The efficacy of biomedical research on chimpanzees is addressed from an empirical point of view. The confounding effects of “standard housing” on experiments are examined, with regard to deleterious effects on the neurophysiological makeup of the subjects and thus the effects on the results of any research examining neurological or immunological factors. Also, specious symptom similarity can cause one to assume a common aetiology, which is often unwarranted. The assumption of common reactions from different species violates sound scientific procedures. The high probability of Type 1 errors in the chimpanzee AIDS model is discussed. Also, unjustified generalisation across species is discussed. Finally, the rational and ethical problems surrounding the use of chimpanzees in biomedical research are discussed.
KingM. E., and WilsonA.C. (1975). Evolution at two levels in humans and chimpanzees.Science188, 107–116.
2.
LewinR. (1984). DNA reveals surprises in human family tree.Science226, 1179–1183.
3.
GibbonsA. (1990). Our chimp cousins get that much closer.Science250, 376.
4.
GoodallJ. (1986). The Chimpanzees of Gombe: Patterns of Behaviour, 678 pp. Cambridge, MA, USA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University
5.
McGrewW.C. (1994). Cultural implications of differences between populations of free ranging chimpanzees in Africa. In The Ethological Roots of Culture (ed. GardnerR.A., GardnerB.T., ChiarelliB., PlooijF.X.), pp. 61–79. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer.
6.
GardnerR.A., and GardnerB.T. (1989). A cross-fostering laboratory. In Teaching Sign Language to Chimpanzees (ed. GardnerR.A., GardnerB.T., & Van CantfortT.), pp. 1–28. Albany, NY, USA: State University of New York Press.
7.
FoutsR.S., and FoutsD.H. (1989). Loulis in conversation with the cross-fostered chimpanzees. In Teaching Sign Language to Chimpanzees (ed. GardnerR.A., GardnerB.T., & Van CantfortT.), pp. 293–307. Albany, NY, USA: State University of New York Press.
8.
FoutsR.S., FoutsD.H., & Van CantfortT.E. (1989). The infant Loulis learns signs from cross-fostered chimpanzees. In Teaching Sign Language to Chimpanzees (ed. GardnerR.A., GardnerB.T., & Van CantfortT.), pp. 280–292. Albany, NY, USA: State University of New York Press.
9.
DavenportR. (1979). Some behavioural disturbances of great apes in captivity. In The Great Apes (ed. HamburgD., McCownE.R.), pp. 341–356. Menlo Park, CA, USA: The Benjamin/Cummings Publishing Co.
10.
MasonW. (1965). Determinants of social behaviour in young chimpanzees. In Behaviour of Nonhuman Primates, Vol. 2 (ed. SchrierA.M., HarlowH.F., StollnitzF.), pp. 335–364. New York: Academic Press.
11.
LiebermanJ.N. (1965). Playfulness and divergent thinking: an investigation of their relationship at the kindergarten level.Journal of Genetic Psychology10, 219–224.
12.
RosenC. (1974). The effects of sociodramatic play on problem-solving behaviour among culturally disadvantaged preschool children.Child Development45, 920–927.
13.
CaplanF., and CaplanT. (1973). The Power of Play.New York: Anchor Press/Double Day.
14.
HarlowH. F., & HarlowM.K. (1962). Deprivation in monkeys.Scientific American207, 136–146.
15.
PoirierF., and SmithD. (1974). Socializing functions of primate play.American Zoologist14, 75–27.
16.
BatesonG. (1955). A theory of play and fantasy.Psychiatric Resident Representative2, 39.
17.
FingerS., & SteinD.G. (1982). Brain Damage and Recovery, 179 pp. New York: Academic Press.
18.
Eibl-EibesfeldtI. (1975). Ethology: The Biology of Behaviour, 26 pp. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
19.
AlterH.J., EichbergJ., MasurH., SaxingerW., GalloR., MacherA., LaneH., and FauciA. (1984). Transmission of HTLV-III infection from human plasma to chimpanzees: an animal model for AIDS.Science226, 549–552.
20.
FrancisD., FeorinoP., BrodersonJ., McClureH., GetchellJ., McGrathC., SwensonB., McDougallJ., PalmerE., HarrisonBarre-Sinoussi F., ChermannJ-C., MontagnierL., CurranJ., CabradillaC., and KalyanarananV. (1984). Infection in chimpanzees with lymphadenopathy-associated virus.Lancet2, 1276–1271.
21.
FultzP., McClureH., SwensonR., McGrathC., BrodieA., GetchellJ., JensenF., AndersonD., BrodersonJ., and FrancisD. (1986). Persistent infection of chimpanzees with HTLV-IIVLAV: a potential model for AIDS.Journal of Virology58, 116–124.
22.
GajdusekD., AmyxH., GibbsC., AsherD., GalloR., PremS., MaluishA., ArthurL., MontagnierL., and MildvanD. (1985). Infection of chimpanzees by human T-lymphotropic retro-virsuses in brain and other tissues from AIDS patients.Lancet1, 55.
23.
EichbergJ., LawlorD., and AlterH. (1984). Cellular immune profile of the chimpanzee: its potential usefulness in acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS).Federal Protocol43, 1914.
24.
FauciA., GalloR., KoenigS., SalkJ., and PurcellR. (1989). Development and evaluation of a vaccine for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection.Annals of Internal Medicine110, 373–384.
25.
HaysWilliam L. (1963). Statistics for Psychologists, 280 pp. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
