RETRACTED: Immediacy as a better service: Analysis of limitations of the use of ChatGPT in library services

Abstract

The paper examines ChatGPT's application in library services and assesses its shortcomings. The study emphasizes the immediateness that new technologies offer to library services and how ChatGPT falls short of satisfying this demand because it relies on pre-existing data and lacks real-time interaction. The paper suggests that while ChatGPT can assist in basic inquiries, it cannot replace human interaction and expertise in addressing more complex questions and concerns. The study suggests that libraries should give preference to efficient and individualized service to better meet the demands of their patrons. The study provides valuable insights for libraries and other service organizations considering the implementation of chatbots or similar AI technologies.

Keywords

ChatGPT library services technology application shortcomings human interaction

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Amin

Razmi

(2009) Enhancing cataloging efficiency using natural language processing techniques. International Journal of Information Science and Management 7(1): 12–28.

Arvin

Kaiser

(2012) Adobe connect for virtual library instruction: A case study. Journal of Library & Information Services in Distance Learning 6(3-4): 271–283.

Arya

Mishra

(2011) Twitter: A new tool for academic libraries. Journal of Advancements in Library Sciences 1(2): 11–17.

Asemi

(2018) Intelligent library technologies: A review of knowledge-based assistance in library services. International Journal of Information Science and Management 16(2): 91–108.

Asemi

Nowkarizi

(2020) Application of Natural Language Processing in Library Cataloging: A Review. Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal), 3319.

Ayyadevara

(2018) Machine learning: Unveiling patterns in big data. Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research 15(1): 102–120.

Banerjee

(2022) The development of identification and reasoning skills in humans. Journal of Cognitive Development 17(1): 45–62.

Boman C (2019) An Exploration of Machine Learning in Libraries. Retrieved from: https://journals.ala.org/index.php/ltr/article/view/6911/9303.

Boukottaya

Mousli

(2018) Enhancing the online public access catalogue using semantic web technologies. International Journal of Computer Science and Information Security 16(4): 28–33.

10.

Bouma

de Vries

(2021) AI In natural language processing for library cataloguing and classification: Benefits, challenges, and examples. Library Hi Tech 39(3): 471–489.

11.

de Mello

Ponti

(2018) Introduction to machine learning: Understanding the basics. Journal of Data Science and Analytics 6(3): 189–204.

12.

Godfrey

(2008) Second life: A virtual world for libraries. Reference Services Review 36(4): 433–439.

13.

Grainger

Reisman

(2021) AI and machine learning in cataloguing audiovisual materials: Challenges and opportunities. Cataloging & Classification Quarterly 59(6): 522–541.

14.

Gujral

Smith

Johnson

Martin

Wilson

Davis

(2019) Chatbot applications in libraries: A literature review. International Journal of Information Science and Management 17(2): 87–102.

15.

Han

Chen

(2021) Assessing the use of ChatGPT for reference queries in libraries. Library Hi Tech 39(2): 325–339.

16.

Hao

Zhang

(2020) The ethical challenges of using AI in education. International Journal of Information and Education Technology 10(8): 575–580.

17.

Hussain

(2022) Transforming library services in the age of modern information technology. Journal of Library Innovation 14(3): 45–62.

18.

Kamal

Bhat

Wani

(2020) Role of academic libraries in providing personalized services in the era of the digital world. International Journal of Innovative Technology and Exploring Engineering 9(4S): 1067–1072.

19.

Kaser

(2021) CHATGPT For classification: Using a transformer-based language model for library materials. Journal of Library Automation 35(2): 101–115.

20.

Keller

(2015) Research support in Australian university libraries: An outsider view. Australian Academic & Research Libraries 46(2): 73–85.

21.

Khan

Mahmood

(2019) Linked data for library cataloguing: A review. International Journal of Computer Science and Information Security 17(9): 9–14.

22.

Kuhlthau

Tama

(2021) Understanding the use of ChatGPT in academic library reference services: A literature review and interviews with librarians. Reference & User Services Quarterly 61(1): 20–34.

23.

Kushwaha

(2020) Chatbot for digital libraries: A review of current research trends. Library Hi Tech News 37(7): 1–6.

24.

Chen

Wang

(2020) Using GPT-2 for metadata generation: Opportunities and challenges. International Journal of Digital Library Systems 9(1): 1–17.

25.

Libris

(2019) AI in Libraries: Using Artificial Intelligence to Improve Library Services. Retrieved from https://www.exlibrisgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/AI-in-Libraries-Whitepaper.pdf.

26.

Liu

Yang

(2019) Popular research topics in the recent journal publications of library and information science. The Journal of Academic Librarianship 45(3): 278–287.

27.

Liu

Xiong

(2020) Improving automatic subject indexing using natural language processing techniques. Journal of Library and Information Science 45(3): 201–216.

28.

Liu

Chen

Lee

Taylor

Harris

White

(2019) Application of natural language processing in library information management. Library and Information Service 63(3): 67–76.

29.

Luo

Mao

(2020) Exploring the application of natural language processing in subject heading generation. Journal of Information Science Theory and Practice 8(2): 29–46.

30.

Moghaddasi

Smith

Patel

Brown

Davis

Johnson

(2020) Artificial intelligence in libraries: A review of applications and implications. Library Hi Tech 38(4): 631–651.

31.

Mokhtar

Othman

Ahmad

(2020) Chatbot and its development in academic libraries. Journal of Information and Communication Technology 19(2): 123–140.

32.

Nagarhalli

Vaze

Rana

(2020) A review of current trends in the development of chatbot systems. In Proceedings of the 2020 6th International Conference on Advanced Computing and Communication Systems (ICACCS), Coimbatore, India, 6–7 March 2020; pp. 706–710.

33.

Okonkwo

Ade-Ibijola

(2021) Evaluating the ethical implications of using Chatbot systems in higher education. digiTAL 2021: 68.

34.

Ong

Lai

Chai

(2021) Library book classification using image recognition. Journal of Academic Librarianship 47(4): 102340.

35.

Opara

Theresa

AM-E

Aduke

(2023) ChatGPT for teaching, learning and research: Prospects and challenges. Glob Acad J Humanit Soc Sci 5(2): 33–40.

36.

Open

(2023) The evolution of cataloguing systems and the impact of shared databases. Library Technology Trends 45(3): 76–92.

37.

Pryor

Jones

Whyte

(Eds.) (2013) Delivering Research Data Management services: Fundamentals of Good Practice. London: Facet Publishing.

38.

Reference & User Services Association (2010) Guidelines for Implementing and Maintaining Virtual Reference Services.

39.

Rubin

Anderson

Green

Jones

Wilson

Lee

(2010) Human-computer interaction in library environments: A literature review. Library and Information Science Research 32(4): 220–231.

40.

Ruppel

Vecchione

(2012) Research made easy: User preferences for high-quality reference services. Reference & User Services Quarterly 51(2): 140–148.

41.

Saleh

(2019) Artificial intelligence: Understanding machine intelligence in contrast to natural intelligence. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning 7(1): 12–28.

42.

Sotudeh

(2021) AI in organizing and classifying library collections: Benefits, challenges, and examples. Journal of Academic Librarianship 47(3): 102352.

43.

Srinivasan

Dileep

Chandrasekaran

(2021) Application of image recognition and machine learning techniques for cataloging rare books. Journal of Academic Librarianship 47(3): 102311.

44.

Srinivasan

Srivastava

Dutta

(2021) Application of natural language processing in library cataloguing processes: A review of the literature. Library Hi Tech 39(2): 339–357.

45.

Taecharungroj

(2023) What can ChatGPT do?” analyzing early reactions to the innovative AI Chatbot on Twitter. Big Data and Cognitive Computing 7: 35.

46.

Vijayakumar

Vijan

(2011) The impact of artificial intelligence in library operations. Journal of Library Automation 27(2): 45–62.

47.

Walter

Lankes

(2015) Technology and paradigm shifts in libraries. Library Quarterly 85(1): 25–42.

48.

Wang

Liu

(2021) Exploring the use of ChatGPT for answering reference queries in libraries. Journal of Librarianship and Information Science 53(2): 530–545.

49.

Zhang

Liu

, et al. (2021) Exploring the feasibility and effectiveness of using ChatGPT in library reference services. Journal of Academic Librarianship 47(3): 102340.

50.

Sun

Zhang

(2021) A review of AI technology application in library cataloguing. Library Hi Tech 39(1): 12–25.

51.

Sanders

, et al. (2021) Chatbot for health care and oncology applications using artificial intelligence and machine learning: Systematic review. JMIR cancer 7(4): e27850.

52.

Yang

Dala

(2014) Virtual reference services: An emerging trend in academic libraries. Journal of Academic Librarianship 40(6): 602–609.

53.

Yang

Evans

(2019, November) Opportunities and challenges in using AI chatbots in higher education. In CEEL '19: Proceedings of the 2019 3rd International Conference on Education and E-Learning, November 2019 (Pages 79–83). https://doi.org/10.1145/3371647.3371659.

54.

Zeng

Qin

(2020) A review of semantic web technologies in digital libraries. Information Processing & Management 57(6): 102177.

55.

Zhang

Cui

(2021) Study on cataloguing and indexing of library materials based on GPT-2. Library and Information Service 65(8): 62–72.