Accessibility of Shared Space for visually impaired persons: An inventory in the Netherlands

Abstract

Shared Space is a concept that comprises the design and planning process of a public space. There are concerns about the accessibility of Shared Spaces for people who are visually impaired. This study provides a systematic overview of the appearance of Shared Spaces in the Netherlands and the consequences that these spaces may have for the independent mobility of visually impaired persons. Environmental characteristics of ten typical Shared-Space locations in the Netherlands were registered. The level of hindrance that these characteristics could cause visually impaired users of these spaces was judged by a group of experts in the field of orientation and mobility. In addition, compliance of the selected locations with existing guidelines for accessibility was assessed. None of the selected Shared-Space locations were free of potential problems for visually impaired persons.

Keywords

Accessibility navigation orientation and mobility public realm shared space visual impairment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Childs

C. R.

Boampong

D. K.

Rostron

Morgan

Eccleshall

Tyler

(2009). Effective kerb heights for blind and partially sighted people (Research report). London, UK: Accessibility Research Group, University College London.

Childs

C. R.

Fujiyama

Boampong

D. K.

Holloway

Rostron

Morgan

Tyler

(2010). Shared Space delineators: Are they detectable? (Research report). London, UK: Accessibility Research Group, University College London.

CROW (Technology platform for transport, infrastructure and public space) (2002). Richtlijn integrale toegankelijkheid openbare ruimte [Guidance Inclusive Accessibility Public Space]. Ede, the Netherlands: CROW.

Department for Transport (2007). Manual for Streets. London, UK: Thomas Telford Publishing.

Department for Transport (2011). Local Transport Note 1/11. Shared Space. London, UK: TSO. Retrieved from http://www.dft.gov.uk/publications/ltn-01-11.

Gesamtverband der Deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft e.V. (2011). Gemeinschaftsstraßen – Attraktiv und sicher. Berlin, Germany: GDV e.V.

Hamilton-Baillie

(2008) Towards Shared Space. Urban Design, 13, 130–138.

Hamilton-Baillie

Jones

(2005). Improving traffic behaviour and safety through urban design. Civil Engineering, 158, 39–47.

Imrie

Kumar

(2011) Shared Space and sight loss: Policies and practices in English local authorities. London, UK: Thomas Pocklington Trust.

10.

Joint Technical Committee on Environment and Transport (2008). Minimum requirements for designing mixed traffic spaces based on the “Shared Space” concept. Berlin, Germany: GFUV. Retrieved from http://www.dbsv.org/fileadmin/dbsvupload/Worddateien/GFUV/Shared_space_requirement_paper.pdf

11.

Keuning Instituut & Senza Communicatie (2005). Shared Space: Room for everyone: A new vision for public spaces (A publication in the framework of the Interreg IIIB project “Shared Space”). Groningen, the Netherlands: PlantijnCasparie.

12.

Limburg

(2007). Epidemiologie van Visuele Beperkingen en een Demografische Verkenning [Epidemiology of Visual Impairment in The Netherlands]. The Hague, the Netherlands: The Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development (ZonMW/Inzicht). Retrieved from: http://www.vision2020.nl/contents/InZicht_rapport.pdf

13.

Ramboll Nyvig (2007). Shared Space > Safe Space: Meeting the requirements of blind and partially sighted people (Research report). Reading, UK: The Guide Dogs for the Blind Association.

14.

Reid

Kocak

Hunt

(2009). DfT Shared Space Project, Stage 1: Appraisal of Shared Space. London, UK: Department for Transport. Retrieved from http://assets.dft.gov.uk/publications/shared-space-appraisal/dft-shared-space-project-stage-1.pdf

15.

The Guide Dogs for the Blind Association (2009). Guide dogs take legal action against the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea Council. Retrieved from http://www.guidedogs.org.uk/news/2009/guide-dogs-takes-legal-action-against-the-royal-borough-of-kensington-and-chelsea-council/

16.

The Guide Dogs for the Blind Association (2010). Shared surface streets perceived as “no go” areas by blind and partially sighted people says new National Survey. Retrieved from http://www.guidedogs.org.uk/news/2010/shared-surface-streets-perceived-as-no-go-areas-by-blind-and-partially-sighted-people-says-new-national-survey/

17.

The Royal Dutch Guide Dog Foundation (2009). Shared Space, Samen Delen? [Shared Space, Sharing Together?] Ten Geleide, 96, 4–5.

18.

Thomas

(2011). Briefing: Minimum effective kerb height for blind and partially sighted people. Proceedings of the ICE – Municipal Engineer, 164(1), 11–12.

19.

TNS-BMRB (2010). The impact of shared surface streets and shared use pedestrian/cycle paths on the mobility and independence of blind and partially sighted people (Report JN:197369). Retrieved from www.guidedogs.org.uk/sharedstreets

20.

Van Lier

(2008). De wereld van Toegankelijkheid [The World of Accessibility]. Utrecht, the Netherlands: Vilans.

21.

Van Veen

(2011). Ontwerpoplossingen voor Blinden en Slechtzienden [Design Solutions for the Blind and Partially Sighted]. Presented at 2nd Shared Space Symposium at Royal Dutch Visio, Huizen, September.

22.

Wijk

(2008). Handboek voor Toegankelijkheid. Over de Ergonomie van Buitenruimten, Gebouwen en Woningen [Accessibility Manual. On the Ergonomics of Outside Spaces, Buildings and Residences]. Doetinchem, the Netherlands: Reed Business.