Previous studies demonstrate that private music training has benefits which may transfer to other domains, including verbal memory, intelligence and self-esteem. The current paper reports on the impact of an increase in school-based music training on a range of cognitive and psychosocial measures for 10–13-year-olds in two independent studies. In the first study, the benefits of increased frequency of classroom-based music classes were compared with classroom-based drama and art lessons in secondary school students (N = 127). The second study compared the effects of introducing a new classroom-based music programme with a new drama programme for primary school students (N = 100). Assessments were obtained at baseline and approximately six months after implementation of each programme. In contrast to previous research on the effects of private music tuition, no convincing benefits of school music classes were apparent. Trends of interest were observed in non-verbal intelligence, aggression scores and verbal memory, which require further investigation. The findings suggest that the benefits of music instruction previously reported may be limited to private or externally-based music tuition, or socio-economically disadvantaged schools. The intrinsic value of music education for enjoyment and learning should therefore remain central to the justification of music education in the national school curriculum.
AnvariS. H.TrainorL. J.WoodsideJ.LevyB. Z. (2002). Relations among musical skills, phonological processing, and early reading ability in preschool children. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 83, 111–130.
2.
Australia Council. (2000). Australians and the arts. A Report by Saatchi & Saatchi Australia. Sydney, Australia: Australia Council.
3.
Australian Council for Educational Research (ACER). (1984). School life questionnaire. Hawthorn, Australia: Australian Council for Educational Research.
4.
Australian Council for Educational Research (ACER). (2004). Evaluation of school-based arts education programs in Australian schools. Research Developments – Articles Online. Retrieved 5 May 2009, from http://www.acer.edu.au/resdev/12_ARTSED.html
5.
Australian Council of State School Organizations (ACSSO). (2005). Improving the condition of school music education across Australia: A submission to the national review of school music education. Curtin, Australia: Australian Council of State School Organizations (ACSSO).
British Educational Research Association (BERA) Music Education Review Group (2004). Mapping music education research in the UK. Psychology of Music, 32(3), 239–290.
8.
BrayD. (2000). An examination of GCSE music uptake rates. British Journal of Music Education, 17(1), 79–89.
9.
BryceJ.WithersG. (2003). Engaging secondary school students in lifelong learning. Camberwell, Australia: Australian Council for Educational Research.
10.
BussA. H.WarrenW. L. (2000). Aggression questionnaire. Los Angeles, CA: Western Psychological Services.
11.
CatterallJ. S.CapleauR.IwangaJ. (1999). Involvement in the arts and human development: General involvement and intensive involvement in music and theater arts. In FiskeE. (Ed.), Champions of change: The impact of the arts on learning (pp. 1–18). Washington, DC: The Arts Partnership and the President’s Committee on the Arts and Humanities.
12.
CatterallJ. S.WaldorfL. (1999). Chicago arts partnerships in education: Summary evaluation. In FiskeE. (Ed.), Champions of change: The impact of the arts on learning (pp. 48–62). Washington, DC: The Arts Partnership and the President’s Committee on the Arts and Humanities.
13.
CheekJ. M.SmithL. R. (1999). Music training and mathematics achievement. Adolescence, 34, 759–761.
14.
CohenM. J. (1997). Children’s memory scale. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
15.
Costa-GiomiE. (2004). Effects of three years of piano instruction on children’s academic achievement, school performance and self-esteem. Psychology of Music, 32, 139–152.
16.
ČrnčecR.WilsonS.PriorM. (2006). The cognitive and academic benefits of music to children: Facts and fiction. Educational Psychology, 26(4), 579–594.
17.
Department of Education and Early Childhood Development. (2006). Attitudes to school survey. East Melbourne, Australia: Department of Education and Early Childhood Development.
18.
EisnerE. W. (1999). Does experience in the arts boost academic achievement?Clearing House, 72, 143–149.
19.
FujiokaT.RossB.KakigiR.PantevC.TrainorL. J. (2006). One year of musical training affects development of auditory cortical-evoked fields in young children. Brain, 129. Retrieved 17 April 2008, from: http://brain.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/awl247v1
20.
GardinerM. E.FoxA.KnowlesF.JeffreyD. (1996). Learning improved by arts training. Nature, 381(6580), 284.
21.
GillA.RickardN. S. (2012). Non-music benefits of school-based music training. In RickardN. S.McFerranK. (Eds.), Lifelong engagement with music: Benefits for mental health and well-being. New York, NY: Nova Science Publishers.
22.
GreshamF. M.ElliotS. N. (1990). Social skills rating system. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
23.
HagborgW. J. (1993). The Rosenberg self-esteem scale and Harter’s self-perception profile for adolescents: A concurrent validity study. Psychology in the Schools, 30, 132–136.
24.
HallamS. (2010). The power of music: Its impact on the intellectual, social and personal development of children and young people. International Journal of Music Education, 28, 269–289.
25.
HamannD.BourassaR.AdermanM. (1991). Arts experiences and creativity scores of high school students. Contribution to Music Education, 14, 35–47.
26.
HarlandJ.KinderK.LordP.StottA.SchagenI.HaynesJ. (2000). Arts education in secondary schools: Effects and effectiveness. London, UK: NFER/The Arts Council of England.
27.
HendricksC. B.RobinsonB.BradleyL. J.DavisK. (1999). Using music techniques to treat adolescent depression. Journal of Humanistic Counseling, Education and Development, 38(1), 39–46.
28.
HoY. C.CheungM. C.ChanA. S. (2003). Music training improves verbal but not visual memory: Cross-sectional and longitudinal explorations in children. Neuropsychology, 17, 439–450.
29.
HodgesD. A.O’ConnellD. S. (2005). The impact of music education on academic achievement. In HodgesD. A. (Ed.), Sounds of learning. Carlsbad, CA: International Foundation for Music Research. Retrieved23November2011, from: http://www.uncg.edu/mus/soundsoflearning.html
30.
HomackS. R.ReynoldsC. R. (2007). Essentials of assessment with brief intelligence tests. New York, NY: Wiley.
31.
HunterM. A. (2005). Education and the arts research overview. Canberra, Australia: Australia Council for the Arts, Australian Government.
32.
KaufmanA. S.KaufmanN. L. (2004). Kaufman brief intelligence test (2nd ed.). Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
33.
Knox-AndersonH.RickardN. S. (2007). A preliminary examination of short-term effects of an active class-based music program on young adolescents’ self-esteem and anger expression. Australian Journal of Music Education, 5(1), 4–16.
34.
LindbladF.HogmarkA.TheorellT. (2006). Music intervention for 5th and 6th graders – effects on development and cortisol secretion. Stress and Health, 23, 9–14.
35.
LuD. T. (1986). The effects of teaching music skills on the development of reading skills among first graders: An experimental study. (Doctoral dissertation). University of Washington, USA. Dissertation Abstracts International, 47(12A), 4344.
36.
LuftigR. (1994). The schooled mind: Do the arts make a difference? Year 2: An empirical evaluation of the Hamilton Fairfield SPECTRA+ program, 1992–93. Oxford, OH: Center for Human Development, Learning, and Teaching, Miami University.
37.
MartinA. J. (2008). Motivation and engagement scale – music (MES-M). Summer Hill, Australia: Lifelong Achievement Group.
38.
McCarthyJ. D.HogeD. R. (1982). Analysis of age effects in longitudinal studies of adolescent self-esteem. Developmental Psychology, 18, 372–379.
39.
MorenoS.MarquesC.SantosA.SantosM.CastroS. L.BessonM. (2009). Musical training influences linguistic abilities in 8 yr old children: More evidence for brain plasticity. Cerebral Cortex, 19, 712–723.
40.
MortonL. L. (1990). The potential for therapeutic application of music on problems related to memory and attention. Journal of Music Therapy, 27(4), 195–208.
41.
O’ConnellD. S. (2005). The impact of music education on aspects of the child’s self. In HodgesD. A. (Ed.), Sounds of learning. Carlsbad, CA: International Foundation for Music Research. Retrieved23November2011, from: http://www.uncg.edu/mus/soundsoflearning.html
42.
OrsmondG. I.MillerL. K. (1999). Cognitive, musical and environmental correlates of early music instruction. Psychology of Music, 27(1), 18–37.
PascoeR.LeongS.MacCallumJ.MackinlayE.MarshK.SmithB.WintertonA. (2005). National review of school music education. Canberra, Australia: Department of Education, Science and Training, Australian Government.
45.
PittsS.DavidsonJ. (2000). Supporting musical development in the primary school. Research Studies in Music Education, 14, 76–84.
46.
PriceH. E. (2004). Mapping music education research in Germany. Psychology of Music, 32(3), 322–329.
47.
RauscherF. H.ShawG. L.KyK. (1995). Listening to Mozart enhances spatial-temporal reasoning: Towards a neurophysiological basis. Neuroscience Letters, 185, 44–47.
48.
RauscherF. H.ZupanM. A. (2000). Classroom keyboard instruction improves kindergarten children’s spatial-temporal performance: A field experiment. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 15, 215–228.
49.
ReimerB. (1989) A philosophy of music education (2nd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
50.
ReimerB. (1999) Facing the risks of the ‘Mozart effect’. Music Educators Journal, 86, 37–43
RickardN. S.JamesR.AppelmanR.MurphyF. M.GillA.BambrickC. J. (in press). Effects of a classroom-based instrumental music program on psychosocial functioning in primary school children. International Journal of Music Education.
53.
RickardN. S.VasquezT.MurphyF.ToukhsatiS. R.GillA. (2010). Benefits of a classroom-based instrumental music program on verbal memory of primary school children. Australian Journal of Music Education, 1, 36–47.
54.
RicksonD. J.WatkinsW. G. (2003). Music therapy to promote prosocial behaviours in aggressive adolescent boys – a pilot study. Journal of Music Therapy, 40(4), 283–301.
55.
RobinsonN. R. (2004). Who is at risk in the music classroom?Music Educators Journal, 90(4), 38–43.
56.
RosenbergM. (1965). Society and the adolescent self-image (Revised ed.). Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press.
57.
RoyseD.AddoA. O.KlingerR.Dunbar-HallP.CampbellP. S. (1999). Comparing music teacher training practices around the world. Journal of Music Teacher Education, 8(2), 14–21.
58.
SchellenbergE. G. (2001). Music and nonmusical abilities. In ZatorreR. J.PeretzI. (Eds.), The biological foundations of music (pp. 355–371). New York, NY: New York Academy of Sciences.
59.
SchellenbergE. G. (2004). Music lessons enhance IQ. Psychological Science, 15, 511–514.
60.
SchlaugG. (2001). The brain of musicians: A model for functional and structural adaptation. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 930, 281–299.
61.
ShieldsC. (2001). Music education and mentoring intervention for at-risk urban adolescents: Their self-perceptions, opinions and attitudes. Journal of Research in Music Education, 49, 273–286.
62.
SouthgateD. E.RoscignoV. J. (2009). The impact of music on childhood and adolescent achievement. Social Science Quarterly, 90(1), 4–21.
63.
StevensR. (2003). Trends in school music education provision in Australia. The Music Council of Australia in Collaboration with the Australian Society for Music Education and the Australian Music Association.
64.
TaylorC. (2008). ‘Both sides, now’: Balancing the extrinsic and intrinsic benefits of music in music advocacy. Canadian Music Educator, 49(3), 36–38.
65.
TeachoutD. J. (2005). The impact of music education on a child’s growth and development. In HodgesD. A. (Ed.), Sounds of learning. Carlsbad, CA: International Foundation for Music Research. Retrieved23November2011, from: http://www.uncg.edu/mus/soundsoflearning.html
66.
ThompsonW. F.SchellenbergE. G.HusainG. (2004). Decoding speech prosody: Do music lessons help?Emotion, 4(1), 46–64.
67.
ToddR. J. (1995). Integrated information skills instruction: Does it make a difference?School Library Media Quarterly, 23(2), 133–139.
68.
TrustyJ.OliviaG. M. (1994). The effects of arts and music education on students’ self-concept. Update: Applications of Research in Music Education, 13(1), 23–28.
69.
UpitisR.SmithrimK.PattesonA.MebanM. (2001). The effects of an enriched elementary arts education program on teacher development, artists practices and student achievement. International Journal of Education and the Arts, 2(8). Retrieved 21November2011, from: http://www.ijea.org/v2n8/.
70.
VaupelC. A. (2001). Test reviews: Cohen, M. J. (1997). Children’s memory scale manual. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 19, 392–400.
71.
WinnerE.CooperM. (2000). Mute those claims: No evidence yet for a causal link between arts study and academic achievement. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 34(3/4), 11–75.
