Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2025-6
A practitioner's response to Tidmarsh and Uche's article: ‘A Professional Register for Probation Practitioners in England and Wales: Opportunities and Challenges’
Tidmarsh and Uche detail three broad opportunities for professional registration (i.e. increasing confidence in probation, professional identity and values, and enhancing continuous professional development frameworks) and three challenges for professional registration (i.e. organisational readiness, unnecessary bureaucracy, and an imbalance of scrutiny). This practitioner response analyses how the imposition of the probation professional register, and its accompanying policy framework, bring risks to the organisational culture of the probation service that ought to be considered. Furthermore, there are wider needs that the service must overcome to maximise the effectiveness of the register and for staff to buy-in. Despite these risks and needs, there are also many strengths associated with professional registration. Although the Probation Professional Registration Policy Framework has now been implemented, it is still in its infancy. This discussion comes at a time when the organisation itself is still establishing internal structures to support the rollout and so encouraging staff to buy-in to the new policy framework is essential.
BurkeLMillingsMRobinsonG (2017) Probation migration(s): Examining occupational culture in a turbulent field. Criminology & Criminal Justice17(2): 192–208.
2.
CantonR (2013) The point of probation: On effectiveness, human rights and the virtues of obliquity. Criminology & Criminal Justice13(5): 577–593.
3.
CantonR (2024) Probation as social work. Probation Journal71(3): 214–233.
4.
DawsonP (2024) Potential Unlocked: Building a Sustainable Prison Workforce. London: Prison Reform Trust.
5.
DeeringJFeilzerM (2017) Questions of legitimacy in probation practice after transforming rehabilitation. The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice56(2): 158–175.
6.
DomineyJCantonR (2022) Probation and the ethics of care. Probation Journal69(4): 417–433.
7.
FlynnS (2024) Implementing the probation professional register – Opportunities and challenges. A Professional Register for Probation Practitioners: Opportunities and Challenges Conference, 2 February, University of Leeds.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) (2019) Report of the chief inspector. HMIP. Available at: Report of the Chief Inspector of Probation (accessed 16 December 2024).
10.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) (2021a) Caseloads, workloads and staffing levels in probation services. HMIP. Available at: Caseloads, workloads and staffing levels in probation services (accessed 14 December 2024).
11.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) (2021b) Race equality in probation: The experiences of black, Asian and minority ethnic probation service users and staff. HMIP. Available at: Race equality in probation: the experiences of Black, Asian and minority ethnic probation service users and staff (accessed 25 March 2025).
12.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) (2024) The role of the senior probation officer and management oversight in the Probation Service. HMIP. Available at: The role of the senior probation officer and management oversight in the probation service (accessed 14 December 2024).
13.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) (2025a) Annual report 2024: Inspection of probation services. HMIP. Available at: Annual report 2024: Inspection of probation services – HM inspectorate of probation (accessed 25 March 2025).
14.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (HMIP) (2025b) A thematic inspection of the recruitment, training, and retention of frontline probation practitioners. HMIP. Available at: A thematic inspection of the recruitment, training and retention of frontline probation practitioners (accessed 25 March 2025).
15.
HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) (2024) A thematic inspection on the role of the senior probation officer & management oversight in the probation service. GOV.UK. Available at: A thematic inspection on the role of the senior probation officer & management oversight in the probation service – GOV.UK (accessed 4 January 2025).
16.
MillingsMBurkeLAnnisonH, et al. (2023) A necessary but painful journey: Experiences of unification in a probation service region. Probation Journal 70(4): 1–19.
17.
Ministry of Justice (MOJ) (2024) Probation Professional Register Policy Framework. London: HMSO.
18.
O'FlynnB (2024) The probation service has been working over capacity every month since January 2023. 4 News. Available at: FactCheck: The probation service has been working over capacity every month since January 2023 – Channel 4 News (accessed 14 December 2024).
19.
O’RourkeM (2024) Professional registration in social care, Northern Ireland. A professional register for probation practitioners: Opportunities and challenges conference, 2 February 2024, University of Leeds.
20.
PhillipsJ (2011) Target, audit and risk assessment cultures in the probation service. European Journal of Probation3(3): 108–122.
21.
PhillipsJ (2021) An analysis of inspection in probation and its impact on practitioners, practice and providers. Probation Journal70(2): 124–142.
22.
PhillipsJWestabyCFowlerA (2020) Emotional labour in probation. HMIP. Available at: Emotional labour in probation (accessed 14 December 2024).
23.
Probation Institute (PI) (2021) Review of potential requirements for regulation and registration for practice in probation, rehabilitation and resettlement. Probation Institute. Available at: Microsoft Word – Report on Regulation of Probation.docx (accessed 2 January 2025).
24.
Probation Institute (PI) (2024) Professionalism and probation: Probation Institute position paper 1/24. Probation Institute. Available at: Position Paper released – Professionalism and Probation—Probation Institute (accessed 3 January 2025).
25.
RaynorP (2019) Supervision skills for probation practitioners. HMIP. Available at: Academic-Insights-Raynor.pdf (accessed 30 December 2024).
26.
RicciardelliRMaierKNormanM (2023) “You have to be really careful, in this environment, of what you say and what you do”: A qualitative examination of how organizational culture shapes parole officers’ work and well-being. Probation Journal70(4): 385–405.
27.
SchofieldH (2025) Probation professional register: A serious challenge. Probation Institute. Available at: PQ35 (accessed 25 March 2025).
28.
Social Work England (SWE) (2024) Registration fees. Social Work England. Available at: Registration fees – Social Work England (accessed 4 January 2025).
29.
StubbsLPearceL (2022) Probation services officer progression pilot: Findings from a process evaluation. MOJ. Available at: Probation services officer progression pilot: A process evaluation – GOV.UK (accessed 11 December 2024).
TidmarshMUcheSCO (2025) A professional register for probation practitioners in England and Wales: Opportunities and challenges. Probation Journal1–19.
33.
WorrallAMawbyR (2013) Probation workers responses to turbulent conditions: Constructing identity in a tainted occupation. Journal of Criminology46(1): 101–118.
