Beyond early language unit provision: linguistic,developmental and behavioural outcomes

Abstract

This study examines a group of children who had attended language unit provision between the ages of 3;6 and 7 years. At follow-up the children were between 7;10 and 13;3 years (mean 9.9 years). Of the 24 children, five went into mainstream school, 12 went into a language unit within a mainstream junior school and seven went to special school provision when they transferred at the end of year 2. Comparisons are drawn between the three groups in five areas, general ability, speech and language ability, literacy, phonological processing ability and behaviour. As a whole, the group continued to perform relatively poorly on most tasks with 19 (79%) continuing to have significantly delayed language development, 15 (62%) delayed reading accuracy and 13 (54%) delayed reading comprehension. Between 10 and 15 were presenting with behaviour difficulties depending on whether their performance is reported by parents or teachers. With some notable exceptions the pattern of results indicated that those children who went straight into mainstream school performed better on all measures than those who either went into further language unit provision or those who went to special schools. However, the differences between the mainstream and language groups did not reach statistical significance for any of the tasks except the two rhyme sub-tests from the Phonological Assessment Battery. The results suggest that there may only be marginal differences (at least on the measures employed in the present study) between those attending units and those deemed to be able to manage in mainstream school. A sub-group (n = 5) was identified which was made up of those children whose language scores had effectively normalized, remained relatively similar to those children whose delays persisted except for the rotation task of the British Ability Scale and for their reading accuracy and spelling. The results are discussed in terms of service provision to children with this type of difficulty.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anthony, A. , Bogle, D. , Ingram, T. T. S. and McIssac, M. W. 1971: The Edinburgh articulation test. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone .

Beitchman, J. H. , Wilson, B. , Brownlie, E. B. , Walters, H. and Lancee W. 1996: Long term consistency in speech/language profiles 1: Developmental and Academic outcomes . Journal of American Academy of Child Psychiatry 35, 804-825 .

Bishop, D. V. M. and Adams, C. 1990: A prospective study of the relationship between specific language impairment, phonological disorders and reading retardation . Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 31, 1027-1050 .

Botting, N. , Conti-Ramsden, G. and Crutchley, A. 1997: Concordance between teacher/therapist opinion and formal language assessment scores in children with language impairment . European Journal of Disorders of Communication 32, 317-327 .

Botting, N. , Crutchley, A. and Conti-Ramsden, G. 1998: Educational transitions of 7-year-old children with SLI in language units: a longitudinal study . International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 33, 177-198 .

Bruges, A. 1988: The outcome of language unit placement: a survey in Avon 1987 . Educational Psychology in Practice 4, 85-90 .

Davison, F. M. and Howlin, P. 1997: A follow-up study of children attending a primary-age language unit . European Journal of Disorders of Communication 32, 19-36 .

Dockrell, J. , George, R. , Lindsay, G. and Roux, J. 1997: Problems in the identification and assessment of children with specific speech and language impairment . Educational Psychology in Practice 13, 29-38 .

Elliot, C. 1983: The British ability scales. Windsor: NFER Nelson .

10.

Frederickson, N. , Frith, U. and Reason, R. 1997: The phonological assessment battery, standardisation edition. Windsor: NFER Nelson .

11.

Frederickson, N. 1997: The British standardisation of the phonological assessment battery: initial findings from children with SpLD and children for whom English is an additional language . Paper presented to the 4th International Conference of the British Dyslexia Association, 1 April.

12.

Fundudis, T. , Kolvin, I. and Garside, R. F. 1979: Speech retarded and deaf children: their psychological development. London: Academic Press .

13.

Goodman, R. 1997: The strengths and difficulties questionnaire: a research note . Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 38, 581-586 .

14.

Haynes, C. and Naidoo, S. 1991: Children with specific speech and language impairment. Clinics in Developmental Medicine 119. Oxford: Blackwell .

15.

Joffe, B. S. , Doyle, J. and Penn, C. 1996: The persisting communication difficulties of ‘remediated’ language-impaired children . European Journal of Disorders of Communication 31, 369-386 .

16.

King, R. R. , Jones, C. and Lasky, E. 1982: In retrospect: a fifteen year follow-up report of speech-language-disordered children . Language, Speech and Hearing Services in Schools 13, 24-32 .

17.

McCartney, E. and van der Gaag, A. 1996: How shall we be judged? Speech and language therapists in educational settings . Child Language Teaching and Therapy 12, 3-3 .

18.

McRae, K. M. and Vickar, E. 1991: Simple developmental speech delay: a follow-up study . Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology 33, 868-874 .

19.

Rapin, I. , editor 1996: Preschool children with inadequate communication: developmental language disorder, autism low IQ. Oxford: MacKeith Press .

20.

Semel, E. , Wiig, E. H. and Secord, W. 1991: The clinical evaluation of language fundamentals - revised (CELF-UK). Sidcup: Psychological Corporation .

21.

Stern, L. M. , Connell, T. M. , Lee, M. and Greenwood, G. 1995: The Adelaide pre-school language unit: results of follow-up . Journal of Paediatric Child Health 31, 207-212 .

22.

Stevenson, J. and Richman, N. 1978: Behaviour, language and development in three year old children . Journal of Autism and Childhood Schizophrenia 8, 299-313 .

23.

Stone, E. 1992: A follow-up study of ex-pupils from a speech and language unit . Child, Language Teaching and Therapy 8, 285-313 .

24.

Stothard, S. E. , Snowling, M. J. , Bishop, D. V. M. , Chipchase, B. B. and Kaplan, C. A. 1998: Language impaired pre-schoolers: a follow-up into adolescence . Journal of Speech, Language and Hearing Disorders 41, 407-418 .

25.

Tomblin, J. B. , Smith, E. and Zhang, X. 1997: Epidemiology of specific language impairment: prenatal and peri-natal risk factors . Journal of Communication Disorders 30, 325-344 .

26.

Vincent, D. de la Mare M. 1989: The Macmillan individual reading analysis. Windsor: NFER Nelson .

27.

Wilson, J. 1993: Phonological awareness training: a new approach to phonics. London: Educational Psychology .

28.

Whitehurst, G. J. , Fischel, J. E. , Lonigan, C. J. , Valdez-Menchuria, M. C. , Arnold, D. S. and Smith, M. 1991: Treatment of early expressive language delay: if, when and how . Topics in Language Disorders 11, 55-68 .