Recent proposals in US cities to ban single-use plastic straws have been adopted quickly and met with little resistance. Environmentalists consider this a small but important win for reducing the harmful impact of single-use plastics on our planet overall. Yet there remains a critical mass of people who are systematically left out of the conversation: disabled people. These people are not only overlooked, they are othered for being poor or disabled or both. We argue that while drastically curtailing plastics production, use, and improper disposal is vital, single-use plastics bans, while just for the planet, are not equally just for all humans. Drawing on disability studies and environmental justice literatures, we problematise existing debates surrounding plastics bans, and recast these bans, and their effects, as an unnecessary othering of poor people and disabled people.
BallAL (2017) ‘The Anti-Packaging Movement’, New York Times, 14March.
2.
BenoitCJanssonMJansenbergerMPhillipsR (2013) ‘Disability Stigmatization as a Barrier to Employment Equity for Legally-blind Canadians’, Disability and Society28: 970–983.
3.
BogdanRBiklenD (1977) ‘Handicapism’, Social Policy7: 14–19.
ClappJSwanstonL (2009) ‘Doing Away with Plastic Shopping Bags: International Patterns of Norm Emergence and Policy Implementation’, Environmental Politics18: 315–332.
11.
DanovichT (2016) ‘Pre-Peeled Oranges: What Some Call “Lazy” Others Call a “Lifesaver”’, The Salt, NPR.org, 7March.
12.
DerraikJG (2002) ‘The Pollution of the Marine Environment by Plastic Debris: A Review’, Marine Pollution Bulletin44: 842–852.
13.
DolmageJT (2014) Disability Rhetoric. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
14.
FraserN (2000) ‘Rethinking Recognition’, New Left Review3(May–June): 107–120.
15.
FraserN (2007) ‘Feminist Politics in the Age of Recognition: A Two-dimensional Approach to Gender Justice’, Studies in Social Justice1(1): 23–35.
16.
GreysonJ (2007) ‘An Economic Instrument for Zero Waste, Economic Growth and Sustainability’, Journal of Cleaner Production15(13–14): 1382–1390.
17.
JambeckJRGeyerRWilcoxCSieglerTRPerrymanMAndradyANarayanRLawKL (2015) ‘Plastic Waste Inputs from Land into the Ocean’, Science347: 768–771.
18.
JampelC (2018) ‘Intersections of Disability Justice, Racial Justice and Environmental Justice’, Environmental Sociology4(1): 122–135.
19.
JenksAB (2018) ‘A Lack of Access: SSA Programs & Experiences of Blind and Visually Impaired People’. ARDRAW. Social Security Administration/Policy Research Inc.
20.
JohnsonVA (2017) ‘Bringing together Feminist Disability Studies and Environmental Justice’, pp. 73–93 in RaySJSibaraJ (eds) Disability Studies and the Environmental Humanities: Toward an Eco-Crip Theory. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
21.
McKinleyJ (2007) ‘San Francisco Board Votes to Ban Some Plastic Bags’, New York Times, 28March.
22.
NhamoG (2008) ‘Regulating Plastics Waste, Stakeholder Engagement and Sustainability Challenges in South Africa’, Urban Forum19(1): 83–101.
23.
NielsenKE (2012) A Disability History of the United States. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
24.
PerryD (2018) ‘Banning Straws Won’t Save the Oceans’, Pacific Standard, 31May.
25.
RameyCTitaB (2018) ‘The Summer of Plastic-Straw Bans: How We Got There’, Wall Street Journal, 7August.
26.
RankinJ (2019) ‘European Parliament Votes to Ban Single-use Plastics’, The Guardian, 27March.
SafiM (2018) ‘Mumbai Bans Plastic Bags and Bottles’, The Guardian, 25June.
29.
SchlosbergD (2004) ‘Reconceiving Environmental Justice: Global Movements and Political Theories’, Environmental Politics13(3): 517–540.
30.
SchweikSM (2009) The Ugly Laws: Disability in Public. New York: NYU Press.
31.
SpokasK (2008) ‘Plastics Still Young, But Having a Mature Impact’, Waste Management28: 473–474.
32.
WalkerTRXanthosD (2018) ‘A Call for Canada to Move toward Zero Plastic Waste by Reducing and Recycling Single-use Plastics’, Resources Conservation and Recycling133: 99–100.
