Predicting the Toxicity of Oil-shale Industry Wastewater by its Phenolic Composition

Abstract

The chemical composition and toxicity of five phenolic wastewater samples collected from the Kohtla-Järve (Estonia) oil-shale industry region were analysed. The total phenolic contents (HPLC data) of these samples ranged from 0.7mg/l to 195mg/l. A total of 11 phenolic compounds were found in the wastewater samples, the most abundant being phenol (up to 84mg/l) and p-cresol (up to 74mg/l). Artificial phenolic mixtures were also composed, to mimic the content of phenolic compounds in the wastewater samples. The theoretical toxicities of these artificial mixtures were calculated by using the toxicities of the individual phenolic constituents to photobacteria (the BioTox^™ test) and were assumed to have an additive mode of action. From the BioTox data, the additive toxic effects of phenolic compounds in the artificial mixtures were confirmed to be highly probable. The toxicities of the wastewater samples and their artificial phenolic analogues (mixtures) were studied by using a battery of Toxkit microbiotests (Daphtoxkit F^™ magna, Thamnotoxkit F^™, Protoxkit F^™ and Rotoxkit F^™) and three photobacterial tests (Microtox^™, BioTox^™ and Vibrio fischeri 1500). The wastewaters were classified as toxic (two samples), very toxic (two samples) and extremely toxic (one sample). Comparison of the test battery responses showed that the industrial wastewaters were 2–28-fold more toxic than the respective artificial phenolic mixtures. The photobacterial tests proved to be the most appropriate for screening purposes. This was the first attempt to use a test battery approach in the toxicity testing of Estonian wastewaters. The study showed that the toxicity of oil-shale industry wastewaters could not be predicted solely on the basis of their phenolic composition, since only 7–50% of their toxicity was shown to be due to phenolic compounds. It is true, to a certain extent, that the majority of environmental samples are usually very complex and contain various types of pollutants. As even a full chemical analysis (which is very expensive) can easily miss the constituent(s) with the greatest toxic effect(s), the use of toxicity tests in parallel to chemical analysis should be encouraged.

Keywords

microbiotests photobacteria phenolic wastewaters mixtures toxicity testing

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Vesi-Hydro (1993). Waste Water Treatment in the Kohtla-Järve Area. Stage One: Waste Water Pilot Plant Study. Report to the Finnish Ministry of the Environment. Final Report. 32 pp. Helsinki, Finland: Vesi-Hydro.

Munter

, Trapido

, Veressinina

, Preis

, & Pikkov

(1994). Detoxification of phenolic and carcinogenic compounds in the leachate from Kohtla-Järve dump. In Proceedings of Estonian Conference on Ecology, pp. 199–203. Tartu, Estonia: Greif.

Trapido

, Munter

, & Kallas

(1994). Oil shale ash dump waste water as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and phenols pollution source. In Proceedings of Estonian Conference on Ecology, pp. 203–205. Tartu, Estonia: Greif.

Kahru

, Kurvet

, & Külm

(1996). Toxicity of phenolic wastewater to luminescent bacteria Photobacterium phosphoreum. Water Science and Technology 33, 139–146.

Kahru

, Kurvet

, & Kurvet

(1997). Study of the toxicological impact of different components of ash-heap water. Oil Shale 14, Special Issue 4, 469–475.

Kahru

, Reiman

, & Rätsep

(1998). The efficiency of different phenol-degrading bacteria and activated sludges in detoxification of phenolic leachates. Chemosphere 37, 301–318.

Blaise

(1991). Microbiotests in aquatic ecotoxicology: characteristics, utility and prospects. Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality 8, 145–155.

International Symposium on New Microbiotests for Routine Toxicity Screening and Biomonitoring: Development, Applications, Cost-effectiveness, 1–3 June 1998, Brno, Czech Republic. Book of abstracts. 134pp.

Persoone

(1998). Development and validation of ToxKit microbiotests with invertebrates, in particular crustaceans. In Microscale Aquatic Toxicology: Advances, Techniques and Practice (ed. Wells

P.G.

, Lee

, & Blaise

), pp. 437–449. Boca Raton, FL, USA: CRC Lewis.

10.

Kahru

(1993). In vitro toxicity testing using marine luminescent bacteria Photobacterium phosphoreum: the BioTox test. ATLA 21, 210–215.

11.

Persoone

, Goyvaerts

, Janssen

, De Coen

, & Vangheluwe

(1993). Cost-effective Acute Hazard Monitoring of Polluted Waters and Waste Dumps with the Aid of ToxKit: Final Report. Contract ACE 89/BE 2/D3. 600 pp. Brussels, Belgium: CEC.