Varieties of local participation? A vignette survey on local executive politicians’ legitimacy perceptions towards different participatory arrangements
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2025
Varieties of local participation? A vignette survey on local executive politicians’ legitimacy perceptions towards different participatory arrangements
This study takes the hitherto understudied perspective of local executive politicians as crucial stakeholders spanning the boundaries of representative and participatory democracy. It aims to examine their legitimacy perceptions of different participatory arrangements. The research was conducted by means of a vignette study in which we included a representative arrangement and six participatory arrangements for which we differentiated for types of initiator (government or citizens) and three types of citizen involvement (consultative, co-decisive and decisive). We found that executives assessed government-initiated arrangements as more legitimate than citizen-initiated ones. Moreover, they perceived the co-decisive arrangement as the most legitimate.
ArnsteinSherry R (1969) A Ladder of Citizen Participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners35(4): 216–224.
2.
BinnemaHarmenMichelsAnkHartPaul ’tTorreLieske van der (2020) Democratic Innovations in Dutch Local Government: Experimentation in search of strategy. The Public Sector Innovation Journal25(1): 1–21.
3.
BrysbaertMarc (2019) How Many Participants Do We Have to Include in Properly Powered Experiments? A tutorial of power analysis with reference tables. Journal of Cognition2(1): 1–38.
4.
BuaAdrian (2019) Democratic Innovations and the Policy Process. In ElstubStephenEscobarOliver (eds) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 282–296.
5.
BussuSonia (2015) Between a Rock and a Hard Place: The councillor’s dilemma between strong mayors and citizens’ needs. Local Government Studies41(6): 841–860.
CaluwaertsDidierReuchampsMin (2015) Strengthening Democracy Through Bottom-Up Deliberation: An assessment of the internal legitimacy of the G1000 project. Acta Politica50(2): 151–170.
8.
CaluwaertsDidierKernAnnaReuchampsMinValckeTony (2020) Between Party Democracy and Citizen Democracy: Explaining attitudes of Flemish local chairs towards democratic innovations. Politics of the Low Countries2(2): 192–213.
9.
CopusColinWingfieldMelvinSteyversKristofReynaertHerwig (2012) A Place to Party? Parties and nonpartisanship in local government. In MossbergerKarenClarkeSusan EJohnPeter (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Urban Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 210–230.
10.
DaemenHarry (2012) Revitalising Representative Democracy. In SchaapLinzeDaemenHarry (eds) Renewal in European Local Democracies. Puzzles, Dilemmas and Options. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, 27–54.
11.
DanielssonMarianneHerttingNilsKlijnErik Hans (2018) Tricky for Good Reasons: Institutionalizing local participatory governance in representative democracy. In HerttingNilsKugelbergClarissa (eds) Local Participatory Governance and Representative Democracy: Institutional Dilemmas in European Cities. New York, NY: Routledge, 18–48.
12.
De Fine LichtJennyNaurinDanielEsaiassonPeterGilljamMikael (2012) When Does Transparency Generate Legitimacy? Experimenting on a context-bound relationship. Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions27(1): 111–134.
13.
DevillersSophieBiardBenjaminVandammePierre-EtienneJacquetVincentReuchampsMin (2022) Direct and deliberative democracy as potential remedies for partitocracy in Belgium. In BaudewynsPierreBransMarleenReuchampsMinRihouxBenoîtVan IngelgomVirginie (eds) The Winter of Democracy: Partitocracy in Belgium. Louvain-la-Neuve: Presses Universitaires de Louvain, 251–271.
14.
ElstubStephenEscobarOliver (2019) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
15.
FungArchon (2006) Varieties of Participation in Complex Governance. Public Administration Review66(Suppl 1): 66–75.
16.
GauthierMarioGagnonLyndaChiassonGuyMévellecAnne (2020) Public participation in planning and urban development in Quebec: Mayors facing the deliberative imperative. Participations 26–27: 165–192.
17.
GeisselBrigitte (2019) Democratic Innovations in Europe. In ElstubStephanEscobarOliver (eds) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 404–420.
18.
GlimmerveenLudoYbemaSierkNiesHenk (2021) Who Participates in Public Participation? The exclusionary effects of inclusionary efforts. Administration and Society54(4): 543–574.
19.
GundelachBirteBuserPatriciaKüblerDaniel (2017) Deliberative Democracy in Local Governance: The impact of institutional design on legitimacy. Local Government Studies43(2): 218–244.
20.
HaesevoetsTessaRoetsArneSteyversKristofVerschuereBramWautersBram (2023) Towards a multifaceted measure of perceived legitimacy of participatory governance. Governance37(3): 711–728.
21.
HeadBrian W (2022) Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
22.
HeineltHubertMagnierAnnickCabriaMarcelloReynaertHerwig (2018) Political Leaders and Changing Local Democracy: The European Mayor. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
23.
HellemansStaf (2020) Pillarization (‘Verzuiling’). On organized ‘self-contained worlds’ in the modern world. The American Sociologist51: 124–147.
24.
HendriksFrank (2021) Key Values for Democratic Governance Innovation: Two traditions and a synthesis. Public Administration100(4): 803–820.
25.
JacobsDaanKaufmannWesley (2021) The Right Kind of Participation? The effect of a deliberative mini-public on the perceived legitimacy of public decision-making. Public Management Review23(1): 91–111.
JuniusNinoMatthieuJokeCaluwaertsDidierErzeelSilvia (2020) Is It Interests, Ideas or Institutions? Explaining elected representatives’ positions toward democratic innovations in 15 European countries. Frontiers in Political Science2: 1–14
28.
KarstenNielsSweetingDavidKjaerUlrikKukovičSimona (2021) Leadership at the Subnational Level: Mayoral and executive models. In CallananMarkLoughlinJohn (eds) A Research Agenda for Regional and Local Government. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 163–176.
29.
KerstingNorbert (2013) Online Participation: From ‘invited’ to ‘invented’ spaces. International Journal of Electronic Governance6(4): 270–280.
30.
KerstingNorbert (2016) Participatory Turn? Comparing citizens’ and politicians’ perspectives on online and offline local political participation. Lex localis – Journal of Local Self-Government14(2): 1–17.
31.
KlausenJan ErlingVaboSigny IreneWinsvoldMarte (2022) Competing Perspectives on Participatory Arrangements: Explaining the attitudes of elected representatives. International Political Science Review44(5): 1–16.
32.
KlijnErik HansKoppenjanJoop (2000) Politicians and Interactive Decision Making: Institutional spoilsports or playmakers. Public Administration78(2): 365–387.
33.
KlijnErik HansSkelcherChris (2007) Democracy and Network Governance: Compatible or not? Four conjectures and their implications. Public Administration85(3): 587–608.
34.
KuhlmannSabineBouckaertGeert (2016) Local Public Sector Reforms in Times of Crisis: National Trajectories and International Comparisons. London: Macmillan Publishers.
35.
LefebvreRemiTalpinJulienPetitGuillaume (2020) Local councilors and public participation. The sociology of a category of elected officials, between functional specialization and positional subordination. Participations 26–27: 41–75.
36.
MichelsAnkDe GraafLaurens (2017) Examining Citizen Participation: Local participatory policymaking and democracy revisited. Local Government Studies43(6): 875–881.
37.
MigchelbrinkKoenVan de WalleSteven (2022) A Systematic Review of the Literature on Determinants of Public Managers’ Attitudes toward Public Participation. Local Government Studies48(1): 1–22.
38.
MouritzenPoul ErikSvaraJames H (2002) Leadership at the Apex. Politicians and Administrators in Western Local Governments. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
39.
PaulyRafVerschuereBramRynckFilip DeVoetsJoris (2021) Changing Neo-Corporatist Institutions? Examining the relationship between government and civil society organizations in Belgium. Public Management Review23(8): 1117–1138.
40.
PitkinHanna F (1967) The Concept of Representation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
41.
PogrebinschiThamyRyanMatt (2018) Moving Beyond Input Legitimacy: When do democratic innovations affect policy making?European Journal of Political Research57(1): 135–152.
42.
RodenbachJohannes (2017) Van Spelverdeler Tot Spits? Over de presidentialisering van het burgemeesterambt in Vlaanderen [From Playmaker to Striker? On the presidentialisation of the mayor’s position in Flanders]. Ghent: Ghent University.
43.
RøiselandAsbjørnIrene VaboSigny (2016) Interactive – or Counteractive – Governance? Lessons learned about citizen participation and political leadership. In EdelenbosJurianVan MeerkerkIngmar F (eds) Critical Reflections on Interactive Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 120–145.
44.
ScharpfFritz (1999) Governing in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
45.
SchmidtVivien (2013) Democracy and Legitimacy in the European Union Revisited: Input, output and ‘throughput’. Political Studies, 61: 2–22.
46.
SchmidtVivienWoodMatthew (2019) Conceptualizing Throughput Legitimacy: Procedural mechanisms of accountability, transparency, inclusiveness and openness in EU governance. Public Administration97(4): 727–740.
47.
SmithGraham (2009) Democratic Innovations. Designing Institutions for Citizen Participation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
48.
SørensenEvaSandfortJordi R (2022) Towards Hybrid Democracy and Interactive Political Leadership. In KroghAndreas HagedornAggerAnnikaTriantafillouPeter (eds) Public Governance in Denmark. Leeds: Emerald Publishing, 93–107.
49.
SørensenEvaHendriksCarolynHerttingNilsEdelenbosJurian (2020) Political Boundary Spanning: Politicians at the interface between collaborative governance and representative democracy. Policy and Society39(4): 530–569.
50.
SteyversKristof (2016) A Knight in White Satin Armour? New institutionalism and mayoral leadership in the era of governance. European Urban and Regional Studies23(3): 289–305.
51.
SteyversKristof (2022) Belgium: Between national barometer and local atmosphere. In GendzwillAdamKjaerUlrikSteyversKristof (eds) The Routledge Handbook of Local Elections and Voting in Europe. New York: Routledge, 114–125.
52.
SteyversKristofReynaertHerwigDe CeuninckKoenraadValckeTony (2006) Mayors in governance: Heading for efficiency and democracy? The Belgian case. Local Government Studies32(4): 429–445.
53.
StrebelMichael AndreaKüblerDanielMarcinkowskiFrank (2019) The Importance of Input and Output Legitimacy in Democratic Governance: Evidence from a population-based survey experiment in four West European Countries. European Journal of Political Research58: 488–513.
54.
ThompsonNivek (2019) The Role of Elected Representatives in Democratic Innovations. In ElstubStephenEscobarOliver (eds) Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 255–268.
55.
Van DammeJanJacquetVincentSchiffinoNathalieReuchampsMin (2017) Public Consultation and Participation in Belgium: Directly engaging citizens beyond the ballot box? In BransMarleenAubinDavid (eds) Policy Analysis in Belgium. Bristol: Policy Press, 215–234.
56.
VandeleeneAudreyDe WinterLievenBaudewynsPierre (2019) Candidates, Parties and Voters in the Belgian Partitocracy. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
57.
Van DethJan W (2014) A conceptual map of political participation. Acta Politica49: 349–367.
58.
VerhelstTomReynaertHerwigSteyversKristof (2011) Foundation or Fragment of Local Democracy? Empirically assessing the roles of local councillors in Belgian governance. Lex localis – Journal of Local Self-Government9(2): 103–122.
59.
VetterAngelika (2009) Citizens Versus Parties: Explaining institutional change in German local government 1989–2008. Local Government Studies35(1): 125–142.
60.
VetterAngelikaHeineltHubertRoseLawrence E (2018) Mayors’ notions of local democracy. In HeineltHubertMagnierAnnickCabriaMarcelloReynaertHerwig (eds) Political Leaders and Changing Local Democracy. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, 173–208.
61.
VisserVivianPopering-VerkerkJitske vanMinkmanEllenvan BuurenArwin (2023) Unleashing or Domesticating the Vitality of Citizens’ Initiatives? The paradoxical relationship between governments and citizens’ initiatives in the energy transition. Cities137: 1–10.
62.
VoschPeter (1992) Pillarization and Democracy: The case of Belgium, Dutch Crossing:. Journal of the Low Countries16(47): 53–68.
63.
WernerHannahMuradovaLala (2022) Scenario Experiments. In ErcanSelenAsenbaumHansCuratoNicoleMendonçaRicardo F (eds) Research Methods in Deliberative Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 190–203.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
