The use of fish cell line cytotoxicity tests as alternatives to acute lethality tests with fish is hampered by the clearly lower sensitivity of the fish cell line tests. Recently, it has been shown that this is not a unique feature of fish cells. In fact, the sensitivity of mammalian and human cell lines toward the cytotoxic actions of chemicals, in general, is comparable to that of fish cell lines. Reviewing some of our recent investigations, the objective of this paper is to show that the sensitivity of in vitro cytotoxicity testing and the correspondence between in vitro cytotoxic and acute fish toxic concentrations (LC50) can be increased, if: a) inhibition of cell growth instead of cell death is used as the endpoint; and b) the bioavailable free cytotoxic concentration (ECu50) of chemicals in vitro, instead of the nominal cytotoxic concentration (EC50), is used as the measure of cytotoxic potency. Based on these results, a pragmatic in vitro testing strategy for estimating the minimal aquatic toxic potency of chemicals is proposed.
BabichH., & BorenfreundE. (1987). In vitro cytotoxicity of organic pollutants to bluegill sunfish (BF-2) cells. Environmental Research42, 229–237.
2.
BabichH., & BorenfreundE. (1990). Applications of the neutral red cytotoxicity assay to in vitro toxicology. ATLA19, 129–144.
3.
BrandaoJ.C., BohetsH.H.L., Van De VyverI.E., & DierickxP. (1992). Correlation between the in vitro cytotoxicity to cultured fathead minnow fish cells and fish lethality data for 50 chemicals. Chemosphere25, 553–562.
4.
SegnerH., & LenzD. (1993). Cytotoxicity assays with the rainbow trout R1 cell line. Toxicology in Vitro7, 537–540.
5.
CastañoA., CantarinoM.J., CastilloP., & TarazonaJ.V. (1996). Correlations between the RTG-2 cytotoxicity test EC50 and in vivo LC50 rainbow trout bioassay. Chemosphere32, 2141–2157.
6.
FentK., & HunnJ. (1996). Cytotoxicity of organic environmental chemicals to fish liver cells (PLHC-1). Marine Environmental Research41, 377–382.
7.
SegnerH. (2004). Cytotoxicity assays with fish cells as an alternative to the acute lethality test with fish. ATLA32, 375–382.
8.
CastañoA., BolsN., BraunbeckT., DierickxP., HalderM., IsomaaB., KawaharaK., LeeL.E.J., MothersillC., PärtP., RepettoG., SintesJ.R., RufliH., SmithR., WoodC., & SegnerH. (2003). The use of fish cells in ecotoxicology. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 47. ATLA31, 317–351.
9.
VaesW.H.J., Urrestarazu RamosE., HamwijkC., Van HolsteijnI., BlaauboerB.J., SeinenW., VerhaarH.J.M., & HermensJ.L.M. (1997). Solid phase microextraction as a tool to determine membrane/water partition coefficients and bioavailable concentrations in in vitro systems. Chemical Research in Toxicology10, 1067–1072.
10.
GüldenM., MörchelS., & SeibertH. (2001). Factors influencing nominal effective concentrations of chemical compounds in vitro: cell concentration. Toxicology in Vitro15, 233–243.
11.
GüldenM., MörchelS., TahanS., & SeibertH. (2002). Impact of protein binding on the availability and cytotoxic potency of organochlorine pesticides and chlorophenols in vitro.Toxicology175, 201–213.
12.
SeibertH., MörchelS., & GüldenM. (2002). Factors influencing nominal effective concentrations of chemical compounds in vitro: serum albumin concentration. Toxicology in Vitro16, 289–297.
13.
HeringaM.B., SchreursR.H.M.M., BusserF., Van der SaagP.T., Van der BurgB., & HermensJ.L.M. (2004). Toward more useful in vitro toxicity data with measured free concentrations. Environmental Science & Technolology38, 6263–6270.
14.
GüldenM., MörchelS., & SeibertH. (2005). Comparison of mammalian and fish cell line cytotoxicity: impact of endpoint and exposure duration. Aquatic Toxicology71, 229–236.
15.
ClemedsonC., BarileF.A., EkwallB., Gómez-LechónM.J., HallT., ImaiK., KahruA., LogemannP., MonacoF., OhnoT., SegnerH., SjöströmM., ValentinoM., WalumE., WangX., & EkwallB. (1998). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. Part III. In vitro results from 16 additional methods used to test the first 30 reference chemicals and a comparative cytotoxicity analysis. ATLA26, Suppl. 1, 93–129.
16.
ClemedsonC., AnderssonM., AokiY., BarileF.A., BassiA.M., CallejaM.C., CastañoA., ClothierR.H., DierickxP., EckwallB., FerroM., FiskesjöG., Garza-OcanasL., Gómez-LechónM.J., GüldenM., HallT., ImaiK., IsomaaB., KahruA., KerszmannG., KjellstrandP., KristenU., KunimotoM., KärenlampiS., LewanL., LiliusH., LoukianovA., MonacoF., OhnoT., PersonneG., RomertR., SawyerT.W., SegnerH., SeibertH., ShrivastavaR., SjöströmM., StammatiA-L., TanakaN., ThuvanderA., Torres-AlanisO., ValentinoM., WakuriS., WalumE., WangX., WieslanderA., ZuccoF., & EkwallB. (1998). MEIC evaluation of acute systemic toxicity. Part IV. In vitro results from 67 toxicity assays used to test reference chemicals 31–50 and a comparative cytotoxicity analysis. ATLA26, Suppl. 1, 131–183.
17.
LenzD., SegnerH., & HankeW. (1993). Comparison of different endpoint methods for acute cytotoxicity tests with the R1-cell line. In Fish Ecotoxicology and Ecophysiology (ed. BraunbeckT., HankeW., & SegnerH.), pp. 93–102, Weinheim, Germany: VCH Verlag.
18.
SegnerH. (1998). Fish cell lines as a tool in aquatic toxicology. In: Fish Ecotoxicology (eds BraunbeckT., HintonD.E., & StreitB.), pp. 1–38, Basel, Switzerland: Birkhäuser Verlag.
19.
GüldenM., MörchelS., & SeibertH. (2003). Serum albumin binding at cytotoxic concentrations of chemicals as determined with a cell proliferation assay. Toxicology Letters173, 159–168.
20.
CastañoA., & Gómez-LechónM. (2005). Comparison of basal cytotoxicity data between mammalian and fish cell lines: A literature survey. Toxicology in Vitro19, 695–705.
21.
GüldenM., KolossaM., & SeibertH. (1992). Influence of the experimental design on the outcome of in vitro cytotoxicity tests with proliferating cells. Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives of Pharmacology345, 144.
22.
GüldenM., & SeibertH. (1997). Influence of protein binding and lipophilicity on the distribution of compounds in in vitro systems. Toxicology in Vitro11, 479–483.
23.
GüldenM., & SeibertH. (2003). In vitro–in vivo extrapolation: estimation of human serum concentrations of chemicals equivalent to cytotoxic concentrations in vitro.Toxicology189, 211–222.
24.
GüldenM., & SeibertH. (2005). Impact of bioavailability on the correlation between in vitro cytotoxic and in vivo acute fish toxic concentrations of chemicals. Aquatic Toxicology72, 327–337.
HayesW.J., & LawsE.R.A. eds. (1991). Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology.1576 pp. San Diego, CA, USA: Academic Press, Inc.
27.
SeibertH., GüldenM., & VossJ.U. (1994). An in vitro toxicity testing strategy for the classification and labelling of chemicals according to their potential acute lethal potency. Toxicology in Vitro8, 847–850.
28.
SeibertH., BallsM., FentemJ.H., BianchiV., ClothierH., DierickxP.J., EkwallB., GarleM.J., Gómez-LechónM.J., GüldenM., LiebschM., RasmussenE., RoguetR., ShrivastavaR., & WalumE. (1996). Acute toxicity testing in vitro and the classification and labelling of chemicals. The report and recommendations of ECVAM workshop 16. ATLA24, 499–510.
