In ecotoxicology, in vitro assays with fish cells are currently applied for mechanistic studies, bioanalytical purposes and toxicity screening. This paper discusses the potential of cytotoxicity assays with fish cells to reduce, refine or replace acute lethality tests using fish. Basal cytotoxicity data obtained with fish cell lines or fish primary cell cultures show a reasonable to good correlation with lethality data from acute toxicity tests, with the exception of compounds that exert a specific mode of toxic action. Basal cytotoxicity data from fish cell lines also correlate well with cytotoxicity data from mammalian cell lines. However, both the piscine and mammalian in vitro assays are clearly less sensitive than the fish test. Therefore, in vivo LC50 values (concentrations of the test compounds that are lethal to 50% of the fish in the experiment within 96 hours) currently cannot be predicted from in vitro values. This in vitro–in vivo difference in sensitivity appears to be true for both fish cell lines and mammalian cell lines. Given the good in vitro–in vivo correlation in toxicity ranking, together with the clear-cut difference in sensitivity, the role of cytotoxicity assays in a tiered alternative testing strategy could be in priority setting in relation to toxic hazard and in the toxicity classification of chemicals and environmental samples.
BabichH., & BorenfreundE. (1991). Cytotoxicity and genotoxicity assays with fish cells: a review. Toxicology in Vitro5, 91–100.
2.
IsomaaB., LiliusH., & RaberghC. (1995). Aquatic toxicology in vitro: a brief review. ATLA22, 243–253.
3.
NewmanM.C. ed. (1998). Fundamentals of Ecotoxicology, 402 pp. Chelsea, MI, USA: Ann Arbor Press.
4.
RaberghC.M.I., LiliusH., ErikssonJ.E., & IsomaaB. (1999). The resin acids dehydroabietic acid and isopimaric acid release calcium from intracellular stores in rainbow trout hepatocytes. Aquatic Toxicology46, 55–65.
5.
SegnerH., ChesneC., CravediJ.P., FauconneauB., HoulihanD., LeGacF., LoirM., MothersillC., PärtP., & ValotaireY. (2001). Cellular approaches for diagnostic effects assessment in ecotoxicology: introductory remarks to an EU-funded project. Aquatic Toxicology53, 153–158.
6.
SmithR.W., JönssonM., HoulihanD.F., & PärtP. (2001). Minimising aerobic respiratory demands could form the basis to sub-lethal copper tolerance by rainbow trout gill epithelial cells in vitro.Fish Physiology and Biochemistry24, 157–169.
7.
HilscherowaK., MachalaM., KannanK., BlankeshipA.L., & GiesyJ.P. (2000). Cell bioassays for detection of aryl hydrocarbon and estrogen receptor mediated activity in environmental samples. Environmental Science and Pollution Research7, 159–171.
8.
FentK. (2001). Fish cell lines as a versatile tool in ecotoxicology: assessment of cytotoxicity, cytochrome P450 induction potential and estrogenic activity of chemicals and environmental samples. Toxicology in Vitro15, 477–488.
9.
EggenR.I.L., & SegnerH. (2003). The potential of mechanism-based bioanalytical tools in ecotoxicological exposure and effect assessment. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry377, 386–396.
10.
PesonenM., & AnderssonT. (1997). Primary hepatocyte cultures: an important model of xenobiotic metabolism. Aquatic Toxicology39, 253–267.
11.
DenizeauF. (1998). The use of fish cells in the toxicological evaluation of environmental contaminants. In Microscale Testing in Aquatic Toxicology (ed. WellsP.G., LeeK., & BlaiseC.), pp. 113–128. Boca Raton, FL, USA: CRC Press.
12.
BraunbeckT. (1998). Cytological alterations in fish hepatocytes following in vivo and in vitro sublethal exposure to xenobiotics: structural biomarkers of environmental contamination. In Fish Ecotoxicology (ed. BraunbeckT., HintonD.E., & StreitB.), pp. 61–140. Basel, Switzerland: Birkhäuser.
13.
MonodG., DevauxA., ValotaireY., & CravediJ.P. (1998). Primary cell cultures from fish in ecotoxicology. In Fish Ecotoxicology (ed. BraunbeckT., HintonD.E., & StreitB.), pp. 39–60. Basel, Switzerland: Birkhäuser.
14.
SegnerH. (1998). Fish cell lines as a tool in aquatic toxicology. In Fish Ecotoxicology (ed. BraunbeckT., HintonD.E., & StreitB.), pp. 1–38. Basel, Switzerland: Birkhäuser
15.
SegnerH. (1998). Isolation and primary culture of teleostean hepatocytes. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology A–Molecular and Integrative Physiology120, 71–81.
16.
CastanoA., BolsN.C., BraunbeckT., DierickxP., HalderM., IsomaaB., KawaharaK., LeeL.E.J., MothersillC., PärtP., RepettoG., SintesJ.R., RufliH., SmithR., WoodC., & SegnerH. (2003). The use of fish cells in ecotoxicology. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 47. ATLA31, 317–351.
AhneW. (1985). Untersuchungen über die Verwendung von Fischzellkulturen für Toxizitäts-bestimmungen zur Einschränkung und Ersatz des Fischtests. Zentralblatt Bakteriologie, Mikrobiologie und Hygiene B180, 480–504.
19.
BolsN.C., BoliskaS.A., DixonD.G., HodsonP.V., & KaiserK.L.E. (1985). The use of fish cell cultures as an indication of contaminant toxicity to fish. Aquatic Toxicology6, 147–155.
20.
IsomaaB., & LiliusH. (1995). The urgent need for in vitro tests in ecotoxicology. Toxicology in Vitro9, 821–825.
21.
CastanoA., SanchezP., LlorenteM.T., CarballoM., de la TorreA., & MunozM.J. (2000). The use of alternative systems for the ecotoxicological screening of complex mixtures on fish populations. Science of the Total Environment247, 337–348.
22.
RachlinJ.W., & PerlmutterA. (1968). Fish cells in culture for study of aquatic toxicants. Water Research2, 409–414.
23.
SegnerH., & BraunbeckT. (2003). End points for in vitro toxicity testing with fish cells. In In Vitro Methods in Aquatic Toxicology (ed. MothersillC., & AustinB.), pp. 77–141. Chichester, UK: Springer Praxis.
24.
LenzD., SegnerH., & HankeW. (1993). Comparison of different endpoint methods for acute cytotoxicity tests with the R1 cell line. In Fish: Ecotoxicology and Ecophysiology (ed. BraunbeckT., HankeW., & SegnerH.), pp. 93–102. Weinheim, Germany: Verlag Chemie.
25.
CastanoA., & TarazonaJ.V. (1994). ATP assay on cell monolayers as an index of cytotoxicity. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology53, 309–316.
26.
SaitoH., KoyasuJ., ShigeokaT., & TomitaI. (1994). Cytotoxicity of chlorophenols to goldfish GFS cells with the MTT and LDH assays. Toxicology in Vitro8, 1107–1112.
27.
SaitoH., & ShigeokaT. (1994). Comparative cytotoxicity of chlorophenols to cultured fish cells. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry13, 1649–1650.
28.
LiH., & ZhangS. (2002). In vitro cytotoxicity of the organophosphorous insectice methylparathion to FG-9307, the gill cell line of flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus). Cell Biology and Toxicology18, 235–241.
29.
ZahnT., ArnoldH., BraunbeckT. (1996). Cytological and biochemical responses of R1 cells and isolated hepatocytes from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) to subacute in vivo exposure to disulfoton. Experimental and Toxicologic Pathology48, 47–64.
30.
SchüürmannG., SegnerH., & JungK. (1997). Multivariate mode-of-action analysis of acute toxicity of phenols. Aquatic Toxicology38, 277–296.
31.
GagnéF., & BlaiseC. (1998). Differences in the measurement of cytotoxicity of complex mixtures with rainbow trout hepatocytes and fibroblasts. Chemosphere37, 753–769.
32.
ClemedsonC., BarileF.A., EkwallB., Gómez-LechónM.J., HallT., ImaiK., KahruA., LogemannP., MonacoF., OhnoT., SegnerH., SjöstromM., ValentinoM., WalumE., WangX., & EkwallB. (1998). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. Part III. In vitro results from 16 additional methods used to test the first 30 reference chemicals and a comparative cytotoxicity analysis. ATLA26, 93–129.
33.
ClemedsonC., AnderssonM., AokiY., BarileF.A., CallejaM.A., CastanoA., ClothierR.H., DierickxP., EkwallB., FerroM., FiskesjöG., Garza-OcañasL., Gómez-LechónM.J., GüldenM., HallT., ImaiK., IsomaaB., KahruA., KerszmanG., KjellstrandP., KristenU., KunimotoM., KärenlampiS., LewanL., LiliusH., LoukianovA., MonacoF., OhnoT., PersooneG., RomertL., SawyerT.W., ShrivastavaR., SegnerH., SeibertH., SjöströmM., StammatiA., TanakaN., ThuvanderA., Torres-AlanisO., ValentinoM., WakuriS., WalumE., WieslanderA., WangX., ZuccoF., & EkwallB. (1998). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. Part IV. In vitro results from 67 toxicity assays used to test reference chemicals 31–50 and a comparative cytotoxicity analysis. ATLA26, 131–183.
34.
LiliusH., SandbackaM., & IsomaaB. (1995). The use of freshly isolated gill epithelial cells in toxicity testing. Toxicology in Vitro9, 299–305.
35.
LiliusH., IsomaaB., & HolmströmT. (1994). A comparison of the toxicity of 50 reference chemicals to freshly isolated rainbow trout hepatocytes and Daphnia magna.Aquatic Toxiology30, 47–60.
36.
SegnerH., & SchüürmannG. (1997). Cytotoxicity of MEIC chemicals to rainbow trout R1 cell line and multivariate comparison with ecotoxicity tests. ATLA25, 331–338.
37.
ClemedsonC., & EkwallB. (1999). Overview of the final MEIC results. I. The in vitro–in vitro evaluation. Toxicology in Vitro13, 657–663.
38.
EkwallB. (1995). The basal cytotoxicity concept. In Alternative Methods in Toxicology and the Life Sciences, Vol. 11, The World Congress on Alternatives and Animal Use in the Life Sciences: Education, Research, Testing (ed. GoldbergA.M., & van ZutphenL.F.M.), pp. 721–725. New York, NY, USA: Mary Ann Liebert.
39.
DierickxP.J. (1993). Comparison between fish lethality data and the in vitro cytotoxicity of lipophilic solvents to cultured fish cells in a two compartment model. Chemosphere27, 1511–1518.
40.
RuscheB., & KohlpothM. (1993). The R1 cytotoxicity test as replacement for fish tests stipulated in the German Waset Water Act. In Fish Ecotoxicology and Ecophysiology (ed. BraunbeckT., HankeW., & SegnerH.), pp. 81–92. Weinheim, Germany: VCH-Wiley.
41.
ZahnT., HauckC., HolzschuhJ., & BraunbeckT. (1995). Acute and sublethal toxicity of seepage waters from garbage dumps to permanent cell lines and primary cultures of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): a novel approach to environmental risk assessment for chemicals and chemical mixtures. Zentralblatt für Hygiene und Umweltmedizin196, 455–479.
42.
RogersJ.T., RichardsJ.G., & WoodC.M. (2003). Ionoregulatory disruption as the acute toxic mechanism for lead in the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquatic Toxicology64, 215–234.
43.
EkwallB., EkwallB., & SjöströmM. (2000). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. VIII. Multivariate partial least squares evaluation, including the selection of cell line tests with a good prediction of human acute lethal peak blood concentrations for 50 chemicals. ATLA28, Suppl. 1, 201–234.
44.
KilemadeM., & QuinnB. (2003). In vitro/in vivo bridging approaches: validating the relevance of in vitro techniques with references to the whole organism in the natural environment. In In Vitro Methods in Aquatic Toxicology (ed. MothersillC., & AustinB.), pp. 377–398. Chichester, UK: Springer Praxis.
45.
SegnerH., LenzD., HankeW., & SchüürmannG. (1994). Cytotoxicity of metals towards rainbow trout R1 cell line. Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality9, 273–279.
46.
SaitoH., IwamiS., & ShigeokaT. (1991). In vitro cytotoxicity of 45 pesticides to goldfish GF scale (GFS) cells. Chemosphere23, 525–537.
47.
SandbackaM., ChristiansonI., & IsomaaB. (2000). The acute toxicity of surfactants on fish cells, Daphnia magna and fish: a comparative study. Toxicology in Vitro14, 61–68.
48.
SegnerH., & LenzD. (1993). Cytotoxicity assays with the rainbow trout R1 cell line. Toxicology in Vitro7, 537–540.
49.
EkwallB., ClemedsonC., BarileF.A., CastanoA., ClothierR.H., DierickxP., EkwallB., FerroM., FiskesjöG., Garza-OcañasL., Gómez-LechónM.J., GüldenM., HallT., IsomaaB., KahruA., KerszmanG., KristenK., KunimotoM., KärenlampiS., LewanL., LoukianowA., OhnoT., PersooneG., RoertL., SawyerT.W., ShrivastavaR., SegnerH., StammatiA., TanakaN., ValentinoM., ZuccoF., & WalumE. (1998). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. Part VI. Prediction of human toxicity by rodent LD50 values and results from 61 in vitro tests. ATLA26, 617–658.
50.
RosenkranzH.S., & CunninghamA.R. (2000). The high production volume chemical challenge program: the rodent LD50 and its possible replacement. ATLA28, 271–277.
51.
GagnéF., & BlaiseC. (1997). Evaluation of cell viability, mixed function oxidase activity, metallothionein induction, and genotoxicity in rainbow trout hepatocytes. II. Validation of the rainbow trout hepatocyte model for ecotoxicity testing of industrial wastewater. Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality12, 305–314.
52.
DayehV.R., SchirmerK., & BolsN.C. (2002). Applying whole-water samples directly to fish cell cultures to evaluate the toxicity of industrial effluent. Water Research36, 3727–3738.
53.
DierickxP., van der WielenC., & LemaireS. (2000). Toxicological evaluation of surface water samples in sensitised cultured fish cells compared with the Microtox method. ATLA28, 509–515.
54.
ScheersE.M., van der WielenC., & DierickxP.J. (2002). Toxicological evaluation of waste-water samples to appropriately sensitized cultured fathead minnow cells compared with the Microtox assay. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology68, 253–260.
55.
WorthA.P., & BallsM. eds (2002). Alternative (non-animal) methods for chemicals testing: current status and future prospects. ATLA30, Suppl. 1, 125 pp.
56.
HutchinsonT.H., BarrettS., BusbyM., ConstableD., HartmannA., HayesE., HuggettD., LängeR., LillicrapA.D., StraubJ.O., & ThompsonR.S. (2003). A strategy to reduce the numbers of fish used in acute ecotoxicity testing of pharmaceuticals. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry22, 3031–3036.
57.
JuhnkeI., & LüdemannD. (1978). Ergebnisse der Untersuchung von 200 chemischen Verbindungen auf akute Fischtoxizität mit dem Goldorfentest. Zeitschrift für Wasser- und Abwasserforschung11, 161–164.
58.
MiltenburgerG. (1996). Validierung eines Zytotoxizitätstests als mögliche Ersatzmethode zum Fischtest nach DIN 38 412, Teil 31: Phase II.42 pp. Abschlussbericht. Darmstadt, Germany: Technische Hochschule Darmstadt.
59.
MunkittrickK.R., PowerE.A., & SergyG.A. (1993). The relative sensitivity of Microtox, daphnid, rainbow trout and fathead minnow acute lethality tests. Environmental Toxicology and Water Chemistry6, 35–62.
60.
EkwallB., ClemedsonC., CrafoordB., EkwallB., HallanderS., WalumE., & BondessonI. (1998). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. Part V. Rodent and human toxicity data for 50 reference chemicals. ATLA26, Suppl. 2, 571–616.
