This paper offers an account of the relationship between free speech and academic freedom. It argues that these principles, properly understood, sometimes cut against one another in practice. It then canvasses two sets of threats to academic freedom in the Trump-era United States: left-wing ‘political correctness’ or ‘cancel culture’ and right-wing legislative and executive incursions on university autonomy. The former threat long predates Donald Trump’s presidency; the latter emerged in its midst and is deeply tied to broader dynamics of democratic backsliding. The paper unpacks the conflicting accounts of free speech and academic freedom that have been advanced in public debates regarding these two threats, and it concludes by highlighting the unavoidable tradeoff between individual free speech rights and the institutional autonomy of academic institutions.
CasperGerhard. 2014. The Winds of Freedom: Addressing Challenges to the University. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
3.
Darian-SmithEve. 2024. Knowledge Production at a Crossroads: Rising antidemocracy and diminishing academic freedom. Studies in Higher Education50: 1–15.
4.
EnosRyan D.2024. Harvard Last in Free Speech? Don’t trust FIRE’s rankings. Chronicle of Higher Education, 16February.
5.
EvansCarolynStoneAdrienne. 2021. Open Minds: Academic Freedom and Freedom of Speech in Australia. Carlton, VIC: LaTrobe University Press.
GreeneJamal. 2021. How Rights Went Wrong: Why Our Obsession with Rights is Tearing America Apart. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
14.
GrumbachJacob. 2022. Laboratories against Democracy: How National Parties Transformed State Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
15.
KamolaIsaac. 2024. Manufacturing Backlash: Right-wing think tanks and legislative attacks on higher education, 2021-2023. AAUP Center for Defense of Academic Freedom, May. Available at: https://www.aaup.org/article/manufacturing-backlash
16.
KeckThomas M.2026. The Distinctive Pathologies of Free Speech Jurisprudence at the U.S. Supreme Court and European Court of Human Rights. International Journal of Constitutional Law24:1. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4227976
KipnisLaura. 2017. Unwanted Advances: Sexual Paranoia Comes to Campus. New York, NY: Harper.
19.
LottLarsKinzelbachKatrinLindbergStaffan I. 2025. Can Free Academia Withstand Autocratization? Why some universities wither while others survive. International Political Science Review 0(0). DOI: 10.1177/01925121251366162.
20.
LukianoffGreg. 2022. The Second Great Age of Political Correctness. Reason, January.
21.
MarshallMonty GGurrTed Robert. 2020. Polity5: Political regime characteristics and transitions, 1800-2018. Dataset Users’ Manual, Center for Systemic Peace. Available at: http://www.systemicpeace.org/inscr/p5manualv2018.pdf
22.
MatsudaMari JLawrenceCharles RDelgadoRichardCrenshawKimberlé W. 1993. Words that Wound: Critical Race Theory, Assaultive Speech, and the First Amendment. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
23.
MickeyRobert. 2015. Paths Out of Dixie: The Democratization of Authoritarian Enclaves in America’s Deep South, 1944-1972. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
24.
MillerVanessaFernandezFrankHutchensNeal H. 2023. The Race to Ban Race: Legal and critical arguments against state legislation to ban critical race theory in higher education. Missouri Law Review88: 61–106.
25.
MoskowitzPE. 2019. The Case Against Free Speech: The First Amendment, Fascism, and the Future of Dissent. New York, NY: Bold Type Books.
26.
NorrisPippa. 2024. Cancel Culture: Heterodox and Self-Censorship or the Curious Case of the Dog Which Didn’t Bark. International Political Science Review46(3): 422–441.
27.
PatelVimal. 2023a. A Lecturer Showed a Painting of the Prophet Muhammad. She lost her job. New York Times, 8January.
28.
PatelVimal. 2023b. At UChicago, a Debate of Free Speech and Cyberbullying. New York Times, 3July.
29.
PostRobert C.2012. Democracy, Expertise, and Academic Freedom: A First Amendment Jurisprudence for the Modern State. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
30.
RabbanDavid. 2024. Academic Freedom: From Professional Norm to First Amendment Rights. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
SachsJeffrey. 2022. Everyone’s Wrong about FIRE. Chronicle of Higher Education, 30November.
35.
SpannagelJanikaKinzelbachKatrin. 2023. The Academic Freedom Index and its Indicators: Introduction to new global time-series V-Dem data. Quality & Quantity57: 3969–3989.
