The politics of evidence-based policy: A comparative analysis of climate adaptation in Australia and the UK

Abstract

This paper presents a comparative analysis of the use of climate science for adaptation policy in Queensland, Australia and the UK. We examine policy players’ perceptions of climate science alongside prevailing political influences on evidence-based policy making. In Queensland, the evidence-based mandate has been weakened by partisan politics so that the political acceptability of evidence is a foremost concern for policy makers. In the UK, the evidence-based mandate is enshrined in the Climate Change Act (2008), yet here too political forces have sought to limit the acceptable use of climate science for policy making. Both cases reveal normative and political tensions in the interpretation and use of climate science, suggesting that important political challenges must be overcome by the scientific community to ensure the ongoing utility of climate science for policy making.

Keywords

Evidence-based policy climate adaptation politics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

Bows

Mander

(2008) From long-term targets to cumulative emissions pathways: Reframing UK climate policy. Energy Policy 36: 3714–3722.

Australian Government (2014) Understanding Climate Change. Department of Environment website. Available at: http://www.climatechange.gov.au/climate-change/climate-science/understanding-climate-change (accessed 29 July 2014).

Bell

(2006) Concerned scientists, pragmatic politics and Australia’s green drought. Science and Public Policy 33(8): 561–570.

Benedick

(2001) Striking a new deal on climate change. Issues in Science and Technology 18(1): 71–77.

Bourke L (2014) Climate change measures like ‘primitive civilisations offering up sacrifices to appease the gods’, says Maurice Newman. The Sydney Morning Herald, 14 August 2014. Available at: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/climate-change-measures-like-primitive-civilisations-offering-up-sacrifices-to-appease-the-gods-says-maurice-newman-20140814-3do0v.html (accessed 15 August 2014).

Carrington D (2014) Climate change will make UK weather too wet and too dry, says Met Office. The Guardian, 26 March 2014. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/mar/25/climate-change-uk-weather-wet-dry-met-office (accessed 12 September 2014).

Cash D, Clark W, Alcock F, et al. (2002) Salience, Credibility, Legitimacy and Boundaries: Linking Research, Assessment and Decision Making. John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Faculty Research Working Papers Series, November 2002. Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=372280 (accessed 13 August 2015).

Cash

Clark

Alcock

(2003) Knowledge systems for sustainable development. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 100(14): 8086–8091.

Christoff

(2008) Aiming high: On Australia’s emissions reductions targets. UNSW Law Journal 31(3): 861–879.

10.

Crowley K and Walker KJ (eds) (2012) Environmental Policy Failure: The Australian Story. Prahran VIC, Australia: Tilde University Press.

11.

CSIRO (2011) South East Queensland Climate Adaptation Research Initiative. Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation. Available at: http://www.csiro.au/partnerships/seqcari (accessed 16 August 2013).

12.

CSIRO (2013) “OzClim”, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation. Available at: http://www.csiro.au/ozclim/home.do (accessed 15 September 2014).

13.

Curran

(2011) Modernising climate policy in Australia: Climate narratives and the undoing of a Prime Minister. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 29: 1004–1017.

14.

Curry J (2013) Consensus distorts the climate picture. The Australian, 21 September 2013. Available at: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/opinion/consensus-distorts-the-climate-picture/story-e6frg6zo-1226724019428 (accessed 13 August 2015).

15.

Davoudi

(2006) The evidence—Policy interface in strategic waste planning for urban environments: The ‘technical’ and ‘social’ dimensions. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 24(5): 681–700.

16.

DEFRA (2010) National Indicator 188: Adapting to climate change. Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, 6 April 2010. Available at: http://archive.defra.gov.uk/corporate/about/with/localgov/indicators/ni188.htm (accessed 28 October 2013).

17.

DEFRA (2012) UK Climate Change Risk Assessment: Government Report. HM Government Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Available at: http://www.defra.gov.uk/publications/files/pb13698-climate-risk-assessment.pdf (accessed 6 May 2013).

18.

DEFRA (2013) The National Adaptation Programme—Making the Country Resilient to Changing Climate, London, UK: HMSO. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/209866/pb13942-nap-20130701.pdf (accessed on 13 August 2015).

19.

DEFRA (2014) Adapting to Climate Change. HM Government 2014. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/policies/adapting-to-climate-change (accessed 21 July 2014).

20.

Department of Business Innovation and Skills (2011) Impact Assessment Template for Government Policies. UK Government website. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/impact-assessment-template-for-government-policies (accessed 29 July 2014).

21.

Devine M (2002) Drought relief sceptics must be hung out to dry. The Sun-Herald, 13 October 2002. Available at: http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/10/12/1034222635512.html (accessed 2 August 2013).

22.

Dilling

Lemos

(2011) Creating usable science: Opportunities and constraints for climate knowledge use and their implications for science policy. Global Environmental Change 21: 680–689.

23.

Dovers

(2000) Environmental History and Policy: Still Settling Australia, Melbourne, Australia: Oxford University Press.

24.

Driedger

Eyles

(2003) Charting uncertainty in science-policy discourses: The construction of the chlorinated drinking water issue and cancer. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 21(3): 429–444.

25.

Environment Agency [EA] (2010) Managing the Environment in a Changing Climate. The Environment Agency of England & Wales. Available at: http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/research/library/publications/130528.aspx (accessed 29 July 2014).

26.

Frigg R, Bradley S, Du H, et al. (2013a) Laplace’s Demon and Climate Change. Centre for Climate Change Economics and Policy Working Paper No. 121, Grantham Research Institute on Climate and the Environment. Available at: http://seamusbradley.nfshost.com/Papers/demon-grantham.pdf (accessed 14 May 2013).

27.

Frigg

Smith

Stainforth

(2013b) The myopia of imperfect climate models: The case of UKCP09. Philosophy of Science 80: 886–897.

28.

Garner

(2000) Environmental Politics—Britain, Europe and the Global Environment—2nd Edition, London: Macmillan Press.

29.

Granger K and Haynes M (2001) Natural hazards and the risks they pose to South-East Queensland. Australian Geological Survey Organisation—Geoscience Australia. Commonwealth of Australia. Available at: http://www.ga.gov.au/image_cache/GA4218.pdf (accessed 19 September 2014).

30.

Gray TS (1997) Politics and the environment in the UK and beyond. In: Redclift M and Woodgate G (eds) The International Handbook of Environmental Sociology. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 287–299.

31.

Grubb

(2002) Britannia waives the rules: The UK, the EU and climate change. New Economy 9(3): 139–142.

32.

Guston

(2001) Boundary organizations in environmental policy and science: An introduction. Science, Technology & Human Values 26: 299–408.

33.

Hajer

(1995) The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernisation and the Policy Process, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

34.

Head

(2008) Three lenses of evidence-based policy. Australian Journal of Public Administration 67(1): 1–11.

35.

Head

(2014) Evidence, uncertainty, and wicked problems in climate change decision making in Australia. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 32(4): 663–679.

36.

Heazle

Tangney

Burton

(2013) Mainstreaming climate change adaptation: An incremental approach to disaster risk management in Australia. Environmental Science & Policy 33: 162–170.

37.

Hennessy

Fitzharris

Bates

(2007) Australia and New Zealand. In: Parry

Canziani

Palutikof

(eds) Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 507–540.

38.

HM Government (2008) The Climate Change Act 2008. Available at: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2008/27/pdfs/ukpga_20080027_en.pdf (accessed 9 September 2012).

39.

Howes

(2005) Politics and the Environment: Risk and the Role of Government and Industry, London: Earthscan.

40.

Howes

Dedekorkut-Howes

(2012) Climate adaptation and the Australian system of government: The gold coast example. In: Crowley

Walker

(eds) Environmental Policy Failure? Learning from Australian Studies, Melbourne: Tilde University Press, Chapter 9, pp. 116–130.

41.

Howes M, Tangney P, Reis K, et al. (2014) Towards Networked Governance: Improving interagency communication and collaboration for disaster risk management and climate change adaptation in Australia. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 58(5): 757–776.

42.

Hulme

Dessai

(2008) Negotiating future climates for public policy: A critical assessment of the development of climate scenarios for the UK. Environmental Science & Policy 11: 54–70.

43.

Hurst D (2012) Environment minister’s climate science doubts ‘refreshing’. Brisbane Times, 5 June 2012. Available at: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/environment-ministers-climate-science-doubts-refreshing-20120605-1zthu.html (accessed 30 July 2014).

44.

Field

Barros

Dokken

(2014) IPCC. Summary for policymakers, Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part A: Global and Sectoral Aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, pp. 1–32.

45.

Johnston

(1988) A Documentary History of Queensland, St Lucia: University of Queensland Press.

46.

Kahan

Peters

Witlin

(2012) The polarizing impact of science literacy and numeracy on perceived climate change risks. Nature Climate Change 2: 732–735.

47.

Keskitalo ECH (2010) Climate change adaptation in the United Kingdom: England and Southeast England. In: Keskitalo ECH (ed) Developing Adaptation Policy and Practice in Europe: Multi-level governance of Climate Change. Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London, New York: Springer Science and Business Media.

48.

Kirchoff

Lemos

Dessai

(2013) Actionable knowledge for environmental decision making: Broadening the usability of climate science. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 38: 393–414.

49.

Macgregor N, Michell H and Webb J (2010) Assessing and responding to climate risks to Natural England’s objectives: Report to the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Natural England, November 2010. Available at: file:///C:/temp/Chrome/Downloads/Climate_change[1]%20(1).pdf (accessed 15 October 2014).

50.

Maher S (2011) Climate change department for chop: Hockey. The Australian, 4 August 2011. Available at: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/climate/climate-change-department-for-chop-hockey/story-e6frg6xf-1226108027421 (accessed 5 August 2013).

51.

McCormick J (2002) Environmental policy in Britain. In: Desai U (ed) Environmental Politics and Policy in Industrialized Countries. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 121–148.

52.

McDonald J, Baum S, Crick F, et al. (2010) Climate Change Adaptation in South East Queensland Human Settlements: Issues and Context. South East Queensland Climate Adaptation Research Initiative, Griffith University. Available at: https://www.griffith.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0013/216130/SEQCARI-Issues-Paper.pdf (accessed 13 August 2015).

53.

McKenzie Hedger

Brown

Connell

(2000) Climate Change: Assessing the Impacts—Identifying Responses. Highlights of the first three years of the UK Climate Impacts Programme, London: Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions.

54.

McLean

(2008) Climate change and UK politics: From Brynle Williams to Sir Nicholas Stern. The Political Quarterly 79(2): 184–193.

55.

Mercer

Christesen

Buston

(2007) Squandering the future—Climate change, policy failure and the water crisis in Australia. Futures 39: 272–287.

56.

Moore C (2013a) To win the battle for the consumer, Cameron must cut taxes soon. The Daily Telegraph, 2 September 2013. Available at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/conservative/10339560/To-win-the-battle-for-the-consumer-Cameron-must-cut-taxes-soon.html (accessed 21 July 2014).

57.

Moore T (2013b) Queensland’s ‘practical’ climate approach. Brisbane Times, 4 April 2013. Available at: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/environment/climate-change/queenslands-practical-climate-approach-20130403-2h791.html (accessed 30 July 2014).

58.

Moss

Meehl

Lemos

(2013) Hell and high water: Practice-relevant adaptation science. Science 342: 696–698.

59.

National Emergency Management Committee (2010) National Emergency Risk Assessment Guidelines, Canberra: Attorney-General’s Department.

60.

Nilsson

Jordan

Turnpenny

(2008) The use and non-use of policy appraisal tools in public policy making: An analysis of three European countries and the European Union. Policy Science 41: 335–355.

61.

Norman B (2012) World Bank calls for greater climate preparedness—In Australia, planning unravels. The Conversation, 20 November 2012. Available at: http://theconversation.edu.au/world-bank-calls-for-greater-climate-preparedness-inaustralia-planning-unravels-10807 (accessed 12 October 2014).

62.

Oberthur

Ott

(1999) The Kyoto Protocol: International Climate Policy for the 21st Century, Germany: Springer.

63.

OECD (1999) National Climate Policies and the Kyoto Protocol. Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development. Available at: http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org.libraryproxy.griffith.edu.au/docserver/download/9799101e.pdf?expires=1381820226&id=id&accname=ocid53013929&checksum=C507522A6EF41AD6929E7EFD74957222 (accessed 16 October 2013).

64.

Ofwat (2014) Strategic direction statements. Available at: http://www.ofwat.gov.uk/pricereview/sds/.

65.

Pielke

Jr (2009) The British Climate Change Act: A critical evaluation and proposed alternative approach. Environmental Research Letters 4: 024010 (accessed 13 October 2014).

66.

Porritt

(1989) The United Kingdom: The dirty man of Europe? RSA Journal 137(5396): 488–500.

67.

Preston BL, Rickards L, Dessai S, et al. (2013) Water, seas, and wine—Science for successful climate adaptation. In: Moser SC and Boykoff MT (eds) Successful Adaptation to Climate Change: Linking Science and Policy in a Rapidly Changing World. Oxon, UK: Routledge, pp. 151–169.

68.

Productivity Commission (2010) Strengthening Evidence Based Policy in the Australian Federation, Volume 1: Proceedings. Roundtable Proceedings, Canberra: Productivity Commission.

69.

Queensland Floods Commission of Inquiry [QFCI] (2011) Queensland Floods Commission of Inquiry: Interim Report. August 2011, Brisbane. Available at: http://www.floodcommission.qld.gov.au/publications/interimreport (accessed 20 November 2012).

70.

Queensland Floods Commission of Inquiry [QFCI] (2012) Queensland Floods Commission of Inquiry: Final Report. March 2012. Brisbane. Available at: www.floodcommission.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/11698/QFCI-Final-Report-March-2012.pdf (accessed 20 November 2012).

71.

Queensland Reconstruction Authority (2011) Rebuilding a stronger, more resilient Queensland. Queensland Government. Available at: http://qldreconstruction.org.au/u/lib/cms2/rebuilding-resilient-qld-full.pdf (accessed 19 December 2014).

72.

Readfearn G (2014) What does Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott really think about climate change? The Guardian, 16 June 2014. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/environment/planet-oz/2014/jun/16/what-does-australian-prime-minister-tony-abbott-really-think-about-climate-change (accessed 15 August 2014).

73.

Richards

Smith

(2002) Governance and Public Policy in the UK, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

74.

Rickards

Wiseman

Edwards

(2014) The problem of fit: Scenario planning and climate change adaptation in the public sector. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 32: 641–662.

75.

Sarewitz

(2004) How science makes environmental controversies worse. Environmental Science & Policy 7: 385–403.

76.

Sheail

(2002) An Environmental History of Twentieth-Century Britain, New York: Palgrave.

77.

Solesbury W (2001) Evidence Based Policy: Whence it came and Where It’s Going—Working Paper 1. ESCRC UK Centre for Evidence Based Policy and Practice, Queen Mary, University of London. Available at: https://www.kcl.ac.uk/sspp/departments/politicaleconomy/research/cep/pubs/papers/assets/wp1.pdf (accessed 12 October 2014).

78.

Tang

Dessai

(2012) Usable science? The UK climate projections 2009 and decision support for adaptation planning. Weather, Climate and Society 4: 300–313.

79.

Tayler-Gooby

(2012) Root and branch restructuring to achieve major cuts: The social policy programme of the 2010 UK coalition government. Social Policy and Administration 46(1): 61–82.

80.

The Met Office (2009) Helping you meet climate change head on. 18 June 2009. Available at: http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/news/releases/archive/2009/warmer-future (accessed 12 September 2014).

81.

Tomaney

Marques

(2013) Evidence, policy, and the politics of regional development: The case of high-speed rail in the United Kingdom. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 31(3): 414–427.

82.

Walker KJ (2002) Environmental policy in Australia. In: Desai U (ed) Environmental Politics and Policy in Industrialized Countries. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 247–293.

83.

Walker KJ (2012) Australia’s construction of environmental policy. In: Crowley K and Walker KJ (eds) Environmental Policy Failure: The Australian Story. Prahran, VIC, Australia: Tilde University Press.

84.

Wanna

Weller

(2003) Traditions of Australian governance. Public Administration 81(1): 63–94.

85.

Weichselgartner

Kasperson

(2010) Barriers in the science-policy-practice interface: Toward a knowledge-action-system in global environmental change research. Global Environmental Change 20: 266–277.

86.

Weiss

(1998) Have we learned anything new about the use of evaluation? American Journal of Evaluation 19(1): 21–33.

87.

Weingart P (1999) Scientific expertise and political accountability: Paradoxes of science in politics. Science and Public Policy 26(3): 151–161.

88.

Weston P (2014) New Gold Coast council flood maps criticised for downplaying storm surge risk and leaving homes vulnerable. The Gold Coast Bulletin, 11 August 2014. Available at: http://www.goldcoastbulletin.com.au/news/gold-coast/new-gold-coast-council-flood-maps-criticised-for-downplaying-storm-surge-risk-and-leaving-homes-vulnerable/story-fnj94idh-1227020099137?from=gold+coast+bulletin_rss (accessed 19 August 2014).