The dark double: the American media perception of Russia as a neo-Soviet autocracy,2008

Abstract

This article combines quantitative and textual analysis of editorials in leading American newspapers devoted to Russia’s internal politics from 2008 to 2014. Despite rapprochement under President Dmitry Medvedev, the media image of Russia has been overwhelmingly negative since 2008. Negative media editorial opinions of Russia reflect fears of autocratic political systems that are represented as a dangerous mirror image of the American system. To maintain this binary, aspects of Russian politics that did not fit into the neo-Soviet autocracy narrative were ignored. An original contribution of the article is its identification of key frames used by leading American media outlets to construct a narrative about contemporary Russia as a neo-Soviet autocracy. It demonstrates that this narrative is instrumental in confirming domestic perceptions of American national identity that emphasize its association with freedom at home and leadership of the ‘free world’ abroad. As such, these findings are significant for reaffirming the importance of media framings, associated narratives, and control over them to global governance and soft power.

Keywords

identity media framing narratives Russia United States

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Batalov

Zhuravleva

Khozinskaya

(2009) ‘Rychaschiy medved’ na dikom vostoke. Moscow: Rosspen.

Bennett

(1990) Toward a theory of press-state relations in the United States. Journal of Communication 40(2): 103–127.

Bennett

(2003) A semi-independent press: Government control and journalistic autonomy in the political construction of news. Political Communication 20(4): 359–362.

Bernardi

Cheong

Lundry

. (2012) Narrative Landmines: Rumors, Islamist Extremism, and the Struggle for Strategic Influence. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

Bruner

(2002) Strategies of Remembrance: The Rhetorical Dimensions of National Identity. Columbia, OH: South Carolina Press.

Brzezinski

(1989) The Grand Failure. The Birth and Death of Communism in the Twentieth Century. New York: Scribner.

Campbell

(1992) Writing Security: United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.

Cohen

(2007) The New American Cold War. The Nation, 8 June. Available at: http://www.thenation.com/article/new-american-cold-war

Cohen

(2012) Stop the pointless demonization of Putin. Reuters, 7 May. Available at: http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/05/07/stop-the-pointless-demonization-of-putin/

10.

Cohen

(2014) Stephen Cohen says U.S. has declared new Cold War against Russia. Harriman Institute, Columbia University, 2 May. Available at: http://harriman.columbia.edu/news/stephen-cohen-argues-us-has-declared-cold-war-against-russia

11.

Cottam

(1994) Images and Intervention. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

12.

Dalby

(1988) Geopolitical discourse: The Soviet Union as other. Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 13(4): 415–442.

13.

Elders

(1999) Synchronization of issue agendas in news and editorials of the prestige press in Germany. Communications 24(3): 301–328.

14.

Embody

(2015) Beware Ukraine’s rising right sector. The National Interest, 12 August. Available at: http://nationalinterest.org/feature/beware-ukraines-rising-right-sector-13558

15.

Entman

(2009) Projections of Power: Framing News, Public Opinion, and U.S. Foreign Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

16.

Feklyunina

(2008) Battle for perceptions: Projecting Russia in the West. Europe-Asia Studies 60(4): 605–629.

17.

Feklyunina

(2012) Russia’s international images and its energy policy. An unreliable supplier? Europe-Asia Studies 64(3): 449–469.

18.

Flockhart

(2012) Towards a strong NATO narrative: From a ‘practice of talking’ to a ‘practice of doing’. International Politics 49(1): 78–97.

19.

Foglesong

(2007) The American Mission and the ‘Evil Empire’. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

20.

Fukuyama

(1989) The end of history? The National Interest 16. Available at: http://www.wesjones.com/eoh.htm

21.

Gorbachev

(2015) Kreml’ dal PARNASU shans. Nezavisimaya gazeta, 12 August. Available at: http://www.infox.sg/others/news/kreml-dal-parnasu-shans/

22.

Hafez

(2007) The Myth of Media Globalization. Oxford: Polity Press.

23.

Hanne

Crano

Mio

(eds) (2014) Warring with Words: Narrative and Metaphor in Politics. New York: Taylor & Francis.

24.

Herman

Chomsky

(1988) Manufacturing Consent. New York: Pantheon Book.

25.

Herrmann

(1985) Perceptions and Behavior in Soviet Foreign Policy. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

26.

Iyegar

Simon

(1994) News coverage of the Gulf Crisis and public opinion. Communication Research 20(3): 369–383.

27.

Izadi

Saqhave-Biria

(2007) A discourse analysis of elite American newspaper editorials. Journal of Communication Inquiry 31(2): 140–165.

28.

Kissinger

(2014) To settle the Ukraine crisis, start at the end. Washington Post, 5 March.

29.

Lane

(2009) Global capitalism and the transformation of state Socialism. Studies in Comparative International Development 44(2): 97–117.

30.

(2010) Editorials and the Power of Media: Interweaving of Socio-cultural Identities. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Co.

31.

Lee

(2013) New York Times Tops USA Today to Become No. 2 U.S. Paper. Bloomberg, 30 April. Available at: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-04-30/new-york-times-leads-major-newspapers-with-18-circulation-gain

32.

Legvold

(2014) Managing the new Cold War. Foreign Affairs, 16 June. Available at: https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2014-06-16/managing-new-cold-war

33.

Lieven

(2000) Against Russophobia. World Policy Journal 17(4): 25–32.

34.

Lieven

(2004) America Right or Wrong: Anatomy of American Nationalism. New York: Oxford University Press.

35.

Linz

(2000) Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

36.

Litvinova

(2015) Russian opposition cornered by authorities in regional election race. Moscow Times, 10 August. Available at: http://www.themoscowtimes.com/news/article/russian-opposition-cornered-by-authorities-in-regional-election-race/527628.html

37.

Lowe

Joel

(2013) Remembering the Cold War. London: Routledge.

38.

Lucas

(2009) The New Cold War. London: Palgrave.

39.

Madsen

(1998) American Exceptionalism. Jackson, MS: Keele University Press.

40.

Mattern

(2005) Ordering International Politics. London: Routledge.

41.

Medvedev

(2009) Go Russia, 10 September. Available at: http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/5413

42.

Miskimmon

O’Loughlin

Roselle

(2013) Strategic Narratives: Communication Power and the New World Order. London: Routledge.

43.

New York Times (NYT) (2008a) Airbrushed by the Kremlin, again. Editorial, 9 June, p.A 20.

44.

New York Times (NYT) (2008b) Kicking democracy’s corpse in Russia. Editorial, 30 January, p.A.22.

45.

New York Times (NYT) (2008c) Putin’s mini-me (or not?). Editorial, 4 March, p.A.24.

46.

New York Times (NYT) (2008d) Putin strengthens his legacy. Editorial, 13 February, p.A.24.

47.

New York Times (NYT) (2008e) Vladimir Putin’s Russia. Editorial, 27 February, p.A.24.

48.

New York Times (NYT) (2010) The Moscow bombings. Editorial, 31 March, p.A.22.

49.

New York Times (NYT) (2011) Spring in the Russian air? Editorial, 6 December, p.A.30.

50.

New York Times (NYT) (2013a) Mr. Putin tries to crush another rival. Editorial, 19 July, p.A.24.

51.

New York Times (NYT) (2013b) Mr. Putin’s war on gays. Editorial, 28 July, p.SR.10.

52.

New York Times (NYT) (2014a) A spotlight on Mr. Putin’s Russia. Editorial, 7 February, p.A 22.

53.

New York Times (NYT) (2014b) The ruble’s Fall and Mr. Putin’s reckoning. Editorial, 17 December, p.A.30.

54.

New York Times (NYT) (2014c) The winter of Mr. Putin’s discontent. Editorial, 5 December, p.A.34.

55.

New York Times (NYT) (2014d) Who ordered Politkovskaya’s murder? Editorial, 11 June, p.A.22.

56.

Norris

(1995) The restless searchlight: Network news framing of the post-Cold War world. Political Communication 12(4): 357–370.

57.

Oren

(2002) Our Enemy and US: America’s Rivalries and the Making of Political Science. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

58.

Petro

(1995) The Rebirth of Russian Democracy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

59.

Petrov

Lopman

Hale

(2014) Three dilemmas of hybrid regime governance: Russia from Putin to Putin. Post-Soviet Affairs 31(1): 1–26.

60.

RIA Novosti (2010) Russians overwhelmingly value order above democracy – Survey. 12 April. Available at: http://sputniknews.com/russia/20100412/158539425.html

61.

Roberts

(2006) History, theory, and the narrative turn in international relations. Review of International Studies 32: 4.

62.

Robertson

(2011) The Politics of Protest in Hybrid Regimes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

63.

Ryan

(2004) Framing the war against terrorism: US newspaper editorials and military action in Afghanistan. International Communication Gazette 66(5): 363–382.

64.

Saff

Ohara

(2006) The media and the pursuit of militarism in Japan. Critical Discourse Studies 3(1): 81–101.

65.

Safire

(1994) Strategic dilemma. New York Times, 1 December. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/1994/12/01/opinion/essay-strategic-dilemma.html

66.

Said

(1997) Covering Islam. New York: Vintage Books.

67.

Skonieczny

(2015) Identity, threat and a discursive approach to US trade politics. In: ISA, New Orleans, LA. Available at: http://www.isanet.org/Conferences/New-Orleans-2015

68.

Smith

Wakefield

(2005) Textual analysis of tobacco editorials. American Journal of Health Promotion 19(5): 361–368.

69.

Stent

(2014) The Limits of Partnership: U.S.-Russian Relations in the Twenty-First Century. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

70.

Titkov

(2015) Тri Rossiyi. 30 March. Available at: http://daily.rbc.ru/opinions/politics/31/03/2015/551a40189a79477151f9b609

71.

Tsoi

(2015) Putin 3.0. 27 March. Available at: http://top.rbc.ru/politics/27/03/2015/551431a59a7947b6b14097ef

72.

Tsygankov

(2009) Russophobia. London: Palgrave.

73.

Tsygankov

(2014) The Strong State in Russia. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

74.

Tsygankov

Parker

(2015) The securitization of democracy: The freedom house ratings of Russia. European Security 24(1): 77–100.

75.

Turner

(2013) Threatening’ China and US security: The international politics of identity. Review of International Studies 39(4): 903–924.

76.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2008a) A run on Russia. Editorial, 18 September, p.A.24.

77.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2008b) President ‘Whatever’. Editorial, 3 March, p.A.16.

78.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2010) Terror in Moscow. Editorial, 30 March, p.A.14.

79.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2011) Terror in Moscow – Again. Editorial, 25 January, p.A.14.

80.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2012) Our friends the Russians. Editorial, 13 February, p.A.14.

81.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2013a) A whistleblower in Moscow. Editorial, 13 July, p.A.12.

82.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2013b) Navalny’s triumph. Editorial, 10 September, p.A 16.

83.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2014a) Kremlin hostage takers. Editorial, 31 December, p.A16.

84.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2014b) Putin and Navalny. Editorial, 24 April, p.A.14.

85.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2014c) Putin’s disinformation matrix. Editorial, 15 November, p.A12.

86.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2014d) Putin’s memory hole. Editorial, 15 October, p.A18.

87.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2014e) Putin’s ruble rout. Editorial, 16 December, p.A14.

88.

Wall Street Journal (WSJ) (2014f) The run on the ruble. Editorial, 3 November, p.A14.

89.

Washington Post (WP) (2008a) A Potemkin election. Editorial, 30 January, p.A.14.

90.

Washington Post (WP) (2008b) Russia’s succession. Editorial, 2 March, p.B6.

91.

Washington Post (WP) (2009a) Mr. Medvedev’s glasnost. Editorial, 14 November, p.A.14.

92.

Washington Post (WP) (2009b) Russia, disgraced. Editorial, 18 July, p.A14.

93.

Washington Post (WP) (2010a) Moscow’s mistrust. 1 July, p.A 14.

94.

Washington Post (WP) (2010b) Show trial in Moscow. Editorial, 9 June p.A.20.

95.

Washington Post (WP) (2011a) Corruptionism. Editorial, 26 September, p.A.18.

96.

Washington Post (WP) (2011b) No monitors, please – We’re Russian. Editorial, 4 December, p.A.28.

97.

Washington Post (WP) (2011c) Russia stirring. Editorial, 26 December, p.A22.

98.

Washington Post (WP) (2011d) Terrorism in Russia. Editorial, 28 January, p.A.22.

99.

Washington Post (WP) (2012) Oil and capitalism. Editorial, 30 October, p.A.18.

100.

Washington Post (WP) (2013a) An assault on civil society. Editorial, 21 July, p.A.18.

101.

Washington Post (WP) (2013b) Russia’s war on gays. Editorial, 9 August, p.A.14.

102.

Washington Post (WP) (2014a) Improvising in panic. Editorial, 31 December, p.A12.

103.

Washington Post (WP) (2014b) In campaign against truth, Mr. Putin wields fear and economic force. Editorial, 26 November, p.A22.

104.

Washington Post (WP) (2014c) Russia’s quiet repression. Editorial, 10 August, p.A.18.

105.

Washington Post (WP) (2014d) Wiping away the Soviet past. Editorial, 16 October, p.A.20.

106.

Weldes

Saco

(1996) The United States and the discursive construction of ‘The Cuban Problem’, 1960–1994. Millennium: Journal of International Studies 25: pp.361–395.

107.

Wolfsfeld

(2011) Making Sense of Media and Politics. London: Routledge.

The dark double: the American media perception of Russia as a neo-Soviet autocracy,2008–2014

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References