Can negative evaluations of a broad outgroup paired with positive evaluations of a broad ingroup, sustain willing affiliation with even intensely self-derogating online communities? Synthesizing concepts from masculinities scholarship, social identity theory, and self-verification theory, this study compares language from two distinctive misogynist communities active on Reddit.com—Men Going Their Own Way, male separatists who positively frame members as superior to other men and men as superior to women, and Involuntary Celibates (incels), who openly derogate incel community members—to understand what sustains misogynist incels’ willing affiliation with the self-derogating incel community. Using thematic qualitative analysis, I find that while male separatists favor both their own narrower online community and the broader ingroup of men, misogynist incels engage in a patriarchal bargain, using relatively benevolent depictions of some men alongside negative depictions of all women to perpetuate broader gender inequality.
AbramsDominicHoggMichael A.1990. “An Introduction to the Social Identity Approach.” Pp. 1–9 in Social Identity Theory: Constructive and Critical Advances, edited by DominicA.HoggM. A.New York, NY: Springer.
2.
BaumgartnerJasonZannettouSavvasKeeganBrianSquireMeganBlackburnJeremy. 2020. “The Pushshift Reddit Dataset.” Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media14:830–39.
3.
BirdSharon R.1996. “Welcome to the Men’s Club: Homosociality and the Maintenance of Hegemonic Masculinity.” Gender & Society10(2):120–32.
4.
BratichJackBanet-WeiserSarah. 2019. “From Pick-Up Artists to Incels: Con(fidence) Games Networked Misogyny, and the Failure of Neoliberalism.” International Journal of Communication13(25). https://ijoc.org/index.php/ijoc/article/view/13216
5.
BridgesTristan. 2021. “Antifeminism, Profeminism, and the Myth of White Men’s Disadvantage.” Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society46(3):663–88.
6.
BridgesTristanPascoeC. J.2014. “Hybrid Masculinities: New Directions in the Sociology of Men and Masculinities.” Sociology Compass8(3):246–58.
7.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 2004. Black Sexual Politics: African Americans, Gender, and the New Racism. London: Routledge.
8.
ConnellRaewyn. 1995. Masculinities. Berkeley: University of California Press.
9.
ConnellRaewyn. 2009. Gender: In World Perspective. 2nd ed.Malden, MA: Polity.
10.
ConnellRaewynMesserschmidtJames W.2005. “Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept.” Gender & Society19(6):829–59.
11.
DasguptaNilanjana. 2004. “Implicit Ingroup Favoritism, Outgroup Favoritism, and Their Behavioral Manifestations.” Social Justice Research17(2):143–69.
12.
DavisJenny L.LoveTony P.FaresPhoenicia. 2019. “Collective Social Identity: Synthesizing Identity Theory and Social Identity Theory Using Digital Data.” Social Psychology Quarterly82(3):254–73.
13.
DignamPierce AlexanderRohlingerDeana A.2019. “Misogynistic Men Online: How the Red Pill Helped Elect Trump.” Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society44(3):589–612.
14.
FarrellTracieFernandezMiriamNovotnyJakubAlaniHarith. 2019. “Exploring Misogyny Across the Manosphere in Reddit.” Pp. 87–96 in Proceedings of the 10th ACM Conference on Web Science, Association for Computing Machinery. New York, NY, United States.
15.
FisherMatthewKnobeJoshuaStricklandBrentKeilFrank C.2018. “The Tribalism of Truth.” Scientific American318(2):50–53.
16.
GarimellaKiranMoralesGianmarce De FrancisciGionisAristidesMathioudakisMichael. 2018. “Political Discourse on Social Media: Echo Chambers, Gatekeepers, and the Price of Bipartisanship.” Pp. 913–22 in Proceedings of the 2018 World Wide Web Conference, International World Wide Web Conferences Steering Committee. Republic and Canton of Geneva, Switzerland.
17.
GingDebbie. 2019. “Alphas, Betas, and Incels: Theorizing the Masculinities of the Manosphere.” Men and Masculinities22(4):638–57.
18.
HaslamNickRothschildLouisErnstDonald. 2000. “Essentialist Beliefs about Social Categories.” British Journal of Social Psychology39(1):113–27.
19.
HaslamS. AlexanderOakesPenelope J.ReynoldsKatherine J.TurnerJohn C.1999. “Social Identity Salience and the Emergence of Stereotype Consensus.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin25(7):809–18.
HerzogHannaYahia-YounisTaghreed. 2007. “Men’s Bargaining with Patriarchy: The Case of Primaries within Hamulas in Palestinian Arab Communities in Israel.” Gender & Society21(4):579–602.
24.
HodesMartha. 1993. “The Sexualization of Reconstruction Politics: White Women and Black Men in the South after the Civil War.” Journal of the History of Sexuality3(3):402–17.
25.
HoggMichael A.2016. “Social Identity Theory.” Pp. 3–17 in Understanding Peace and Conflict through Social Identity Theory. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
26.
HornseyMatthew J.2008. “Social Identity Theory and Self-Categorization Theory: A Historical Review.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass2(1):204–22.
27.
JostJohn T.BanajiMahzarin R.1994. “The Role of Stereotyping in System-Justification and the Production of False Consciousness.” British Journal of Social Psychology33(1):1–27.
28.
KandiyotiDeniz. 1988. “Bargaining with Patriarchy.” Gender & Society2(3):274–90.
29.
KayAaron C.JostJohn T.MandisodzaAnesu N.ShermanSteven J.PetrocelliJohn V.JohnsonAmy L.2007. “Panglossian Ideology in the Service of System Justification: How Complementary Stereotypes Help us to Rationalize Inequality.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology39:305–58.
KilgoDanielle K.Margaret NgYee ManRiedlMartin J.Lacasa-MasIvan. 2018. “Reddit’s Veil of Anonymity: Predictors of Engagement and Participation in Media Environments with Hostile Reputations.” Social Media+ Society4(4). doi:10.1177/2056305118810216.
32.
LeonardelliGeoffrey J.TohSoo Min. 2015. “Social Categorization in Intergroup Contexts: Three Kinds of Self-Categorization.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass9(2):69–87.
33.
LinJie Liang. 2017. “Antifeminism Online: MGTOW (Men Going Their Own Way).” Pp. 77–96 in Digital Environments, edited by FrömmingU. U.KöhnS.FoxS.TerryM.Bielefeld, Germany: Transcript Verlag.
MannCoramae RicheySelvaLance H.1979. “The Sexualization of Racism: The Black as Rapist and White Justice.” The Western Journal of Black Studies3(3):168.
36.
MarkhamAnnetteBuchananElizabeth. 2012. “Ethical Decision-Making and Internet Research: Version 2.0. Recommendations from the AoIR Ethics Working Committee.” aoir.org/reports/ethics2.pdf.
37.
MarwickAliceLewisRebecca. 2017. Media Manipulation and Disinformation Online. New York, NY: Data & Society Research Institute.
38.
MassanariAdrienne. 2017. “#Gamergate and the Fappening: How Reddit’s Algorithm, Governance, and Culture Support Toxic Technocultures.” New Media & Society19(3):329–46.
39.
MesserschmidtJames W.2018. “Multiple Masculinities.” Pp. 143–53 in Handbook of the Sociology of Gender, edited by RismanB. J.FroyumC. M.ScarboroughW. J.Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
MummendeyAmélie. 1995. “Positive Distinctiveness and Social Discrimination: An Old Couple Living in Divorce.” European Journal of Social Psychology25(6):657–70.
42.
NemotoKumiko. 2008. “Climbing the Hierarchy of Masculinity: Asian American Men’s Cross-Racial Competition for Intimacy with White Women.” Gender Issues25(2):80–100.
43.
O’ConnorCliodhnaJoffeHelene. 2020. “Intercoder Reliability in Qualitative Research: Debates and Practical Guidelines.” International Journal of Qualitative Methods19. doi:10.1177/1609406919899220.
ReidScott A.HoggMichael A.2005. “Uncertainty Reduction, Self-Enhancement, and Ingroup Identification.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin31(6):804–17.
47.
RibeiroManoel HortaBlackburnJeremyBradlynBarryCristofaroEmiliano DeStringhiniGianlucaLongSummerGreenbergStephanieZannettouSavvas. 2020. “The Evolution of the Manosphere Across the Web.” arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.07600.
48.
RobardsBrady. 2018. “Belonging and Neo-Tribalism on Social Media Site Reddit.” Pp. 187–206 in Neo-Tribes, edited by HardyA.BennettA.RobardsB.London: Palgrave Macmillan.
49.
SaldañaJohnny. 2021. The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers. SAGE Publications Limited.
50.
SchmalzMarcCarterMichelleLeeJin Ha. 2018. “It’s Not You, It’s Me: Identity, Self-Verification, and Amazon Reviews.” ACM SIGMIS Database: The DATABASE for Advances in Information Systems49(2):79–92.
51.
SchwalbeM.1992. “Male Supremacy and the Narrowing of the Moral Self.” Berkeley Journal of Sociology37:29–54.
52.
ShifmanLimor. 2014. “The Cultural Logic of Photo-Based Meme Genres.” Journal of Visual Culture13(3):340–58.
53.
SobierajSarah. 2020. Credible Threat: Attacks against Women Online and the Future of Democracy. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
54.
StetsJan E.BurkePeter J.2000. “Identity Theory and Social Identity Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly63(3):224–37.
55.
SwannWilliam B.Jr.2011. “Self-Verification Theory.” Pp. 23–42 in Handbook of Theories of Social Psychology. Vol. 2, edited by Van LangeP. A. M.KruglanskiA. W.HigginsE. T.Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
56.
SwannWilliam B.Jr.ReadStephen J.1981. “Self-Verification Processes: How We Sustain Our Self-Conceptions.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology17(4):351–72.
57.
TajfelHenriBilligMichael G.BundyRobert P.FlamentClaude. 1971. “Social Categorization and Intergroup Behaviour.” European Journal of Social Psychology1(2):149–78.
58.
TajfelHenriTurnerJohn C.2004. “The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behavior.” Pp. 276–93 in Political Psychology: Key Readings, edited by JostJ. T.SidaniusJ.New York, NY: Psychology Press.
59.
TalaifarSanazmSwannWilliam B.2020. “Self-Verification Theory.” Pp. 4813–21 in Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences, edited by Zeigler-HillV.ShackelfordT. K.New York, NY: Springer.
60.
TavoryIddoTimmermansStefan. 2014. Abductive Analysis: Theorizing Qualitative Research. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
61.
TrepteSabineLoyLaura S.2017. “Social Identity Theory and Self-Categorization Theory.” In The International Encyclopedia of Media Effects. New York, NY: Wiley Online.
62.
TurnerJohn C.BrownRupert J.TajfelHenri. 1979. “Social Comparison and Group Interest in Ingroup Favouritism.” European Journal of Social Psychology9(2):187–204.
63.
VaismoradiMojtabaJonesJacquelineTurunenHanneleSnelgroveSherrill. 2016. “Theme Development in Qualitative Content Analysis and Thematic Analysis.” Journal of Nursing Education and Practice6(5). doi:10.5430/jnep.v6n5p100.
64.
von HippelC. D.2006. “When People Would Rather Switch Than Fight: Out-Group Favoritism among Temporary Employees.” Group Processes & Intergroup Relations9(4):533–46.
65.
WoodWendyEaglyAlice H.2012. “Biosocial Construction of Sex Differences and Similarities in Behavior.” Pp. 55–123 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. Vol. 46, edited by OlsonJ. M.ZannaM. P.Burlington, VT: Academic Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
