The article has two aims. First it explores how winners of wider discursive battles
over ‘public interest’ and ‘freedom of
speech’ have increasingly shaped national interpretations of
children’s media rights in the western world. This article argues that the
winners of these discursive battles are powerful in terms of shaping
children’s media provision. The second part of the article focuses on the
particular challenges facing policymakers and broadcasters in New Zealand as they go
about defining new public service outputs for children. This nation of four million
inhabitants is in the middle of a difficult experiment. The Labour Government,
elected in 1999 (and again in 2002), has declared an intention to claw back public
service outputs on its state-owned broadcaster TVNZ, after a decade in the
deregulated media marketplace.
Advertising on TV: Getting it Right for Children. A Socially Responsible
Approach (2002)
Wellington: New Zealand Television Broadcasters Council
.
2.
Blumler, J.
and
D. Biltereyst
(1997) The Integrity and Erosion of Public Television For
Children: A Pan-European Study, research monograph.
Washington, DC: Center for Media
Education/London: The Broadcasting Standards Authority/Dusseldorf: The
European Institute for the Media/Brussels: European Broadcasting Union (EBU)
.
3.
Born, G.
(2000)
‘Inside Television: Television Studies and the Sociology of Culture’
, Screen41(4):
404-424
.
4.
Buckingham, D.
and
H. Davies
(2000) After the Death of Childhood: Growing Up in the Age of
Electronic Media.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
5.
Buckingham, D.
,
H. Davies
,
K. Jones
and
P. Kelley
(1999) Children’s Television in Britain: History,
Discourse and Policy.
London: British Film Institute
.
6.
Calfee, J.
(2003)
‘Advertiding Bans, Restrictions and Controls: Do They Work?’
, speech at ‘Obesity and Children: Possible Causes,
Possible Solutions and the Role of Advertising’ seminar, Advertising
Standards Authority, 5 March; at:
www.asa.co.nz/food_symposium/Jack_Calfee.htm (accessed 30 March 2003).
7.
‘Capturing Kids: Selling to Children, Teenagers and their Parents’
(1999) proceedings of the IIR seminar,
Auckland, 11-12 October.
8.
Davies, M.M.
,
O. O’Malley
and
B. Corbett
(1998) ‘Channels to the Future:
Children‘s Views about Broadcasting Provision’, pp.
109-115 in
S. Ralph
,
J. Langham Brown
and
T. Lees
(eds) What Price Creativity?Luton: University of Luton Press
.
9.
Edling, A.
(1999)
‘TV Advertising and Children: Ethics and Public Policy’
, paper presented at the Food Advertising
Unit/Children‘s Programme Conference,
London, 23 November.
10.
Given, J.
(2003) America’s Pie: Trade and Culture after
9/11.
Sydney: UNSW Press
.
11.
Goonasekera, A.
,
Huang Chan Zhu, L.Eashwer, B.Guntarto, S.Bairaj-Ambigapathy, J.Dhungana, Lin Ai-Leen
,
A. Chung
and
V.T.M. Hanh
(2000) Growing Up with TV: Asian Children’s
Experience.
Singapore: Asian Media Information and
Communication Centre
.
12.
Herman, E.
and
R. McChesney
(1997) The Global Media: The New Missionaries of Corporate
Capitalism.
London: Cassell
.
13.
Howell, R.
(1999)
‘Should our Children be Spared Ronald?: No Says Rupert Howell’
. The Guardian22 November:
9
.
14.
Jenks, A.
(1996) Childhood.
London: Routledge
.
15.
Kantrowitz, B.
and
P. Wingert
(1999)
‘The Truth about Tweens’
, Newsweek18 October.
16.
Kelley, P.
,
D. Buckingham
and
H. Davies
(1999)
‘Talking Dirty: Children, Sexual Knowledge and Television’
, Childhood6(2):
221-242
.
17.
Kline, S.
(1993) Out of the Garden: Toys and Children’s
Culture in the Age of TV Marketing.
London: Verso
.
18.
Kunkel, D.
(1999)
‘Children’s Television Policy in the United States: An
Ongoing Legacy of Change’
, Media International Australia93:
51-64
.
19.
Laybourne, G.
(1993) ‘The Nickelodeon
Experience’, pp. 303-307 in
G. Berry
and
J. K. Asamen
(eds) Children and Television.
London: Sage
.
20.
Laybourne, G.
(1995)
‘This is Nickelodeon’
, presentation to the First World Summit on Children and
Television, Melbourne, 14 March.
McBeth, R.
and
M. Snowden
(1998) Local Content Provisions In Television: Background
Documents and Discussion, report.
Wellington: Screen Producers and Directors Association
.
23.
Maharey, S.
(2003) ‘Advertising and Public Service
Broadcasting’, speech by the Minister of Broadcasting, 18 March;
at: www.beehive.govt.nz (accessed 26 March 2003).
24.
Ministry of Health (2003) at:
www.moh.govt.nz/moh.nsf/wpg_Index/Forusm-Index (accessed 20 February 2003).
25.
Minow, N.
(1995) Abandoned in the Wasteland: Children, Television, and
the First Amendment.
New York: Hill and Wang
.
26.
Nickelodeon
(1998) Tools and Rules: Marketing Information for
Partners.
Wellington: TVNZ Enterprises
.
27.
Norris, P.
,
B. Pauling
,
R. Zanker
and
G. Lealand
(2003) The Future of Public Broadcasting: The Experience in 6
Countries, report.
Wellington: New Zealand On Air
.
28.
Pecora, N.
(1998) The Business of Children’s
Entertainment.
New York: Guilford Press
.
29.
Qvortrup, J.
,
M. Bardy
,
G. Sgirtta
and
H. Wintersberger
(eds) (1994) Childhood Matters: Social Theory, Practice and
Politics.
Aldershot: Avebury/Vienna: European Centre
.
30.
Rydin, I.
(ed.) (2003) Media Fascinations: Perspectives on Young
People’s Meaning Making.
Goteborg: Nordicom at Goteborg University
.
31.
Schneider, C.
(1987) Children’s Television: The Art, the
Business, and How it Works.
Chicago, IL: NTC Business Books
.
32.
Seiter, E.
(1993) Sold Separately: Children and Parents in Consumer
Culture.
New York: Rutgers University Press
.
33.
Smith, N.
(2003)
‘Food Industry Battles Ad Ban’
, National Business Review7 February:
1
.
34.
Snoddy, R.
(2001)
‘A Kiwi Guide to Bad TV’
, The Times7 December.
35.
Steemers, J.
(1999)
‘Selling Children’s Television Ancillary Rights in
Youth and the Global Media’
, paper presented at Youth and the Global Media, 29th Broadcasting
Symposium, University of Manchester.
36.
Twinn, I.
(1999)
‘Opinion: Resist EU Threat to Children’s Advertising’
, Reuters News Service, 22 March (accessed 23 May 1999).
37.
Wiggs, G.
(1999)
‘The Boundaries of Commercial Speech’
, paper presented at the World Congress of the World Federation of
Advertisers, Seoul, 23 May; at:
www.asa.co.nz (last accessed 20 September 2004).
38.
Zanker, R.
(1999)
‘Kumara Kai or the Big Pac Mac’
, Media International Australia93:
91-102
.
39.
Zanker, R. (2002) ‘What Now? A New Zealand Children’s
Television Production Case Study’, PhD dissertation, Waikato University.
40.
Zanker, R.
(2003) ‘Tracking the Global in the Local: On
Children’s Culture in a Small National Media
Market’, pp. 77-95 in
C. von Feilitzen
and
U. Carlsson
(eds) Children, Young People and Media Globalisation, The UNESCO
International Clearinghouse on Children, Youth and Media.
Nordicom: Goteborg University
.
