To what extent is partisan ability to shape policies affected by an economic downturn? Based on the analysis of the fulfilment of 2,412 election pledges in Italy (1996–2018), this article demonstrates that governing parties prioritize different types of promises in tough economic times compared to normal or growing periods. Despite the presence of important constraints, parties have incentives to still try to carve out space for (some of) their policy preferences. In addition, results suggest that the effect of the economic context on pledge fulfilment is contingent on: (a) the policy issue; and (b) parties’ political affiliation.
AlonsoSoniaRuiz-RufinoRubén (2020) The Costs of Responsibility for the Political Establishment of the Eurozone (1999–2015). Party Politics26(3): 317–333.
2.
ArmingeonKlausGuthmannKaiWeisstannerDavid (2016) Choosing the Path of Austerity: How Parties and Policy Coalitions Influence Welfare State Retrenchment in Periods of Fiscal Consolidation. West European Politics39(4): 628–647.
3.
BorghettoEnricoCarammiaMarcello (2014) Party Priorities, Government Formation and the Making of the Executive Agenda. In ContiNicolòMarangoniFrancesco (eds) The Challenge of Coalition Government. The Italian Case. Abingdon: Routledge, 36–57.
4.
BorghettoEnricoRussoFederico (2018) From Agenda Setters to Agenda Takers? The Determinants of Party Issue Attention in Times of Crisis. Party Politics24(1): 65–77.
5.
BorgninoGiorgia (2023) Do Parties Still Shape Policies in Times of Crisis? The Impact of Financial Constraints on Partisan Policymaking in Italy (1996–2018). Party Politics29(6): 1088–1099.
6.
BoscoAnnaVerneySusannah (2012) Electoral Epidemic: The Political Cost of Economic Crisis in Southern Europe, 2010–11. South European Society and Politics17(2): 129–154.
7.
BremerBjörn (2018)The Missing Left? Economic Crisis and the Programmatic Response of Social Democratic Parties in Europe. Party Politics24(1): 23–38.
8.
CarammiaMarcelloBorghettoEnricoBevanShaun (2018) Changing the Transmission Belt: The Programme-to-Policy Link in Italy Between the First and Second Republic. Italian Political Science Review48(3): 275–288.
9.
DassonnevilleRuthHoogheMarc (2017) Economic Indicators and Electoral Volatility: Economic Effects on Electoral Volatility in Western Europe, 1950–2013. Comparative European Politics15(6): 919–943.
10.
De VriesCatherine E.SolazHector (2019) Sweeping It under the Rug: How Government Parties Deal with Deteriorating Economic Conditions. Party Politics25(1): 63–75.
11.
GuinaudeauIsabelle (2014) Toward a Conditional Model of Partisanship in Policymaking. French Politics12(3): 265–281.
12.
HauptAndrea B. (2010) Parties’ Responses to Economic Globalization: What Is Left for the Left and Right for the Right?Party Politics16(1): 5–27.
13.
HibbsDouglas A. (1992) Partisan Theory after Fifteen Years. European Journal of Political Economy8(3): 361–373.
14.
HofferbertRichard I.BudgeIan (1992) The Party Mandate and the Westminster Model: Election Programmes and Government Spending in Britain, 1948–85. British Journal of Political Science22(2): 151–182.
15.
HornAlexander (2021) The Asymmetric Long-Term Electoral Consequences of Unpopular Reforms: Why Retrenchment Really Is a Losing Game for Left Parties. Journal of European Public Policy28(9): 1494–1517.
16.
HornAlexanderJensenCarsten (2017) When and Why Politicians Do Not Keep Their Welfare Promises. European Journal of Political Research56(2): 381–400.
17.
ImbeauLouis M.PetryFrançoisLamariMoktar (2001) Left–Right Party Ideology and Government Policies: A Meta-Analysis. European Journal of Political Research40(1): 1–29.
18.
JensenCarstenMortensenPeter B. (2014) Government Responses to Fiscal Austerity: The Effect of Institutional Fragmentation and Partisanship. Comparative Political Studies47(2): 143–170.
19.
KwonHyeok Y.PontussonJonas (2010) Globalization, Labour Power and Partisan Politics Revisited. Socio-Economic Review8(2): 251–281.
20.
LipsmeyerChristine S. (2011) Booms and Busts: How Parliamentary Governments and Economic Context Influence Welfare Policy. International Studies Quarterly55(4): 959–980.
21.
MatthießTheres (2020) Retrospective Pledge Voting: A Comparative Study of the Electoral Consequences of Government Parties’ Pledge Fulfilment. European Journal of Political Research59(4): 774–796.
22.
McManusIan P. (2018) Political Parties as Drivers of Post-Crisis Social Spending in Liberal Welfare States. Comparative European Politics16(5): 843–870.
23.
McManusIan P. (2019) The Re-Emergence of Partisan Effects on Social Spending after the Global Financial Crisis. Journal of Common Market Studies57(6): 1274–1291.
24.
MouryCatherine (2011) Italian Coalitions and Electoral Promises: Assessing the Democratic Performance of the Prodi I and Berlusconi II Governments. Modern Italy16(1): 35–50.
25.
NaurinElinRoyedTerry J.ThomsonRobert (2019) Party Mandates and Democracy: Making, Breaking, and Keeping Election Pledges in Twelve Countries. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press.
26.
PétryFrançoisDuvalDominic (2018) Electoral Promises and Single Party Governments: The Role of Party Ideology and Budget Balance in Pledge Fulfillment. Canadian Journal of Political Science51(4): 907–927.
27.
PritoniAndrea (2020) Public Agendas and Policy Agendas in Three Western European Countries: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis. Government and Opposition55(3): 371–392.
28.
RossFiona (2000) ‘Beyond Left and Right’: The New Partisan Politics of Welfare. Governance13(2): 155–183.
29.
Ruiz-RufinoRubénAlonsoSonia (2017) Democracy without Choice: Citizens’ Perceptions of Government Autonomy During the Eurozone Crisis. European Journal of Political Research56(2): 320–345.
30.
SingerMatthew M (2013) The Global Economic Crisis and Domestic Political Agendas. Electoral Studies32(3): 404–410.
31.
StokesSusan C. (2001) Mandates and Democracy: Neoliberalism by Surprise in Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
ThomsonRobertCostelloRory (2016) Governing Together in Good and Bad Economic Times: The Fulfilment of Election Pledges in Ireland. Irish Political Studies31(2): 182–203.
33.
ThomsonRobertRoyedTerryNaurinElinArtésJoaquìnCostelloRoryEnnser-JedeiastikLaurenzFergusonMarkKostadinovaPetiaMouryCatherinePétryFrançoisPraprotnikKatrin (2017) The Fullfillment of Parties’ Election Pledges: A Comparative Study on the Impact of Power Sharing. American Journal of Political Science61(3): 527–542.
34.
TraberDeniseGigerNathalieHäusermannSilja (2018) How Economic Crises Affect Political Representation: Declining Party–Voter Congruence in Times of Constrained Government. West European Politics41(5): 1100–1124.
35.
WenzelburgerGeorgKönigPascal D.WolfFrieder (2019) Policy Theories in Hard Times? Assessing the Explanatory Power of Policy Theories in the Context of Crisis. Public Organization Review19(1): 97–118.
36.
WilliamsLaron K.SekiKatsunoriWhittenGuy D. (2016) You’ve Got Some Explaining To Do. The Influence of Economic Conditions and Spatial Competition on Party Strategy. Political Science Research and Methods4(1): 47–63.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
