Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2025-7
“Tell Me Who You Are and I’ll Tell You What You Are”: Postcolonial Theory and Representations and Perceptions of Ethnic Minority Groups. The Case of Mizrahim and Israeli Arabs on Israeli Television
This theoretical article shows the benefits of using postcolonial theory in research of presentations and perceptions of ethnic minority groups on television. It introduces postcolonial theory and applies it to two minority ethnic groups in Israel: The Mizrahim and Israeli Arabs, analyzing their representations on mainstream Israeli television shows. This article also offers using a psychological theory called “media boundary situation” in order to discover perceptions of ethnic minority groups based on research of Mizrahim and Israeli-Arabs. The article assesses how postcolonial theory can be used to attain a better understating the unique representations of an ethnic groups and to develop an understanding of the perceptions of them.
AburaiyaI. (2001). The Arab minority and the Israeli media. In YishuviN. (Ed.), Exclusion and negative image: Inequality in the Israeli media (pp. 4–40). The Association for Civil Rights in Israel.
2.
AlgaziG (2002). Studying the studied nature: on shaping the concept of the "habitus" in Bourdieu's work. Israeli sociology4(2), 410–401.
3.
Al-HajM. (2004). The status of the Palestinian in Israel: A double periphery in an ethno national state. 2004 Symposium of The Association of Israel Studies. Retrieved fromhttp://www.aisisraelstudies.org
4.
Al-HajM. (2020). Arab local government in Israel. Routledge.
5.
AllanM. (2018). The SAGE encyclopedia of communication research methods. Sage.
6.
AmorM. (2002). Israeli Citizenship: From multiculturalism to interculturalism. In HeverH.ShenhavY.Motzafi-HallerP. (Eds.), Mizrahim in Israel (pp. 244–272). Van Leer Jerusalem Institute.
7.
AvrahamE. (2000). The media in Israel, center and periphery: Coverage of the development towns. Academon Press.
8.
AvrahamE. (2001). The hidden Israel: Kibbutzim, Jewish settlements, development cities and Arab towns in the Israeli press. Academon Press.
9.
AvrahamE. (2003a). Behind media marginality: Coverage of social groups and places in the Israeli media. Lexington books.
10.
AvrahamE.FirstA. (2010). Combining the representation approach with the framing concept: Television news coverage of the Arab population in Israel during conflict. Journalism, 11(4), 481–499. https://doi.org/10.1177/1464884910367594
11.
AvrahamE.FirstA.Elephant-LeflerN. (2004). The absent and the present in prime-time: Multi-cultural diversity in TV commercial broadcasting in Israel. The Second Authority for Television and Local Radio.
12.
AvrahamE. (2003b). Press, politics and the coverage of minorities in divided societies: The case of Arab citizens in Israel. Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics, 8(4), 7–26. https://doi.org/10.1177/1081180X03256577
13.
BalmasM. (2007). Competing messages: The impact of the satirical program Eretz Nehederet vs. hard news on the political images of leaders in the 2006 Israeli election campaign [unpublished MA thesis]. Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
14.
Ben Hay-SegevY. (2008). Mizrahim in Israel talk about prime time television shows [unpublished doctoral dissertation]. Bar-Ilan University.
15.
BhabhaH. (1994). The question of the other: Difference, discrimination and post-colonial discourse. Teoriya Vebikoret [Theory and Criticism], 5(1), 79–105.
16.
BhatiA (2022). What can postcolonial theory contribute to the study of social equity?American Society for Public Administration, 83(1), 203–209.https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13523
17.
BhatiA (2022). What can postcolonial theory contribute to the study of social equity. Public administration review, 83(1), 203–209. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13523
18.
BisharaA. (1993). On the question of the Arab minority in Israel. In RamU. (Ed.), Hachevra Hayisraelit: Hebetim Bikortiim [Israeli society: Critical aspects] (pp. 203–221). Am Oved.
19.
BourdieuP. (1998). On television. New Press.
20.
FanonP (2004). Black skin, white masks. Maariv.
21.
FirstA.AvrahamE. (2004). Representations of the Arab population in the Hebrew media: Comparison between coverage of the First Land Day (1976) and coverage of the Al-Aqsa Intifada (2000). The Tami Steinmetz Center for Peace Research, Tel-Aviv University.
HallS. (1977). Culture, the media and the "ideological effect". In CurranJ.GurevitchM.WoolacottJ. (Eds.), Questioning the Media: A critical Introduction (pp. 315–348). Sage.
24.
HallS. (1980). Encoding/decoding. In HallS.HobsonD.LoweA.WillisP. (Eds.), Culture, Media, Language (pp. 128–138). Hutchinson.
25.
HallS (1989). Ethnicity, Identity and difference. Radical America, 23(4), 9–13.
26.
HallS. (1993/2003). Encoding, decoding. In LiebesT.TalmonM. (Eds.), Communication as culture (pp. 259–271). The Open University.
27.
HarindranathR. (2000). Ethnicity, national culture(s) and the interpretation of television. In CottleS. (Ed.), Ethnic minorities and the media (pp. 149–164). Open University Press.
28.
HerzogH. (1986). Political ethnicity: The image and the reality. Hakibbutz Hameuchad.
29.
HeverH.ShenhavY.Motzafi-HallerP. (2002). Mizrahi epistemology in Israel. In HeverH.ShenhavY.Motzafi-HallerP. (Eds.), Mizrahim in Israel (pp. 15–28). Van Leer Jerusalem Institute.
KatzN. (2015). Tell me who you are and I’ll tell you what you are. Panim, 69(2), 22–45.
36.
KatzN. (2016). "Communicational Boundary situations": Minorities' Perceptions of their presentation in Israeli mass media. Media Frames, 16, 143–150.
37.
KatzNNossekH. (2019). Mizrahi Perceptions of their TV portrayal in Israel. Israel Affairs. https//doi.org/10.1080/13537121.2019.1626084
38.
KatzNNossekH. (2020). Watching televised representations and self-identity of national minorities: Perceptions of Israeli Arab Citizens of their media representations on Israeli television. Communications, 45(4), 1–33. https://doi.org/10.1515/commun-2020-2088
39.
KatzNNossekH. (2021). What I can't change I don’t see”: How cultural minorities perceive their media representations—Immigrants from the Former Soviet Union in Israel as a case study. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies. https://doi.org/10.1080/15562948.2021.1985199
40.
KimmerlingB. (2001). The end of the AHUSLIM rule. Keter.
41.
KumarS. (2014). Media, communication, and postcolonial theory. In FortnerR. S.FacklerM. (Eds.), The handbook of media and mass communication theory (pp. 381–399). John Wiley & Sons.
LiebesT.KatzE. (1986). On the critical abilities of television viewers. In SeiterE.BorchersH.KreutznerG.WarthE. M. (Eds.), Remote control: Television, audiences and cultural power (pp. 204–222). Routledge.
44.
LiebesT.KatzE. (1988). Dallas and genesis: Primordiality and seriality in popular culture. In CaveyJ. W. (Ed.), Media, myth and narrative: Television and the press (pp. 113–125). Sage.
45.
MeirovitzY. (1985). No sense of place: From the print environment to the electronic environment. In LiebesT.TalmonM.KamaA. (Eds.), Communication as culture (pp. 38–54). The Open University.
46.
MemmiA. (1974, September 2). Who is an Arab Jew. Haaretz, p. B–17.
47.
OzA (2002/2015). A tale of love and darkness. Keter.
48.
PersicoO. (2022). Only 4% of Ramadan engagement was positive Hahayin Hashviet.
49.
PersicoO. (2023). Not only size matters Hahayin Hashviet.
50.
RashmyL. (2020). Postcolonial approaches to communication and culture. Oxford University Press.
51.
SaidE. (2000). Orientalism. Am Oved.
52.
SegevM.LifshitzD.ShalmonA.(Creators) (2010). Eretz Nehederet [It’s a Wonderful Country]. [Television series]. In BroadcastingK.(Producer) (Ed.), Keshet.
53.
ShenhavY. (2003). Arab Jews, nationalism, religion and ethnicity. Am Oved.
54.
ShiranV. (2001). We are Mesuda from Sderoth. In YishuviN. (Ed.), Exclusion and negative image: Inequality in the Israeli media (pp. 4–40). The Association for Civil Rights in Israel.
55.
SmoohaS. (2000). The regime of the state of Israel: Civil democracy, non-democracy, or ethnic democracy?Sociologia Yisraelit [Israeli Sociology], 2, 565–630.
56.
SmoohaS. (2001). Arab-Jewish relations in Israel as a Jewish and democratic state. In YaarE.ShavitZ. (Eds.), Megamot bachevra hayisraelit [trends in Israeli society] (pp. 231–364). The Open University.
57.
SmoohaS. (2014). Don’t break the rules: Assessment of Arab-Jewish relations 2013. Israel Democracy Institute.
58.
SmoohaS. (2022). The Arab-Jewish Divide and Arab politics in Israel. University of Haifa press.
59.
SvirskyB., & BernsteinD (1993). Who worked what, for whom and for what?. In A. Ram (ed.), Israeli society - critical aspects (pp. 120–147). Brerot.
60.
SvirskyS. (1981). Not slow but slowed: Mizrahim and Ashkenazim in Israel. Mahberot lamehkar uletarbut.
61.
TaylorC (1992). Multiculturalism and the Politics of Recognition. Princeton University Press.
62.
TuchmanG. (1978). Making news: A study in the construction of reality. Free Press.
63.
YishuviN. (2001). Inequality in the media and human rights. In YishuviN. (Ed.), Exclusion and negative image: Inequality in the Israeli media (pp. 4–40). The Association for Civil Rights in Israel.
64.
YoungR. (2003). Postcolonialism: An introduction. Oxford University Press.
