Since the so-called ‘refugee crisis’, research on migration in the Euro-Mediterranean region has highlighted the entanglement of humanitarian and securitarian logics in the transformation of the EU border regime, with most attention focused on rescue and push-back operations at sea and systems of detention, selection and reception on land. This article moves beyond the point of arrival to examine how humanitarianism has also been implicated in the management of migrant labour in agriculture. Focusing on the tomato districts of southern Italy, the article interrogates the recent legislative and emergency measures devised to tackle labour violations and to facilitate the reproduction of the workforce. Measures have included the establishment of impromptu worker shelters run by humanitarian organizations and the recourse to criminal law to combat gangmasters and to assuage public opinion. By developing the conceptual framework of humanitarian exploitation, the article illustrates how humanitarian government is functional both to the regulation of the migrant workforce and to the maintenance of the industrial agri-food system.
Altro Diritto/FLAI CGIL (2022) Laboratorio sullo sfruttamento lavorativo: Inchiesta in corso di analisi al 2021. Available at: http://www.adir.unifi.it/laboratorio/tabella.htm (accessed 27 July 2022).
4.
AnselmiM (2018) Populism: An Introduction.
Abingdon:
Routledge.
5.
AvalloneG (2017) The land of informal intermediation: The social regulation of migrant agricultural labour in the Piana del Sele, Italy. In: CorradoADe CastroCPerrottaD (eds) Migration and Agriculture: Mobility and Change in the Mediterranean Area.
Abingdon:
Routledge, pp. 217–230.
6.
BagnardiFD’OnofrioGGrecoL (2022)
The state in chains: Public policies against adverse incorporation in Southern Italian production networks. Globalizations 19(1): 34–58.
7.
BergerJMohrJ (1975) The Seventh Man.
Harmondsworth:
Penguin.
8.
BoggACollinsJFreedlandMHerringJ (eds) (2020) Criminality at Work.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
CampesiG (2015)
Humanitarian confinement: An ethnography of reception centres for asylum seekers at Europe’s southern border. International Journal of Migration and Border Studies1(4): 398–418.
CaprioglioCRigoE (2020)
Lavoro, politiche migratorie e sfruttamento: la condizione dei braccianti migranti in agricoltura. Diritto, Immigrazione e Cittadinanza22(3): 33–56.
14.
CarusoFCorradoA (eds) (2021) Essenziali ma Invisibili: analisi Delle Politiche e Delle Iniziative di Contrasto Allo Sfruttamento e per L’inclusione Dei Lavoratori Migranti in Agricoltura Nel Sud Italia.
Turin:
Rosenberg & Seller.
Dal ZottoELo CascioMPiroV (2021) The emergency management of migration and agricultural workforce during the pandemic: The contradictory outcomes of the 2020 amnesty law. In: Della PuppaFSpanòG (eds) Stuck and Exploited: Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Italy Between Exclusion, Discrimination and Struggles, pp.321–342.
Venice:
Edizioni Ca’ Foscari.
20.
Di MartinoA (2020) Sfruttamento Del Lavoro: Il Valore Del Contesto Nella Definizione Del Reato.
Bologna:
il Mulino.
21.
DinesN (2013)
Bad news from an aberrant city: a critical analysis of the British press’s portrayal of organised crime and the rubbish crisis in Naples. Modern Italy18(4): 409–422. 10.1080/13532944.2013.801677
22.
Dines N (2018) Humanitarian reason and the representation and management of migrant agricultural labour. Theomai: Estudios Críticos sobre Sociedad y Desarrollo 38: 37–53.
23.
DinesNRigoE (2015) Postcolonial citizenships and the ‘refugeeization’ of the workforce: Migrant agricultural labor in the Italian Mezzogiorno. In: PonzanesiSColpaniG (eds) Postcolonial Transitions in Europe: Contexts, Practices and Politics,
Lanham MD:
Rowman and Littlefield.
24.
FassinD (2012) Humanitarian Reason: A Moral History of the Present.
Berkeley:
University of California Press.
25.
FassinD (2013)
The predicament of humanitarianism. Qui Parle22(1): 33–48.
GargiuloE (2021) Invisible Borders: Administrative Barriers and Citizenship in the Italian Municipalities.
Cham:
Palgrave MacMillan.
29.
GarrapaAM (2017) The citrus fruit crisis: Value chains and ‘just in time’ migrants in Rosarno (Italy) and Valencia (Spain). In: CorradoADe CastroCPerrottaD (eds) Migration and Agriculture: Mobility and Change in the Mediterranean Area.
Abingdon:
Routledge, pp. 111–127.
HowardNForinR (2019)
Migrant workers, ‘modern slavery’ and the politics of representation in Italian tomato production. Economy and Society48(4): 579–601.
LewisHDwyerPHodkinsonS, et al. (2015)
Hyper-precarious lives: Migrants, work and forced labour in the Global North. Progress in Human Geography39(5): 580–600.
36.
MaaroufiM (2017)
Precarious integration: Labour market policies for refugees or refugee policies for the German labour market. Refugee Review3: 15–33.
Medici Senza Frontiere (2005) I Frutti Dell’ipocrisia: Storia di Chi L’agricoltura la fa. Di Nascosto.
Rome:
Sinnos.
39.
MEDU (Medici per i Diritti Umani) (2015) Terraingiusta. Rapporto sulle condizioni di vita e di lavoro dei braccianti stranieri in agricoltura. Available at: http://www.mediciperidirittiumani.org/pdf/Terraingiusta.pdf (accessed 27 July 2022).
Molinero-GerbeauY (2021)
The problem is not Covid-19, it’s the model! Industrial agriculture and migrant farm labour in the EU. EuroChoices20(3): 69–74.
45.
Moulier BoutangY (1998) De L’esclavage au Salariat: Économie Historique du Salariat Bridé.
Paris:
Presses Universitaires de France.
46.
OliveriF (2015) Giuridificare ed esternalizzare lo sfruttamento. Il caso dei lavoratori immigrati nella vitivinicoltura senese. In: RigoE (ed.) Leggi, Migranti e Caporali. Prospettive Critiche e di Ricerca Sullo Sfruttamento Del Lavoro in Agricoltura.
Pisa:
Pacini, pp. 47–67.
47.
OrsiniGSergeA, (2018) The emergency business. Migrants’ reception, mafia interests and glocal governance: from Lampedusa to Rome. In: van DuyneP, et al. (eds) The Janus-Faces of Cross-Border Crime in Europe. The Hague: Eleven International, pp. 49–72.
48.
Pallister-WilkinsP (2020)
Hotspots and the geographies of humanitarianism. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space38(6): 991–1008.
PascucciE (2019)
The local labour building the international community: Precarious work within humanitarian spaces. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space51(3): 743–760.
51.
PerrottaD (2017) Processing tomatoes in the era of the retailing revolution: Mechanization and migrant labour in northern and southern Italy. In: CorradoADe CastroCPerrottaD (eds) Migration and Agriculture: Mobility and Change in the Mediterranean Area.
Abingdon:
Routledge, pp. 58–75.
52.
PerrottaDRaeymaekersT (2022)
Caporalato capitalism. Labour brokerage and agrarian change in a Mediterranean society. The Journal of Peasant Studies : 1–22. https://doi.org/10.1080/03066150.2022.2072213
53.
PerrottaDSacchettoD (2014)
Migrant farmworkers in Southern Italy: Forms of mobility and resistance. International Journal on Strikes and Social Conflicts1(5): 75–98.
54.
PrattJ (2007) Penal Populism.
London:
Routledge.
55.
RaeymaekersT (2023) Liminal City: Extractive Urbanism and Migrant Labour in the Black Mediterranean.
Ithaca NY:
Cornell University Press.
56.
Reid-HenrySM (2014)
Humanitarianism as liberal diagnostic: Humanitarian reason and the political rationalities of the liberal will-to-care. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers39(3): 418–431.
57.
RigoE (2015) Introduzione: Lo sfruttamento come modo di produzione. In: Rigo E (ed.) Leggi, migranti e caporali. Prospettive critiche e di ricerca sullo sfruttamento del lavoro in agricoltura. Pisa: Pacini, pp. 5–14.
58.
SavianoR (2006) Gomorra: Viaggio Dell’impero Economico e Nel Sogno di Dominio Della Camorra.
Milan:
Mondadori.
59.
TorreV (2018)
Il diritto penale e la filiera dello sfruttamento. Giornale di Diritto Del Lavoro e di Relazioni Industriali158: 289–320.
60.
WaltersW (2011) Foucault and frontiers: Notes on the birth of the humanitarian border. In: BröcklingUKrasmannSLemkeT (eds) Governmentality: Current Issues and Future Challenges.
New York:
Routledge, pp. 138–164.
