journalism in Germany in the 21st century. In: Weaver

Willnat

(eds) The Global Journalist in the 21st Century. New York: Routledge, pp. 205–219.

66.

ZDF (2012) Das Nachrichten-Herz des ZDF. [The news core of ZDF.] Available at: http://www.zdf.de/heute-plus/Das-Nachrichten-Herz-des-ZDF-6798002.html (accessed 6 September 2013).

67.

Zubayr

Gerhard

(2005) Tendenzen im Zuschauerverhalten. Fernsehgewohnheiten und Fernsehreichweiten im Jahr 2004. [Tendencies in audience behavior. TV using habits and TV reach in 2004.] Media Perspektiven (3): 94–104.

68.

Zubayr

Gerhard

(2011) Tendenzen im Zuschauerverhalten. Fernsehgewohnheiten und Fernsehreichweiten im Jahr 2010. [Tendencies in audience behavior. TV using habits and TV reach in 2010.] Media Perspektiven (3): 126–138.

69.

Zubayr

Gerhard

(2012) Tendenzen im Zuschauerverhalten. Fernsehgewohnheiten und Fernsehreichweiten im Jahr 2011. [Tendencies in audience behavior. TV using habits and TV reach in 2011.] Media Perspektiven (3): 118–132.