The clinical practice of speech and language therapists with children with phonologically based speech sound disorders

Abstract

Children with speech sound disorders (SSD) represent a large number of speech and language therapists’ caseloads. The intervention with children who have SSD can involve different therapy approaches, and these may be articulatory or phonologically based. Some international studies reveal a widespread application of articulatory based approaches in children with different SSD. In Portugal no survey has been previously conducted about speech and language therapists (SLTs) practices when working with children with SSD, so it is still unknown how SLTs treat children with SSD. This study aims to explore the use of different intervention approaches of SLTs in Portugal, and to describe the approaches most frequently used in treating children who have phonologically based SSD. Data collection was conducted through a questionnaire available on the web platform Advanced Communication and Swallowing Assessment (ACSA; http://acsa.web.ua.pt), and data analysis was based on 88 responses, corresponding to 5% of the total Portuguese SLTs population. Results showed that the intervention approaches most used with children who have SSD are phonological awareness (97% of the participants), auditory discrimination (92%), meaningful minimal contrast therapy (75%) and parent-based work (58%). The great majority of SLTs combined several approaches in their intervention. There was also a high percentage of SLTs that used articulation based approaches, namely articulation work (31%) in cases of phonologically based disorders. Most (63%) SLTs used weekly interventions over a period of more than six months (51%).

The data presented here agrees with the results obtained in South African, UK and USA studies in terms of the approaches most frequently used in intervention with children who have phonologically based SSD. Regarding the frequency and duration of intervention, there is a discrepancy between the results obtained and what is commonly used across research. The characteristics described by the Portuguese SLTs for establishing the differential diagnosis of SSD do not always reflect the evidence available in recent literature. The findings presented in this article revealed the intervention approaches that SLTs currently use to treat children with phonologically based SSD and the theoretical foundations that guide their clinical practice. This allows the reader to compare clinical practice of SLTs across countries and research studies.

Keywords

Speech sound disorders phonological disorder articulation disorder clinical practice intervention approaches speech and language therapy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ASHA (2000) Communication facts. Rockville, MD: American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA).

Baker

McLeod

(2011) Evidence-based practice for children with speech sound disorders: Part 1 narrative review. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 42: 102–39.

Baptista

(2009) Prova de Avaliação de Capacidades Articulatórias [Articulation assessment test]. Coimbra: Grácio Editor.

Beaton

Bombardier

Guillemin

Ferraz

(1998) Recommendations for the cross-cultural adaptation of health status measures. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, Institute for Work and Health.

Berry

Eisenson

(1956) Speech disorders: Principles and practices of therapy. London: Peter Owen.

Bowen

(2009) Children’s speech sound disorders. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

Breakwell

Hammond

Schaw

Smith

(eds) (2006) Research methods in psychology. 3rd edition. London: Sage.

Broomfield

Dodd

(2004) The nature of referred subtypes of primary speech disability. Child Language Teaching and Therapy 20: 135–51.

Costa

(2008) Perturbações da linguagem na criança: caracterização e retrato-tipo [Language disorders in children: Characterisation and typical cases]. Unpublished M.Sc. Thesis, University of Aveiro, Portugal.

10.

De Renzi

Vignolo

(1962) The token test: A sensitive test to detect receptive disturbances in aphasics. Brain 85: 665–78.

11.

Dodd

(2005) Differential diagnosis and treatment of children with speech disorder. 2nd edition. London: Whurr.

12.

Dodd

Bradford

(2000) A comparison of three therapy methods for children with different types of developmental phonological disorders. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 35: 189–209.

13.

Dodd

Iacono

(1989) Phonological disorders in children: Changes in phonological process use during treatment. British Journal of Disorders of Communication 24: 333–51.

14.

Dodd

Holm

Hua

Crosbie

(2003) Phonological development: A normative study of British English-speaking children. Clinical Linguistics and Phonetics 17: 617–43.

15.

Gee

(1992) The social mind: Language, ideology, and social practice. New York: Bergin and Garvey.

16.

Geisinger

(1994) Cross-cultural normative assessment: Translation and adaptation issues influencing the normative interpretation of assessment instruments. Psychological Assessment 6: 304–12.

17.

Gierut

(1990) Differential learning of phonological oppositions. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 33: 540–49.

18.

Gillon

(2000) The efficacy of phonological awareness intervention for children with spoken language impairment. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 31: 126–41.

19.

Guillemin

Bombardier

Beaton

(1993) Cross-cultural adaptation of health-related quality of life measures: Literature review and proposed guidelines. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 46: 1417–32.

20.

Guimarães

(1995) Protocolo de Avaliação Orofacial [Orofacial assessment protocol]. Lisboa: Fisiopraxis.

21.

Guimarães

Grilo

(1996). Curso teórico-prático sobre articulação verbal [A course in articulation]. Lisboa: Fisiopraxis.

22.

Hodson

Paden

(1991) Targeting intelligible speech: A phonological approach to remediation. San Diego, CA: College-Hill Press.

23.

Hoffman

Norris

Monjure

(1990) Comparison of process targeting and whole language treatments for phonologically delayed preschool children. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 21: 102–09.

24.

Howell

Dean

(1991) Teaching phonological disorders in children: Metaphon - theory to practice. London: Whurr.

25.

Hutchinson

Bentzen

Konig-Zahn

(1997) Cross cultural health outcome assessment: A user’s guide. Ruinen: European Research Group on Health Outcomes.

26.

Joffe

Pring

(2008) Children with phonological problems: a survey of clinical practice. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 43: 154–64.

27.

Kamhi

(2006a) Prologue: Combining research and reason to make treatment decisions. Language Speech and Hearing Services in Schools 37: 255–57.

28.

Kamhi

(2006b) Treatment decisions for children with speech–sound disorders. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools 37: 271–79.

29.

Kay

Santos

(2003) Grelha de Observação da Linguagem: Nível Escolar [Language checklist: School level]. Alcoitão: Escola Superior de Saúde do Alcoitão.

30.

Kay

Tavares

(2008) Teste de avaliação da linguagem na criança [Language test for children]. 5th edition. Lisboa: Oficina Didáctica.

31.

Kerlinger

Lee

(2000) Foundations of behavioral research. Orlando: Wadsworth and Thomson.

32.

Lancaster

Pope

Martin

(2003) Working with children’s phonology. Telford Road: Speechmark.

33.

Lancaster

Keusch

Levin

Pring

Martin

(2010) Treating children with phonological problems: Does an eclectic approach to therapy work? International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 45: 174–81.

34.

Lousada

Mendes

Valente

Hall

(2012) Standardization of a Phonetic-Phonological Test for European Portuguese Children. Folia Phoniatrica et Logopaedica 64: 151–56.

35.

Lousada

Jesus

LMT

Capelas

Margaça

Simões

Valente

. (2013) Phonological and articulation treatment approaches in Portuguese children with speech and language impairments: A randomized controlled intervention study. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 48: 172–87.

36.

Lousada

Jesus

LMT

Hall

Joffe

(2014) Intelligibility as a clinical outcome measure following intervention with children with phonologically-based speech sound disorders. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders. doi:10.1111/1460–6984.12095

37.

McLeod

Harrison

(2009) Epidemiology of speech and language impairment in a nationally representative sample of 4- to 5-year-old children. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 52: 1213–29.

38.

Mendes

Afonso

Lousada

Andrade

(2013) Teste fonético–fonológico ALPE (TFF-ALPE) [Phonetic–phonological Test ALPE (TFF-ALPE)] (Edubox). Aveiro.

39.

NDP (2004) Nuffield Centre Dyspraxia Programme NDP3. London: The Nuffield Hearing and Speech Centre, Royal National Throat Nose and Ear Hospital.

40.

Oetter

Richter

Frick

(1993) M.O.R.E.: Integrating the mouth with sensory and postural functions. PDP Press.

41.

Pappas

(2009) The australian experience of family-centred practice in intervention for speech impairment. In: Bowen

(ed.) Children’s speech sound disorders. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 157–60.

42.

Pascoe

Maphalala

Ebrahim

Hime

Mdladla

Mohamed

Skinner

(2010) Children with speech difficulties: A survey of clinical practice in the Western Cape. South African Journal of Communication Disorders 57: 66–75.

43.

Passey

(1990) Cued articulation. Melbourne: ACER.

44.

Peter

(2011) Critical review: In children with phonological/articulation disorders, do non-speech oral motor exercises improve speech production compared to direct speech therapy? Unpublished article, School of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Western Ontario, Ontario, Canada.

45.

Shriberg

(2003) Diagnostic markers for child speech–sound disorders: Introductory comments. Clinical Linguistics and Phonetics 17: 501–05.

46.

Silva

Peixoto

(2008) Rastreio e prevalência das perturbações da comunicação num agrupamento de escolas [Screening and prevalence of communication disorders in a group of schools]. Revista Da Faculdade de Ciências Da Saúde 5: 272–82.

47.

Skahan

Watson

Lof

(2007) Speech-language pathologists’ assessment practices for children with suspected speech sound disorders: Results of a national survey. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology / American Speech-Language-Hearing Association 16: 246–59.

48.

Smit

(2004) Articulation and phonology: Resource guide for school-age children and adults. Clifton Park: Thomson Learning.

49.

Torgesen

Wagner

Rashotte

(1994) Longitudinal studies of phonological processing and reading. Journal of Learning Disabilities 27: 276–86.

50.

Van Riper

Emerick

(1984) Speech correction: An introduction to speech pathology and audiology. 7th edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall .

51.

Waring

Knight

(2013) How should children with speech sound disorders be classified? A review and critical evaluation of current classification systems. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders 48: 25–40.

52.

Weiner

(1981) Treatment of phonological disability using the method of meaningful contrast: Two case studies. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders 46: 97–103.