Vulnerability has been a guiding narrative to state interventions towards children and their families in New Zealand. This article shows how this progressive notion has been systematically managed to fit pre-established political and policy priorities. These processes have emphasised: (i) categorisations of risk to those who demonstrate vulnerabilities; (ii) pre-emptive, multi-agency involvement in the lives of those deemed potentially ‘vulnerable’; and (iii) a responsibilising expectation that children and families will avoid vulnerable situations and comply with interventions. This individualising logic of vulnerability has solidified policy interventions towards Māori, and re-emphasised colonial practices of viewing Māori children and young people as deficit-laden risks to be managed. With a late 2017 change in government, the political dalliance with vulnerability appears to be in decline. A new progressive policy discourse – of child ‘well-being’ and ‘best interests’ – is being engaged. Yet, the emphasis on risk, and its corresponding elements of pre-emption and responsibility, persist. These discursive and institutional arrangements will ensure that Māori remain perilously entrenched in welfare and justice systems.
BrownK (2014) Questioning the vulnerability zeitgeist: Care and control practices with 'vulnerable' young people. Social Policy and Society13(1): 371–387.
2.
BrownK (2015) Vulnerability and Young People: Care and social control in policy and practice. Bristol: Policy Press.
3.
CarrJTamH (2013) Changing the lens – Positive developments from New Zealand. The Chronicle, International Association of Youth and Family Judges and Magistrates. January: 14–19.
4.
CaseS (2007) Questioning the 'evidence' of risk that underpins evidence-led youth justice interventions. Youth Justice7(2): 91–105.
5.
CPAG, Child Poverty Action Group (2014) Our Children, Our Choice: Priorities for Policy. Auckland: CPAG.
6.
Children’s Action Plan (2015) He Taonga Te Tamariki: Identifying, Supporting and Protecting Vulnerable Children, Progress Report. Wellington: Children’s Action Plan.
7.
ChristieN (1986) The ideal victim. In: FattahEA (ed.) From Crime Policy to Victim Policy. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press.
8.
CohenS (1985) Visions of Social Control. Oxford: Polity Press.
CramF (2011) Poverty. In: McIntoshTMulhollandMT (eds) Māori and Social Issues. Wellington: Huia Press.
11.
CroweK (2016) Secure welfare services: risk, Security and Rights of Vulnerable Young People in Victoria, Australia. Youth Justice16(3): 263–279.
12.
DanielB (2010) Concepts of adversity, risk, vulnerability and resilience: A discussion in the context of the ‘child protection system’. Social Policy and Society9(2): 231–241.
DoogueJustice J (2018) Generations of Disadvantage: A View from the District Court Bench, 22nd Annual New Zealand Law Foundation Ethel Benjamin Commemorative Address. Dunedin, 15October2018.
15.
DuncansonMObenGWickenAMorrisSMcGeeMSimpsonJ (2017) Child Poverty Monitor Technical Report. Dunedin: University of Otago. Available at: http://www.nzchildren.co.nz/ (accessed 1 February 2019).
16.
GeorgeLNgamuESidwellMHaurakiMMartin-FletcherNRipiaLDavisRRatimaPWihongiH (2014) Narratives of suffering and hope. MAI Journal3(3): 183–196.
HackingI (2003) Risk and dirt. In: EricsonRDoyleA (eds) Risk and Morality. Canada: University of Toronto Press.
19.
Hannah-MoffatK (2016) A conceptual kaleidoscope: Contemplating ‘dynamic structural risk’ and an uncoupling of risk from need. Psychology, Crime and Law22(1–2): 33–46.
20.
HaydonD (2014) Early intervention for the prevention of offending in Northern Ireland. Youth Justice13(3): 226–240.
21.
HaydonD (2018) Children deprived of their liberty on ‘welfare’ grounds: A critical perspective. In: StanleyE (ed.) Human Rights and Incarceration: Critical Explorations. Cham: Palgrave.
22.
HollingsworthK (2008) Protecting rights at the margins of youth justice in England and Wales. Youth Justice8(3): 229–244.
23.
HyslopI (2017) Child protection in New Zealand: A history of the future. The British Journal of Social Work47(6): 1800–1817.
24.
HyslopIKeddellE (2018) Outing the elephants: Exploring a new paradigm for child protection social work. Social Sciences7: 1–13.
25.
KeddellE (2018) The vulnerable child in neoliberal contexts: The construction of children in Aotearoa New Zealand Child Protection Reforms. Childhood25(1): 93–108.
26.
KeddellE (2017) The Child Youth and Family Review: A Commentary on Prevention. Auckland: The Policy Observatory.
27.
MCYFP. Modernising Child, youth and family panel (2016) Expert Panel: Final Report – Investing in New Zealand’s Children and Their Families. Wellington: MSD.
28.
McCullochJWilsonD (2015) Pre-Crime: Pre-Emption, Precaution and the Future. Abingdon: Routledge.
29.
McFarlaneK (2017) Care-criminalisation: The involvement of children in out-of-home care in the New South Wales criminal justice system. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology51(3): 412–433.
30.
McIntoshTCosterS (2017) Indigenous insider knowledge and prison identity. Counterfutures: Left Thought and Practice Aotearoa3: 69–98.
31.
MeyerS (2016) Still blaming the victim of intimate partner violence?Theoretical Criminology20(1): 75–90.
New Zealand Treasury (2016) Characteristics of Children at Greater Risk of Poor Outcomes as Adults. Analytical PaperWellington: New Zealand Treasury.
39.
O’BrienM (2016) The triplets: Investment in outcomes for the vulnerable – Reshaping social services for (some) New Zealand children. Aotearoa New Zealand Social Work28(2): 9–21.
40.
OCC, Office of the Children’s Commissioner (2018) Maiea te Tu¯ruapo¯, Fulfilling the Vision: Supporting Young People with At-Risk Behaviour to Live Successfully in their CommunitiesWellington: OCC.
RoetsGRooseRDe WildeLVanobbergenB (2017) Framing the ‘child at risk’ in social work reports: Truth-telling or storytelling?Journal of Social Work17(4): 453–469.
46.
OPMCSA, Office of the Prime Minister’s Chief Science Advisor (2018) It’s Never Too Early, Never Too Late: A Discussion Paper on Preventing Youth Offending in New Zealand. Auckland: OPMCSA.
SharpeGGelsthorpeL (2015) Girls, crime and justice. In: GoldsonBMuncieJ (eds) Youth Crime and Justice. London: Sage.
50.
ShawJ (2014) Residential Children’s Homes and the Youth Justice System. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
51.
StanleyE (2016) The Road to Hell: State Violence against Children in Postwar New Zealand. Auckland: Auckland University Press.
52.
StanleyE (2017a) Child victims of human rights violations. In: WalklateS (ed.) Handbook on Victims and Victimology (second edition). London: Routledge.
53.
StanleyE (2017b) From care to custody: Trajectories of children in post-war New Zealand. Youth Justice17(1): 57–72.
UNCRC, UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (2011) General Comment No. 13 (2011) The Right of the Child to Freedom from All Forms of Violence, CRC/C.GC/13, 18April2011.
56.
ValentineG (1996) Angels and devils: Moral landscapes of childhood. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14: 581–599.
57.
WalklateS (2011) Reframing criminal victimization: Finding a place for vulnerability and resilience. Theoretical Criminology15(2): 179–194.
